Fresh Kills (32 page)

“You need a woman?” I broke in. “Why?”

“Because Davia Singer is the lead lawyer for the prosecution,” he replied. “She's young, ambitious, a tiger on cross—and she looks great in a tailored black suit.”

“Which is one thing I've never been known to wear,” I countered. “If you're trying to answer femininity with femininity, I'm not your woman.”

“Cass, I'm not asking you to be anything but yourself; I just don't want to present the image of a big, tall man pushing Davia around the courtroom.”

“Whereas if I push her around, the jury thinks it's a fair catfight?” A nice double bind; if he said no, he'd be lying. If he said yes, he'd brand himself a sexist.

This time the smile was genuinely amused. “You've got it.”

I smiled back. His deep blue eyes connected with mine and a surge of sexual energy filled my body. God, he was good-looking, full of masculine power.

I was glad I'd dressed. The silk felt sensual next to my skin, and I knew the teal blouse and brightly colored vest looked good on me. I rested my chin on my hands and gazed into his hypnotic eyes, pretending if only for a moment that the night might end in bed, that his manicured hands might unbutton my blouse and reach inside to unhook my Victoria's Secret bra.

It wasn't going to happen. His eyes might have a spark of sex in them, but his words were all business.

“Cass, Nick Lazarus would give his left nut to see me convicted and disbarred. He's had a hard-on for me ever since my first Scaniello trial.” I had to smile; the phallic images only served to confirm my earlier notion that the bull elephant wasn't about to ask a rival bull to stand up for him in court.

I started a checklist in my head. One column was headed
Take the Case
; the other said
Hell, no
. I put a great big check mark in the
Hell, no
column; I didn't want a client who'd hired me on the basis that I wasn't a man.

I spoke a truth I'd known for a long time, but had never said aloud, at least not to Matt. “Lawyers like you have a limited lifespan,” I remarked. “Like dancers.”

I looked down at my plate, at the sea of virgin olive oil and the stray linguine strands and the one lone clam. I decided what the hell and stabbed the clam with a fork.

“You had to know it would happen someday,” I pointed out. “You had to know the prosecutors couldn't stand to lose all the time, that one day they'd come after you the same way they came after your clients. The question is, did you do anything that would give them the ammunition they need?”

“You mean, did I sit around the Ravenite Social Club and discuss taking out a hostile witness?” he countered. His tanned face reddened as he spoke; the words collided with one another as they left his lips. “You mean, did I accept fees in cash handed to me on the street in a paper bag? Did I act as go-between in a drug deal?”

“Look, Matt, everything you've just mentioned was done at one time or another by a lawyer who swore up and down he was just representing his clients,” I shot back. The one constant in our relationship was that I was determined not to be bullied. In the past, he'd always liked that about me; it was one reason he was considering putting his future in my hands. “I know you're not dumb enough to do those things, but did you do anything that might have blurred the line between acting as counsel for Mob clients and getting on the payroll?”

“I am not a Mafia lawyer,” he pronounced, as if speaking for the record. “I have represented some clients who've been accused of—”

“Save it for the next time you're on
Charlie Rose
,” I cut in. All thoughts of date behavior were forgotten. He'd come to me for some kind of truth, and he was going to get it, whether he liked it or not. “The last time out, Lazarus managed to get you bounced off a Frankie Cretella case on the grounds that you were, and I quote, ‘house counsel to organized crime.' True or not, Judge Schansky bought it and the Second Circuit affirmed. That decision set the stage for this indictment; it served notice that you were no longer immune by virtue of having a law degree.”

Matt reached for the after-dinner brandy he'd ordered. He lifted the snifter to his nose and swirled the liquid around. I could smell its potent aroma from my side of the table. He took a bigger sip than I would have. Then he took another.

He'd had a Scotch in front of him when I'd arrived, and since I was late, I doubted it was his first. Together we'd finished a carafe of Chardonnay, with him drinking three glasses to my one. Now he was plowing through the brandy.

The Matt Riordan I'd known had liked his liquor, but he'd always, always limited his intake. He was a man who needed to be in control the way other men need to surrender to the oblivion of intoxication. I'd never seen him drunk, never even seen him slightly tipsy.

