God's Problem (24 page)

Read God's Problem Online

Authors: Bart D. Ehrman

BOOK: God's Problem
5.75Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
 

The Overall Structure of the Poetic Dialogues

 

The poetic dialogues are set up as a kind of back-and-forth between Job and his three “friends.” Job makes a statement and one of his friends replies; Job responds and the second friend replies; Job responds again and then the third friend replies. This sequence happens three times, so that there are three cycles of speeches. The third cycle, however, has become muddled, possibly in the copying of the book over the ages: one of the friend’s (Bildad’s) comments are inordinately short in the third go-around (only five verses); another friend’s (Zophar’s) comments are missing this time; and Job’s response at one point appears to take the position that his friends had been advocating and that he had been opposing in the rest of the book (chapter 27). Scholars typically think that something has gone awry in the transmission of the dialogues at this point.
2

But the rest of the structure is clear. After the friends have had their say, a fourth figure appears; this is a young man named Elihu who is said to be dissatisfied with the strength of the case laid out by the other three. Elihu tries to state the case more forcefully: Job is suffering because of his sins. This restatement appears to be no more convincing than anything the others have said, but before Job can reply, God himself appears, wows Job into submission by his overpowering presence, and informs him that he, Job, has no right to challenge the workings of the one who created the universe and all that is in it. Job repents of his desire to understand and grovels in the dirt before the awe-inspiring challenge of the Almighty. And that’s where the poetic dialogues end.

 

Job and His Friends

 

The poetic section begins with Job, out of his misery, cursing the day he was born and wishing that he had died at birth:

 

After this Job opened his mouth and

cursed the day of his birth. Job said:

“Let the day perish in which I was

born,

and the night that said

‘A man-child is conceived.’…

“Why did I not die at birth,

come forth from the womb and

expire?

Why were there knees to receive

me,

or breasts for me to suck?…

Or why was I not buried like a

stillborn child,

like an infant that never sees the

light?” (Job 3:1–3, 11–12, 16)

 

Eliphaz is the first friend to respond, and his response sets the tone for what all the friends will say. In their opinion, Job has received what was coming to him. God does not, they claim (wrongly, as readers of the prologue know), punish the innocent but only the guilty.

 

Then Eliphaz the Temanite answered:

“If one ventures a word with you,

will you be offended?

But who can keep from

speaking?…

“Think now, who that was

innocent ever perished?

Or where were the upright cut

off?

As I have seen, those who plow

iniquity

and sow trouble reap the same.

By the breath of God they perish,

and by the blast of his anger

they are consumed.” (Job 4:1–2, 7–9)

 

All three friends will have similar things to say throughout the many chapters of their speeches. Job is guilty, he should repent, and if he does so, God will relent and return him to his favor. If he refuses, he is simply showing his recalcitrance and willfulness before the God who punishes those who deserve it. (These friends seem well versed in the views of the Israelite prophets we considered in chapters 2 and 3.) And so Bildad, for example, insists that God is just and seeks Job’s repentance.

 

Then Bildad the Shuhite answered:

“How long will you say these

things,

and the words of your mouth

be a great wind?

Does God pervert justice?

Or does the Almighty pervert

the right?

If your children sinned against

him,

he delivered them into the

power of their

transgression.

If you will seek God

and make supplication to the

Almighty,

if you are pure and upright,

surely then he will rouse himself

for you

and restore to you your rightful

place.

Though your beginning was

small,

your latter days will be very

great.” (Job 8:1–7)

 

Zophar too thinks that Job’s protestations of innocence are completely misguided and an affront to God. If Job is suffering, it is because he is guilty and is getting his due; in fact, he deserves far worse (one wonders what could be worse, if the folktale is any guide).

 

Then Zophar the Naamathite answered:

“Should a multitude of words go

unanswered,

and should one full of talk be

vindicated?

Should your babble put others to

silence,

and when you mock, shall no

one shame you?

For you say, ‘My conduct is

pure,

and I am clean in God’s sight.’

But O that God would speak,

and open his lips to you,

and that he would tell you the

secrets of wisdom!

For wisdom is many-sided.

Know then that God exacts of you

less than your guilt

deserves.” (Job 11:1–6)

 

And this is what Job’s
friends
are saying! Sometimes they bar no holds in accusing Job, wrongly, of great sin before God, as when Eliphaz later declares:

 

“Is it for your piety that he

reproves you,

and enters into judgment with

you?

Is not your wickedness great?

There is no end to your

iniquities.

For you have…stripped the naked of their

clothing.

You have given no water to the

weary to drink,

and you have withheld bread

from the hungry….

“You have sent widows away

empty-handed,

and the arms of the orphans you

have crushed.

Therefore snares are around you,

and sudden terror overwhelms

you.” (Job 22:4–7, 9–10)

 

The word
therefore
in the final couplet is especially important. It is
because
of Job’s impious life and unjust treatment of others that he is suffering, and for no other reason.

For Job, it is this charge itself that is unjust. He has done nothing to deserve his fate, and to maintain his personal integrity he has to insist on his own innocence. To do otherwise would be to lie to himself, the world, and God. He cannot repent of sins he has never committed and pretend that his suffering is deserved when in fact he has done nothing wrong. As he repeatedly tells his friends, he knows full well what sin looks like—or, rather, tastes like—and he would know if he had done anything to stray from the paths of godliness:

Other books

Electric Engagement by Sidney Bristol
Yellow Room by Mary Roberts Rinehart
Here Comes the Bride by Gayle Kasper
Mad Dog by Dandi Daley Mackall
Brother Dusty-Feet by Rosemary Sutcliff
Sentido y sensibilidad y monstruos marinos by Jane Austen, Ben H. Winters
Castle of the Heart by Speer, Flora
The Midnight Guardian by Sarah Jane Stratford
The Ascent of Eli Israel by Jonathan Papernick, Dara Horn