Authors: Franklin W. Dixon
Coach Perotta leaned back in his chair and listened, not taking his eyes from mine. Sometimes he looked surprised, sometimes he looked horrified, but he didn't say anything, and he didn't ask me to stop. When I finished, he sat in silence for a moment.
Then suddenly he sat up and roared, “ARE YOU
KIDDING
ME?!”
I jumped, startled. “Sir?”
He lunged across the desk, pointing a finger in my face. “Do you expect me to believe this hogwash? This elaborate lie?”
“Coach Perotta, why would we lie, sir?” Frank asked, sounding as surprised as I was.
The coach turned to him. “Why would you lie?” he asked. “I don't know. Possibly because my contract is up for renewal this year, and I'm coaching potential state champions? You expect me to believe that it's a coincidence Principal Gerther told me I had to add you boys to the team, and then you
come back with these outlandish stories of
hazing
? Stories I've
never
heard the like of before?”
There was a knock on the door then, and I felt a shudder of relief.
Please, someone come in and break this tension.
I wasn't sure what reaction I'd been expecting the coach to have, but this definitely wasn't it.
“Come in,” Coach Perotta called, and the door opened to reveal Assistant Coach Noonan. From the concerned looks he swept over me and Frank, I got the sense he must have heard Coach Perotta yelling.
“I just came to drop off these stats from the last game,” he said, holding up a manila folder. “Is there . . . something I can help with?”
Coach Perotta dropped his head into his hands and then rubbed his temples with his fingers, like Frank and I had given him the world's worst headache. “Have you ever heard of a hazing problem on our team?” he asked quietly.
Coach Noonan frowned. “Hazing? Like at a college fraternity or sorority?” he asked.
Coach Perotta nodded. “Players being forced to do things they don't want to do, humiliating or painful things, to stay on the team. Have you ever heard of anything like that?”
Coach
Noonan looked at him for a moment, like he might be missing something, then shook his head. “No, never.”
Coach Perotta gestured at us. “Frank and Joe here say they had a very interesting experience with some of our players the other night. Why don't you tell him, boys?”
Coach Noonan looked at me, and I briefly told him the same story we'd just told Coach Perotta.
Coach Noonan paled visibly when I got to the part about the branding.
When I finished, Coach Perotta asked, “Now does that sound familiar at all?”
“No way,” Coach Noonan said. “But if there's any possibility our boys are involved in something like that . . . we'd better have a talk with them, hadn't we?”
Coach Perotta looked nonplussed. “What kind of talk?”
Coach Noonan shrugged. “Well, after the next practice, we can sit them down and make it very clear that no hazing will be tolerated on this team. Anyone caught involved in any hazing will be booted off, no questions asked.”
Coach Perotta nodded slowly. “Yes,” he said after a few seconds, “that sounds reasonable to me. What do you think, boys? If we have a stern chat with our playersâis that enough for you to feel comfortable staying on the team?”
Can a stern talk be enough?
I thought. I remembered Gabe saying he wouldn't wish the hazing he'd gone through on anybody. I remembered the pizza delivery guy saying this was the third time this month he'd found kids with bound hands and feet and bags over their heads in his parking lot.
“All right,” said Frank, and I nodded too.
I guess it's a start.
J
OE AND I DID NOT
return home in the best of moods that afternoon. It was a rare day with no basketball practice and no game, so my plan was to crawl into bed and not get out until seven the next morning.
Instead Dad met us at the door. That was unusual. “Hello, boys. Can we speak in my office for a moment?”
I glanced at Joe. “Um, sure.”
Thus far we hadn't shared any of our basketball-related adventures with our dad. It's not like we were trying to hide anything from him; we just usually try to leave him out of the crazy complications of the cases we take on. Our dad is a pretty well-known retired detective, and Joe and I inherited the sleuthing gene from him. But we've gotten in enough
trouble over the years to realize that the less our family gets involved in our mystery-solving problems, the better.
That doesn't mean our dad doesn't know we solve mysteries. He does. And he tries not to ask too many questions.
