Authors: Parker Witter
I don't know how long we've been here, or how long we've been apart, but it feels like forever. Months, maybe more. In reality, it has probably been no more than a few weeks, but time slows down, spreads out, when you're stuck on a deserted island. There isn't any TV to fill the days. No school. No homework. No friends or family.
Some days I think my sister and Ed didn't make it. That they crashed in the sea just like us and drowned or, more mercifully, were killed on impact. But some daysâ¦
Some days I let myself think about them being alive. I think about the coast guard coming to get them. I think about Maggieâscared, small, and Ed helping her. I think about my little sisterâall alone at home with a disconnected dad and a stepmother who doesn't even know her middle name. And some days? Some days not being able to be there for her, not being able to save her either wayâfrom death, or a life without support at homeâmakes it difficult to get out of bed. She wasn't even supposed to come on that trip. If I hadn't insisted we spend spring break looking at schoolsâ¦if I hadn't convinced Dad to make the school let her comeâ¦she wouldn't have been on that plane. She wouldn't have been dragged around looking at colleges that had nothing to do with her own life. She was only a freshman. She should have been home painting her nails with her friends and going to the movies and shopping with Dad's credit card. She should have been lying out on our sundeck and watching movies and making popcorn and blowing off studying. She's fifteen years old. She shouldn't be dead.
 Â
Noah is so distant. I hardly ever see him for more than a few minutes at night. He's gone in the morning before I wake up, and if he's around during the day he's silent. He won't touch me. He will barely even look at me. This notion that the island is keeping us apart starts to feel crazier and crazier. It's Noah; it has to be. Noah doesn't want me. He's the one who doesn't want
us
.
Or maybe it's Ed. Like Maggie, he's always on my mind. I can't get past our last conversation, that the last words I said to him were that I didn't know. It was a lie; I knew. I loved him. I wanted to be with him. Why didn't I tell him that?
“You're like a piece of modern art,” he told me a week before we left on the trip. We were sitting on my bed, finishing up some homework, I don't remember what. We had stopped to make out. He had his hand on my stomach and was drawing some circles there, above my tank top.
“Modern art?”
Ed smiled. He kissed my cheek. “It's so hard to figure out what's going on with you.”
I pushed his hand off and laughed. “There's nothing going on with me.”
Ed blew some air out of his lips, ran a hand through his hair. “You are,” he said. “Sometimes it's like⦔
“What?” I put my hand on his back, right below his shoulder blades. Ed was always a little bit more sensitive than me. He didn't love me more than I loved him, I don't think, but I guess you could have looked at it that way. Thinking about it now, maybe he did.
“Like you're somewhere else even when you're here.”
I reached for his cheeks. I turned his face to mine. “I'm not,” I said. “I promise. I'm right here with you.”
I was. And maybe I still am. Because Ed wouldn't do what Noah is doing. Ed wouldn't turn me away.
 Â
“I need to talk to you,” Noah says that night. Asku has just left. We've been making woven baskets from leaves. Every resource is in abundance now. I can't deny that under Noah's guidance, presence, whatever, the island is coming back to life. We have more vegetables. The fruit is ripe and not rotted. We cook with spices that Asku gathers.
We're also learning to communicate better every day. Some days he even brings his wife. She's a shy girlâshe barely looks older than meâand she always keeps her head bent low. Today he told me they're expecting a baby. I threw my arms around him. They were both smiling so wide.
I'm still in a good mood, washing some ceramic plates in the water basin in the kitchen. Noah comes up behind me. I can feel the air charge between usâstatic electricity that increases in voltage the closer he comes. “Okay,” I say, not turning around, “talk.”
I hear him exhale. “I know you're mad.”
I let the plate slide out of my hands in the water. “I'm not mad,” I say. I keep my back turned.
“It's not easy for me, either.” I hear him behind me, edging closer, until I can feel the warmth of his body inches from mine. It makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. I squeeze my eyes shut. I will myself not to respond to him this way.
“Then why are you doing this?” I ask.
In the next moment he reaches out and touches my neck. I feel his fingertips on my skin. They ignite thereâso striking I think he might have just set my skin on fire.
“Because I need to protect you,” he says. I can hear how hoarse his voice is.
I turn slowly to face him. I put a palm on his cheek. It's wet, and some water slides down his skin like tears. I watch his eyes reflexively close. “You can protect me by being with me.”
