Play Dead (8 page)

T
HERE IS A
noticeable spring in Richard’s step when he is brought into the interview room. Since this is an official attorney’s visit, Kevin and I don’t have to talk to him through the glass in the visitors’ area. We get to talk in this private room, a risk the state is willing to take because Richard is in handcuffs and leg shackles. Should this prove insufficient, two guards are stationed outside the room, probably armed with tactical nuclear weapons.

Despite the fact that our chances for success are remote, Richard’s improved outlook is at least somewhat warranted. For the past five years he has had absolutely no reason to be hopeful; no one was working on his behalf to win his freedom or supporting his cause. Now we’re doing that, and for the first time Richard can believe that things are happening.

I introduce Kevin, and then we get right to it. I start by giving the standard speech about how we can help him only if we know everything, and that he should leave nothing out when answering our questions. Any detail, however small or insignificant it might seem, can be the crucial one.

“Tell us about that night,” I say.

“There was nothing unusual about it except for the way it ended,” he says. “It was summer, and Stacy and I would go out on the boat most weekends, at least when the weather was good. When it wasn’t, we’d go to a cabin I have in upstate New York.” He pauses a moment. “That’s the ironic thing. If we had known a storm was coming, we would probably have gone to the cabin. But it wasn’t predicted.”

“When you went out on the boat, did Reggie always go along?”

He nods. “Absolutely. Reggie went everywhere with us. Stacy loved him almost as much as I did.”

“You slept on the boat?”

He nods. “Most of the time. It was a forty-footer… slept six.”

“So there was nothing out of the ordinary about that night that you can remember?”

“Nothing. I’ve thought about it a thousand times. We went to bed at about nine o’clock. By then we had heard there was a chance of weather coming in, and I set the warning system up loud so I would definitely hear it.”

“Warning system?” Kevin asks. He knows as little about boating as I do.

Richard nods. “If there are weather warnings, a general alert is sent out. We were only about four miles out, so we’d have plenty of time to get back if we had to.”

“And you never heard a warning?” I ask.

“I never heard anything. I went to sleep and woke up in the hospital.”

“Do you remember taking the sleeping pills?” Kevin asks.

Richard shakes his head vigorously. “I never took sleeping pills. Not that night, not ever in my life. I didn’t even have any. They were not mine.”

“Were they Stacy’s?” I ask.

“I don’t believe so. If they were, she never mentioned it. I never knew her to have trouble sleeping.”

“So you have no idea how they got in your system?”

He shakes his head. “None at all.”

We talk some more about the night of the murder, but he has little else to add. While the important things were happening, he was asleep. All he remembers is a pleasant night out on the water, dinner, some wine, and an early trip to bed since he was tired from working all day.

I turn the focus to his job, that of a senior customs inspector at the Port of Newark. I ask him if there was anything about his job that could have made him a target.

“No, nothing,” he says. “It was a slow time.”

The answer is a little quick for my tastes. “Richard, I want you to understand something. You may not have committed this murder, but someone did. Someone with a reason. Now, that reason could involve you or Stacy, or the two of you together. So you need to open your mind to anyone who could have possibly hoped to gain from putting you in this position.”

“Don’t you think I’ve done nothing but think about that for five years? If someone was trying to get rid of me because I knew something, they shouldn’t have bothered, because I sure as hell don’t know that I know it. Besides, if I was a danger to someone, why not just kill me?”

It’s a good question, and one I eventually must answer. But for now I take him through a description of day-to-day life on his job. Border security in this era of terrorism has taken on an obviously extreme importance, and it was Richard’s task to make sure that the Port of Newark was as free of contraband as possible.

Finally, I turn the conversation to Stacy, and even five years later, it’s evident that his grief over her loss is still powerful. “How did you meet?” I ask.

“At a counter, having lunch. She was sitting next to me, and before I knew it we were having a conversation. We had dinner that night, and it just went from there.”

“Where was she from?” Kevin asks.

“Minnesota… a town just outside of Minneapolis. Her parents were killed in a car crash when she was eighteen. She worked there and then decided to move east.”

“What did she do?”

“She was a teacher, but what she really wanted was to be a chef. The things she made were incredible. She wanted to open her own restaurant.”

He talks about Stacy for a while longer, answering every question but never getting much below surface platitudes. He makes her sound so perfect she reminds me of Laurie.

“Were you in the Army?” I ask.

He nods. “National Guard. Served three months in Kuwait during the first Gulf war.”

“Do the names Archie Durelle or Antwan Cooper mean anything to you?”

