Lost Causes (10 page)

‘How was your weekend?’ Jean Roberts asked when Steven arrived at the Home Office in the early afternoon.

‘The trip to Newcastle to see Kincaid’s sister was well worth it,’ he said. ‘Kincaid was investigating the Northern Health Scheme along with the GP Neil Tolkien. They both thought people were dying who shouldn’t have been dying. The drugs war story was a cover-up. Lisa Hardesty is convinced that the people running the scheme killed her brother because he figured out what they were up to.’

‘And what were they up to? I thought people were very much in favour of it,’ said Jean.

‘The majority were,’ Steven agreed. ‘But from what Lisa Hardesty told me, her brother suspected there was a downside to the scheme, a lethal one.’

‘I don’t think I understand.’

‘James Kincaid’s father was long-term sick. He developed cancer and died shortly after his operation.’

Jean’s expression indicated that she didn’t think that was too unusual.

‘A number of Neil Tolkien’s patients met a similar fate – died when he hadn’t expected them to. It made him suspicious.’

Jean pursed her lips but still didn’t comment.

‘James Kincaid had a daughter in long-term care because of brain damage. She died of pneumonia.’

‘Are you suggesting they were murdering people?’ asked Jean, looking shocked. 

‘Selectively,’ said Steven. ‘There’s a strong possibility they were killing off “lost causes”, as Tally called them.’

‘But how? That sounds like something the Nazis would do.’

‘I don’t know how. I don’t even know if we’ll be able to prove it after all this time.’

‘It’s hard to see where you’d begin.’

‘Medical records. We need to look at the records of people who were treated under the Northern Health Scheme, in particular the people who might have been regarded as lost causes …’

‘As defined by?’

Steven thought for a moment. ‘Likely to be a long-term drain on public resources.’

‘Assuming we can access these records – and that’s a big if after all this time – we’re going to need help. It sounds like a big undertaking.’

Steven nodded. ‘Bring in all the help you need, but check if we can get the records first. Start with the College Hospital records department and then try the local GP practices,
beginning
with the one Neil Tolkien was a partner in. He was also involved in some drug rehabilitation initiative, but I doubt if that still exists. These places tend to come and go.’

‘I take it we’ll have full Home Office backing on this?’ said Jean.

‘You bet.’ Steven smiled as he felt an unspoken question in the air. ‘I’m going over to see John now,’ he said. ‘I think he’s well enough to make the handover to me official. I’ll ask him to sign the relevant paperwork.’

‘Tell him I was asking for him. Oh, I nearly forgot. I came up with something this morning you’ll be interested in. You asked about Gordon Field, the manager at College Hospital in the early nineties. I found him.’

‘Well done.’

‘He’s in Leigh Open Prison doing eighteen months for fraud.’ 

Steven gave a sigh of resignation. ‘Well, at least I’ll know where to find him.’

He found John Macmillan doing the
Times
crossword. The
Sci-Med
director was sitting in a wing-backed armchair in dressing gown and slippers, his feet resting on a footstool in front of a coal fire. His head was still bandaged but his eyes were bright and alert. ‘Come in, Steven. Good to see you.’

‘I don’t believe it,’ exclaimed Steven. ‘You’ve just had serious brain surgery and you’re doing the
Times
crossword?’

‘Don’t be fooled. I used to do it regularly in twelve minutes. I’ve been stuck on four down for the past two hours.’

Steven smiled at what appeared to be a genuine complaint. He could see that the puzzle was already three-quarters done.

‘Help yourself to a drink. I would have asked you to stay to dinner but my wife is away, staying with our daughter for a few days. I thought she needed a break from me so there’s just the agency nurse and the housekeeper at home.’

Steven poured himself a gin and tonic. Macmillan declined with a slight wave of the hand. ‘So how are things going?’

‘I think you were right to have … concerns over recent events in Paris and the death of John Carlisle,’ said Steven. ‘I share them. In fact, I’m going to have to expand the investigation. I need our arrangement to be put on a more formal basis. I need something on paper.’