But I had a funny feeling that this conversation might have something to do with our current activities.
We followed him into his office and sat down opposite him at his big desk.
“Boys,” he began, “I had my tires slashed today while the car was in the driveway.”
Groan.
“Oh, um, I'm sorry, Dad.”
He looked at me. “And I got a call this morning, Frank,” he said. “It was from a Mr. Porter. Said you'd turned in some ridiculously offensive English paper and got an F and in-school suspension. I told him, that doesn't sound like the Frank I know.”
I felt like I was sinking into the chair. “Um, thanks, Dad.”
He nodded quickly and then looked from me to Joe. “Trouble in this family seems to follow a certain pattern. Can I deduce that you boys are working on a case?”
I sighed.
“We are,” Joe said. “I'm sorry it's affecting you, Dad.”
“I'm not worried about me,” he said. “I just hope you're not putting yourselves at risk.”
That's when we told him the story of everything that had happened to us this week. The weird meeting with Principal Gerther, the night of the masked men, the game, the paper,
and Marianne breaking up with Joe. I told him about our conversation with Coach Perotta, and Coach Noonan's proposal that they talk to the other players.
“A talk?” Dad said. “Do you think that will be enough to stop it?”
“I'm not sure,” I admitted. “I feel like when hazing gets this bad, it takes a lot to put an end to it. And it sounds like it's been a problem for a while.”
Dad nodded, tapping his lip thoughtfully. “When I was in college,” he said, “I decided to try to join the same fraternity your grandfather had been part of. But when I started rush as a pledge, I was stunned by what they wanted the pledges to do. We had to humiliate ourselves, acting as servants to the brothers, making them food, doing their laundry. And there were stories of beatings. . . .” He shook himself, like he was picturing it all now. “I gave up,” he said. “I didn't want to be a member of any club that would do that to its members. But one of my good friends rode it out, and later, when he was a brother, he loved to lord it over me, how amazing it was to be a brother in this fraternity.”
“That's crazy,” Joe said. “He wasn't angry they'd treated him that way?”
Dad shook his head. “Oh no. In fact there's a psychological term for itâthe loyalty you feel for an organization that's mistreated you. It's called cognitive dissonance,” he said. “Essentially, it's your brain's way of dealing with the fact that you've made some odd choices. Instead of being
angry with the people who've mistreated them, people convince themselves that it was all worth it, that they
chose
to experience that punishment in order to get the reward. It's all very strange.”
“Strange indeed,” I agreed.
Dad looked at us sympathetically. “Are you going to stick with the case?” he asked. “You don't have to. Whatever Principal Gerther had in mind, I can't imagine he knew things would get this bad for both of you.”
“We're going to stick with it,” Joe said decisively, and I turned to look at him in surprise. Originally, it was me who wanted to defeat these bullies, and Joe who (maybe sensibly, I realized now) wanted to go back to Principal Gerther and quit. “We can't let this go on,” Joe added. “And I feel like we're getting close now.”
“Just be careful,” Dad suggested. “Try talking to more of your teammates. They know the truth, even if Coach Perotta doesn't. And do talk to Principal Gerther when you can.”
“Good advice, Dad,” I said. “But right now I think I want to crawl into bed and turn off my brain for a few hours.”
Joe pulled out his phone. “Wait until I send Gabe an e-mail,” he said, frantically typing one out.
“Sent!” said Joe, tapping the send button with his thumb.
“Nice job,” I said. “Now, we nap.”
â¢Â â¢Â â¢
I napped hard.
So
hard. I roused myself out of bed when Aunt Trudy shook me and said she'd made lasagna, and then
I ate some lasagna, and then I relocated to the couch in front of
Dancing with the Stars
(don't judge, my mom is into it) and napped some more. I was shaken awake by Mom, who was holding out my phone. “I think you have a call, Frank.”
I struggled to sit up. It was an unfamiliar Bayport number. “Okay. Thanks, Mom.” I swiped right to answer the phone. “Hello?”
