Read A Killing Kindness Online
Authors: Reginald Hill
'And what's a Choker motive?' demanded Dalziel. 'What that trick-cyclist - whatsisname? - Potty, says?'
‘Pottle,' said Pascoe. 'Perhaps. Something like that. But not personal, not in the strict sense. You know what I mean, sir.'
'Do I?'
'Oh yes. You were very sure, I recall, that Brenda was a Choker victim even though she was found in the water, just as you had doubts about Pauline Stanhope, even though she was laid out in the classic style.'
'I can change my mind, can't I?' said Dalziel. 'I mean, a man gets fed up of being right all the time.'
'It must be painful,' said Pascoe and tried not to respond to Wield's grin behind the fat man's shoulder.
He continued. 'I just wondered if you were thinking what I've been thinking. Perhaps Dave Lee wasn't the only one to get worried when Rosetta Stanhope got so near the mark. Perhaps someone went to the fairground on Wednesday to shut Madame Rashid up and didn't know enough to know that Pauline wasn't Rosetta.'
'Perhaps, perhaps,' said Dalziel irritably. 'But why should anyone but a pig-ignorant gyppo get so upset by this mumbo-jumbo? I mean, what did that newspaper report say?'
The offending paper was produced.
'Blue sky, golden sun, big birds, black faces,' itemized Dalziel. 'Makes it sound like a travel brochure.'
'That's what I thought,' said Pascoe.
'So what's to be scared of?' grumbled Dalziel. 'This was that Duxbury woman, the neighbour? Oh yes, here she's mentioned. She says it was definitely the girl's voice.'
'The mother thought so too,' said Pascoe. 'But of course the situation was hysterical.'
‘Aye. I bet old Wield here was falling about, pissing himself,' grunted Dalziel in the sergeant's direction.
'Perhaps I should have let that pair of linguists have a listen,' said Pascoe.
'For what? Experts, I've shit 'em,' announced Dalziel. 'What have they done for us so far, tell me that?'
'They've analysed those phone voices. Why don't we get every man connected with the case on tape and pass them over for comparison?' suggested Pascoe.
'That implies that (a) you trust that pair of Midsummer Night Dreams and (b) you're certain the Choker made one of those calls. It wouldn't be admissible evidence in any case.'
'No, but it's surely worth a try,' urged Pascoe.
Dalziel continued to look doubtful. He glanced at his watch.
'Christ, it's after two o'clock,' he said. 'And I haven’t had my dinner. Peter, I think we may have gone as far as we can today. Why don't you push off home, take your rest day as scheduled? You've earned it.'
'Oh no,' said Pascoe firmly. 'The bargain was, I get next Friday and Saturday, guaranteed. Try to wriggle out of that and Ellie'll twist your arm off and hit you with the soggy end. I'll just give her a ring and see how she is, though.'
But the phone rang before he could reach it.
He picked it up and listened.
'For you,' he said, handing it over to Dalziel.
'Of course I wouldn't try to wriggle out of anything,' said Dalziel, aggrieved. 'I was saying you could take the afternoon off as a bonus, but seeing as you don't want it . . .
Hello!
He bellowed into the receiver from which a tinny voice had been emerging unregarded as he spoke.
'Jesus!' said the voice. 'Why don't you just open the window and forget about the phone.'
'Who's that?' demanded Dalziel.
'Sammy Locke,
Evening News.
How's business?'
'Quiet,' said Dalziel suspiciously. 'What've you heard?'
'Well, one of our contributors has phoned in a piece about strange goings-on among the gypsies. Police raids, brutality, interference with traditional funeral rites.'
'What? Who the hell was that? You print that and you won't get within spitting distance of another crime story in this town.' promised Dalziel.
'We'll see,' said Locke indifferently. 'And nothing else has been happening?'
'No. Why? Should it?'
'You tell me. Listen to this.'
There was a click, a pause, then a voice said wearily.
'Oh God! I could be bounded in a nut-shell and count myself a king of infinite space, were it not that I have bad dreams.'
There,' said Sammy Locke, 'Perhaps you'd better start looking for a body.'
Chapter 22
Interestingly, a message without a body seemed to stir up Dalziel much more than a message with a body.
'Got them linguists yet?' he demanded of Pascoe for the third time.
