“Gee, I don’t know,” Coon said. “Maybe someone at DOJ tipped Templeton off. Maybe Templeton acted a lot more quickly than the bureaucracy thought possible and they weren’t prepared yet. Have you thought of that? We’re a big agency and we move slow. Someone may have started something that quickly went over their head.”
“They wouldn’t want anyone to know that,” Joe said. “There would be some big-time CYA action going on right now.”
Joe drove on. He could hear Coon breathing on the other end.
“Are you done?” Coon asked.
“I guess so. I’ve got a lot to think about.”
“You do.” Then, with his voice softening, Coon asked, “How’s your girl, Joe? I hear she’s in the same hospital.”
Joe brought Coon up to speed, and told him briefly about the calamity in the courtroom that morning.
Coon said, “It’s a good thing you’ve got Marybeth. If I had all that going on . . . I don’t know what the hell I’d do.”
Joe agreed.
“Chuck,” Joe said before punching off, “please let me know if you hear anything about Nate or Templeton.”
“Not officially,” Coon said. “But I may give you a call from time to time on your cell phone.”
“Thank you.”
“Hang in there, man,” Coon said.
A
pril’s hospital room was dimly lit and quiet except for the muffled hum of the HVAC and an occasional soft click from one of the many electronic monitors hovering over her bed. Thin wires from embedded catheters coiled up from her head. She was being fed intravenously through a tube, and other tubes delivered hydration and medication. Additional tubes carried waste away into receptacles underneath the bed. Because she was so still, it seemed to Joe she was simply serving as a disinterested processing center for the transfer of incoming fluids.
Marybeth was with him when he entered the room and she stood behind him as he approached the bed.
“I haven’t seen her since she left,” he said, reaching out and brushing April’s cheek with the back of his hand. She was battered but sleeping, her expression untroubled. He could not tell from looking at her that she had brain trauma. Her hair was brushed neatly, although the part was wrong. How would the nurses know?
Joe listened as Marybeth explained the procedure the doctors had undertaken, and she pointed out what the readings on the monitors meant. She showed Joe the all-important readout that would indicate an increase—or decrease—in brain activity when she was brought out of the coma.
He found April’s limp hand under the blanket. It was warm but unresponsive.
“I’ve seen her eyelids flutter a couple of times,” Marybeth said softly. “That’s not supposed to happen unless there’s brain activity. But when I asked, I was told the monitors didn’t pick it up. But I swear I saw it happen.”
Joe looked over. He believed her, of course. But he didn’t want to read too much into it.
“She’s got great doctors and nurses,” Marybeth said. “They’ll look out for her. They know to call or text me the minute they determine they want to bring her back, or if her situation changes in any way. I want to make sure I’m here if either happens.”
Joe nodded. He had trouble speaking. His job was to take care of his family, to protect them. He hated it that there was nothing he could do to help April now. Her fate was up to doctors he didn’t know, to April herself, and to God. He could only hope that somewhere in her sleeping body she had the ability and the will to get better.
He leaned down close enough to April that he could smell her hair. It smelled medicinal, not like it used to smell. She belonged to the hospital now. He started to say something, but his throat was constricted.
He rose and took a deep breath. Then two.
After a few moments, he leaned back down to her and said, “I just wish you could wake up and tell me who did this to you. I’ll get the man who did it.”
He hoped against hope for a fluttering of her eyelids or a sign—any sign—of a reaction.
Nothing.
Marybeth reached under the covers and gently placed her hand on Joe’s. She whispered to him, “Don’t you dare lose hope.”
—
I
N THE HALLWAY
,
Joe said to Marybeth, “Do you know where Nate is?”
“They haven’t let me see him.”
“Who told you that?”
She said, “There’s a special agent in charge. Kind of an unpleasant man, if you ask me. I know there are rules about only family members in ICU, but . . .”
“Is his name Stan Dudley?”
“He didn’t introduce himself.”
Joe said, “Let’s go find him.”
—
S
HRI
R
ECKLING
had just come on the night shift and she agreed to help them. She used her key card to open the secure ICU door. When the nurse on duty looked up to see three people come into the hallway, Reckling said, “It’s okay. They’re with me.”
“We’re here to see Nate Romanowski,” Joe said.