Macmillan nodded. ‘Stating that you are now head of
Sci-Med
?’

‘No, stating that I’m officially
acting
head of Sci-Med pending your return. The way things are I just might need a big stick to wave at authority. I’d be happier knowing there’s one in the cupboard. So would Jean. She sends her regards, by the way.’

‘Consider it done,’ said Macmillan. ‘I’ll put something down in writing and send it over in the morning. Now, are you going to bring me up to speed?’ 

Steven did so. He was genuinely delighted to see Macmillan apparently almost back to his old self. He sat, listening without interruption, looking off into the middle distance, as was his habit, but, as Steven knew only too well, taking absolutely
everything
in. When he’d finished, Macmillan continued to sit in silence for a few moments before saying, ‘No wonder the Northern Health Scheme was so bloody efficient. They didn’t address problems: they buried them.’

‘That’s certainly what it looks like,’ Steven agreed. ‘But it’s going to take some work to prove it and establish exactly how they did it.’

‘If all this should turn out to be true, the meeting in Paris could have been the first step in starting up the whole thing all over again.’

‘Presumably the prospect of a change of government and an easier administration to infiltrate brought their long
hibernation
to an end.’

‘But something went wrong. Instead of conducting a secret meeting in Paris, away from prying eyes, they ended up dead. Any ideas?’

‘The killer had to be one of their own,’ said Steven, giving his reasons for thinking so, and adding, ‘Apart from anything else, you don’t go around with a lump of Semtex in your pocket on the off chance …’

‘Quite so,’ Macmillan conceded.

‘I’d like to think that one of them had an attack of conscience and decided to put a stop to things for once and for all, but … there are alternative explanations.’

‘Like?’

‘Internecine strife? A policy disagreement? A takeover bid?’

Steven went on to tell Macmillan of his doubts surrounding John Carlisle’s suicide. ‘It looks to me as if someone went for a complete wipe-out of the old guard, including Carlisle.’

‘In order to do what?’ mused Macmillan. 

‘Now ain’t that the big question. I suppose it could be the same thing again. It could have been that the others in Paris weren’t keen to try that. The scheme seemed to work well enough the first time. If it hadn’t been for James Kincaid and his
interfering
little band, it could well have spread across the whole country, the end result being …’

‘A leaner, fitter, richer nation,’ said Macmillan with a wry smile. ‘Right-wing politics do have that unhappy knack of appealing to plain, ordinary common sense, don’t they? It’s only when you start uncovering the pits full of bodies that you see the reality.’

A middle-aged woman in nurse’s uniform knocked and entered. ‘Excuse me, gentlemen. Time’s up, Sir John,’ she said, pointing to the face of the watch hanging on the front of her dress. ‘You don’t want to overdo things when you’ve been doing so well.’

‘Sorry, Steven,’ he said. ‘Keep me informed. I’ll get that letter to the Home Office in the morning.’

James Black, the new head of the Schiller Group in his guise as the secretary of the competitions committee of Redwood Park golf club, had called a meeting at only four hours’ notice, so he wasn’t sure how many would make it to the private
function
room at the usual restaurant by the suggested time of eight p.m. In the event all had arrived by twenty past.

‘I take it we’re not about to be given good news,’ said Toby Langton.

A murmur came from the others.

‘Nothing we should be greatly concerned about, but I thought it best you should know. Sci-Med has started to take an interest in the old Northern Health Scheme.’

‘And we shouldn’t be concerned?’ exclaimed Constance Carradine. ‘That’s the last thing we need.’

‘What in God’s name made them do that?’ asked Rupert Coutts. 

‘Take it easy,’ said Black. ‘They’re not exactly knocking at our door. They probably looked at the identities of the dead in Paris to see what they had in common, made the connection to John Carlisle …’

‘And came up with the Northern Health Scheme,’ completed Elliot Soames. ‘I don’t like it.’

‘How much do they know?’ asked Langton.

‘What is there to know?’ said Black. ‘The scheme was very popular and highly successful in its time. Everyone behind it is now dead.
Sic transit gloria mundi
and all that.’

