Cutter 3 (7 page)

“CUTTER!” She screamed right before
she came all over my face.

Her pussy tasted like fucking
pineapple.

I licked my lips and jumped up, I
couldn’t take it anymore. I had to feel myself inside of her. I had to take her
in the most personal way possible, she was my pure little angel and I couldn’t
wait to break her in just like the good girl I knew she was.

Every good girl needed to be bad once
in a while; bad just for me.

I pushed her legs apart roughly and
inched closer to her. “It’s time for me to feel how good you’ll feel around my
dick, baby.” I ran my finger back and forth over her slit a few times, getting
it ready for me.

Fear crossed over her face. “Cutter,
no. I need to talk to you.”

“
Shhhhh
,” I
told her, still rubbing on that honeyed flower. “It’s okay, just sit back and
relax, I’m going to take you to a world you’ve never been to before in your
life.” I started to inch forward.

“Cutter! No!” She yelped. “I’ve never…
I’ve never done this before.”

Her words snapped me out of it and I
fell back a few paces, startled. I looked down at my hard cock and her soft
pussy then back up to her wide brown eyes.

And I had thought she couldn’t get any
more perfect.

I had been wrong.

I was going to be her first.

She still owned the most precious gift
she had to offer.

And it was all mine.

Chapter Six

GRACE

I had been terrified to tell Cutter
the truth, so scared that he would think less of me because I had never gone
that far with a man before, but my words seemed to snap him out of whatever
weird trance he had been in since he entered the room minutes earlier.

He looked down at me, his chiseled and
sexy chest beating up and down so fast that I felt like I could feel it from
where I was laying underneath him. He pulled his shirt over his dead and
dropped it, taking my breath away with his perfect body, just like any other
time I got to see it up close.

He leaned down, positioning himself
between my legs and looked deeply into my eyes. “You don’t even know how perfect
you are, Grace.” He pushed a piece of hair behind my ear and kissed me gentle
on my eyelids. “My valuable little flower.”

I could feel his member between my
legs, harder than ever.

“I’m sorry,” I whispered.

He looked shocked. “For what?”

“For not knowing how to do it.”

He shook his head. “I should be the
one thanking you, Grace, for giving yourself to me, completely.” He leaned down
and kissed me on the lips tenderly. “I’m going to make you feel so good, baby.”

He made me feel as perfect as I thought
he was.

He worked his hands down to my legs
and spread me open nice and wide. “Open your legs,” he demanded, starting to
push them apart for me. “Don’t worry I’ll put it in nice and slow at first.”

I knew that I should stop him: I knew
that I should tell him I couldn’t sleep with him. Not because I didn’t want to,
I did more than anything. I’d been waiting for someone special to take my
virginity, someone who I felt like really cared about me. And Cutter made me
feel things I never knew a man would.

But it was wrong like this, with the
promise I had made to his father about giving him a grandson hanging over my
head. I was on edge all the time, worried he would send another brother to
deliver another warning to me. Plus. I didn’t want to lie to Cutter, and while
I wasn’t directly, I was still keeping something from him indirectly.

And even though I knew all those
things, I couldn’t bring myself to stop him. I couldn’t bring myself to pull
away from him and tell him what the hell was going on, I wanted him too much
for that.

And so I lied to myself.

I told myself that it was okay, that
it was my first time, and that there was no way Cutter would cum inside of me
and when we were done I would tell him the truth about everything. When how
damn good this felt had all faded away from my mind.

I spread my legs apart as far as I
could, ignoring my worry and enjoying the thrilling feeling that was coming
over my body. A second later a rush of pain shot through my body as Cutter slid
his huge cock inside of my small inner folds.

“It’s okay,” he said softly, feeling
me tense up. “It’ll only sting for a second.” He thrust himself even deeper
inside of me and let out a little moan. “Fuck, Grace, you’re so damn tight,
baby.”

“That’s good?” I breathed.