'I've sent cars out, told the lads to pick them up as soon as they come home,' said Pascoe. 'But really, all they can tell us is which of the other four, if any, this is. Sounds like (A) to me.'
'Me too,' said Wield. 'Though it's hard to be sure. He sounds different somehow. You know, not so certain of himself. Unhappy.'
'Hell's bells,' said Dalziel.
'He's
unhappy! Wait till this hits the papers. They'll give us stick, and not having had the advantage of a public school education, I don't care for stick.'
'No, sir. But the sergeant's right. I've sent for Dr Pottle as well to see what he thinks,' said Pascoe.
Dalziel's shrug, like Atlas getting a bit restless, indicated his opinion of Dr Pottle.
Sergeant Brady came into the Murder Room. He had been checking the missing persons reports. Weekend nights always brought in a good crop of non-returning youngsters.'
'Seven lasses,' said Brady. 'Three turned up very late, looking satisfied, likely. Another two are back as well, only the parents didn't bother to tell us. That leaves two. They sound like they've just taken off to the Smoke. Classic backgrounds, like Mr Pascoe says.'
'Keep after them all the same,' ordered Dalziel, adding when the sergeant left, 'Christ, Peter, what're you doing to Brady?
Classic backgrounds
! He'll be spelling psychology with two p's and only one k next!'
On cue, the sergeant returned to announce that Dr Pottle was here.
'Hasn't he got a golf-course to go to?' muttered Dalziel.
In fact whatever it was that Pottle did on Saturday afternoons he seemed only too pleased to have been invited away from it. He took the new tape into a neighbouring room and played it through several times.
'You have no body?' he enquired when he had finished.
'No. You think we're likely to get one?' said Dalziel.
'That I can't say. But whether this is your man or not, he certainly sounds to me very disturbed. If we assume that he is the (A) of the previous set of tapes, the change is marked.'
'That's what I thought,' said Wield. 'Unhappier, sort of.'
Pottle looked at him approvingly.
'You have a sensitive ear,' he said.
Wield coughed almost noiselessly into his fist. Pascoe who was beginning to be a keen student of Wieldology noted this down as the equivalent of a flush of pleasure.
'Last time his tone was regretful but resolved, as though he were performing a painful necessity,' continued Pottle.
'This is hurting me as much as it hurts you, you mean?' said Dalziel. 'We had an old sod at school used to say that as he thumped you.'
'Partly that. More being cruel to be kind. Compassionate, almost,' said the doctor. 'As I said in my written report, these are just impressions, but supported, I think, by the treatment of his victims and the tone and content of the telephone calls. Now, here there are two distinct changes. His voice sounds much more distressed, there's not the same authority there as before. And the words he speaks are concerned with himself, not with his victim.
Oh God! I could be bounded in a nut-shell and count myself a king of infinite space, were it not that I have bad dreams.
He's beginning to find it hard to live with himself, I would say.'
'Would this show in his outer behaviour?' wondered Pascoe.
'Not necessarily. Not yet anyway.'
'More important, does it mean he's less or more dangerous?' demanded Dalziel.
'I can't answer that,' said Pottle.
Dalziel gave an expressive pout of his thick lips and putting his hand into his waistband began to scratch his stomach audibly.
'One last thing,' said Pascoe. 'Suppose that his last killing, that is the last we definitely knew about, had been motivated not by whatever it is that's bugging him deep down, but by a simple desire not to be caught. How would this affect him?'
Pottle lit a cigarette from the one he was already smoking.
'This is a hypothesis, or do you know something?' he asked.
'An educated guess,' replied Pascoe.
'Then I would guess also that his own survival might not be sufficient justification to himself for taking life. Not unless it was definitely a one-off once-for-all-time act.'
'In other words, he might do it, resolved that after this there would be no more killings.'
'Yes.'
'And then if he found there were going to be other killings, that the compulsion was still there . . . ?'
'I see what you're getting at, Mr Pascoe,' said Pottle. 'Yes, that could explain the change of tone here in this message. If he has killed again because his compulsion, he now knows he may be tempted to kill again for his survival. And that is what he finds it hard to contemplate.'
'Hold on, now,' said Dalziel. 'If he killed that girl on the fairground just to protect himself, surely it's the call that followed that murder which should be full of this unhappiness your sensitive ears are picking up.'
