Perfect Fit (3 page)

“Thanks, Alexa,” Cara said.

The other woman smiled. “I can honestly say it’s my
pleasure. It’ll also be my pleasure to kick his ass for ignoring pain. And trust me, he had to have felt something earlier.”

“I’ll help you,” Mike muttered. “Thanks for everything.”

Alexa nodded. “I’ll be back soon with news.” She, too, took off, leaving Cara and Mike alone.

Most of her earlier shakiness had subsided, leaving Cara exhausted. “I’m going to get some coffee. Want some?” she asked the hulking, silent man beside her.

“No, thanks.”

She shrugged. “Suit yourself,” she said, more uncomfortable now that the mood between them had shifted from connected to awkward. But awkward was the way things had been since his return. She turned and headed for the door.

“Cara.”

Surprised, she pivoted back toward him. “Yes?”

“Thank you. For calling 911 and making sure Sam got here quickly.”

It was as much of an apology for his earlier rudeness as she was likely to get. If she hadn’t been in the room with him that night three months ago, under him, over him, him deep inside her, his recent behavior would have convinced Cara that the most spectacular evening of her life had never happened. But it had, she thought, shivering as her body recalled the intimate connection. And that brief time together along with the flare of heat in his eyes today had convinced her she wasn’t crazy. He’d been as affected as she was, whether he showed it or not.

It was his choice not to acknowledge it that proved he wanted nothing to do with her. Heck, he clearly didn’t even want a repeat performance, which merely reinforced Sam’s point. As he’d informed Cara before she’d left the bar with his brother, Mike viewed everything and everyone in life as temporary. He’d even reminded her of Tiffany Marks, the woman he’d dated before leaving for Atlantic City. Everyone
in town knew she’d gone so far as to make inquiries into booking the only church in town for a wedding Mike had never planned on happening. Except Tiffany had been certain Mike was on the verge of popping the question, and she’d been heartbroken when he’d left.

When Cara had agreed to their one night, she’d been okay with that. She knew that while he didn’t stick around, she was a small-town girl at heart, with small-town aspirations. She’d happily remain in Serendipity long after the big-city detective left his temporary job as chief of police behind. She had no doubt if she got involved with Mike again, she’d end up with a broken heart. But he wasn’t asking her for anything.

Yet if he pressed, she’d be tempted. And what did that say about her? She shook her head to dislodge thoughts of a man who clearly wasn’t interested. Cara wouldn’t chase after a man any more than she’d let one take advantage of her. Her mother and father’s unbalanced, unhealthy relationship set an example Cara refused to follow.

With that reality firmly in mind, she went for coffee.

Mike had faced down drug dealers and embezzlers
with enough at stake to warrant killing him in order to keep their activities secret, and he hadn’t been afraid. He’d be damned if he’d let one pint-sized police officer with ocean-blue eyes get under his skin. His brother would be okay, and that was what he needed to focus on, not the way Cara, the always-in-control cop, had nearly broken down, reminding him she was also soft and female. He already knew that all too well.

After seeing Cara at the hospital yesterday, Mike had promised himself that except for work, he’d steer clear. He’d even thought his self-imposed directive would be simple. But when he came to visit his brother the next morning, Cara was already there, having stopped by on her way to
work. He heard her laughter from the hallway as he approached Sam’s room.

Though he wanted to come back later, Mike wasn’t a coward. He gripped the handle and let himself inside.

“Nice way to get some attention,” Mike said to Sam, who was laid up in bed.

“I’m not stupid.” His light-brown hair was messed and sticking up at odd angles, his face pale, yet he managed a grin.

“No, you’re not. The nurses are lining up to take care of him,” Cara said, catching Mike’s gaze.

She rose to her feet. In her blue uniform, she looked every inch the professional.

“I was just leaving for work. I’ll let you two visit.” She gestured for Mike to take the chair she’d vacated by the side of the bed.

“Don’t let me run you off,” Mike said. “I’m sure your boss won’t mind if you’re a few minutes late for your shift.”

Cara pursed her lips. “Oh, I don’t know about that. He’s quite the hard-ass sometimes.”

Sam burst out laughing, then groaned and shut his eyes.

“I’m sorry.” Cara leaned over and pressed her hand to his cheek. “Are you okay?”

