ROMANCE: Mr. Mystery: (New Adult Bad Boy Romance) (Contemporary Mystery Short Stories) (48 page)

I grimaced and scanned the scene for Mason.  I had expected to find him the center of attention, but he was nowhere to be found.  I even tried braving the sea of people, but I was only pushed and groped.  I didn’t find him, all I did find was his keys on the coffee table.  At least he hadn’t left. 

I left the living room and kept looking for him.  I couldn’t find him anywhere.  Eventually, I started asking around for him.  No one seemed to know where he was.  I was getting worried.  What if something had happened to him?  I asked more people, when finally someone seemed to know the answer.

“Oh Mason?  The cutie is upstairs with you!”  The drunk girl giggled before stumbling away.  I watched her as she nearly fell over, but then some guy caught her.  They started to make out.  I promised myself I would never get drunk, ever.

I turned toward the stairs, thinking about what the girl said, ‘The cutie is upstairs with you!’  How did that make any sense?  It was only then that I remember I had a twin sister, a clone to anyone who was smashingly drunk.  I rushed upstairs now, something in my stomach telling me there something wrong,
very
wrong. 

I made it upstairs, looking around.  I didn’t see Mason, or my sister, for that matter.  I wondered if maybe the drunk girl had been mistaken.  I looked around at the closed bedroom doors.  All was quiet.  I didn’t think anyone was up there, not until I started to hear the moans and groans. 

I froze up instantly.  I knew those moans, and I knew them well.  It was Mason.  I flew down the hall, toward the noises.  I opened up the bedroom door quickly.  It was then that my whole world came crashing down around me. 

Chapter 4

I couldn’t believe my eyes.  My worst nightmares had come to life.  As I looked into the bedroom and I saw my boyfriend and my twin sister doing the unthinkable.  They were making the beast with two backs as Shakespeare liked to put it. 

I just watched them for a moment, completely shocked.  Mason was going to town, thrusting away at my sister, making her moan in pleasure as he leaned down and kissed her neck.  I watched as her nails dug into his back.  I watched as he made love to her in exactly the same way as he had made love to me countless times before.  It made everything we had ever done seem totally and utterly meaningless.

Had all those sweat filled nights of passion meant nothing to him?  How could he just fuck Avery like that?  He didn’t even love her!  I continued to watch, unable to look away, frozen in place, as if under some horrible spell.  I could feel my heart breaking with every thrust he took like every thrust was a hammer being pounded into my chest, breaking my heart into a million little pieces.

They were completely oblivious to me standing there at the doorway.  Mason had Avery pinned to the bed, biting her neck roughly.  I could hear her moan as he did.  Her moans seemed loud and exaggerated as she wrapped her legs around him and begged him for more, “Mmm Mason!  Fuck me!  Hard!  Harder!”  She begged him, as her nails ran down his back. 

I watched and cringed as he responded, “Oh, I’m going to fuck you so hard baby!  You won’t be able to walk straight for a week!”  He hiccupped in his drunken state as he continued to pound into her.  I watched in shock as he moved in and out of her making her moan in pleasure. I could hear their hips slamming into each other, the sound of flesh slapping against flesh.  I could have sworn his balls were slapping into her that was how hard he was pounding her.  The bed was shaking in its frame as Avery pulled him closer and closer to her.

As she was getting close he leaned down and took her breast into his mouth, sucking her slowly, just like he had done to me on our first night.  I could tell his tongue was teasing her nipple, making her moan, just like he had made me moan countless times before with the same move.  I knew, deep down, he was sucking and teasing, occasionally leaving a light bite mark on her delicate skin, making her his.  I had experienced it all before; I couldn’t believe he could do it with someone else so easily.

As their bodies shook I knew they were getting closer.  I watched as my sister attacked my boyfriend’s neck, biting him hard.  He moaned softly as a hickey was made on his neck.  She continued to kiss him until they rolled around and she was on top. 

I couldn’t believe my eyes as she got on top and started to ride Mason.  I had never done anything like it before but Mason really seemed to like it.  His eyes were stuck on her breasts that were bouncing up and down as she bounced on his throbbing dick.  They were both moaning loudly and the noise was almost deafening. 

“Mmm I’m going to cum baby.”  Avery whispered in his ear. 

“Mmm cum for me.”  Mason responded back, pulling her down to him, kissing her passionately.  I could see him bucking his hips toward her, thrusting into her even though she was riding him. He was slamming into her hard and fast.  He couldn’t take it any longer and rolled them back over, picking her up and putting her in a doggy position. 

She instantly wiggled her ass at him and I bit my lip watching.  Mason just smirked before plunging balls deep into her soaking pussy.  I could hear from the sloshing sound that occurred after his thrust that she was soaking wet.  I couldn’t look away as he slammed into her, making her body rock like a rag doll.  Her tits were bouncing crazily and she was nearly screaming in pleasure at this point.  Mason’s kept going and going, harder and harder.

It was only when I heard the undeniable sound of his orgasm that I was finally able to break free from my spell.  I looked at them, disgusted.  How could they do this to me?  I couldn’t even yell at them, I couldn’t.  I just slammed the door shut.  I could already feel the tears running down my cheeks as I ran down the stairs.  All I wanted to do was go home. 

Never in my life would I have thought that something like this would happen.  My life had been perfect.  I had the perfect boyfriend.  Why would he do this to me?  I didn’t get it.  Was it the alcohol?  I didn’t know, but my heart was broken alcohol or not.  I was crushed and broken.  I didn’t know what to do.  I was rushing to the front door as quick as I could, clutching Mason’s car keys in my hands.  I would drive home.  I had no idea where I was, but somehow I would drive home.

