âSo you've come a long long way from nowhere, Luriel. Nothing could be plainer than the evidence that you're building on God's willâthat's the Third Stepâwith His will, and that He actually wants you to stick with you, to stay here and submit and trust us to help you.'
âBut I don't trust
anybody!
'she cried out.
âYou trust what I've been saying to you, or you wouldn't have changed so in the last ten minutes. How about Harley, who was so gentle with you in Group?'
âMaybe you two, but not the others.'
Severance was not having that, after Letty. âWe're all for you,' he said with hard tenderness, liking her as much as he could, âyou can't stalk out on us like this and destroy yourself.'
âThat's just what I felt like doing.'
âExactly. That's just what I really was afraid of. Do you think I don't care about you, Luriel?'
âWell,
I
don't care,' she said roughly, âbut if you do, I
don't mind staying, I guess. I'd have to put all this stuff away'âshe looked helplessly round her.
âGet Letty to help you,' he said, standing up with a surge of relief. It had been easy, after all, the work had not been done by him, and he went back to his room and his own work with a better heart.
That night on his bony knees he was visited by a calm joy of prayer, long-lasting: the miracle of me-suicidal three weeks ago to me-now, survivor of renewed access to realities, partly in true touch with myself for the first time in many years, confident (though fear tooâof OutsideâI won't go home, whatever they say, with my problem hanging), happy, and
useful
to my friends these last days, certain to be so in days to come, goodnight, thank You.
Â
Â
MONDAY WENT SWIFTLY BY, punctuated however with new thoughts of an alarming kind which was not to declare itself until the following morning and of which meanwhile the less said the better, Severance only felt rushed from time to time, and menaced. Nobody spoke of his being discharged, and he was as glad not to face the temptation. Stack was confronted for nearly the whole two hours without result. Accused of self-pity, he chimed in heartily, âThat's right! Self-pity!' but did not see either that he ought to cast it off or that it was grounded in measureless resentment, which, further, he could not name. âMe? I don't resent anybody or anything! Not me!' boiling with
it, innocent. Keg wrote on the board a favourite aphorism: âWe are as sick as we are secret.' Severance looked at it with grave doubts. Called out of Group to see Dr Gullixson he took up with him the question, from Saturday's trouble, of his actual superiority in communication. âWhy should it matter?' he asked aggrieved.
âHow can you ask?' said the older man. âIt's the one main way in which we know other people and make ourselves known.'
âIs it unavoidably obvious, except in diction?' Alan pursued a lost hope of equality, his mind telling him at the same time: phrasing, syntax, pace, rhythm, pauses, his sudden great volume (hated by all, including Ruth, an eccentricity no doubt from lecturing).
ââeverything that aims at persuading or emphasizing or dominating,' Gullixson was saying. âIt's your racket, naturally. Part of how you got where you are.'
âWherever I am,' Alan said unhappily. âThen there's nothing to be done about it. People resent it, or some do.'
âTheir affair. Yes, it's a permanent real problem, neither alcoholic nor neurotic. You don't really think we don't pay for our advantages, do you? But about this roaring of yours: you ought to consider whether it isn't a means of intimidation, and whether whatever satisfaction it gives you is worth your wife's discomfort, or indeed anybody's, since you seem to dislike it yourself. I must say you've never roared at me.'
âIt comes out with awful naturalness,' Severance said grimly. âBut I may as well change my whole way of life while I'm at it.'
âHardly that,' Gullixson was smiling. âJust enough to acquire and equip dryness. Roar away if you like.'
But the scientist roared not all that day, instead he grew increasingly and mysteriously abashed, until after dinner he was scarcely able to speak to his wife and daughter visiting, he heard no lecture and half-slept fitfully after a despairing
prayer, still without knowing just what was wrong, until in the darkness of earliest morning he came to suddenly on a forgotten scene. He was in his aunt's apartment in California twenty years ago. He had come in very late and very drunk, to spend the night as he sometimes on trips did, after a loud party for him following his high-powered evening lecture at UCLA. She had waited up or got up. They were sitting drinking, a nightcap, nightcaps? Had he made a gesture, or said something? He felt so, now stretched in his hospital bed, trembling with horror. Nothing was clear, two lamps shifting, a shadowy alcove, except that he was drunker than she was. Merciful, that. He seemed to feel her put a palm on his forehead, smoothing him back, before he passed out. So nothing had happened, no kiss even? But the terrible design was clear. His mother's closest sister. It stood before him worse than what he
had
remembered last year in the second week of treatment at Howarden, and begun his Fifth Step with, walking into the office and saying shamed to Father L, âThe worst things I have done in my awful life were to make three excellent women utterly miserable with my drinking and bad sex and to seduce once after we both married my dearest girl cousin.' Darker still.