“It’s fucking amazing.” He inched
closer to me, sticking the tip of his dick in and out of my pussy over and over
again, each time it hurt a little bit less. “I can feel your tight little pussy
stretching right over my dick, Grace!” He rocked back and forth and looked down
at me. “Fuck!”

The look on his face made me feel
satisfied.

I was pleasing him in the best way.

“I need to put it in further, baby, I
need to feel that pussy all the way around my dick.” He pushed inside of me
deeper, without waiting for my permission.

It hurt. It felt like he was tearing
me apart. “Cutter!” I hit him in the center of his muscular chest, trying to
tell him that it was too much. He needed to pull some out.

He shook his head. “No, stop, it’s
okay. Give it a second.”

I listened to him because somewhere
deep down I knew that I could trust him, even if my insecurities did get the
best of me when it came to him sometimes. And he was right, after a few more
seconds it didn’t hurt as much and inch-by-inch he took me more and more until
he completely emerged inside of my pink pussy.

“Yes, Grace, yes!” Cutter leaned down
and kissed me on the lips. “I have to move now, baby, I have to feel how good
you feel around me.” He started to rock back and forth slowly inside of me,
taking me completely.

Pleasure shot up and down my bones,
Cutter felt so wonderful inside of me, like he belonged there. The initial
thrusts ached but all I could feel now was how magical he made my body feel, I
felt like he was molded just for me. I wanted nothing more than to be his forever.

“Grace,” he gasped. “I’m going to cum,
baby. I’m going to cum all over the inside of your sweet virgin pussy!” He
pumped his hips into me harder and harder, getting off.

“What?” I shook my head. “No! No! You
can’t cum inside of me!”

“I can’t help it, baby!” He kept
going, even faster now. “I need to bust inside of you! I want every drop to be
inside of your perfect body!” His breathing sped up and his eyes looked intense
and lost.

“You can’t!” I panicked. “I’m not on
the pill!”

“I don’t care! You’re mine, that pussy
is all mine, and I want my cum all over it!” He looked down at me and smirked.
A second later he gave one final dig and then I felt his thick white
jizz
all over the inside of my walls. “Yes!” he screamed.
“Yes!”

He came inside of me!

A second later he pulled himself out,
a look of pure lust on his face. “That was incredible.” He leaned down and
kissed me hard on the lips and then rolled over on his back, panting heavily.

I looked down at my stomach.

What the hell had I done now?

Chapter Seven

CUTTER

I grabbed the paper bag out of Blaze’s
hand and shoved it into my pocket then turned around and took a long sip out of
the beer that was sitting in front of me.

“Don’t you want to check and make sure
that it’s right?”

I shook my head. “Hell no, I don’t
want to check that shit.”

Blaze laughed and grabbed the beer out
of my hand. “I’d get it up to her if I were you, you don’t want to mess around
with shit like that.” His tone was filled with warning.

He didn’t need to tell me twice, I was
already in over my head. All I could think about was how good last night was. I
had taken Grace’s virginity and now she was for sure completely mine.

I hadn’t ever had the urge to cum
inside of a girl the way I had last night with Grace. And now that I had done
it, I never wanted to not do it again. Sure, giving her a facial was hot and I
might still do it once and a while but knowing that I could cum inside of her
whenever I wanted to was a whole new high I had never experienced before.

“Have you talked to
Heather
at all?” Blaze asked, snapping me out of it.

I shook my head. “Nope, I tried to
call her a bunch if times this morning and get her to come by the room to talk
but I got no answer. How about you?” I downed the rest of the beer and pushed
the empty bottle across the bar.

“Only once to tell me how she never
wants to hear from me again.”

I chuckled. “She’ll come around.” I
glanced at the screen on my phone, making sure Grace hadn’t texted me, she
seemed just as okay with last night as I was but I was still worried, she’d
really freaked out when I came inside of her. I didn’t see the big deal: no one
got knocked up their first time.

“I hope you’re right.” Blaze shrugged.
“But I can’t let myself think about it right now.” He ran his head back and
forth through his thick black hair. “I need to concentrate on what’s going down
tonight.”