‘I still don’t like it,’ said Constance. ‘Sci-Med have a reputation for picking away at things.’

‘How did you find out about this?’ asked Toby Langton.

Black hesitated before answering, knowing that his reply would not help to settle nerves. ‘A contact in the police forensic service told me that Sci-Med weren’t convinced Carlisle took his own life.’

‘Jesus Christ, they’re really onto us,’ said Coutts.

‘Whoa,’ said Black. ‘The pathologist’s initial report was confirmed.’

‘Thank God for that.’

‘I heard that the head of Sci-Med was seriously ill,’ said Soames.

‘He is.’

‘So who started asking questions about Carlisle?’

‘Someone called Dr Steven Dunbar, Sci-Med’s chief investigator apparently.’

‘Do we know what made him suspicious?’ asked Constance.

‘I understand he went to see Carlisle’s wife.’

‘Do we know why?’

‘No.’

‘Maybe we should ask her?’

‘I considered that,’ said Black. ‘She’s out of the country, in South Africa, getting over the demise of John. Look, I think we’re worrying unnecessarily here. There’s nothing to connect French and the others and what they did to us. They’re all dead.’

‘I suppose you’re right,’ said Coutts. ‘Still, the thought of
Sci-Med
nosing around is … disconcerting.’

‘It’s my bet their interest is over,’ said Black. ‘They probably felt obliged to take an interest in the Paris deaths and the suicide of an ex-health secretary and now it’s over.’

‘If you say so,’ said Coutts. ‘But it wouldn’t do any harm to keep an ear open.’

‘We should certainly do that,’ agreed Black. ‘But they’re an independent lot. Tend not to advertise what they’re up to.’

‘What do we know about Dunbar?’ asked Constance.

‘Rumour has it he’s good at his job, but it’s my understanding that he’d actually left Sci-Med but came back to stand in for Sir John Macmillan when he fell ill. Probably just holding the fort. Going through the motions. Perhaps now you’d like to hear how things are going with our plans?’

‘There are no official hospital records from the time of the Northern Health Scheme,’ said Jean Roberts. ‘The practice Dr Neil Tolkien was a partner in ceased to exist fifteen years ago. No record of patient reallocation was kept, and no one can remember anything about the drug rehabilitation scheme he was involved in. All thoroughly depressing.’

‘Damnation,’ said Steven. ‘But you said “official” hospital records?’

‘I thought you might latch on to that,’ said Jean with a smile. ‘Apparently hospitals like to get rid of records as soon as they possibly can, so when the legal requirement time for keeping them passes they simply don’t exist on the system any more. That doesn’t actually mean that they’ve been destroyed. They’re often not, a bit like deleted items on the hard disk of a computer. They’re still there; they just don’t have a label any more and you can’t reference them.’

‘And?’

‘There’s a reasonable chance that the files still exist in
physical
form somewhere in the basement of College Hospital. Apparently it’s a warren of cellars and tunnels that people use for storage when they’re pressed for space upstairs. My informant couldn’t guarantee that what you’re interested in will be down there but there’s a chance.’

‘Then I’d best take it,’ said Steven. ‘Perhaps you could inform College Hospital of our interest and get me permission to rifle through their cellars?’ 

‘Of course.’

‘And I’d like to go see Gordon Field some time. Where exactly is Leigh Open Prison?’

‘Yorkshire. Do you want me to approach the governor?’

‘Please. I plan to visit him some time in the next few days.’

Steven drove up to Leicester on Sunday and stayed overnight at Tally’s place. ‘What do you think the Lib Dems are going to do?’ Tally asked as she and Steven did the washing up after dinner. She got the expected grunt in response. ‘You don’t care, do you?’

‘Correct.’

‘Oh, Steven, I know you’ve had a lot of bad experiences with politicians, and I know you don’t like them, but all the same …’

‘You don’t know the half of it.’

‘Maybe not, but it won’t change unless you make it.’

