Authors: Chris Kraus
“Lived experience,” said Gilles Dleuze in
Chaosophy
“does not mean sensible qualities. It means intensification. âI feel that' means that something is happening inside me. It happens all the time with schizophrenics. When a schizophrenic says âI feel that I'm becoming God' it's as if he were passing beyond a threshold of intensity with his very body⦠The body of the schizophrenic is a kind of egg. It is a catatonic body.”
You didn't sound surprised when I told you I was calling from LA. Or maybe you just sounded non-committal. At first your voice was cold, detached, but then it softened. You said you couldn't really talk⦠But then you did, you did. I don't remember which conference in which European country you'd just got back from. You said you were exhausted and depressed. Two nights ago you'd narrowly escaped a DUI driving on Route 126 and you'd decided to stop drinking.
“I feel clearer now than I've ever felt before,” you said, after 36 hours of sobriety. Waves of remorse pounded from my heart out to my fingers. I clasped the phone, regretting this entire schizophrenic project that'd started when I met you. “I've never been stalked before,” you said in February. But was it stalking? Loving you was like a kind of truth-drug because you knew everything. You made me think it might be possible to reconstruct a life 'cause after all, you'd walked away from yours. If I could love you consciously, take an experience that was so completely female and subject it to an abstract analytic system, then perhaps I had a chance of understanding something and could go on living.
“I never asked for this!” you said. And on the phone I was ashamed. My will had ridden over all your wishes, your fragility. By loving you this way I'd violated all your boundaries, hurt you.
Then you asked me how I was. Your way of asking ordinary social questions makes me think of Ruffo: it's way past simple listening. It's like you really want to know. Your attentive unshockability makes it possible to say anything. “I'm really fine,” I said. But I wanted you to know how much good you've done me. “It's likeâI've finally moved outside my headâI don't think I'll go back,” I said. Three days before I'd written in my notebook: “Since knowing D. my eyes have moved into my ribcage. My body's turned to liquid glass and all the pieces fit⦔ And quoting Alice Notley quoting Donne: “No woman is an island-ess.”
And then again, remorse. I wanted you to understand I'd never use this writing to âexpose' you. “Look,” I said. “I'll change the names, the dates, the place. It'll be a past-tense narrative about cowboy love. I'll call you âDerek Rafferty' instead of Dick.”
You sounded less than thrilled. Was there any chance of redeeming things, this situation?
(A month before I'd sent you the first draft of a story called
The Exegesis
. On
page 1
there was a line: “You were so wet,' Dick
ââ
'd said, glancing at his watch⦔ â¦You freaked. “But that's my
NAME
!” you howled into the phone. And then you'd told me how, when you were writing your first book, you worked so hard to protect the people who you wrote about by concealing their identities. “And those were people who I
loved
,” you'd said. “You don't even know me.”)
My feelings for you were so strong I had to find a way to make love selfless. So even though I'd travelled all this way just hoping I might see you, if seeing me was bad for you, I wouldn't. It was April, the season of blood oranges, emotion running like the stream behind my house upstate, turbulent and thawing. I thought about how fragile people get when they withdraw from anything, how they become bloody yolks protected only by the thinnest shell.
“Soâ” you said.â“Did you want to see me?”
And this time (if morality's repressing what you want over what you think is right) I responded morally: “I think the question's more, do you feel like seeing me? 'Cause if this is a bad time for you, I think we should forget it.”
But then you said: “Ah, I just have to check my schedule for the next few days.”
You said: “Why don't you call me back around this time tomorrow?”
It was 10:52. My hand was wet from holding the telephone so tightly.
19.
Love has led me to a point
where I now live badly
'cause I'm dying of desire'
I therefore can't feel sorry for myself
AND
â
20. My hand was wet from holding the telephone so tightly. I was sitting on the edge of the double bed in the motel room. The bedside lamp glared back into the room against the windows.
