Foreplay (4 page)

offending fabric down her hips.

“Not comfortable enough,” he growled as he

yanked them off her feet. Spreading her legs wide and

hooking them over his shoulders, Connor dove

between them, and, in the eroticism of the moment, all

rational thoughts disappeared.

CHAPTER TWO

How the fuck had she ended up with her legs

spread and one of the two handsomest men she‟d ever

seen between them, tonguing her pussy like there was

no tomorrow? And how did the other of the two

handsomest men she‟d ever seen end up doing the

tonsil tango with her while all that pussy tonguing was

going on? Lilly was sure she‟d died and gone to Hell.

Heaven surely wouldn‟t allow this!

Well, if she really had given up her soul, the two

devils she was surrendering to were definitely worth

the pain later. She‟d dreamed about this for longer

than she cared to think about, and now it was finally

happening. She might kick them out later, but she‟d

always have a silly grin on her face whenever she saw

them. Besides, ditching them first was a sight better

than thinking they might simply be using her for a

quick romp. If she were honest, she was probably

already half in love with them, which kind of scared

the shit out of her. Not that she‟d let them see either

her fear or her love.

The things Connor was doing between her legs

left her breathless, and Caleb kissed her like she‟d

35

Foreplay

always longed to be kissed. They both made her feel

like they were starving men and she was the feast.

It wasn‟t simply about having two lovers —which

was definitely a first for her—but the sounds they

made. These men did not show their feelings

frequently. With the exception of the times he teased

her, Connor kept his feelings under wraps. Caleb hid

his emotions with humor. Neither of them let anyone

see the real men beneath. In fact, no one could even

tell the two of them apart unless they wanted them to.

Except her.

Then it hit her. There was more to this than

simply scratching an itch. Determined to let it play out

as it would and to simply enjoy the moment, Lilly let

them play with her body. The pleasure built within her

like nothing she‟d ever experienced, and she knew no

other man would ever be able to elicit this kind of

response from her. It was like lightning coursing

through her body, zinging from limb to limb and

making her hair stand on end. Her whole body tingled

and buzzed, just begging for release.

A storm was brewing within her. A fire tried to

burn out of control and consume her with an unholy

heat. These men corrupted her with the sweetest sinful

pleasure, and she welcomed it with opened arms.

36

MARTEEKA KARLAND

Caleb finally tore his mouth from hers, and Lilly

hissed at him. He roared, “Enough! Get up, Connor! I

want inside her.”

“But I thought we—”

“Change of plan. I‟m absolutely not waiting until

we get her home. I want her now.” He turned to Lilly,

his eyes so full of lust and wild, untamed love she had

to grin. “I want you now, Lilly.”

Careful not to whack Connor in the head with

her foot, Lilly swung her leg to the floor and stood. She

whipped the sweater over her head and stood before

them naked and proud. “Where, exactly, do you want

me?”

Caleb‟s fierce expression immediately softened,

replaced by a lopsided grin Lilly had grown to love

over the years. He sat on the couch and opened his

arms. Lilly moved toward him, but stopped next to

Connor first and pulled him to her for a deep kiss. She

loved the way he tasted. Even through her own

intimate moisture, she could taste the woodsy musk

she‟d always associated with him as a scent.

Underneath it all was a slight hint of mint and

cinnamon. She found it addictive.

After only a few seconds, she pulled herself away

and turned her attention back to Caleb. Dropping to

her knees, she unzipped his jeans and pulled out his

very hard cock. She wanted to study it. Memorize it.

37

Foreplay

But she figured there would be plenty of time for that.

Besides, she was impatient. The quicker she got him

undressed, the quicker she could get him inside her.

He raised his hips to help her peel his jeans

down his hips and legs. Once she got them off, she dug

into his back pocket. Sure enough, the condom

wrapper teased her fingers as she dug it out.

She raised an eyebrow. “Taking a bit for granted,

aren‟t you?”

“Not in the least.” He didn‟t hesitate at all in his

response. “I was a Scout as a kid.
Always Be Prepared

was our motto too.”

Lilly chuckled as she moved between his legs

and ran her hands lightly up the column of his thighs.

The hair-roughened skin abraded her palms erotically,

and she was thankful they were both all man. No

smooth, girly skin for these two. She‟d definitely know

it was a man in her bed in the dark.

With a happy sigh, Lilly took him in her mouth

as deeply as she could and pulled slowly upward. Once

was it, though. Caleb shuddered and groaned, pulling

her up by her hair and snatching the condom pack

from her fingers as he did. “Sweet mother of God! Give

me that thing and let me get inside you, woman.”

Musical laughter filled the tiny room as Lilly

straddled him. Caleb ripped the packet open and

sheathed himself before probing her opening with his

38

MARTEEKA KARLAND

cock. Her laughter disappeared to be replaced by an

excited whimper when his length disappeared inside

her.

Lilly arched her back and offered her breasts to

him, which he took eagerly. Caleb took one ripe peak

into his mouth and sucked. Wrapping his tongue

around her nipple several times, he milked sighs of

pleasure from her that Lilly gave up willingly. He

didn‟t stop until she pushed him back to grab the hem

of his shirt and whip it off. Her fingers danced over his

chest, and Caleb couldn‟t help but flex a bit, giving her

a great view of his pecs and abs.