I nodded. “Right, right, but when this
is all over and we have Stone in our possession and hand him over to The
Misfits, I think you should be in charge of guarding my sister for a while.
You’re the only person I trust enough to keep an eye on her. Clearly, no one
else can handle it.”

Maybe having Blaze around would wake
my baby sister up.

Blaze swallowed. “Are you sure it’s
the smartest thing to take me off all my other business commitments right now?”
He had a strange look on his face, the one that he got when he wasn’t sure if
he wanted to do something or not. “It’s just a crazy time.”

“It won’t be once we capture Stone,
then all of this will be over with,” I pointed out. “And everything can go back
to normal, and Grace and me can stop fighting every damn day about what she can
or can’t do.”

Blaze zipped up his black jacket.
“Whatever you want me to do, you know I got you. I just want to get tonight
over with, I need to stay focused,” he paused. “You sure about this?”

“I wouldn’t be doing it if I wasn’t,”
I told him. “Give me a minute.”

Blaze glanced at the clock on the bar
wall. “Okay, but time is ticking.”

I left him there and took the steps upstairs
toward my room three at a time. I had to get this shit to Grace and then get
back down to Blaze so we could get on the road.

I didn’t care what my father or anyone
else had to say.

I knew the committee had voted against
me going but I didn’t care.

Grace was my property, my
responsibility.

Even if it was risky, I had to take
care of her.

And that’s why I was going with my
crew to get Stone.

It was going to be a long night.

***

GRACE

I glanced down at the brown bag Cutter
had just thrown onto the bed. “What’s that?” I looked his body up and down and
tried to not gasp. I couldn’t believe that I had had sex for the first time
less than 24 hours ago and that it had been with someone who looked as good as
Cutter. I felt like the luckiest girl in the whole world.

“Open it and see.” Cutter had his head
inside of his safe, loading and unloading guns and then stuffing them into his
pockets. “Where did I put my knife?” he mumbled to himself.

I picked up the bag and tried to
ignore the worry that was starting to fill my body about where he was going and
what he was doing tonight. I assumed it had something to do with Stone but I
was trying to not ask too many questions and trust his choices like he asked me
to. I pulled out a pouch of pills and looked at him. “Birth control pills?”

He slammed the safe shut and turned
around. “Yeah, I called your doctor and had her write you a prescription then
one of the brothers ran out to pick them up this morning.”

“How did you know who my doctor was?”
I yelped. It was bad enough I had to watch my mom faint yesterday then calm her
down when she woke up, assuring her this was all one big misunderstanding and I
wasn’t involved with the cops, but now Cutter had contacted my doctor, going
even deeper into my personal life.

Cutter shrugged. “Who cares how I
knew? The point is that they’re safe and you can start taking them right now, I
don’t want to have to worry about it every time I want to cum inside of you.
Besides, I can’t have you having a heart attack every time I decide to do it.”
He laughed.

I turned the pills over again and
again in my hands.

Tell him, a voice told me, tell him
now.

“Okay.” Cutter moved closer to me. “I
have to go. I put a guard outside and left you some money in case you need
anything, I’ll be back by tomorrow morning, hopefully.” He leaned down and
kissed me on the head. “Have a good night, Grace.”

“Please be careful,” I whispered.

“I always am.”

And then he was gone, closing the door
softly behind him.

I jumped up from the bed in a panic.
What the hell was I going to do now? If I started taking the pills I definitely
couldn’t get pregnant, if Casper ever found out he would have me killed
instantly.

But if I didn’t take them, I could get
pregnant.

And I’d be lying to Cutter.

I was so stressed out; I hated feeling
this way, so out of control.

Before I had a chance to change my
mind I ran into the bathroom that was attached to Cutter’s room and popped open
the pill packet. I took a deep breath and then dumped the entire pack into the
toilet, flushing it all down the drain.

And then I turned around…

And came face to face with Heather.

*Want to find out as soon as part 4
comes out?
SIGN UP FOR MY MAILING LIST HERE!

*TURN THE PAGE FOR YOUR BONUS STORY!