On a Beam of Light

On A Beam Of Light

Gene Brewer

In March 1995, 1 published an account of sixteen sessions with a psychiatric patient who believed he came (on a beam of light) from a planet called K-PAX. The patient, a thirty-three-year-old male Caucasian who called himself “prot” (rhymes with “goat”), was, in fact, a double personality whose alter ego, Robert Porter, had been devastated by a severe emotional trauma. The latter survived only by hiding behind his formidable “alien” friend. When prot “returned” to his home planet at precisely 3: 31 A. M. on August 17, 1990, promising to reappear “in about five of your years, ” Robert was left behind in a state of intractable catatonia, kept alive by constant monitoring and attentive care.

Many of the patients in residence at the Manhattan Psychiatric Institute at the time of prot’s tenure have since departed. These include Chuck and Mrs. Archer (all names have been changed to protect individual privacy), who only recently moved out to a retirement complex on Long Island, thanks to an annuity established by her late husband; and Ed, a psychopath who gunned down six people in a shopping mall in 1986, but who has evinced little tendency toward violent behavior since a chance encounter with prot in 1990. He now lives in a community care home with La Belle Chatte, a former feline resident of MPI. The only patient mentioned in K-PAX who was still with us in 1995 was Russell, our resident “chaplain, ” who had nowhere else to go.

Nevertheless, all our inmates, even the most recent arrivals, were well aware of prot’s promised return, and as the miserably hot, rainless summer days oozed by, the tension began to mount among patients and staff alike. (Only Klaus Villers, our director, remained unperturbed. In his opinion, “He vill neffer be back. Robert Porter vill be here foreffer. “)

No one anticipated prot’s return more than I, however, not only because of a paternal fondness I had developed for him during the course of our sessions together, but also because I still hoped to get Robert out of the catatonic ward and, with prot’s help, on the long road to recovery.

But “about five years” from the time of prot’s departure could have been anytime in 1995 or even later, so my wife and I went ahead with our usual plans to spend the middle two weeks of August at our Adirondack retreat.

That was a mistake. I was so preoccupied with the possibility of his imminent reappearance that I was very poor company for Karen and our friends, the Siegels, who tried every possible means to get my mind off my work. In hindsight I probably realized unconsciously that “five years” meant, to a mind as precise as prot’s, sometime within minutes or hours of that exact interval. In fact, it was on Thursday, August 17, at 9: 08 A. M., that I received a tearful call from Betty McAllister, our head nurse. “He’s back!” was all she could say, and all she needed to.

“I’ll be there this afternoon, ” I assured her. “Don’t let him go anywhere!”

Karen (a psychiatric nurse herself) merely smiled, shook her head, and began to pack a lunch for my return trip to the city while I grabbed up unread reports and unfinished manuscripts and stuffed them into my briefcase.

The drive gave me a chance to reflect once more on the events of 1990, which I had reviewed only a few weeks earlier in preparation for his possible return. For the benefit of those who are not familiar with the history of the case, a brief summary follows:

Robert Porter was born and raised in Guelph, Montana. In 1975, when he was a high-school senior, he married a classmate, Sarah (Sally) Barnstable, who had become pregnant. The only job he could find to support his new wife and budding family was “knocking” steers in the local slaughterhouse, the same job that had killed his father some twelve years earlier.

One Saturday in August 1985, Robert arrived home from work to find a stranger coming out the front door. He chased the man through the house, past the bloody bodies of his wife and daughter, and into the backyard, where he broke the intruder’s neck. Numb with grief, he attempted suicide by drowning in the nearby river. However, he washed ashore downstream, and from that moment forward was no longer Robert Porter, but “prot, ” a visitor from the idyllic planet K-PAX, where all the terrible things that had befallen his alter ego could never happen.

Indeed, his was a truly Utopian world, where everyone lived happily for a thousand years without the tiresome need to work for a living, where there was little or no sickness, poverty, or injustice, nor, for that matter, schools, governments, or religions of any kind. The only drawback to life on K-PAX seemed to be that sexual activity was so unpleasant that it was resorted to only to maintain the (low) population levels.

After prot, a true savant who knew a great deal about astronomical matters, was brought to MPI (how he got to New York is still a mystery), it took me several weeks to understand that he was a secondary personality behind whom his primary psyche was hiding and, with the help of Giselle Griffin, a freelance reporter, to identify that tragic soul as Robert Porter. But this revelation came too late. When prot “departed” the Earth on August 17, 1990, Robert, no longer able to hide behind his alter ego, retreated deep into the recesses of his own shattered mind.

Nothing, including a series of electroconvulsive treatments and the most powerful antidepressant drugs, had been of any use in arousing Robert from his rigor. I even tried hypnosis, which had proven so effective in revealing what had happened to him in 1985. He ignored me, as he did everyone else. Thus, it was with mounting excitement that I arrived at the hospital that hot August afternoon and hurried to his room, where I somehow expected prot to be ready and eager to get on with whatever he had “come back” to do. Instead, he was weak and unsteady, though a bit impatient to be up and going, as anyone who had spent five years in the fetal position would be. He was asking (more of a croak) for his favorite fruits, of course, and blamed his feeble state on his recent “voyage. ” Betty had already seen that he had some liquid nourishment, including a little apple juice, and Dr. Chakraborty, our chief internist, had ordered a sedative to help him sleep, which he did almost immediately after I arrived.

It may seem odd to the reader that prot needed rest after five years of inactivity, but the fact is that the catatonic patient, unlike the comatose, is neither asleep nor unconscious but rigidly awake, like a living statue, afraid to move for fear of committing further “reprehensible” acts. It is this muscle rigidity (sometimes alternating with frenetic activity) that results in the utter exhaustion the patient feels when he is finally aroused.