“Relax there, Caleb.” She‟d almost forgotten

about Connor, though how she‟d managed that was

beyond her. Now his presence was almost

overwhelming. They both were. “She‟s impressed. You

don‟t have to puff up like a blowfish.”

Lilly couldn‟t help her nervous giggle. She even

jumped when Connor kissed her shoulder.

“Nervous?” He whispered his question next to

her ear, just like he always did. It served to ground

Lilly more than anything else ever could.

She took a breath and looked back at him over

her shoulder. “No. Not with the two of you.”

That seemed to please Connor greatly judging by

his expression. “Good. We want you excited, not

scared.”

39

Foreplay

“You two have never frightened me—everyone

else, maybe, but not me.”

“Just another reason why we‟re so infatuated

with you.”

Caleb started to move slightly inside her, urging

Lilly to move with him. It felt good. Better than good.

She moved fluidly with him, slowly and leisurely as if

they had all the time in the world. Connor kissed her

shoulder, her back, her waist. It was thrilling to say the

least. Every nerve ending she had was on high alert.

These two men stimulated her beyond anything she‟d

ever known or thought to know.

Lilly hadn‟t realized her eyes had drifted closed

while she enjoyed the pleasure until something rested

lightly on her lip. She opened her eyes to find Connor‟s

finger tracing the seam of her lips.

“Open up, Lilly,” he whispered again. “Let me

in.”

She did. Her tongue snaked out and swirled

around his fingertip like she had Caleb‟s cock. Caleb‟s

fingers tightened on her ass and urged her to move

faster while she sucked his brother‟s finger.

“That‟s it, sweetheart. Get it good and wet. I have

plans for it…and you.”

Lilly did as he‟d commanded. She always did.

Looking back, it was funny. She didn‟t normally take

orders well—not even from Caleb—but from Connor, it

40

MARTEEKA KARLAND

was almost as if she were compelled. It just seemed

natural.

She let his finger go with his slight withdrawal,

making sure the digit was coated with her saliva. It

didn‟t take a rocket scientist to figure out what he

intended. Sure enough, a few seconds later, his finger

gently probed her ass. One finger entered her slightly.

He twirled it around the opening several times before

retreating only to plunge in again, this time deeper.

Several times he repeated the process with one finger,

then two. The second finger burned slightly, but Lilly

found it only enhanced her pleasure. Made it naughty.

As if what they all were doing wasn‟t naughty enough.

Once, when he retreated, he didn‟t immediately

plunge back into her. When he did return to her ass,

his fingers were cool and very slick. Lilly looked to the

side as he pitched the small bottle of lube away and

continued to caress her on the inside.

Caleb kept his movements easy and slow. It was

as if he were waiting for them all to be together to

share this first experience. Lilly agreed. Still, she

couldn‟t help calling them out on it.

“Lube, too? What is it with the two of you

thinking I‟m easy?”

Their warm chuckles gave her a wicked thrill.

She loved the way the two of them sounded. Caleb‟s

41

Foreplay

chest vibrated, tickling her front while Connor kissed

one cheek of her ass.

“Believe me, Lilly—” Caleb kissed her mouth

once. “There‟s nothing easy about you. You‟re

probably the only woman who could resist our charm.

You keep us honest. Besides that, we need you.”

“We only hope we can convince you that you

need us as well.” Connor nibbled her earlobe. Lilly

heard the condom wrapper being torn and knew he

was covering himself. Seconds later, the blunt tip of

his cock pressed against her ass. She pushed out

against him, and he slid easily inside. The feeling of

both men seated inside her was magical. Her whole

body came alive and tingled with an orgasm ready to

burst through the surface.

Then they began to move.

Caleb flexed his hips upward, gripping her ass

and pulling her cheeks apart. Connor moved slowly,

easing in and out of her with measured thrusts,

obviously careful not to hurt her. It warmed Lilly‟s

heart, but she was ready for more. She tried to slam

her hips down, but she found it hard to control the

tempo from this angle. If she arched her back too

much, she ran the risk of hurting Caleb. If she didn‟t

arch enough, Connor would slip out of her. Her lack of

movement was painfully frustrating, but allowed the

pleasure to build to almost a fever pitch.

42

MARTEEKA KARLAND

Sweat beaded on Lilly‟s skin, and she moved

with the two men fluidly. Her sighs and gasps were

wrung from her with little effort on their part, and

Lilly was convinced they‟d been inside her head, living

out every fantasy she‟d ever had about the two of

them. Their groans and growls were music to her ears,

and their possessive touches inflamed her like never

before.

Caleb latched on to one breast when she threw

her head back, and Lilly screamed. Connor found her

neck with his lips, and both men sucked her sensitive

flesh as they fucked her. With a ferocity she‟d never

experienced, Lilly‟s orgasm built within her, then three

strokes later, it happened.

Pleasure burst within her, centered at the places

where her body joined the bodies of her men. Lilly

pushed through it, grasping for every tingle and every

pulse of orgasmic bliss. Even her fingers tingled.

The men groaned and murmured their

encouragement, but Lilly couldn‟t understand them

for the roaring in her ears. Her breath came in short

gasps as her lungs seized along with the rest of her

body. Finally, the pleasure started to ebb, but she