Before the ICU nurse could respond, a portly man in an ill-fitting suit leaned out from the waiting lounge and said, “Forget it. He’s back in surgery again. Patching this guy up just so he can die in a couple of days is going to bust my budget.”
Joe said, “You must be Stan Dudley.”
Dudley looked Joe over carefully, from his lace-up outfitter boots to his Wranglers to his red uniform shirt and weathered Stetson. He said, “And you must be Joe Pickett.”
“I’m Marybeth,” she interjected, stepping forward.
“The two of you, then,” Dudley said. He seemed to be contemplating what he’d say next. Then: “Well, it doesn’t really matter that you’re here, because there’s no chance to see Romanowski. They took him back into surgery about half an hour ago. More internal bleeding, I guess. He hasn’t regained consciousness and he hasn’t said a damned word since we found him. It wouldn’t do anybody any good to try and see him now anyway. The doctors won’t let you into the room.”
Joe said, “I hope their bedside manner is better than yours.”
Dudley puffed out his chest. “I don’t sugarcoat things. I’m a straight shooter.”
“I think you’re an ass,” Joe said.
Marybeth shouldered past Joe and stood in front of him so he couldn’t advance on Dudley.
Her voice was calm. “How long will he be in surgery?”
Dudley shrugged. “Your guess is as good as mine. He’s been in there twice already. The doctors removed something like seventeen hunks of buckshot. There are a couple near his heart they may just leave there because it’s too dangerous to try and get them. Plus, he lost a lot of blood. One more hour of him lying in the dirt on that ranch and we wouldn’t even be talking here right now.
“So,” Dudley said, gesturing with his hand at Joe and Marybeth as if shooing them away, “you two should just scoot on out of here. You can’t see him, and he’s not likely to ever sit naked in a tree again, or whatever it is he supposedly does for fun.”
“Not so fast,” Joe said, lowering his voice.
“Come again?” Dudley said, glancing back inside the lounge, where, Joe guessed, there were a couple of backup agents.
“Who bushwhacked him?” Joe asked.
“Your guess is as good as mine,” Dudley said. “But my guess includes the name Templeton.”
“How would he know Nate would be there?”
“The guy probably has his tentacles in everything,” Dudley said. “Somebody must have tipped him off. But I do know who could probably answer that question. Do you know Olivia Brannan?”
Joe heard Marybeth gasp in front of him and saw her raise her hand to her mouth.
“I know that’s your theory,” Joe said. “But it doesn’t wash.”
“So where is she?” Dudley asked with a forced grin. “She picks him up, takes him to that ranch, and vanishes off the face of the earth. It isn’t a stretch to guess she colluded with the shooters.”
Joe shook his head.
“Do
you
know where she is?” Dudley asked. “Does anybody? She wasn’t at the scene, and her and her van are AWOL.”
Marybeth said, “She’s head over heels for Nate, and he feels the same way about her.”
“She devoted years of her life to working for Wolfgang Templeton,” Dudley countered. “She’s known Romanowski for what—six months?”
“I’m not buying it,” Joe said. But his mind was spinning because it made sense.
“Maybe we can ask her,” Dudley said. “If she can
ever be found
.”
—
L
ATER
,
AS
J
OE
’
S PICKU
P
rose above the rimrocks that defined Billings and the dark prairie was stretched out in front of them, Marybeth said, “If both April and Nate are taken away from us . . .”
Joe said, “Don’t you dare lose hope.”
—
A
S THEY CROSSED
the border back into Wyoming, Joe’s cell phone lit up. Dulcie Schalk.
“Hello, Dulcie,” he said.
He could tell by her long pause that bad news was coming.
She said, “Tilden Cudmore hanged himself in his cell. They found his body an hour ago.”
Joe tapped his brakes so he could pull over to the shoulder of the highway. Marybeth studied his face. Joe repeated what he had just heard, and Marybeth closed her eyes.
“How did it happen?” Joe asked, holding the phone away from his face and punching the speaker button so Marybeth could hear the conversation as well.
“He used a bedsheet for a rope and he tied it to the light fixture,” Dulcie said.
“Where were the deputies?”
“We just interviewed them. They checked on him at eight-fifty p.m. and he appeared to be sleeping in his bunk. When they went back in at five past nine, he was dead. They did CPR on him when they cut him down, and the clinic tried to revive him, but he was DOA.”
Joe said, “He didn’t seem like the kind of man who would do himself in.”