Inappropriate and paralyzing sexual images danced before his closed eyes in their dozens, or hundreds or thousands. Vulvas, hands on him, mouths, hot breasts, spread bottoms, their clenched feet and scissoring, in cemeteries, parks, cars, sand-dunes, darkness and daylight, floors, beds, beds. Heavy breathing, gropings back. Once without even knowing who it was. Friends' wives, virgins. Unspeakable. And the myriad unacted. He might not be as bad, Severance thought with clenched teeth, as the poor maniac in Stekel who before speaking to a man had to look fixedly at him and repeat to himself, âFirst I will bite off his nose, then knock in his teeth, then shove his chest,' while thinking first of his penis, then of his anus; noâbut nearly.
With disheartening regularity he phantasised on women in any degree attractive, on busses, sidewalks, in crowds, anywhere. His poor thing shrivelled in his groin as he cursed himself. He envied, not for the first time, the great early Alexandrian theologian who taking, âIf thine eye offend thee,' literally, castrated himself.
Then a thought if possible more drastic entered his tortured head. Should he report all this in Group? Grievous hours raced toward ten o'clock. But it was taken out of his hands.
Confrontation with Letty began, when he felt his head tilting backward, his mouth opening crookedly, his neck-muscles taut, and a soundless sobbing in his throat begin. He prayed not to be noticed or he prayed to be noticed. At length of course he was, and voices stopped. Finally somebody said, âDo you want to talk about it?' and his body arched forward and down and, gasping, fighting tears, with his face just above his knees, he spilled out in spurts of shame his sordid life. It took a long long time.
He sat sunken, amid dead silence.
âI'm a monster,' he choked out hoarse.
âMaybe it's easier to be a monster,' he heard Harley say, âthan a human being.'
Without attempting to understand this, he burst at last into convulsive tears. When he came back under control, Keg said, âDon't you want to try to sit up and look at us,' and with deep reluctance and a sudden, growing animosity he slowly did. He looked at the faces without looking at the faces. He hated his grievous confession to these remote bastards, and hardened his heart against them. During the prolonged confrontation that followed, he grew more and more morose, only once snapping bitterly, âDon't ask me that question any more, Mary-Jane,' and once starting to cry again, leaning his head against Hutch's shoulder on his rightâthe big man warned in a low voice, âSelf-pity,' and with one rare impulse of gratitude he straightened
back up. He heard Harley and her read in his tale âlonely despair' and felt none, except of the Group. Harley also said he saw the ârage and hatred of women' that Alan had certainly mentioned with passion at one point in his outburst, as overlying some different emotion. Several people saw fear, and he didn't understand this either, and detested them. When they finally gave up, he heard as from a great distance Keg's harsh summary: âunable to level with anger, fear, guiltâunable to level.' Nothing mattered to him, surrounded by enemies. Far from any longer trusting the Group or imagining that he could ever expect any help from it, he felt no concern for anyone in it and wondered what he was doing there, listening now, wounded, stony, to the details of Letty's relation with her ambivalent mother.
Â
Â
A FAILURE SO ABJECT after the embracement of a risk so great might have been expected to drive a man out of treatment. But Severance had survived something of the sort once before, in the Spring, during his second confrontation, and it did not occur to him to leave hospital. He had developed a little nervous hum, unawares until other patients teased him about it at table one day. Vin noticed it, andâa great natural producer lost to the stageâmade him take it out and put it on a chair facing him, and talk to it; and have the hum talk back. Semi-hallucinatory after an hour under high pressure, he conducted a one-man merciless dialogue, with the hum attacking. âYou're
doomed!' it roared at him. âThat's right!' he roared back. But later he was unable to describe the hum, and sank into defiant stupor, until at last Vin turned to someone else saying, âI've seen you take risks in the past, Alan, but today you're playing it safe.' Also Severance was tough, a hard-case if quivering veteran of you name it, with nothing to lose.
