Grace felt her skin come apart on the first lash and screamed with pain on the second. On the third she fainted. Later, she was told, her limp body was tied to the pole at her wrists and subjected to another five.
She awoke the next day in agony. It took her a moment to realise the screaming voice floating above her was her own. She tried to roll but her back had scabbed to the bed. She felt cracked hands on her brow. Sister Angela was standing over her, muttering prayers through her ageless toothless mouth and wiping Grace's face with a cool wet cloth. Grace looked away in shame.
âAre you ready to make a good confession, Grace?' the sister asked. Grace was surprised by the kindness in her voice.
âYes, Sister.'
âThen with the grace of God, you might start again. Hold my hand, dear. Squeeze it tight. We need to turn you now.'
The wounds ripped open. Grace screamed and felt the old nun's head pressed close against her own.
âHush, child. Hush. You will get through this.'
âWhy are you being so nice to me, Sister?' Grace asked. The kindness confused her. âAfter what I have done?'
âGod will judge you, not us.' Sister Angela smiled.
âButâ¦but you did judge me. I was whipped.'
âWe must oppose the devil, Grace,' the old woman said. âIf we made it easy for you to give in to temptation we would be doing his work for him. Come now, pray with me before the priest comes.'
âAnd I prayed harder than I'd everâ'
Grace was cut short by shuddering, a reverberation so deep Tristan could sense the centre of it, a knot in her tight frightened stomach. He could smell her fear, or perhaps it was his own. He wriggled, painfully finding her shoulder with his hand. He counted the beats of her heart against the ticking of an imagined clock, willing the pace to slow, and praying it would not end this way. Too late now to understand that prayer was not supplication but desperation.
Whatever had brought the shock was passing. He felt her lips against his cheek as he pressed forward to hear her breathing. Even, no longer panicked.
âI'm all right now. It's passedâ¦' Her voice dropped, as if in apology.
âDid you hate them?'
âWho?'
âThe nuns who whipped you.'
âNo, I didn't hate them. I was young. I believed what they told me.'
âWhat changed?'
âI saw you.'
âYou're laughing at me.'
âI wish I was. It would be easier.'
While the St Augustine's boys were being trained in the skills of logic and oratory, the convent girls were being taught that cleverness was the devil's doing. They grew closer to God not through contemplation but through hard work and humility. They didn't question the point because the nuns were careful to emphasise that questions too were the work of the devil. Whatever Satan's vices, sloth was not amongst them.
Sister Angela, though, was good to her word, and Grace was given the chance to make a new start working in the laundry. The convent earned money taking in washing from the stately homes on the hill. The laundry rooms were thick with steam and Grace ended each shift dizzy with exhaustion. She had no energy for signing with Josephine, even if that were still possible. Grace slept alone now, on a small stretcher at the far end of the dormitory, where she could not infect the other girls with her brush with the devil.
Grace could not define the soulâthe contortions of theology left her boredâbut she knew what it felt like to lose one. Each day without talking to Josephine her insides withered a little more. Grace spent every moment looking forward to the next time she and Josephine might share a secret smile. But the nuns kept special watch on her, and opportunities were few.
As Grace grew hollow with loss, her friend suffered even more. Grace watched Josephine's walk become a shuffle, and her once proud head bow with the weight of sorrow. Each night Grace prayed to be forgiven for the sin of bringing her friend so low. But she kept one secret even from God: the small pleasure she gained from the knowledge that her absence from another's life mattered that much. Selfish pride. Her guilt tightened inside her, but she couldn't admit it, not to God or to herself.
The beginning of the end announced itself with a cough during silent prayers. Grace saw Josephine's narrow shoulders heaving in her attempts to conceal her distress. The next day the coughing was harsher; it played angrily in the throat and reached deep into the lungs. A nun rushed forward and assisted a doubled-over Josephine from the room. It was the last time Grace saw her.
Two days passed without news and Grace's fear turned to desperation. After the evening meal she approached Sister Monica, who had stayed to supervise the cleaning of the plates. The nun looked at her the way you might look down at a dog that has soiled the path before you, calculating whether to make the effort to kick it. Sister Monica waited for the girl to think again and move on but Grace was determined.
âShouldn't you be joining the others at prayers?'
âCan I see her, Sister?' Grace asked.
âWho?'
âMy friend, Sister, Josephine. She was taken sick.'
Sister Monica smiled then, the coldest smile Grace would ever feel.
âThe Good Lord took her this morning, Grace. She is fortunate to have been called so soon.'
Grace fell to the ground, screaming and kicking at the air. It took five nuns and a broken nose to calm her.
The exorcism lasted four days and Grace was barely conscious for most of it. Afterwards she remembered flashes, the smell of incense, the sound of chanting, the cold dripping of holy water on her forehead.