Until tonight. Tonight the spider veins in his nose stood out like a roadmap. Tonight the famous voice slurred ever so slightly. Tonight he was drinking more than the self-imposed limit he'd always so rigidly set for himself.

“What have they got?” I asked, keeping my tone crisp and businesslike. I wanted to reach over and give his hand a reassuring squeeze, to stand up and knead his tense shoulders. To bring back the urbane, witty, controlled Matt Riordan I'd known, and banish this worried shell of a man.

“They say I bribed a court clerk, bought grand jury minutes.”

“What's bribery worth in the federal system?” I asked, keeping my tone professionally detached.

“Fifteen years max,” he replied. “That's the going rate for bribery. Of course, I doubt the judge would send me away for that long, but if I lose this case, I'm ruined even if I never see the inside of a jail cell.”

I nodded. That was a given in a case involving a lawyer; a felony conviction would lose him his license, and the notoriety might lose him his clientele no matter how the case came out.

“And, in case you were wondering,” he said with a sarcastic edge to his voice, “I did not put money in Paul Corcoran's pocket in return for the grand jury minutes of Nunzie Aiello.”

He said it crisply, decisively, unambiguously. I put a mental check mark in the column headed
Take the Case
.

“Nunzie,” I mused aloud. “He's the guy who—”

“Please, Cass,” Riordan said, holding up a restraining hand, “let me tell this in my own way.”

I nodded; interrupting people is one of my besetting sins. It's just one more example of my resistance to the concept of patience.

“Nunzie was a low-level Mob guy,” Riordan explained. “He pretty much ran errands and talked tough. There were rumors he was involved in street drugs, which Frankie Cretella hates like poison. But nothing was ever proved.”

I ran the risk of Matt's displeasure by saying, “I never believed that crap about the Mafia being down on drugs. It always struck me as sentimental nonsense.”

“It isn't sentiment,” Matt disputed. “It's self-preservation. Guys could do serious time for drug-selling, and a guy facing serious time could decide to cut a deal and sell out the bigger fish. So the big fish made a hard-and-fast rule: Deal drugs and you're dead. They didn't want to risk going down because of something they couldn't control.”

“And this Nunzie broke the rules?”

“So I heard,” Riordan replied. “But that's another story. He got caught up in Frankie Cretella's garment union case; Lazarus charged him with being the one who threatened Lou Berger with a strike that would cripple his business. I represented Nunzie on that case.”

He paused. I decided a question wouldn't be out of order. “As I recall, Cretella himself wasn't charged with anything.”

Matt shook his head. He signaled the waiter for another brandy, making a little circle with his finger to indicate the need for another round. In my case, that meant a refill of insipid coffee. I schooled my face to show nothing; this wasn't the time for a temperance lecture.

“Lazarus wanted Frankie in the worst way, but he just didn't have the evidence. The only one Berger could identify was Nunzie. One day Nunzie hands me an airline ticket and a hotel receipt that put him in Barbados on the day Berger said he was threatened. I presented the evidence to the jury, but they convicted Nunzie anyway.” Riordan's face was troubled; I could see why the conviction bothered him. If a jury was prepared to discount such seemingly strong evidence of an alibi, it meant they believed it was a fake. Riordan's reputation as a miracle worker was catching up with him; people were beginning to wonder what was really inside the magician's hat.

“Did you check this alibi out?” I asked. “Did you call the hotel employees to back up Nunzie's story? Did you—”

“Cass, I took what appeared to be genuine documents from my client's hands and I entered them into evidence. It was for the jury to decide whether—”

“But you had your doubts,” I persisted. “It's obvious from the way you're talking now—you didn't believe Nunzie's alibi, but you presented it to the jury, anyway.” This called for two check marks in the
Hell, no
column. At least.

“Cass, please, haven't you ever presented evidence that you weren't one hundred percent convinced of yourself? Do you always act as judge and jury?”

I opened my mouth to retort that I would never have permitted a client to slip bogus documents past me, but then I remembered Bobo.