“There's something I haven't told you,” he says, his eyes still closed. “I've known it since I first met the tribe. Maybe when I first pulled you out of the water, but it was too terrible to think about.”
“What?” Whatever he has to say cannot be worse than what already is. It cannot be worse than being here with him and not being allowed to talk to him, touch him.
He opens his eyes. They're cold. The blue has crystallized all the way down to ice. “The plane crashed because I was on it,” he says. “The island didn't just open to save me. It opened to pull me in.” He puts a hand over his forehead. Holds it there. “All of this. Ed. Your sister. The reason you're here. It's all because of me.”
I don't say anything. I don't move. I know he thinks I should be angry. That I should hate him. “It wasn't your fault,” I say.
“How can you say that?” His face is in so much pain. I want to touch him, to smooth his frown lines down with my fingers.
“Because it's true,” I say. “You did not call yourself back here. You did not rush the cockpit and force us into the ocean. Your birthright was not your choice, Noah. And I won't sit by and watch you punish yourself for something you couldn't control.”
“It might not have been my choice,” he says. “But it is my destiny.”
“Noah⦔
He smiles at me. It's small. Hopeless. “I've done so much damage already. I've hurt so many people.⦔
“No,” I say.
“August, listen. I can't take back what happened. But I can make other things right. The chief wants me to be their Healer. He wants me to ascend to the position.”
My hands are still dripping water, and I wipe them on my dress. “Ascend? You're not a king, Noah.” Something flashes across his face, but it's slow enough that I can catch it. “Are you?”
“It's a high position,” Noah says. “The highest in the tribe. Higher than chief. My people believedâ”
“
Your
people?” I shake my head. Now I'm angry. Angry at Noah for learning all this without telling me. Angry that while we've been moving around this cabin like strangers for the past few weeks he's been building a life here, one I'm not a part of.
“August,” Noah says. His voice is soft. “If I accept my role, I can help. I can do good. I can set the balance back. You see how the island is changing already with me here. They're dying, August. Without me, they won't last another ten years. If I stay. If
we
stayâyou and I can⦔ He looks at me, and then down at the floor.
“We can what?”
He holds his eyes to meet mine. “Be together. The Healer sets the natural order of the tribe and the island. If I step into the role, things will be the way they should. I can control that. It wants you to go because it thinks you're going to take me with you.”
“And then what?” I say. “So you have a purpose here and I'm justâ”
“With me,” he says. He steps closer to me and places his hands on my waist.
“Is that what you want?” I ask.
“I want you to be safe,” he says. “I want to do what's right.” He moves his thumb back and forth over my hipbone. I want to take his hands in mine, but I don't. I stay still. Because I can tell he's not done talking. “I don't want to lose you again.”
“Again? Noah, I've been right here. You didn't lose me; you turned away from me.”
But I see his face, and I know that's not what he's talking about. He's referring to something else, something that happened long before we landed on this island. All at once I see Ed and Noah on my doorstep. I feel the flowers in Noah's hands. I see his eyesâshining, but hopeless. I hear Ed's confessionâ“I came here tonight because I want to be with you”âand I feel the way I did that night: confused. Like it's coming out of the wrong lips. Because it was.
“The night Ed asked me to be his girlfriend,” I say. “You showed up first. You weren't there for him. You were there for me.” I can hardly believe it but as I say the words I know they're true.
Noah exhales. “August⦔ he starts.
“And that fight I saw you guys have a week before we left. You weren't really fighting about college. You were fighting about me. I heard you. I heard you say âMaybe after this we'd be even.' You let him have me. You traded me like a piece of property. I just don't understand why.”
Noah's face clouds. “It wasn't like that,” he says. “I didn'tâ”
“Tell me it's not true,” I say, my voice rising. “Tell me you didn't show up at my house that night two years ago because you wanted to be with me, too.”
I think about everything before that and everything that came after. About how heartbroken I was. About how stupid I thought I had been to ever think it could have been different. That all of our history could have led to love on his side, too.
“Yes,” Noah says. “It's true.”
We stare at each other for a moment, both afraid to blink.
“Ed,” I say, my jaw tense. “I can't believe he'd do that. I can't believeâ”
“That he loved you, too?” Noah says. “Come on, you know he did. And he deserved you. I didn't.” He shakes his head. “He was right. You were safer with him. I mean, look at us now. Look where we are. Look what I've brought into your life.”