When she recovered, Grace knew only one thing: her friend's death was her punishment. She prayed harder than she had ever prayed, begging God for forgiveness, and for mercy on the soul of Josephine. She imagined her dead friend as an angel with wings and a flowing white gown, her sharp nose always wrinkled in delight and her pale hair, weak and welcome as winter sun, forever glowing.
Grace thought she saw Josephine flitting across the darkened halls. At night, as she fell close to sleep, she believed Josephine sat beside her, signing cold messages on her palm. The holy books left Grace unmoved, with all their death and suffering, but she grew to love the angels.
Grace was only ten years old then, a child capable of believing in the simplest plans. She would work hard and pray even harder, and God would come to love her again and forgive her for her wickedness. When she was older she would be invited to join the convent and she would dedicate her life to the saving of Josephine's wretched soul.
Her good intentions lasted two devout years. During that time she came to know the approval the powerful reserve for the submissive. It might have gone on longer if not for the problem of the people of the night.
Each year on Good Friday the people of the night were permitted to knock at the convent door, a concession made in the name of the prophet's sacrifice. They came to hawk trinkets fashioned from the City's waste. The girls were each given a small amount of money and allowed to purchase one item.
Grace looked forward to that night for months. Everybody did. There was no problem ignoring the rags and stench of the visitors; they'd had plenty of contact with the broken through their charity work and understood such hardship to be part of God's mysterious plan. The girls were used to the quick darting eyes of the children and hardly noticed the sores they suffered. They closed their ears to the pleading whispers that reached up to them, creepers intent on strangling their host.
Good Friday came and Grace handed over her small coins in a spirit of generosity and holiness. This was the one day a year the girls were allowed to feel special and they weren't about to ruin it with a show of misplaced sympathy. She bought a small wire butterfly from a woman with a furrowed face and small, suspicious eyes. It was perfectly formed and Grace imagined the long careful hours spent bending it into shape. Like all the girls, Grace had a special box where she kept her trinkets, but this year she wasn't adding to the pile. Instead she took the tiny sculpture and left it outside Sister Angela's door. The nun had kept special watch over her since the whipping, and it felt good to be able to repay her kindness. Grace decided not to leave a note with the gift. It was enough to imagine the old woman's smile.
The following night Grace was on duty at the front gate. It was a promotion from the laundry, engineered, she suspected, by the same old nun. The work was easier. She simply had to sit beside the locked gate in case someone came knocking. Most nights nobody did and she was left with her dreaming. If anybody did knock the procedure was clear. She was to ask them their name and if the voice that came back was female Grace was permitted to look down on her from the small slit above the viewing platform. She would ask her business, take her name and then tell her to return in daylight hours. Male voices were to be ignored, although after three months of working the gate Grace was still to hear one.
The knock came and Grace stirred from her almost-slumber.
âWho is it?'
âI need your help.'
It was a young woman. Grace climbed the ladder to the platform which ran at height a little above her own head and from there peered down through the slot. Grace could see she was holding something up for inspection. It appeared to be a bundle of rags.
âPlease,' the young woman said. Thick strands of hair framed her sunken face and her eyes were deep with pleading. âMy child is very sick. There is no hope for him out on the plains. You must help me.'
âI am sorry,' Grace replied, repeating carefully the words she had been taught, âyou must come back tomorrow, during the hours of daylight.'
âWe are not allowed in the City in daylight,' the mother replied.
She was one of them, the people of the night. They had no right to knock here. They knew that. Everybody knew that. Grace didn't know where to look, or how to dismiss the woman. Worse than that, she wasn't sure she wanted to. Normally following instructions made Grace feel holy, but there was something about that faceâits desperate darknessâand the dreadful shape of her package.
âPlease,' Grace asked, although she didn't know what it was she was asking. For the mother and her baby to vanish perhaps, for neither of them to have ever existed.
âPlease,' the mother echoed, but with an intensity Grace couldn't match. âHis name is Ronan. If you do not take him, he will die.'
Give me strength, God
, Grace recited silently as she had been taught to do in times of trial.
God, give me strength
.
âI cannot take him,' Grace told the woman. âI am just a girl.'
âThen get someone who can,' the young mother implored.
âIt is not permitted.' Grace felt the words' coldness freeze her throat.
The woman moved back a step, and the light fell on her face. Grace recognised the look in her eyes. She had felt it herself. She understood loss.
âHe is a baby, just a baby. He has done nothing wrong. He deserves to live.'
Grace made the mistake of looking at the child. He was only a few weeks in the world and she saw in his wizened features the old man he would never become. The little boy's eyes opened momentarily and in his exhausted half blink Grace glimpsed the vastness of the human tragedy. She was no more able to understand the world's cruelty than he was, and, like him, she would never recover.