“I agree,” Dulcie said. “Otherwise, we would have put him on a suicide watch. You just never know what’s going on in a man’s head. Especially that man’s head.”
“Is it possible someone got to him?” Joe asked.
She sighed. “No. It’s all on videotape. He waited until the deputy left the cell and he jumped up and went to work. No one was watching the monitor at the time he did it. So, no. He killed himself.”
“His guilt got to him,” Marybeth said. “Or he was a coward who couldn’t face jail.”
“I’m guessing the latter,” Dulcie said. Then: “Marybeth, I’m sorry I had to call you with this news.”
Marybeth said, “Don’t be. I would have gladly handed a rope to the man who assaulted April.”
“That’s one way to look at it,” Dulcie said. “I’d rather have sent him to Rawlins, but in a sense, we’ve got justice—just not the kind I prefer.”
After a pause, she asked, “So how
is
April?”
Joe turned off the speaker and handed the phone to Marybeth.
While Dulcie and Marybeth talked, he eased the pickup back out onto the highway.
He could not have predicted this turn of events. It was not at all satisfying to him. He couldn’t get over the fact that he wasn’t sure justice had been served at all.
Cudmore was a creep and a paranoid conspiracy theorist. The evidence was stacked against him. The things he had said and done at the arraignment hearing had almost convinced Joe he was capable of beating and dumping April. Dulcie obviously believed Cudmore had done it. Marybeth seemed to think the same thing.
Joe wasn’t so sure. And he couldn’t reach out to Nate for help because Nate was dying.
T
wo days later, Liv Brannan looked up when she heard the heavy oncoming footfalls approach the root cellar from outside. She’d come to recognize the day-to-day routine.
It was dinnertime on Friday night, March 21. It was her thirty-third birthday, but she didn’t plan on telling anyone about it because she knew they wouldn’t care. When a single tear leaked out of her left eye, she violently wiped it away.
She sat on a rickety hard-backed chair near the air mattress and a mass of rumpled sleeping bags. It was the only chair available.
By the looks of it, the cellar had been dug into the earth many years ago, probably before the motley collection of houses, double-wide trailers, and metal buildings had been assembled above ground. She’d seen glimpses of the compound through a tiny gap at the bottom of her blindfold when they brought her here after the shooting. There were old trucks and cars rusting in a field, a pack of dogs that had rushed out to greet the Suburban, and stray chickens in the yard. Elk, moose, and deer antlers whitened by age and sun covered the entire side of an old clapboard barn. She thought:
White trash.
By the glow of a utility light that hung from a slit in the double doors, she’d studied every inch of the root cellar. She didn’t have anything else to do except reread the dozen magazines—
American Hunter
,
National Enquirer
,
Taste of Home
—they’d left for her. Someone had torn off the address labels on the front of each one so she wouldn’t know who the subscriptions were for—or the address they’d been sent to. All she knew was that the compound was about an hour from the HF Bar Ranch. She had no idea which direction they’d come from, and she hadn’t seen which roads they had taken, because she hadn’t been allowed to get off the floor of the second row of seats in the SUV until they arrived. She knew they’d been on gravel roads, asphalt, and finally a rutted dirt road that was a bruiser.
The walls of the cellar were hard dry clay. It had been dug by hand tools and she could make out the pick marks. Webs of dried roots reached out of the walls like gnarled hands. Several rows of empty shelving covered each wall, no doubt where someone used to store canned vegetables or jam. She’d heard that people out here used to can trout and wild game in Mason jars as well. The shelves were held up by rusted metal L-shaped braces. She’d tried to pull one out, but it was stuck fast. She’d continue to try to get one free because it was the only thing she had that could possibly serve as a weapon.
Plotting her escape was better than crying to herself. Liv was cried out.
The other items in the cellar—the blankets, the ancient thick sleeping bags lined with deer and elk montages that were no doubt used in a hunting camp, the humming electric space heater, the five-gallon white bucket that served as her toilet, the case of bottled water—were harmless.
—
T
HE HASP WAS THROWN
on the double doors twelve feet above her. The left door was opened, then the right. The particular smell of the place—the mixture of spilled diesel fuel, manure, and sage—wafted down from outside. She could see a square of pure blue sky.
“Stand back,” the man said. “I’m puttin’ the ladder down.”