“No,” I say. “You've brought in good. You always brought in good.” I take his face in my hands. “There is nowhere else I should be than right here with you.”
Noah pulls me close to him, and I bury my head against his chest. His arms wrap tight around me, and I feel the beating of his heartâfast and strong but steady, too. Solid. Safe.
I pull myself back to look up at him, but he keeps his arms tight around me. “I wanted it to be you,” I say. “That night, I wanted it to be you so badly.”
Noah glides his thumb over my cheek. Then he takes my chin in his hands and lifts my face up to meet his. Our lips touch, and when they do I feel myself falling into him. His lips taste like lemonade on the hottest summer day. They feel like relief. Immediately I grope for whatever I canâhis hair, his back. I feel his hands anchor my sides and then he's moving me so I'm pressed up against a wall. His hands are everywhere. On my neck. Down my arms. “Noah,” I whisper, and he pulls back just enough to look at me. “I thought we couldn't,” I say.
He presses his lips to my ear. His words come out in a growl. “I don't care.”
He lifts me up then and carries me into the bedroom. He sets me down gently like he did that night weeks ago. The night the roof caught on fire.
His lips push all thoughts awayâthe island. Leaving. Maggie. Ed. And I know as he kisses me that this time is different. This time he won't stop us.
He lifts my clothing up and over my head and then I'm lying naked under him. It's chilly in the roomâthere is a breeze coming through the cabin, and I feel my skin prick with goose bumps.
Noah lies down next to me and pulls the blankets over us. I peel his shirt off, and he helps me toss it to the floor. Then he gathers me to him, and I feel his skin against mine. His is warm, like a heater, and I press my torso against his. His hands are strong on my back, and his lips find mine, then my neck. I gasp and dig my nails into his shoulders. I see the flashes of gold and silverâtrails of warm, metallic dust he leaves across my body as he touches me. They shine like stars in the night sky. I think, if I followed the trails, they'd lead me home.
He rolls me underneath him gently and then sits up. He keeps a hand flat on my stomach, traces my navel with his pinkie.
“I can't believe it,” he says. “I never thoughtâ” His voice breaks off and he clears his throat. “I never thought I'd be here with you.”
“Stranded on a deserted island?” I smile.
“You know what I mean.”
I nod. “I do.” I bring his lips down to mine, and when we kiss, it's like nothing else in the universe exists. Not Ed. Not anyone. No past, no future. Only here, together.
“Are you okay?” he asks. Breathless, half blind, but I hear him.
“Yes,” I say.
I pull him down and then we're lost togetherâsomewhere new and different and yet totally familiar all at once. And for the first time since we got here, I feel that if we never leave it will be okay. If I am just here, forever, it will be worth it because I'll be here with him.
We fall asleep tangled in each other, my head on his chest, his arms around me. When I sleep, I dream of nothing.
I wake up alone. I'm only half conscious, images of last night spiraling around my head. For a moment, with Noah gone, I think maybe I dreamed it, maybe it was all the makings of my foggy subconscious, but then I remember his lips on my skin, and how warm his body was pressed up against mine, and I know it really happened.
“Noah?” I call. No response.
I snuggle farther down under the covers and allow myself another minute of glee. I can't help smiling. Despite everything, I feel happy. Really, truly happy. We were together last night, and we didn't die, nothing happened. I can feel the island bend to us. It's warming to me, I know it is. Because we are so right together. Nothing has ever felt this true beforeâI belong with him.
I swing my legs over the side of the bed and wrap the blanket around me. I peek into the living room. He's not there.
I head through the kitchen and out onto the deck. The sun is up, and it's warming the island. It's becoming summer quickly. The air is hot and heavy. I slip the blanket off and let the sun shine down on me. It radiates from the outside in. It feels delicious. The sun is reflecting off the waterâcreating silver sparkles all the way out to the horizon. Everything is so beautiful, I think.
And then I hear him behind me.
I turn around and see him leaning against the doorway. His hair falls into his face, and I notice how much longer it's gotten since we've been here. I wonder if I could track the days that way, the way some people do with the sun.
He doesn't move, just watches me, but I don't feel like I need to cover up. He's seen every part of me now. There is nothing to hide.
“Good morning,” I say.