By the time I got out to Silverlake, 11:45 p.m., Ray's party was already breaking up. Ray introduced me to Michelle Di Blasi, a writer-filmmaker who'd been all over New York in the early '80s. Where are they now? (a favorite conversational routine among survivors, sightings of the once-famous waiting tables, picking garbageâ¦) But Michelle looked great, and on the plane that afternoon I'd been reading one of her new stories. It was the kind of story everybody likes, about a tough girl who becomes a truer version of herself by uncovering her vulnerability. It was the kind of story people like because its universe is played out in the story of one person. It was the kind of story (dare I say it?) that women're supposed to write because all its truths are grounded in a single lie: denying chaos. Michelle was nice: smart and open, radiant and charming.
The crowd was thinning out. Ray Johannson sat down and drank a beer with me and started to critique my writing. He said the “flaw” in all these stories is that I'm addressing them to you. I should learn to be more “independent.” Everyone was disappointed that Amanda Plummer hadn't showed but I met another famous person's sister.
21. Last January when Sylvère and I had dinner at your house and I handed you a xerox of my first 120 letters you said, “I'm gobstruck.” The other guests had all gone home and we sat around your table drinking vodka. The glass shattered when you poured Sylvère a shot. The three of us agreed to meet for breakfast the next day in Antelope Valley at Five Corners Diner.
Sylvère and I found you already sitting there at 9 a.m. and it was a gloomy fucking morning. The worn-out raincoat you were wearing reminded me of the record that you'd played the night before,
The Greatest Hits of Leonard Cohen
. It's geometrically impossible to arrange a group of three in anything but a straight line or a triangle. Sylvère sat next to you, I sat across. The conversation circled nervously. Sylvère was elusive, you were cryptic. I could hardly eat my oatmeal. Finally you focussed sharp and looked at me and asked “Are you still anorexic?” An allusion to my second letter. “Not really,” I demurred, hoping you'd say more. But then you didn't, so I blurted out: “Did you read them? Did you really read my letters?”
“Oh, I glanced through them,” you said. “Alone this morning in my bedroom. With all this rain, I found it very film noir⦔
I wondered what you meant (I didn't ask) but now I'm right there too: shuttling urban & alone the night of April 5 between the airport and the rental car, the car and the motelâ¦fixed points on a floating grid. The motel phone, the ashtray. The stupid Heidi-in-Bavaria waitress costumes at the restaurant party, a Tyrolean horrorshow, the dregs of food, the conversations. Taking foolish stabs at girlfriendhood to Michelle Di Blasi by burbling on about the problems of my film.
CUT-CUT-CUT
. Robbe-Grillet meets Marguerite Duras and suddenly you're nowhere. Dennis Potter's Singing Detective stumbles up out of a basement bar sometime in the '70s and rounds a corner into wartime London. Paint it Black, Noir. Time's an unsealed envelope and crime's a metaphor for anguish, private symphonies of intensity exploding in the dark.
22. Of course it's no surprise when Félix Guattari talks about love in the same breath as schizophrenia. Here's a passage that I found three weeks ago when I started writing this and now it's August and I can't find the citation, and anyhow it's my translation, i.e., a cross between what he wrote and what I wanted him to say: “It's like this: someone falls in love and in a universe that once was closed, suddenly everything seems possible. Love and sex are mediums for semiotizing mutation.”
I disagree, at least I think I do, about the “semiotizing” part (Dear Dick, Dear Marshall, Dear Sylvère, What is semiotics?). Love and sex both cause mutation, just like I think desire isn't lack, it's surplus energyâa claustrophobia inside your skinâ
Félix goes on: “Previously unimagined systems unfurl themselves in a once empty world. New possibilities of freedom are revealed. Of course none of this is ever guaranteed.”
And now
IT
'
S GETTING VERY LATE
. It's August and since July 6 when I started writing this I've been in an altered state, have lost 10 lbs, etc.
This morning when I took a walk I thought about a talk I'll give next fall (I've been invited to your school) about poetics. I want to play video I edited two years ago for Jim Brodey's funeral. Jim was a quote-minor New York poet who died of AIDS after living in the street. In the tape he talks about Lew Welch, a quote-minor San Francisco poet who would've drunk himself to death if he hadn't suicided first in the '70s. I want to hand out copies of Alice Notley's brilliant essay
Dr William's Heiresses
where she talks about how female poets like herself who externalize and twist internal daily life have hardly any female ancestors. The critic Kathleen Fraser thought that for not inventing some, Alice was a bad feminist. Alice Notley proved the possibility of writing poems no matter what; Kathleen Fraser is an academic. “No woman is an island-ess,” oh⦠The message is,
IT
'
S GETTING VERY LATE
. Be glad you're in a California art school but don't forget you live by compromise and contradiction 'cause those who don't just die like dogs.