I decided to let him recuperate for a few days before bombarding him with the list of questions I had been compiling for half a decade and getting on with his (Robert’s) treatment and, I fervently hoped, successful recovery.

I scheduled the first session (the seventeenth overall) with prot for 3: 00 P. M., Monday, August 21, remembering to dim the lights for his sensitive eyes. Indeed, he removed his dark glasses as soon as he was escorted into my examining room by his old friend Roman Kowalski (Gunnar Jensen had retired), and I was delighted to find that he appeared to be fully recovered from five years of rigid immobility, though technically it was Robert, not prot, who had been catatonic throughout that period. He was, in fact, much as I remembered him: smiling, energetic, alert. The only notable changes were some weight loss and a hint of premature graying at the temples—he was now thirty-eight years old, though he claimed to be closer to four hundred. Betty had reported that he was already able to eat soft, easily digestible foods, so I had a few overripe bananas on hand, which he dug into with his usual relish, skins and all. “The riper the better, ” he reminded me. “I like them pitch-black. ” He seemed utterly at home, as if our last session had been only yesterday.

I turned on the tape recorder. “How are you feeling, prot?” I asked him.

“A little tired, gene. ” Note to reader: prot capitalized the names of planets, stars,
etc.
Everything else, including human beings, was, to him, of little universal importance and therefore lowercase. “How about yourself?”

“Much better, now that you’re back, ” I told him.

“Oh? Have you been ill?”

“Not exactly. Frustrated, mostly. “

“Maybe you should see a psychiatrist. “

“Actually, I’ve conferred with the best minds in the world about the source of my frustration. “

“Does it have anything to do with your relationships with other humans?”

“In a way. “

“I thought so. “

“To be frank, it concerns you and Robert. “

“Really? Have we done something wrong?”

“That’s what I’d like to know. Maybe we could begin with your telling me where you’ve been for the past five years. “

“Don’t you remember, doc? I had to return to ‘K-PAX for a while. “

“And you took Bess with you?” Note: Bess was a psy-chotically depressed patient who “disappeared” in 1990 along with prot.

“I thought a change of scene would do her good. “

“And where is she now?”

“Still on K-PAX. “

“She didn’t come back with you?”

“Nope. “

“Why not?”

“Are you kidding? Would you want to come back to this place after you’ve seen pa-ree?” NB: the “place” he referred to was the Earth, not the hospital.

“Can you prove to me that Bess is on K-PAX?”

“Can you prove she is not?”

A familiar sinking feeling began to set in. “And how is she doing?”

“Like a fish in water. She laughs all the time now. “

“And she didn’t come back with you. “

“Haven’t we been over this?”

“What about all the other K-PAXians?”

“What about them?”

“Did anyone else come with you?”

“No. I wouldn’t be surprised if no one ever did. “

“Why not?”

“They read my report. ” He yawned. “Still, you never know…. “

“Tell me something: Why did you come to Earth in the first place, knowing from our radio and TV broadcasts that it was such an inhospitable planet?”

“I told you before: Robert needed me. “

“That was in 1963?”

“By your calendar. “

“Just in time for his father’s funeral. “

“In the nick. “

“And you’ve made the trip several times since. “

“Nine, to be exact. “

“All right. Just for the record, then, you’ve been back on K-PAX for the past five years. “

“Well, it’s not that simple. There’s the round trip, which—oh, I explained all that last time, didn’t I? Let’s just say I stayed around for a little r and r after turning in my report to the libraries. Then I hurried on back here. “

“Why were you in such a hurry?”

“Ah, I get it. You’re asking me questions you already know the answers to. ” There it was: the familiar Cheshire-cat grin. “Just for the record—right?”

“In your case, I don’t know many of the answers yet, believe me. “

“Oh, I can believe that, all right. But to answer your question: I promised certain beings I would come back in five of your years, remember?”

“To take them to K-PAX with you. “

“Yep. “

“So what’s the rush?”

“They all seemed to want to leave as soon as possible. “

“And how many of them do you plan to take back with you when you go?”

Up to this point prot had been gazing about the room as if searching for familiar objects, pausing occasionally to study the watercolors on the various walls. Now he looked directly into my eyes and his smile vanished. “I came prepared this time, doctor b. I can take as many as a hundred beings with me when I return. “

“What? A hundred?”

“Sorry. Not enough room for more. “

The transcript indicates a long pause before I could think of a response. “Who do you think you’ll be taking, for example?”

“Oh, I won’t know that until the time conies. “

I could feel my heart pounding as I asked, as casually as I could, “And when will that be?”

“Ah. That would be telling. “

Now it was my turn to stare at him. “You mean you’re not even going to tell me how long you’ll be here?”

“I’m happy to see that your hearing is still unimpaired, narr” (pax-o for “gene, ” or “one who doubts”).

“I’d really like to know that, prot. Can you give me some idea at least? Another five years? A month?”

“Sorry. “

“Why the hell can’t you tell me?”

“Because if you knew when I was leaving you’d watch me like a cat watches a bird in this carnivorous WORLD. “

I had learned a long time ago that there was no use arguing with my “alien” friend. All I could do was make the best of whatever situation he sprang on me. “In that case, I’d like to schedule you for three weekly sessions. Every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at three o’clock. Would that be all right with you?”

“Whatever you say, dahktah. For the time being I’m at your service. “

“Good. There are a few more questions I’d like to ask you before you go back to your room. “

He nodded sleepily.

“First, where did you land on this trip?”

“The pacific ocean. “