‘Human nature doesn’t change, Tally. It’s the driving force behind everything, always has been. It’s circumstances that change.’

‘What does that mean?’

‘Today’s freedom fighters are tomorrow’s corrupt rulers. Yesterday’s idealists are today’s self-interested liars. It’s
circumstances
that change. The selfish gene will always out. People will grab the best for themselves.’

‘Gosh,’ said Tally, as if she’d just heard more than she bargained for. ‘What are
you
planning on grabbing, Steven?’

‘Your bottom … just as soon as I’m finished these dishes,’ said Steven, trying to keep a straight face.

‘Oh well,’ said Tally. ‘No use trying to fight human nature, I suppose …’

Steven had the usual trouble finding a parking place near a big city hospital. The situation was exacerbated by College Hospital’s being the oldest hospital in the city, built at a time when two legs were the most common form of transport. He was on his second circuit of the area when he saw reversing lights go on on a silver estate car up ahead, and paused to let the driver reverse out before slipping into the space, feeling the inevitable sense of achievement such success always brought.

‘I’m expected,’ he told the receptionist when she asked about an appointment. This prompted a phone call to ‘Mrs Rutherford’ before he was told that someone would be down shortly. He used the time to look around him, seeing what he expected: a mixture of Victorian architecture and bland, modern signing to departments not yet dreamt of when the place was built, tiled walls and corridors that stretched into the distance like the set of a nightmare and possessed that smell which all hospitals had.

He saw a young man in a suit pause at the desk to ask
something
, and the receptionist pointing in his direction.

‘Dr Dunbar? I’m Paul Drinkwater. The hospital manager asked me to give you his apologies – he has a meeting. I’m to give you all the assistance you need.’

Steven shook hands and said that all he required was access to the basement area.

‘I hope you’ve brought a boiler suit with you,’ said Drinkwater. ‘It’s pretty dirty down there.’

‘Didn’t think of that.’

‘Out through here.’ Drinkwater led the way out of the main building and across a cobbled courtyard to a small group of buildings signed as
Works Department All Trades
. Steven was introduced to the clerk of works, Dennis Drysdale, a short, stocky man, who Drinkwater told him would show him the way down. ‘If you need anything else, I’m on extension 117.’

Steven, who had thought that accessing the basement would simply mean opening a door and descending some stairs, followed Drysdale on another short safari across uneven cobbles to a pair of wooden double doors in the wall of the main building. Drysdale unlocked the padlock on them and said, ‘All yours.’

Steven peered down a narrow, sloping walkway which looked like the entrance to a mine, the stone walls lit at intervals with caged bulkhead lights.

‘Let me know when you’re finished and I’ll lock up again,’ said Drysdale. ‘Otherwise the winos and smackheads will move in.’

At least it wasn’t cold was Steven’s first thought as he walked down the slope to an intersection with corridors leading off in three directions. He opted for the middle one, calculating that it would take him under the centre of the hospital where, with luck, he would find more than long stretches of featureless corridor designed mainly for housing the supply pipes for the hospital’s services. Hot water and steam were uppermost in his mind as the temperature seemed to rise with every yard of progress. He had to stoop to avoid contact with the pipes but could still feel the heat on his face.

His spirits rose when he saw the corridor widen to
accommodate
a series of arched cellars, some with doors, some without. He could see piles of old furniture in one and what looked like antiquated anaesthetic equipment in another. Old steel bedheads and oil lamps made him feel as though he’d entered a museum. Long-skirted nurses in frilly caps and frock-coated surgeons flitted across his imagination.

He thought the last door might be locked when he tried it but it yielded to his shoulder and the slight echo the noise provoked suggested he was entering a much bigger space. It was in darkness, the bulkhead lights outside only illuminating the first few feet, so he ran his hand up the wall and found a bank of old-style metal light switches. To his surprise and relief, they worked.