He nodded. “Maybe you should go. I may burst my stitches if you stick around while he’s here.” Sam inclined his head toward Mike.

He frowned, not liking that Cara hadn’t yet removed her hand from his brother’s cheek. “I’m her boss,” Mike reminded them. “Doesn’t that warrant at least some respect?”

“Only when you’re on duty, big brother.” Sam swallowed what was sure to be another laugh.

Cara shook her head, her smile coming through as she finally pulled her hand away.

Apparently she’d taken his sister’s words to heart and decided she could give him a hard time off duty. Her sassy
mouth was one of the things he’d enjoyed about her when he’d visited a few months ago, and it could definitely get him in trouble again now.

“I’m going, I’m going,” Cara muttered. “But I’ll be back after my shift. You,” she said, wagging a finger at Sam. “Behave and listen to your nurses.”

“Bring me a burger from The Family Restaurant?” he asked.

Cara shook her head. “Not until the doctors say it’s okay.” She glanced at Mike, meeting his gaze with a wry smile, showing off two dimples in her cheeks.

Damn. How could she be professional, cute, and sexy all at the same time? He’d worked with many women over the years, and he’d never been affected like this. Never mixed business and pleasure on the job because that made a situation harder to walk away from.

“Who’s her partner while I’m stuck here?” Sam asked.

One of the changes Mike intended to make within the department was eliminating partners. The way he viewed it, the force was small, as was the town. No need to tie up two officers together who could cover more areas separately. He’d planned to schedule a meeting with his officers next week, but now he’d wait a little while longer until Sam was up to speed.

“I paired her with Dare,” Mike said, giving her a heads-up.

“Dare and I work well together, so thanks,” she said, sounding surprised.

Did she really think he’d deliberately put her with someone more difficult after the day she’d had yesterday?

“Don’t forget to save the fun stuff for me,” Sam said, sounding suddenly intense.

Cara met Sam’s gaze. “You know it,” she said.

Which, to Mike, sounded like a promise. He glanced from his brother, who lay prone in his bed, to Cara. She stood by the door, massaging the muscles in her neck.

“Are you sure you’re up to working today?” Mike asked. “No whiplash, pain, or trauma?”

“Nah. I’m tougher than I look. And definitely tougher than my partner.” With a wink at Sam and a quick gaze at Mike, she ducked out the door, leaving the brothers alone.

“Sit,” Sam said in a no-argument tone that belied the fact that Mike was the older brother and Sam was laid up in a hospital bed.

Not wanting to upset Sam in his condition, Mike lowered himself into the chair. Folding his arms across his chest, he leaned back. “What’s up?”

“What’s going on with you and Cara?” Sam asked.

“Nothing.”

“You haven’t discussed what happened between you two yet?” Sam asked, or rather croaked through his dry throat.

Mike handed his brother a cup of water from his tray. “It hasn’t come up.”

Sam drank and put his cup down. “You mean she hasn’t brought it up, so you won’t.”

“Why the hell did you wait until you were lying in a hospital bed for this discussion? It’s not like we couldn’t have had this talk weeks ago.”
Or preferably not at all
, Mike thought.

“Because you’ll pay attention to me now.” Sam smirked at that little bit of truth.

“It’s none of your business,” Mike tried reminding his brother. He shifted his gaze to the white hospital walls. Unless…A sudden thought came to him. “Did Cara say anything to you about us?” The word sounded awkward on his tongue.

“No. She knows not to expect anything from you,” Sam muttered.

“Good.” Mike exhaled the breath he hadn’t realized he was holding.

The last thing he needed was a woman he’d slept with and who now worked for him having any expectations. He
shuddered at the thought. It was taking all he had inside him to focus on staying in Serendipity, working at his father’s job, and worrying about his old man.

“Good?” Sam clenched his fists at his side.

When it came to Cara, his brother’s protective instincts came out like crazy. Another reason Mike knew he’d made a mistake sleeping with her.

Except it hadn’t felt like a mistake at the time. And he wanted to do it again.

“Just because she knows doesn’t mean you aren’t making her feel like shit by ignoring what happened. Jesus, Mike, was it that bad?”

“No, it was that good. Now can we drop it?” Mike barked at his brother.