Liv stood and moved the chair, then retreated to the wall in back of her as the aluminum extension ladder was lowered until the feet were solidly on the floor. She looked up as the opening filled with the shoulders and head of a man. He wore a cowboy hat with sharp upturned side brims like he always did, and he appeared to be grinning.
“
There
you are,” he said finally. “It took me a minute to see where you were.”
“I’m here,” she said.
“I got your supper.”
He backed off for a second and then reappeared. His cowboy boots descended rung by rung. His back was to her as he came down, but he had his head turned so he could watch her and make sure she didn’t try anything. He steadied himself with his left hand on the rail. A black feed bucket with a small quilt over the mouth of it hung from his right.
“You’ve got a hell of a treat coming your way. Fried chicken, corn on a cob, rolls, butter, and salad with Thousand Island dressing,” he said.
When he got to the bottom, he turned. He was big, with wide shoulders and a barrel chest. His head was blocky and he had a lantern jaw and small, close-set eyes. As always, he had her Smith & Wesson Governor tucked into the front of his jeans and an electric hot-shot, designed for livestock, sticking out of his back pocket. She knew he wouldn’t hesitate to use it on her if he felt the need. Or maybe just for fun.
She could smell the aroma of fried chicken from the bucket.
“How long are you going to keep me down here?” she asked. “It gets really cold at night.”
He snorted and pointed at the space heater that glowed red.
“It doesn’t exactly keep it toasty in here.”
He said, “I woke up once in the woods with five inches of snow on me. This ain’t so bad.”
“It is for
me
.”
He shrugged. “That ain’t my call.”
“Whose call is it?”
“Why do we have to get into all this again?” he said. “Can’t we ever just have a nice conversation? Why do you always have to be so feisty?”
“
I’m in a hole in the ground
. What if it rains or snows?”
“That’s why we put them blankets down here, I think.”
“What if it rains hard and this cellar fills with water?”
“Yeah, well,” he said after a long pause. As if he really had to think that over, she thought.
“Why did you kill him?”
“I just do what I’m told to do for the good of the family. It wasn’t nothing personal. Mom always says we gotta cover all the bases.”
Those were the same words he’d used when she’d asked him the last time. The same words he used every time she asked.
“
‘Cover all the bases’?
What does that even mean?”
He shrugged again and said, “She’s always thinking a few steps ahead of everybody else. I don’t even try to outguess her on this kind of thing.”
“Are you sure he’s dead?” she asked.
That made him think. It was as if he’d never even considered the question.
He said, “We hit him with three full loads of buckshot. That’d kill any man.”
“Nate’s not any man. He’s a good man. And he was unarmed.”
“Yeah, I know,” he said. Then: “Why was that? Why didn’t he have that famous gun of his on him?”
“The feds took it away.”
“Damned feds anyway,” he said. “That’s what they’re tryin’ to do with all of us—take away our guns. That’s what your president wants to do.”
Liv said, “Why is he
my
president?”
He reddened. “You know. Jeez, it seems like everything I say makes you mad.”
“I’m in a hole.”
“Could be worse,” he said.
“What did you do with the van?”
“We took care of it.”
“What’s that mean?”
“It’s okay if you don’t eat it all,” he said, lowering the bucket to the floor. “I noticed you don’t eat everything I bring you. That’s probably why you’re so skinny.”
She sighed.
“Man, that chicken smells good, don’t it?” he said, nudging the black bucket with his boot tip. “I bet you can’t wait to dig into that.”
“Why?” she asked. “Because that’s what my people eat?”
“Shit, that ain’t what I meant,” he said, looking down for a second. “Me, I love fried chicken, and as you can see, I’m a white man. Mom makes it once a week, on Friday night, and I always make sure I’m around. It’s my favorite thing. I usually eat six or seven thighs.” He paused. Then: “I’m a thigh man. I love that dark meat.”
“There you go again,” she said.
When he looked up, this time he wasn’t embarrassed at all, and she realized he’d meant to say it. He’d probably been practicing it to himself on his walk over from the main house. He probably thought he was clever.
“Oh,” she said, sickened by the realization, but trying not to show it. She refused to show him weakness.
Above, Liv heard a door slam shut in the distance, then a woman shout.
“Bull? What are you doing down there?”
The man rolled his eyes and boomed, “No names, Cora Lee!”
He looked at Liv and shook his head as if he expected her to agree with him what a dolt Cora Lee was.