I have to find a way of ending this, of getting to the point.
23. I wasn't really that surprised to get your answerphone on Thursday night when I called back, (April 6, 10:45 p.m.) the way you'd asked me to, just short of 24 hours later.
Desire, claustrophobia. If I left a message I'd have to wait in the motel room, wondering if you'd call back. So I hung up and smoked some pot and went outside. The pot was very strong and I started flashing back again to 20 years ago (I know, I know). Remembering what it felt like to be 20, overwhelmed by feeling and sensation, lost for words. While having lots and lots of words to talk about
Douglas Weir
and Ian Martinson, Angola, China, rock & rollâthe host culture, male. My schizophrenia. Is this letter all about the past? No, it's about intensity. R.D. Laing never figured out that “the divided self' is female subjectivity. Writing about an ambitious educated 26-year-old “schizophrenic girl” in the suburban 1950s: “â¦the patient repeatedly contrasts her real self with her false compliant self.” Oh really.
That night I sat on a curb in sleeping Pasadena, stoned and spinning, writing notes about the bungalows.
Later on, I left this message on your answerphone: “Hi it's Chris. Just calling back to see if you still want to get together. If the timing isn't good for you, just let me know. I'll be in 'til 9 tomorrow morning.” The normalcy of this message sounded totally surreal.
The philosopher Luce Irigaray thinks there is no female “I” in existing (patriarchal) language. She proved it once by bursting into tears while lecturing in a conference on Saussure at Columbia University.
24. According to Charles Olsen, the best poetry is a kind of schizophrenia. The poem does not “express” the poet's thoughts or feelings. It is “a transfer of energy between the poet and the reader.”
25. The next morningâFriday, April 7âyou returned my call.
26. It was 8:30 a.m. The Violent Femmes song
Add It Up
was cranked up on a cheap cassette and I was getting ready to go to school. “Hello Chris,” you said, “it's Dick.” Your accent sounded strained and bitter. It was the first time I'd ever heard you speak my name, or yours. “Look,” you said. “It turns out I've got a previous engagement this evening. So how about the weekend? Why don't you give me a call tomorrow morning around this time?”
A tsunami wave inside my body rolled. The telephone became a schizophrenic instrument, the “therefore” placed between us, two non-sequiturs. I had to take control.
“No!,” I said, then curbed the violence of it. “I'm only here 'til Tuesday and there're other things I need to do. If we're going to get together it'd be better if we could make a plan right now.”
You suggested that we meet for lunch the following afternoon.
27. David Rattray was a 26-year-old American junkie when he started translating Antonin Artaud. He'd read Artaud in French at Dartmouth College, but in 1957, living on his own in Paris, he decided to become him. At the old Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris, the cataloging system held a list of every book checked out by every reader. Artaud was fairly freshly dead. And isn't scholarship just a stalking of the dead by people who're too stoned or scared to chase live bait? That year David Rattray read every single book checked out by Antonin Artaud.
This afternoon (August 12) I went over to the Occidental College Library. It was about 102 degrees. I wanted to look at Katherine Mansfield's famous story
At The Bay
, set in Wellington, New Zealand. I was hoping that its qualitiesâtime frozen soft in green and blueâwould help me write about the lunch we had in April, that Saturday afternoon. The third floor of the library was cool and empty and all of Katherine's books were there. Among them was a gorgeous Knopf edition of Mansfield's
Bliss and Other Stories
, the sixth printing, published in the year she died, 1923. Its dark green cover, thick lead type sunk deep on creamy pages, cheerful green and orange endpapers, threw me back into a time when books were friends. I sat down between the stacks and started thumbing through the pages. They were as intimate, delicious and inviting as Venusian skin.