'Oh no,' said Pottle. 'His motivation would have been sufficient at the time to justify himself thoroughly. Therefore he would be most meticulous about his cover-up.'
'Cover-up?'
'That's right. By laying the girl out as he did and by making the phone-call in the same tone and terms as before, he was attempting to misdirect you into pursuing him as the motiveless Choker still.'
'Which is what you hinted at in the first place, sir,' reminded Pascoe.
'Aye, I know,' muttered Dalziel. 'But I always get suspicious of my good ideas when clever buggers start supporting them. Well, thank you, Doctor. You've been very helpful.'
Pottle closed his notebook so firmly that an ashy emanation puffed out of his hands like fumes from a censer. He is after all our society's high-priest, thought Pascoe. The ungodly Dalziel had already turned away.
'He doesn't care for "clever buggers", I see,' murmured Pottle. 'And yet . . . how clever is he himself? Of the other, I have no doubts.'
'Oh, he knows a hawk from a handsaw,' said Pascoe lightly. 'Any more thoughts on why Hamlet, Doctor?'
'The first lady is the key, I believe,' said Pottle, making for the door. 'Had she been a little older, and had she remarried after her husband's death, and had she got a son who was a thirty- five-year-old adolescent . . .'
'She had a daughter who died,' said Pascoe.
'That might be significant. But you'll need powers other than mine to establish
that
connection, Inspector. Good day to you.'
'Inspector Pascoe,' bellowed Dalziel as the door closed behind the psychiatrist.
Pascoe went to the table behind which the fat man was sitting, viewing with distaste its paper-strewn surface.
'There's too many people just hanging around here,' he said fretfully. 'It's like just after pub closing-time in a brothel.'
'Some brothel,' said Pascoe. 'The girl we're all waiting for is dead.'
'I'll believe that when I see it,' said Dalziel. 'Meanwhile, there's things to be done. The fair finishes tonight. They'll be packing up in the morning, so I'm sending a team down there just in case there's any last-minute memories or anything turns up when the council start raking in the rubbish. Next, I'm fed up with all these wiseacres farting about with these tapes. Let's get something really useful out of 'em. Every man connected with this case, I want his voice on tape. It can be by agreement or by stealth, I don't mind. Sergeant Wield's a dab hand at working with a microphone up his nostrils aren't you, Sergeant? Then we'll see if these sodding experts can actually say if it was one of this lot on the telephone, right?'
He glared at Pascoe as if defying him to recall that this had been his own suggestion only an hour earlier.
'Excellent idea, sir,' said Pascoe. 'I'll do Wildgoose. I want another word with that sod anyway.'
'And I'll have another chat with Mr Mulgan,' said Sergeant Wield who had been studying the linguists' report with great interest.
'Talking of Mulgan, was there anything on that list of the Sorby girl's transctions?' enquired Dalziel.
Guiltily, Wield took it out of his pocket and handed it over.
'Forgot all about it, sir,' he confessed. 'What with the bother at the encampment and all.'
Dalziel grunted and glanced down the list. Because it was half-day closing, a lot of the local traders had been putting their takings in during the afternoon, including M. Conrad, the jeweller. Also, he noticed, there had been a deposit made on behalf of the Aero Club account and a large sum withdrawn from the Middlefield Electronic account.
He frowned.
'She was wearing her engagement ring that day, wasn't she?' he said.
Pascoe and Wield exchanged glances.
'I think so,' said Wield. 'Why, sir?'
'Nothing. You're getting me as loopy as the rest of you. Go on, bugger off and get some work done, will you?'
Before he left the station, Pascoe put a copy of the latest tape in an envelope and addressed it to Gladmann or Urquhart in case either should surface before his return. Then, as an afterthought, he dropped in the Rosetta Stanhope cassette with a copy of Wield's transcription and a note with the vague query, 'What do you make of this?'
Wildgoose's milk and paper still remained uncollected. Pascoe contemplated burglary but was deterred by the appearance of a neighbour, a hairy young man apparently dying of consumption, who told him in a series of wheezy grunts that he'd heard Wildgoose go out last night but hadn't heard him return. Deterred from his criminal intents by the young man's presence, if not his information, Pascoe left.