His facial expression shows no recognition at all. “No, I don’t think so,” he says. “Who are they?”

I’m not ready to tell him that they took a shot at me on the highway. “Just some names I’ve heard; I’m checking out everything I can.”

The last ten minutes of our visit are devoted to the obligatory questions he has about progress we might be making and strategy we might be employing. I fend them off because basically we’re not making any progress and don’t yet have a strategy.

Once Kevin and I are in the car, I ask, “So, what do you think?”

“I find myself wanting to believe him.”

“Do you believe him?” I ask.

He shakes his head. “Not yet. His version is just too full of holes. The prosecution has it locked up airtight.”

“Except for Reggie. Reggie says he’s innocent,” I say.

“He told you that?”

“Not in so many barks, but I got the message.”

I like dogs considerably more than I like humans. That doesn’t make me antihuman; there are plenty of humans I’m very fond of. But generally speaking, if I simultaneously meet a new human and a new dog, I’m going to like the dog more.

I’m certainly going to trust the dog more. They’re going to tell me what they think, straight out, and I’m not going to have to read anything into it. They are what they are, while very often humans are what they aren’t.

I say this fully aware that dogs cannot replace humans in our day-to-day lives. I have never met a competent dog airline pilot, short-order cook, quarterback, or bookmaker. These are necessary functions that we must trust humans to provide, and I recognize that. It’s not that I’m an eccentric about this.

So for now I’m going to pursue this case, even though Richard has nothing going for him.

Except for Reggie.

J
OEL
M
ARSHAL IS
on the front lines, protecting our country.

I can’t say he looks the part. At about five eight and a hundred and fifty pounds, he’s one of the few male adults under ninety that I would be willing to get in the ring with. As a protector of the country, he is not the type you would describe as someone “you want on that wall, you need on that wall.”

Marshal is U.S. Customs director for the Port of Newark, and it’s his job to ensure that the endless flow of cargo that comes in each year does not include things like drugs, guns, anthrax, and nuclear bombs. It is a daunting task, which is why I’m surprised it was so easy to get an immediate meeting with him.

It may have been a quickly arranged meeting, but it won’t be a long one. He’s looking at his watch almost as soon as I sit down. It’s a common tactic; I think watches are more often used to demonstrate a lack of time than to tell time.

“Thanks for seeing me so soon,” I say. “I won’t take much of your time.”

“I appreciate that,” he says. “It’s a busy day today.” He glances at his watch again, though less than fifteen seconds have passed since the last time he looked. “What can I do for you?”

He says this with what seems to be a permanent smile on his face. If the smile could talk, it would say, “I am a political appointee, and this smile is government issue. It doesn’t mean I am happy or amused.”

“I’m representing Richard Evans.”

“Yes, you mentioned that,” he points out, accurately.

“I’m operating under the assumption that the evidence against Mr. Evans was deliberately faked. What I am trying to find out is why.”

“What does that have to do with me?”

I explain that one of my theories is that Richard was targeted because of something involved with his work. He could have been removed from that work because of something he knew, or possibly to get him out of the way.

“It hardly seems likely,” Marshal says. “But in any event, there’s little I can help you with. I’ve only been assigned here for one year, and I had never even met Mr. Evans.”

“So you’re not familiar with his case?” I ask.

He shakes his head. “Should I be? It’s pretty much ancient history, and my understanding was that it did not involve his job. It was a personal matter.”

Murders usually are “personal matters,” but I decide not to point this out. “Who replaced him?” I ask.

“I’m not sure. Roy Chaney is in the job now, but I’m not aware if he followed Mr. Evans, or if there was somebody else in the interim.”

“Can you check?”

This prompts another look at his watch and, while not a frown, a slight weakening of the smile. Finally, he asks his assistant to get the information, but it proves to be unnecessary, as the assistant was working here five years ago. She confirms that Chaney replaced Evans.

I thank Marshal and leave. Rather than go straight to my car, I decide to display my awesome investigative prowess and walk aimlessly around the area. It’s an enormous place, with endless, cavernous warehouses starting near the water and stretching well inland.

There are not many people around, just thousands of unattended boxes and crates. Security is either nonexistent or very subtle; I get the feeling that if one of the boxes had “ANTHRAX – IF YOU ARE WITHIN TWO MILES OF THIS CRATE, YOU WILL BE DEAD IN FOUR MINUTES” printed on the side it wouldn’t attract attention.

After about twenty minutes of intensive investigating, all I’ve really managed to do is get lost, to the point that I have no idea where my car is.