The cellar was about the size of two tennis courts, although the openness of the space was broken by a regular series of brick pillars holding up the hospital above. Piles of wooden chairs and tables near the entrance impeded his progress, but once past them he found exactly what he’d hoped to find: rows of shelving reaching up to the ceiling and laden with cardboard file holders. A cursory opening of one of them revealed the patient notes of Mrs Matilda Gardner, who had been treated for gallstones in 1976.

The big question now in Steven’s mind was whether or not the notes had just been piled there haphazardly or whether they were in any kind of order. If the former, he was looking at a career, and one he had no wish to embark on. He stood in the eerie silence of the underground cavern, looking for any helpful signs on the shelving, his spirits falling as he failed to find any.

He walked towards the nearest row, already starting to
calculate
just how many people it would take to sift through the mountains of files and put them in chronological order. Then something caught his eye and he ran his fingers along the bottom edge of one of the shelves. To his joy, as the dust and grime cleared a little, he could just about make out something scrawled in black pen: two numbers and a dash: 75 –

With hope rekindled, Steven collected an armful of files and took them back to the cellar entrance where he dumped them on the floor while he fetched a table and a chair from the pile, and set them up as an impromptu office where he could sit and look through the files. It only took a few moments to establish that the ones he’d picked up were all from patients who’d been in the hospital in 1975. There was order among the feared chaos.

Steven put back the ’75 files and started hunting for more pen markings on the shelves. He felt his pulse-rate rise as he came across ‘91 –’. Another armful of folders and a few minutes sitting at his reclaimed dusty desk and he had established that he was looking at files from patients treated in the hospital at the time of the Northern Health Scheme. He now had to decide whether to make arrangements for people to come here to sift through the records or to organise transport to take the files back to London.

It only took a few moments for him to plump for London. Sci-Med had a network of consultants, agencies and contacts they could call in at a moment’s notice. Jean Roberts would be able to come up with a team of people with the necessary skills to analyse medical records and report on their findings. They could be doing that while he went to pay Gordon Field a visit in prison. He had phone calls to make.

Steven paused at the door to examine the metal light switches. He hadn’t seen these for years but they looked the same as the ones his grandmother had had in her house in Keswick. He was thinking about her and picturing the front room with its piano and lace curtains when he heard a sound suggesting that someone was outside in the corridor.

‘Hello, is anyone there?’ he called out.

There was no reply.

He couldn’t quite convince himself it had been his imagination so he tried again.

Nothing.

Steven shrugged and switched out the chamber lights before closing the door and crossing the cellar junction, preparing himself for the stooped journey back along the pipe corridor he’d come in through. He felt the heat on his face as once more he came into close proximity to the supply pipes, carefully steering a middle course so that he didn’t touch them. Maybe it was the slight unease he felt about thinking he wasn’t alone that heightened his alertness, but when he thought he saw a movement a few metres ahead he instinctively dropped to his knees and put his hands up in front of his face.

At the same moment a valve opened and high-pressure steam shot out, scalding the back of his hands and filling the tunnel with deafening noise and the sulphurous smell of a boiler-house. Steven cried out in pain as he rolled away. He crawled along the floor under the steam jet until he was past the open valve, where he was just in time to see a running figure up ahead.

‘You son of a bitch,’ he yelled out, as anger vied with pain and sent him off in pursuit. He could see it was a male figure, tall – like him it had to stoop to avoid hitting its head – dressed in denims and trainers … and getting away.

Steven stopped running. Get a grip, Dunbar, he thought. Think about your hands. He remembered seeing occasional taps set in the wall on the way in so he turned all his attention to finding one of them. When he did, he’d found a supply of cold water. He held his hands under the flow and experienced instant remission from the pain although he knew it would return when he removed them. He held them there long enough to catch his breath and regain rational thought. In spite of the pain, he’d been lucky. Had he not dropped to his knees so quickly the steam would have caught him full in the face. As it was, he needed to seek medical help as soon as possible to minimise the damage. At least he was in a hospital.

‘What the hell!’ exclaimed the clerk of works, Drysdale, when he saw the backs of Steven’s hands.

‘Steam burns,’ said Steven, hurrying past to get to A&E.