Dominion (25 page)

The civil rights movement, like the abolitionist movement one hundred years earlier, opposed the exercise of free choice that much of society defended. It was solidly anti-choice when it came to racial discrimination. Historically whites had a free choice to own slaves, and later to have segregated lunch counters. After all, America was a free country. But the civil rights movement fought to take away that free choice from them. Likewise, the women’s movement fought to take away an employer’s free choice to discriminate against women.

Nearly every movement of oppression and exploitation—from slavery to abortion—has labeled itself “pro-choice.” Likewise, opposing movements offering compassion and deliverance have been labeled “anti-choice” by the exploiters.

In reality, the pro-choice position always emphasizes one person’s right to choose instead of the other’s. But what about the
victim’s
right to choose? Blacks didn’t choose slavery. Jews didn’t choose the ovens. Women don’t choose rape. And babies don’t choose abortion.

He pressed the word count button. Only two hundred words, a quarter of the way to a column. He’d have to flesh it out, tie it to some current event of the last few days. He took some comfort knowing how many toes he would step on. But he also hoped maybe he would do some good. Maybe somebody out there would listen.

Clarence and Jake went out to a late lunch at Lou’s Diner, which Jake called “the diner time forgot,” a throwback to the fifties. The owner, Rory—Jake’s friend—waited on them hand and foot, bringing them complimentary mochas after their burgers, as the jukebox played “Under the Boardwalk,” “Stop in the Name of Love,” and an endless parade of old hits. They talked and laughed for forty minutes.

“So, how’s it going with Ollie?” Jake asked. “Sounds like he’s gone out of his way for you.”

Clarence shrugged. “He’s okay, I guess.”

“Okay? Is that all?”

Clarence sat stiffly, saying nothing.

“It’s still the brutality charge, isn’t it?” Jake asked. “Sometimes people get accused of stuff. It doesn’t mean they’re guilty.”

“You think I don’t know that? I’m a black man, remember?”

“Maybe you should forget you’re black,” Jake said, “and just think of yourself as a man.”

“Easy for you to say.”

“Yeah, maybe it is. But maybe it’s still right. You taught me that, Clarence. You used to tell me how much it bugged you that people made skin color such an issue. But lately you’ve been doing it. It’s as though you don’t trust Ollie just because he’s white. And frankly it makes me feel like you must not trust me either. I’m white too, you know”

“Really? I hadn’t noticed.” Clarence smiled.

“Look,” Jake said. “You still haven’t talked to Ollie about the brutality charge, have you?”

“No.”

“Then do it. If you don’t, I’ll ask him to talk to you about it.”

“It’s none of your business.”

“Yeah it is. You’re my brother, Clabern. And Ollie’s my friend. And I’m the one that linked you up—I mean, after you met at Dani’s. It’s my business, all right. You talk to him or I’ll have to.”

“Is that a threat?”

“It’s a promise.”

Clarence drove home brooding. It stung him that Jake didn’t understand his skepticism about the police. Jake’s father hadn’t been beaten by police because of the color of his skin. Jake wasn’t a suspect in every crime committed by someone of his race. He wasn’t pulled over three or four times a year for no good reason.

Clarence recalled some of his tense conversations with Jake during the O. J. Simpson trial. On the one hand, Clarence hated the race-bating. He wrote a column taking on Johnnie L. Cochrane for not just playing the race card but the whole deck. He’d been disgusted and embarrassed when Cochrane told the jury that to show opposition to LAPD’s racism, they needed to acquit O. J. As if whether the evidence indicated Simpson was the killer wasn’t the
real
issue. As if even if he was guilty of murdering two people he should go free because Mark Fuhrman was a racist jerk. As if one man saying the word
nigger
was sufficient reason to acquit another man for two vicious murders.

Clarence couldn’t buy the full-scale conspiracy theory against Simpson that would have involved forty police officers from seven different departments. But unlike Jake, he couldn’t dismiss the possibility of racist conspirators at a smaller level, enough to raise reasonable doubt. Jake had seen it differently. To him, Fuhrman was just one bad apple. To Clarence, it was obvious there were a lot more bad apples in the barrel. Ollie Chandler might be one of them. And the fact he’d come from LAPD and was accused of brutality against a black man gave Clarence cause to believe he was.

Clarence understood Jake’s world much better than Jake did his. When they crowded around their tiny black and white in the sixties, My
Three Sons, Ozzie and Harriet, Donna Reed
, and
Leave It to Beaver
allowed blacks to study the white world. All whites saw of the black world were the caricatures of Amos ’n Andy and Buckwheat and Stymie, and maybe Rochester on Jack Benny. This culture was a white man’s culture, and blacks couldn’t help but learn about white people, while whites could get by knowing almost nothing about blacks.