Bobo wasn't my client. My client was Jaime Ortega, late of Puerto Rico. He swore on a stack of Bibles that the car he was accused of stealing was sold to him by a guy on the street named Bobo. I explained to him that he was going to be convicted of possession of stolen property unless he produced a bill of sale proving that he'd bought the car in good faith. I was confident that he had no such bill of sale, and would be taking the eminently reasonable plea offer extended by the assistant district attorney.

Instead, on the next court date Jaime proudly presented me with a bill of sale. In the space marked “Seller's name” was scrawled the single word: “Bobo.” No last name, no address. Just “Bobo.”

The anxious lines around Riordan's mouth disappeared as I told the story, and his booming laugh filled the room. “So what did you do?” he teased. “Throw the bill of sale back into the guy's face and call him a liar?”

“He might not have been the liar,” I said defensively. “Maybe some guy on the street really gave him a bill of sale in the name of ‘Bobo.'”

“At least that's what you told the judge,” Matt surmised.

“There were two possibilities,” I explained. “Either my client was a very stupid man who was taken advantage of by an unscrupulous seller, or he—”

“Or he was a very stupid man who stole a car and didn't have the brains to fill out a bogus bill of sale with a believable seller's name,” Riordan finished. “I take it you didn't see fit to present the judge with that alternative.”

“I told the judge my client was a cane-cutting peasant from Puerto Rico who got ripped off by a city slicker named Bobo,” I admitted.

“What happened to the case?”

“God, I don't remember. This happened years ago.”

“But you tried to get your guy a better deal on the basis of a bill of sale you had some reason to believe he might have forged. That might be penny ante stuff compared to Nunzie's trip to Barbados, but the principle is the same. Does a good defense attorney look a gift horse in the mouth?”

“He does if the horse might turn around and bite him.”

He considered that remark in silence; this horse had bitten Matt with a vengeance. But I did erase one of the two check marks I'd placed in my mental
Hell, no
column.

“And then?” I prompted, bringing him back to the matter at hand.

“And then Lazarus, the snake, put the squeeze on Nunzie,” he said. “He promised him a walk if he'd incriminate me in the phony alibi. Word on the street is that Nunzie bought the deal and told Lazarus that he was given the documents by my investigator.”

“This is Fat Jack Vance, the bail bondsman?” He was a legend in Manhattan court circles; the fat man and Riordan went back a long way together.

Matt nodded. “The next word I hear is that Lazarus sent Nunzie into the grand jury to get an indictment for subornation of perjury against Jack and me.”

“And right after that, Nunzie Aiello went missing,” I finished. Nunzie's disappearance right after his grand jury appearance had been the subject of a certain amount of press speculation. Half the reporters in town thought he'd taken a strategic trip to the Old Country, while the other half had him swimming in the East River in cement shoes. Either way, his absence was Riordan's reprieve. There could be no trial without the chief witness.

“Lazarus was steamed, I take it.”

“Lazarus was rabid,” Riordan amended. “Now there was even wild talk he was going to prove I killed Nunzie to prevent him from testifying against me.”

I finished the story for him. “And then, last October, the Department of Sanitation towed a derelict car from under the Williamsburg Bridge. The car was in the pound for a month. It was about to be auctioned, when the guys inspecting it smelled something rotten. They opened the trunk, and there was Nunzie. One bullet to the head, another in the mouth.”

“Classic,” was all Matt said. “The bullet in the mouth is a traditional way of marking an informer.”

“Do you think Cretella did it?” I asked. This was, strictly speaking, irrelevant to Matt's defense. But I had decided that if the answer was yes, Matt would have to keep looking for counsel. I could represent Matt himself without becoming known as a Mafia lawyer, but if there were deeper Mob crimes underlying Matt's troubles, I preferred to stay on the Brooklyn side of the bridge.

Matt's eyes narrowed; at first, I thought he resented the question. But his thoughtful tone told me that he was thinking the matter through. “If Nunzie was
shtupping
me,” he said in an uncharacteristically tentative tone, “then he was probably sticking it to Frankie too. I've represented Frank Cretella for almost fifteen years now, and this isn't the first of his former associates to be found with a bullet in his mouth.”