“Bull and Cora Lee,” Liv said. “So was that your mother I met at the ranch?”
“Quit asking me all these damned questions,” Bull said, irritated. She couldn’t tell if he was angry at her or at Cora Lee. Or both.
“Bull!”
Cora Lee shouted. “We’re all fuckin’ waiting on you to eat! You’re supposed to lower that bucket down to her. You ain’t supposed to deliver it like you was fuckin’ room service.”
“She’s got a mouth on her,” Bull said as an aside to Liv. “And she could probably afford to miss a few meals, if you know what I mean.”
Liv forced herself to grin. She could tell he liked that.
“Bull, goddamnit!” Cora Lee yelled.
“I’m coming!” he yelled back. “I’m coming.”
Before he climbed back up the ladder, he asked, “You need anything?” His tone was much gentler than the one he’d used to answer Cora Lee.
“Yes. Let me out of here.”
“Very funny,” he said with a chuckle.
He climbed to the top. She heard Cora Lee say, “Jesus, man. There you are. Hurry the fuck up.”
“Shut up, Cora Lee,” Bull said as he pulled the ladder up and swung the doors closed and locked them.
—
T
WO HOURS LATER
,
the footfalls came back. Lighter this time, but not much.
Instead of Bull, it was Cora Lee. Liv recognized her by her voice.
“I’m doin’ the shit run,” Cora Lee said, dropping the coil of thin rope to the floor. It nearly hit Liv. “Tie it on your feed bucket first. Then I’ll drop it back down for the chamber pot.”
While Liv bent down to fix the rope to the black bucket handle, Cora Lee said, “What is it you and Bull was talking about for so long?”
“I wasn’t the one talking,” Liv said.
“Goddamn that man,” Cora Lee said under her breath. “You just stay the hell away from him.”
Liv looked up, exasperated. “I’m not the one coming down the ladder.”
Cora Lee narrowed her eyes. She was a sturdy, rough-looking blonde. She looked like she’d lived hard. Liv could see where she had once been pretty, twenty years and fifty pounds ago. Now, though, she had a weathered face set in a scowl.
“Tell them to let me go and I’ll never breathe a word of this to anyone,” Liv said.
“Like I’m gonna believe that,” Cora Lee said, untying the feed bucket and setting it aside. She dropped the rope back down. “Now your shitter.”
As Cora Lee hoisted the white bucket, it thumped on each rung of the ladder. Liv retreated to the far corner of the cellar before any of the contents could splash out and hit her. A few foul drops stained the floor near the feet of the ladder.
“Oh, sorry,” Cora Lee said, not sorry at all.
Liv heard Cora Lee empty the bucket on the ground a few steps away from the cellar door, then she returned to lower it back down.
“Would you mind rinsing it out first?” Liv asked.
“Yeah, I mind,” Cora Lee said. “I gotta get myself ready. Me and Bull are goin’ to town later.”
Liv thought,
His name again
. Either Cora Lee was especially stupid or she knew Liv would never have the chance to identify them to anyone.
So there were four of them at least, Liv thought to herself. Bull and his wife, Cora Lee. A man—the father?—called Eldon. She knew that name because she’d heard Cora Lee call to him a day ago. Eldon had responded with “No names!” and Liv could picture him pointing toward the root cellar in the distance. At other times, though, she could hear conversations between family members where they seemed to either have forgotten about her or didn’t think she could overhear. Or they just didn’t care, like Cora Lee.
She’d heard a couple of references to someone named Dallas, but she’d not heard Dallas speak for himself. Either Dallas was away or he’d not left the house.
Then there was the mother. The woman who “covered all the bases.” The woman who originally claimed she was Kitty Wells. Liv cursed herself for falling for that. Kitty Wells had been a country singer back in the fifties and sixties. Liv’s mother used to sing “It Wasn’t God Who Made Honky Tonk Angels”
around the house, and she sang it better than Kitty Wells.
Liv hummed,
Too many times married men think they’re still single
And that’s caused many a good girl to go wrong.
Her head snapped up when she recalled the lyrics. Maybe, she thought, she had a weapon after all.
She was still thinking it through later that night when she realized it had become remarkably colder in the cellar, and the outside seemed oddly hushed. Only when a few rivulets of precipitation trickled down the clay walls did she know it was snowing.