Just last week Clarence and Geneva had rented the movie
Out of Africa.
It struck both of them how Meryl Streep and Robert Redford were continuously surrounded by black Kenyans on the edges of the screen. The blacks were nothing but props, like the lions and wildebeests and trees. Clarence found himself thinking not about the white central characters, but the blacks in the supporting roles. Who were they? They were people, with families and inner lives and philosophies and theologies and joys and struggles, successes and failures. But they were portrayed as one-dimensional, like the natives surrounding Tarzan, who as one white man in the midst of a jungle full of blacks still managed to be the main character. Black Africans were no more than a backdrop for those at the center of the human drama— European and American whites.

Though he was less than ten in their heyday, Clarence remembered well the Clairol hair-coloring commercials, where they zoomed in for a closeup on a beautiful young white woman whose blonde hair rippled in the wind and captivated the viewer like a bleached version of a Greek goddess. Then a throaty voice affirmed, “Blondes have more fun.” There was no such thing as a blonde Negro. People like him were destined not to have fun.

Clarence hadn’t been around many whites in Mississippi, but he was aware that white people
did
have more fun for at least two reasons—the way they looked and the money they had. The only people in town with convertibles were white. The only blondes were white. The only rich people were white. Black men served the whites as hired laborers, black women as domestics, maids and cooks and house-cleaners and babysitters and such, getting up in the dark, catching two or three city buses to make it to the big houses in time to fix up breakfast. “Livin’ large,” that’s how they described the white lifestyle, and all of them wanted it. Who wouldn’t?

Clarence remembered Mama catching her buses to make it to the Haverstrom’s to care for little Billy, Joseph, and Karen. When Mrs. Haverstrom decided to throw out their old clothes, Mama retrieved them from the garbage. They were Clarence’s best clothes, white kid clothes, white kid jackets. It troubled him now that those clothes had meant so much to him.

He thought of how jealous he used to be of Billy, Joseph, and Karen when Mama showed him the picture of them with her, crowded up close to her as if she belonged to them. They had their own mother, yet all day they received the attention of his mother. Their gain was his loss. Did they ever ask to see a picture of him? He never met these kids. His mama crossed into their world every day. Not once did they cross into hers.

They probably thought she just disappeared at the end of her day, like an image in a Star Trek holodeck. When it was time again, she materialized from nowhere to serve them, a piece of scenery on the stage of their lives, a minor character in the drama of which they were stars, a drama in which coloreds, if they were lucky, only got bit parts as gardeners and maids.

Black people’s hair was a silent testimony to their destiny. People who had fun possessed hair that blew in the wind. Black people’s hair didn’t blow in the wind. Black people’s hair was steel wool. It couldn’t be slung or tossed back out of their eyes— unless they imitated white people’s hair, which dozens of hair care products encouraged them to do, thick greases to tame the nappiness as though it were a wild beast.

Maybe if they acted white and looked white and thought white, maybe then they could have fun. Maybe that’s what he was thinking when he went to the old burn barrel out back and dumped it out and sifted through the white ashes and spread them all over his body. Clarence remembered looking in a mirror and feeling shame when he saw his black skin peeking out from behind the white.

Funny how he could forget the name of someone he met ten minutes ago, but he could never forget the flowing blonde mane of the white Clairol woman and the look and feel of the white ashes on his skin and the picture of the Haverstrom kids with Mama. His mama, not theirs.

He remembered Aunt Greta, his mother’s sister, chastising him and his cousins for their mischief in the chicken coop. “Stop showin’ your color,” she’d said. Whenever they’d go out in public in a white area she’d say, “Don’t go actin’ like niggers, now.”

He remembered how it angered him that when he got a little rowdy it was a federal offense, but it was fine for the white kids to act like niggers.

Lots of white people had called him nigger back in Mississippi and Chicago days. But not nearly as many whites as blacks. Clarence now believed the clearest sign his people had bought into the lie of black inferiority was that they called each other “nigga.” How often would they say, “Get off your black rear end,” as if black was the most demeaning adjective they could think of?

In the black pride days of the early seventies, black skin took on an almost religious significance. His skin color became his primary reference point. He was ashamed of the ash, ashamed he’d tried to look white even for that half hour. And that was the story of black people’s lives, he thought. Ashamed because you’re not white, then ashamed because you wanted to be white, and then ashamed because white people think black people are stupid and incompetent and immoral, and then ashamed because now so many black people believe the same myth about themselves. The immoral myth perpetrated by white racists was like radiation poisoning passing itself from generation to generation. Among many blacks, the effects of racism had become self-perpetuating.

There were two Americas, the white one bright with promise and unlimited opportunity. And the black one, dark with hopelessness. Clarence had fought against the system, overcome it, succeeded as a black man in a white world. He refused to bend either to racism or to the accusations that he was sleeping with the enemy. Yet here he sat, still feeling the shame of the Haverstrom throwaways, the hair grease, the ashes, and being called “nigger” by whites and blacks alike.

When it came to being black in America, Clarence had long ago realized, shame came with the territory So did anger. He wished he could explain all of this to Jake, he
longed
to explain it. But how could he? Where could he find the words? How could he risk the humiliation and rejection? Some things you can’t change. Jake was white. Could he ever understand a black man?