I happen upon a small building that contains a few glass-enclosed offices. A woman sits behind one of the desks, so I lean in and ask if she knows where Joel Marshal’s office is, since that’s where I parked my car.

She smiles. “Just walk in the direction you were going, and after the second building make a right.”

“Thanks,” I say, and then decide to try another question. “Do you happen to know where I can find Roy Chaney?”

She smiles again, ever helpful, and calls out, “Roy! Somebody here to see you!”

All this time I thought I was lost, when in fact I was relentlessly zeroing in on Chaney’s office. Within a few moments a man I assume to be Chaney comes out of a rear office and walks toward the doorway, where I am standing. He looks as though he’s pushing 40, pushing 5'10", and has already pushed past 240 pounds. I wouldn’t want to try to sneak any contraband chocolate cupcakes or potato chips into the country with this guy around.

“What can I do for you?” he asks.

“You’re Roy Chaney?”

He nods. “Yup. Who are you?”

“My name is Andy Carpenter. I’m an attorney representing Richard Evans.”

“Is that right?” he says as he walks past me and out the door, leading me to step out as well. It was a clumsy attempt to conceal that he does not want the woman at the desk to hear the conversation.

“Yes. I understand you replaced him when he went on trial.”

“That’s right. I didn’t know him, though. I mean, we never met. When I got here he was already gone.”

I’m not that great a judge of human behavior, but Chaney seems nervous. “But you took over his responsibilities?”

“Right.”

“Was there anything unusual about any of the things he was working on? Or any of the people he was working with?”

“Unusual like what?”

“Unusual like something which would have made someone want to get him off the job and out of the way. Do you remember anything like that?”

“No.” It’s far too quick an answer; this was five years ago, and he would have had no reason to be thinking about those days until my question. This guy is hiding something and is not at all good at it.

“You didn’t notice anything out of the ordinary with his work… anything that you might have reported to your superiors?”

“I haven’t done anything wrong,” he says. “I just show up and do my job.” It’s an answer completely unresponsive to my question, and when I get those kinds of answers, I usually assume they are both unresponsive and untruthful.

I give him my card and tell him that he should call me if he thinks of anything. As I’m leaving, he says, “You trying to get Evans out of jail?”

I nod. “I’m doing more than trying.”

Laurie calls on my cell phone as I’m leaving the port area.

“Andy? Where are you?” is how she starts the conversation.

“Newark,” I say.

“You’re kidding,” she says.

“I am?”

“Are you serious?” she asks.

“Why would I lie about being in Newark? And why are we having this inane conversation?”

“Because I’m in Newark, also. At the airport.”

“Are you serious?” I ask.

“Why would I lie about being in Newark?” she asks, and then laughs. “I got someone to cover for me… We switched vacation times. There was a flight and I rushed to catch it; I tried your cell but it didn’t go through. Can you pick me up?”

“Gee, I sort of had plans for tonight,” I say as I race at high speed toward the airport.

“Okay, I’ll hitch a ride with the good-looking guy I sat next to on the plane.”

“Or I can change my plans.”

I’m at the terminal within ten minutes, and Laurie is waiting for me outside baggage claim.

She looks fantastic, which does not come as a major surprise. A long flight is not going to affect that; she could go through three wash cycles at Kevin’s Law-dromat and come out looking one corsage short of ready for the prom.

As I pull up, I’m faced with a choice. I can get out and help her get the suitcases into the car, or I can let her do it herself. My instinct is to get out, but it means that our hug and kiss hello will take place out in public, surrounded by travelers. If she gets in, we can do it in the car, in relative privacy.

It’s decision making like this that is the reason they pay me the big bucks.

I get out, put the suitcases in the trunk, and we do the hug and kiss routine for all Newark Airport to see. It’s not ideal, but it’s not half bad, either. In fact, it’s so not half bad that I briefly consider whether to take a room at the airport hotel.

Five minutes into our ride, Laurie says, “Is this where you got shot at?”

I was so focused on getting Laurie home that I hadn’t even noticed that. “Just up ahead.”

“Is Marcus around?”

I shrug. “You know Marcus. He’ll show up if I need him.” Then it hits me. “Wait a minute—you switched your vacation and came here early because you were worried about me. You don’t think I can take care of myself.”

She smiles. “You can’t.”

I laugh. “Then it’s good you showed up.”

We get home, and Laurie spends five minutes petting and hugging Tara, then another five meeting and petting Reggie.

“You want something to eat?” I ask.

She shakes her head. “I want to get these clothes off.”

“Don’t let me stop you,” I say.

She smiles. “I was talking about your clothes.”

“Don’t let me stop you.”