I walk over and kiss him. I weave my fingers through his hair and then take his hands and place them on my sides. His fingers glide against my bare skin. In the next moment we're pressed up against the side of the cottage. I feel last night between us like a magnetic chargeâdrawing us closer and closer.
But something stops Noah. He unhooks me from him gently. He runs his hands down my arms and then crosses the deck and picks up my blanket. Instantly, I feel my body flush. And then he hands it to me. “We need to talk,” he says.
“I know,” I say. “I've been thinkingâlast night, nothing happened.” I blush and shake my head. “I mean, there was no fire. No tidal wave. Think about it. We were together and the world didn't end. Noahâ”
But he cuts me off. “August, you have to listen to me.” His tone is harsh. Set.
“Let me guessâyou're the mayor of this place, too. Does that job come with a better house?” I smile, but it doesn't catch on. It doesn't change him. And I know now that what he has to tell me is serious.
Something inside me comes crashing down. Like there was a beautiful chandelier in my chestâhigh, crystal, illuminated, brilliant, and it has become unhinged. It falls through my body, leaving shards of broken glass as it finally splatters.
Please don't take last night away
, I silently pray.
Whatever it is, please don't say it was a mistake.
I slip the blanket over my shoulders. “What's wrong?” I ask.
Noah sucks in his bottom lip. He paces on the porch. It's hot out here, but now I want the blanket as close around me as I can get it.
“I went out to get some water this morning,” he starts, “and Asku was there. He said the chief wanted to see me.”
“But nothing happened,” I say again. I suddenly have the intense need to defend us. “No meteors hit. There was no lightning. We didn't do anything wrong.”
“I know,” Noah says. “It's not that.” He stops moving and looks at me. I want, more than I ever have, to let him put his arms around me. To tell me that it's all going to be okay. But whatever it is he has to say, he hasn't, yet.
“But that's good, right?” I say. “That's good. I mean, then you can choose. We canâ”
“August.”
I take a step closer to him. The sun beats down, and I see him squint at me.
“Whatever it is, it's okay,” I say. “We can figure it out now.” I'm directly in front of him. “We can figure it out together.”
“I found out something,” he says. “It's good news. Really good news.” He looks up at me, and I see how liquid his eyes areâfull. Like they're about to spill over.
I stand perfectly still. If it's such good news, why does he look like it's physically hurting him to get the words out?
“Ed is alive,” he says. “Maggie, too. Everyone. They were rescued by the coast guard right after the crash.”
My hands feel numb. A million emotions cascade through my body like a riptideâlike they're carrying me out to sea. Maggie is alive. Ed's alive. They're okay. I imagine their facesâsmiling. Real. Relief covers my body like the sun.
“They're still in Seattle,” Noah continues. “They're still looking for you.”
“Us,” I say. “They're looking for us.” Then: “Oh my God.”
I blink and look at him. Noah was the one who believed they were okay. He was the one who kept insisting they were alive. And he was right. He had hope.
“I know,” Noah says. “It's amazing.”
“No, Noah, listen to me.” I hike the blanket up. “If the chief knows this, there must be a way off this island. There must be something they're not telling us.”
Noah reaches forward. He puts a hand on my shoulder. “I'm going to get you off here,” he says. “I'm going to get you back to them.”
His words spear my chest. A steel rod through my heart.
You.
“I'm going to get
you
back.” Not
us
,
you
.
“Noah,” I start, but he shakes his head.
“I promise,” he says.
I want to ask him a million questions. What did the chief say specifically? They're alive, but were they hurt? But I get the sense now is not the time. So instead I say, “I know.” I reach my hand out slowly and touch his chest. I can feel his heart beating thereâsteadily and fiercely. I was so happy to be in this moment. So happy to be just with him. Thinking, maybe, we could stay this way forever. But now the moment has been punctured, and it's spilling out. There is a future now, which means there is a past. Everything that happened before the crash. Ed. High school. Everything we were. Everything we wanted. What if we can get it all back now? What if the life we were heading toward before the crash is still the one that is meant for us?
“I should go to the stream,” Noah says. “Catch something for today.”
He puts a hand on my shoulder. And then he leans his head downâbut his lips don't meet mine. They land on my forehead. Light. Like a whisper. Like the last remaining notes of a song. “I'll see you,” he says, and then he is gone.