Read Angels and Absences: Child Deaths in the Nineteenth Century Online

Authors: Laurence Lerner

Tags: #History, #Modern, #19th Century, #Social Science, #Death & Dying, #test

Angels and Absences: Child Deaths in the Nineteenth Century (42 page)

BOOK: Angels and Absences: Child Deaths in the Nineteenth Century
5.69Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
ads
 
Page 107
conventions; so it is natural that we should look for an extra-literarythat is, a biographicalsource for it. But Mary was a young woman, Nell is a child. How important is this difference?
To answer this, it will be best to look first at a similar liminal case in the fiction.
"Come up and be Dead"
The most important link between childhood and death in
Our Mutual Friend
is purely metaphoric. "Come up and be dead," Jenny Wren calls to Riah, the kindly old Jew who has befriended her. Sitting on the roof, far from the squalor by which she is normally surrounded, Jenny sees "the clouds rushing on above the narrow streets," and "the golden arrows pointing at the mountains in the sky from which the wind comes, and you feel as if you were dead" (book 2 chapter 5). Jenny is a pathetic child, crippled, poor, and with a drunken father to support. She does not die, but Mrs. Marcet would have been forgiven for expecting her to, for death seems ever lurking when she appears. She sees her father die, she retreats to a kind of heaven on the roof and refers to it as "being dead," and she is surrounded with the icons of death, especially with flowers and angels. She describes to Eugene how she keeps smelling flowers, though she has seen very few flowers indeed, in her life:
As I sit at work, I smell miles of flowers. I smell roses till I think I see the rose-leaves lying in heaps, bushels, on the floor. I smell fallen leaves till I put down my handsoand expect to make them rustle.
And, as well as flowers, children: but not the children she meets and is mocked by:
They were not chilled, anxious, ragged or beaten; they were never in pain. Such numbers of them, too! All in white dresses, and with something shining on the borders, and on their heads. They used to come down in long bright slanting rows and say all together, "Who is this in pain?"
(Our Mutual Friend
2:2).
These children are easy enough to identify; and although Jenny does not die, I have no hesitation in adding her to the company of Nell and Paul,
 
Page 108
as an example of how inextricably child pathos is associated with death. When she first appears in the novel, Lizzie Hexam describes her with the traditional attributes of the suffering orphan
the Mother is dead. This poor ailing little creature has come to be what she is surrounded by drunken people from her cradleif she ever had one
and the chapter ends with exclamatory pathos:
Poor little dolls' dressmaker! How often dragged down by hands that should have raised her up; how often so misdirected when losing her way on the eternal road, and asking guidance! Poor, poor little dolls' dressmaker (2:2).
This is familiar enough, and there are occasional reminders, as the novel proceeds, that there was "no querulous complaining in [her] words, but they were not the less touching for that"; and like Little Nell she is a natural nurse, as emerges when she sits at the bedside of the injured Eugene and anticipates his slightest need. But this direct pathos is marginalized in the full portrait of Jenny: though a suffering child, she is a variant of the pattern.
The fact that Jenny does not die is both crucial and unimportant. Once again we can turn to Garrett Stewart for some illuminating remarks (though once again they need to be treated with caution) about the contrast between actual death and the luxury of "being dead":
The predication "be dead" is. an exonerating oxymoron, reminding us that we are in the presence not of death and non-being, but of rebirth. You can come up and be dead as often as you like, but one day body will catch up with soul, and then no one, not even yourself, will be able to bring you down and back.
26
This is true; but we could claim that the opposite is true of Nell, whose body has caught up with her soul, but in a way that transforms ordinary death into something very like "come up and be dead." The real oxymoron comes when we juxtapose Jenny and Nell: the character pretending to be dead as a way of coping with the pain of living and the author "pretending" that, turned to an angel, the young girl is not really dead.
Jenny differs from Nell in other ways too. She has, in the first place, much more of the wise child about her. She sees through Eugene's supercilious
BOOK: Angels and Absences: Child Deaths in the Nineteenth Century
5.69Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
ads

Other books

Detroit: An American Autopsy by Leduff, Charlie
Hostage by Kay Hooper
Referendum by Campbell Hart
Vices of My Blood by Maureen Jennings
Hitch by John Russell Taylor
Zeke and Ned by Larry McMurtry
Not After Everything by Michelle Levy
The Devil on Her Tongue by Linda Holeman