I was crying hard when I suddenly bumped into someone.  I looked up to see Keith.  He had his arms around me, keeping me upright.  If it wasn’t for his arms I would have fallen down.  He could see the tears in my eyes and frowned.

“What’s wrong?”

“N… nothing…”  My voice cracked as I tried to choke back my sobs.  Keith didn’t believe me.  He knew, probably from my bad acting, that something was wrong.

“C’mon Addison, what happened?  Did someone do something to you?  Did someone hurt you?” I looked at him, my eyes begging for him to drop the topic.  He could tell something was wrong when I started to shake.  He sighed, before picking me up bridal style.  I wanted to protest, to tell him to put me down, but at the same time I no longer had fight left inside of me.

He carried me outside to his car.  He sat me down in the passenger seat, before walking over to the driver’s seat.  He turned and looked at me.

“C’mon Addison, tell me what’s wrong.”  It was then that everything really hit me.  It felt like a train had slammed into my face, tearing me in half. I felt like I was trapped in a nightmare, but there was a part of me that knew that this was just a horrible reality.  I couldn’t believe it.  How could they do this to me?  I had been nothing but good to them.  I felt so betrayed. 

Keith, seeing me a sobbing mess just leaned over and held me for a long time.  He gave me as long as I needed to compose myself.  I was grateful for his friendship at that moment.  I was glad that at least one person at the party wasn’t drinking.  I cried into his chest for a long time, losing track of time.  Finally, I managed the courage to choke out the words that needed to be said.

“Mason… Avery… they… they… had sex in one of the bedrooms.” 

Chapter 5

After I spoke those words I felt like there was a weight being lifted off my shoulders, but I still had an overwhelming need to cry. I could tell that Keith felt sorry for me, but still he didn’t say a word.  He probably didn’t know what to say.  What
did
you say in a moment like that?  There was nothing in the world he could have said that would have made me feel better.  My whole world was crashing down around me.  All I wanted to do was crawl into a hole and never come out again.

“Let me get you home.”  He finally said after starting his car. 

“Tha… Thank you.”  I was grateful.  I just wanted to get away from the party.  I never wanted to see Madison’s house ever again.  I never wanted to see Mason or my sister.  My depression was turning to anger, but I didn’t know which emotion was better. As Keith drove me home I just became angrier at them.

How could they do this to me?  Were they that heartless?  Had I dated a monster for four years?  Why had I let him waste a part of my life like that?  That was four years of my life I would never get back, and to think that during our slow dance at prom, I was thinking about our
wedding
.  I was angry at him, but I was also angry at myself.

I was mad at myself for being so stupid.  I should have seen it coming.  My sister had always been jealous of Mason and me.  She wanted what we had, never finding it with any of her boyfriends.  She always commented on how handsome Mason was.  And prom?  She was all over him on the dance floor.  I should have seen it coming.  I felt like a fool.

Keith was quiet through the entire drive.  He allowed me to sort through my feelings in silence and I was grateful for that.  He was a good friend.  Eventually, he dropped me off in front of my house.  With a heavy heart, I walked into my home, alone.  I didn’t know what I was going to tell my parents, but either way they would be heartbroken.  Mason was the one who was supposed to bring me home after prom, not Keith.  They would know something was wrong the moment I walked into the house.

“Hey honey, how was prom?”  My mom called out from the living room.  She couldn’t see me yet and I was dreading the conversation I was about to have. 

“Did you have fun?” Now it was my dad’s voice.  I wondered why they weren’t in bed, I had told them not to wait up for me.  I walked into the living room slowly.  Their faces fell the moment they saw my tear stained face.  They looked around, looking for Mason, but saw no one.  I was on the verge of tears again.  My mother could tell and instantly came rushing toward me, wrapping me in a hug.  I started to sob again.

“Oh, honey, what happened?”  I continued to sob, unable to control myself.  My mom rubbed my back gently as my father stood there, looking awkward as if he didn’t know what to do.  Finally, I pulled away from my mom, looking at her.  I decided it would be best to just tell them the truth.  I sat down, my legs felt numb.

I looked at them, waiting for them to sit down before I took a deep breath to steady myself.  “Avery got us invited to this after party.  Mason convinced me to go, but when I found him again, he was drunk and with Avery… in bed.”  I wasn’t crying anymore.  No, instead my voice was hollow as I told my story.  I no longer felt angry or depressed, just numb.  I could feel my life escaping from my body. 

My mom just hugged me tightly.  My father looked shocked.  He couldn’t believe it.  How could one of his daughters hurt his other daughter so much?  How could the boy he trusted abuse his daughters like this?  He couldn’t believe it.  Maybe it was all just a nightmare and he would wake up.  I had wished the same thing only to realize that it’s just one miserable reality. 

“I want to go to grandma’s house,” I said numbly.  My mother frowned.

“Honey, are you sure?  Maybe we can talk to them.  Maybe it was just some sort of misunderstanding or something.  Maybe they weren’t actually doing anything.  I shook my head. 

“I know what I saw mom.  And if I have to stay in this town and face them, I know I will go insane.  If you don’t take me to grandma’s, I will just run away.”  My dad nodded.  He seemed to understand somehow as if he had been through this before.

“She’s right, Sherry, she shouldn’t have to see Mason or Avery until she’s ready.  It will just cause her more pain.  I know you want to keep her under your wing, but it will only hurt her.  I will call my mother and tell her what happened.”

Chapter 6

After that night, I began a new life of sorts.  I moved in with my grandmother.  I had my high school diploma mailed to me; I didn’t want to go to graduation and face all my classmates, especially not Avery and Mason.  Everyone begged me to come back, but I couldn’t.  I couldn’t face them.  I couldn’t face my heart break so I kept it tucked away, written in multiple journals, but never spoken in words, never presented in the open.