To his shock, Sam grinned. “Just one question first. What would you do to someone who treated Erin the way you’re treating Cara?”

Mike preferred to think of his younger sister as a sweet innocent, not a twenty-seven-year-old woman. “I’d kick his ass,” Mike said immediately.

Sam’s knowing stare, full of meaning and, yeah, disappointment, stabbed Mike in the gut, and blood rushed to his cheeks in embarrassment. Shame quickly followed. Okay, so he and Cara had some talking to do.

And clearly Mike had walked right into his brother’s trap. “I’m still not discussing Cara with you.”

“Good, because I don’t want details. I just wanted you to look at things the right way.” Sam gestured to the water, and Mike poured him some more. “Besides, I figure you two can only ignore the obvious for so long before something gives.”

Sam had a point. Which brought Mike full circle to his earlier thoughts. No matter how much he denied it or tried to pretend otherwise, the woman got to him in a way that made her more dangerous than any potential suspect or case. And now that he realized he could no longer ignore the past,
putting it out for discussion would only make the feelings between them more real.

No, not feelings, he thought with a hard shake of his head. That word involved emotion. What he and Cara had shared was hot sex. Hotter than any he’d ever had—

“So how are you feeling?” Mike asked Sam, deliberately changing the subject.

His brother’s wince said it all. “Like my head’s about to explode, and my abdomen’s bloated and hurts like a son of a bitch.”

Mike nodded in understanding. “Rest. I’ll tell everyone at the station to hold off visiting for a day or two.”

Sam’s eyes began to close. “I’d appreciate that. I’m getting kicked out in two days, so they can come by and visit me then.”

“Do you need me to move in for a couple of days and help you out?” Mike asked.

Knowing his stay in town wasn’t permanent, and never needing much space, he’d rented the empty room over Joe’s Bar. Sam, like the true Marsden son, had already bought himself a small house in Serendipity, picket fence and all.

“Nah. Cara offered to let me take the spare room at her new condo.”

Mike ignored the hot flush of jealousy creeping through his veins. It was as unwarranted as it was ridiculous. Sam and Cara were best friends and partners, but there was nothing sexual between them. And even if there was, Mike didn’t plan to pick up where they’d left off, so what was his problem?

“That was nice of her to offer.” Mike forced out the words.

“Yeah. I might take her up on it,” Sam said, sounding groggier by the minute.

“Hey, did you click on your meds while I wasn’t looking?” Mike gestured to the button attached to his brother’s IV.

Sam nodded, a goofy grin on his face. “Yeah. Feeling no pain, my man.”

Mike rolled his eyes. Time for him to go. He braced his hand on the bed and rose to his feet. “You get some sleep. I’ll come by after work. Mom said to tell you they’ll be here around lunchtime.”

“Okay. They came late last night for a quick hello, but I was pretty out of it.”

“Yeah, but they both slept better for seeing you.”

Sam didn’t reply. He was already passed out cold. Mike shook his head and walked out. First stop coffee shop, then he’d get lost in work. Later on today, he’d deal with Cara Hartley.

Two

The morning passed quickly. A beat-up Trans Am
blew through the stop sign at the corner of Main Street, forcing Cara and Dare to pull over a teenage driver who carried only a permit and who wasn’t supposed to be driving without a licensed adult in the car. His attitude didn’t help his cause, nor did the fact that he should have been in school. They wrote up the ticket and gave the truant an escort to the high school before heading back to town and doing their basic drive-by.

“Man, I hope Tess doesn’t end up like that punk,” Dare said of his fifteen-year-old half sister.

“I’m sure having a cop for a brother will keep her from turning into Danica Patrick too soon,” Cara said with a laugh. “Although knowing Tess, she’ll find a way to keep you all up at night worrying.”

Tess lived with Dare’s oldest brother, Ethan, and his wife in the landmark mansion on the edge of town. Making things more interesting—and titillating for the more gossip-minded residents in town—his middle brother, Nash, was
married to Tess’s half sister. But whomever she lived with, they all worried about Tess, given her history before moving to Serendipity.

“I just hope Ethan doesn’t buy her an over-the-top car,” Dare said.

Cara shook her head at the thought. “Ethan has a level head.” She caught Dare’s look of disbelief. “Now. He has a level head now.” The whole town remembered his past.