“Frank, is that you?”
I struggled to recognize the voice through the layers of sleep that still hung over my brain like a fog. “Uh . . . yes.”
“Max Crandal here.”
Max . . . Crandal.
Oh.
Max
Crandal!
“Hey, Max, what's up? Listen, I'm really sorry I had to bail on the assembly the otherâ”
“Yeah. Yeah, listen, Frank. Did you know there was a practice this afternoon?”
I racked my brain.
Practice?
Oh shoot. Yes. It was Wednesday.
“Omigod, Max. I'm really sorry. I just totally blaâ”
“Frank, listen. I think you're a nice guy and all, but I don't think you're cut out for the B-Sharps. We had this new freshman join this week, his name is Kyle? And he took over your âLion Sleeps Tonight' solo. I just . . . I think he's a better fit for us. Sorry, Frank. Maybe you can try out again next year.”
Click.
He'd hung up.
I stared at my phone.
This is what it feels like when your dream dies.
That's when Joe came barreling down the hallway from his room. “Frank!
Frank!â
”
“In here!” I yelled.
Joe came running in, holding his own phone in front of him. He ran over to the couch and shoved his phone into my face. “Check it.”
The screen showed a text from “Gabe Zimmerman.”
brett is willing to talk to you guys about what happened to him. but we should meet soon before he changes his mind. see you at meet locker in 10?
I jumped up. “Text back âyes,'” I said, fishing for my shoes under the couch. “We can be there in five, even.”
“Way ahead of you,” Joe said, scrolling down on his phone to show his reply:
see you there.
T
HERE WAS NOWHERE TO PARK
in front of the Meet Locker, a local diner and hangout, so I ended up parking down Farragut Alley, this tiny little dead-end street off to the right.
It was nine thirty by the time we parked the car, and the Meet Locker closes at ten. “We'd better hurry,” I told Frank. “We want to have time to hear everything he has to say.”
We jumped out of the car and were heading back out of the alley toward Main Street when suddenly Gabe was standing in front of us.
“Hey!” he said, moving toward us. “Listen, bad news, guys. Brett got cold feet. He doesn't want to hang out in the Meet Locker, in case anyone from the team sees us.”
I stared at him. “Ooookay,” I said. “So, now what?”
Gabe gestured behind us. “His cousin has an apartment over here,” he said. “Just follow me.”
There are no streetlights on Farragut Alley, so keeping Gabe in our sights was a little difficult. We followed him down toward the dead end, and then suddenly a door opened to our right, in one of the nondescript retail buildings. I wasn't aware of apartments being inside, but maybe above the stores . . .
“JOE!” Frank suddenly yelled behind me, but it was too late. A dark shape advanced on us from inside the doorway, and a bag was thrown over my head again. I could hear them doing the same to Frank, too. I felt arms reach out and roughly pull me inside.
“I'm sorry,” I heard Gabe say behind me, just before it sounded like he was grabbed too.
It felt like there were people on either side of me again, and just like before, they forced me down a short flight of stairs. This time I was led over to a chair and told to sit, and then I felt them tying me to the chair at my waist and my ankles. They tied my wrists together too. When the bag was pulled off my head, I was staring into the same scenario as before: a dark room, black light. This time, though, I was sitting next to not just Frank, but a whole row of guys. When I looked closer, I could just barely make out Pete Gruner, Ty Coolidge, and Jayden Speck.
Just like before, a line of masked, robed figures stood before us. But this time there seemed to be even more of them.
The figure in the center moved forward and began to speak.
“Congratulations.”
Like the last time, he was using a voice modulator to disguise his voice. The sound was low and creepyâlike something you'd hear at a haunted house.
“The five of you are the lowest performers on the basketball team. None of you are cut out for basketball. Until you either prove your worth or quit, the harassment will not stop.”
I swallowed and glanced over at Frank.
What form will that harassment take tonight?
I remembered that masked guy advancing on me with the burning-hot pin and felt a shiver run down my spine.