Also he had picked up something: that concern is not necessary for help, you can be sharply helped by someone who doesn't give a damn about you or even hates you. Joining perfunctorily, towards the end of the session, in a confrontation of Stack, he had been amazed to find the slit-eyes in the huge face glaring at him and lashing, âWhat about you? You say you're hard of hearing! But you always come late to lectures and sit at the back! You can't hear a word!' His first impulse to deny it failed: it was too true, he had been neglecting, without realizing it, an important part of treatment. âGod damn it, you're right, Stack. I've been goofing off, there's no excuse for it. It'll change,' and when they were leaving Group in the hall Stack put an arm around his shoulder, âSorry, Alan,' they agreed to look for each other, go down to lectures together and sit together, without exception. Here was a definite gain. He even felt affection for savage old Stack, for Hutch; remnants of, for Mary-Jane who had come in after lunch with, âYou make me madâthe great Alan Severance,' and so on.
Also, he decided, he had as usual set his goal too high. âAim high, then,' Thoreau might warn, but character-reformation in a month, at fifty-five? Unrealistic expectations, as usual. This was a hospital, the matter was medico-psychological, the purpose simply to safeguard sobriety as a habit, break apart the delusions that allow (enforce?) drinking. He had swallowed the Group-mystique too far for himânot much of a Group-man after all. Rigorous honest private mental work had brought him wherever he
was. He saw no reason to give up. When groups, though, of which he felt part in the past had been beleaguered he had sprung into public actionâhe was no hermit or lighthouse-keeper or prospector (attractive destinies, however) âand this Group utterly was beleaguered. Look at Wilbur. Maybe after his resentment had faded some,
some
Group-sense might return.
Also there was his problemânot the Jewish aspiration, pursued daily, that didn't have to be solved here on the Ward, but the missing years and his father.
How
had he really felt about him, down the deep backward and abysm? He could not remember ever once being punished by him, though Mother's hairbrush as a paddle was vivid enough and Uncle Jack's declaring, âI'll never again meet you anywhere,' when as a boy he was late for an appointment on some corner in New York chilled his blood and still did. Could he recall his father ever even angry? Mother said once he had been rather a
cold
manâas Thoreau called himself. Am I wrong about the warm close fishing hunting father-son duo I've always seemed to remember?
He sat up in his chair and reached for the scratch-pad, jotting:
âNew problem. Did I myself feel any
guilt
perhapsâlong repressed if so, and mere speculation now (defence here)â
about Daddy's death?
(I certainly picked up enough of Mother's self-blame to accuse her once, drunk and raging, of having actually murdered him and staged a suicide.) Lecturer lately on children's blaming themselves for father drunk (=What did I do to make Daddy angry and get drunk?). BLANK, probably odd. He
was
drinking heavily, all four of them were in those last weeks, nightmarish quarrels. Gun-death at dawn, like Hemingway's, imitating his father. Does my fanatical drinking emulate his, and my fanatical smoking (both “manly”)? So possibly it wasn't rage/self-pity, but guilt, that were simply driven
underground for a year (Why? if so) to emerge after all and cripple my prep school years. Then I “solved” the problem all wrong my first week here!?
âHow do I actually now see him: limited, weak, honest (but unfaithful at least twice), prominent only very locally, not a soldier (
fake
soldier, National Guard)âand do I feel guilty about this rather
contemptuous
view, in the face of my real love? Queer that that Faulkner story hit me so hard, hit me
only,
the sole early work of art I remember. Very young hero a British torpedo-boat second officer (my unfailing, planned juniority to somebody), hopeless drunkard between reckless missions, misunderstood by (older) American aviators, thought a sissy (me at St Paul's, because I wore glasses and didn't go out for football my first yearâhave always seen myself ruined there by this, but is it likely? And the bullying? awful, but adequate to explain an almost-four-year ambition-lacuna?)âanyway, braver than them, cooler in crisis, lost at last. What subtle identifications are worth pursuing? How many models can a grown man survive?'
He dropped his pen, confused. The mystery of what I was reading under the covers after lights-out! Tall handsome Daddy, adored and lost so soon!