Rough Country (23 page)

The Boehms lived out of town, on Lake Pokegama, in a tree-thick neighborhood of ranch-style houses, long driveways, and boats. Virgil pulled his truck into the Boehms' place, glanced at a beat-up sixties Pontiac sitting on a trailer he wasn't a gearhead and knocked on the front door.

Sue Boehm looked like an attorney: dark brown hair, dark brown suit, beige blouse, practical heels, panty hose. A real estate attorney, Virgil thought, as she asked, Could I see some ID?

He showed her his identification, and she said, curtly, Okay, as though she were still suspicious, and, Come in.

Inside, no sign of Jared. Boehm backed off a few steps and asked, What's this about?

I need to talk to Jared about Erica McDill.

Is this informational, or do you see him as a suspect? she asked.

I'm interviewing a pretty broad group of people, Virgil said. Is there any reason that I should treat him as a suspect?

Of course not, she said. He's a teenager and a good kid. He graduated from high school near the top of his class.

Virgil spread his hands in a placating gesture: Then . . . there should be no problem. But let me ask you, are you a criminal attorney?

No. I do mostly property law, Boehm said.

Virgil nodded. My concern is, if you're not familiar with criminal procedure, you'll unnecessarily block the investigation, when a criminal attorney would recognize the questions as routine. And I have to treat Jared as a potential suspect: read him his rights and so on. I think . . . if you think an attorney is a necessity, that you'd be better off getting a criminal attorney. I could come back later, if you wish.

He doesn't need to be defended against a crime, she said. He needs to be defended against somebody who's trying to pin something on anybody available.

Virgil shook his head: We really don't try to do that, Mrs. Boehm. A criminal attorney would probably know that. Maybe you should call somebody.

She looked at him for another moment, then said, In here.

JARED BOEHM WAS A TALL, thin boy young man with a fashionably gelled upright haircut that gave him a permanent look of surprise and irony. He was sitting on the living room couch, wearing jeans and a T-shirt that said, Make tender and awkward sexual advances, not war. He was nervous; over his shoulder, through the window, a Hobie Cat had been dragged onto the lawn, and a run-about was hanging off a wooden dock.

His mother said, This is Officer Flowers.

Virgil shook hands with him, sat down, said, Like the shirt, and Boehm nodded and asked, Want to trade? and Virgil said, I'll stick with the Stones, I guess. He opened his notebook and explained about rights, and read the Miranda card to the kid. Boehm nodded that he understood, and Virgil made a note of the time and circumstances, and then asked, Could you tell me where you were when Miss McDill was killed?

He was in Duluth, Susan Boehm said.

Virgil waved her down: I really have to get this from Jared, okay? Your answers don't work for me.

Jared said, I was in Duluth. I worked until three, and Erica Miss McDill was up at her cabin when I left, and I said good-bye and went home, and got my bag, and started off to Duluth. Driving. I got to the campus about five and checked into the dorm there was an orientation, and I ate with some other guys in the cafeteria. There was a guy named Rusty Jones who took us around.

How many people in the group? Virgil asked.

Maybe . . . ten. Or eleven. Something like that.

Okay. And if I talk to Rusty Jones, he'll tell me that you were there around five o'clock?

He should. I was, Jared said.

Virgil doodled, and then asked, Did you see anybody hanging out with Miss McDill, or did you ever see any kind of conflict, any trouble?

He said, No, not really.

Was she popular in the camp?

I guess. She had friends . . . I never really saw any hassles. I've been thinking about who might have something against her, but all I can think of is that sometimes people disagreed about stuff, you know? One wants to do this, the other wants to do that. . . . But not something that would get anybody shot. I've seen people pissed off, but never like I thought there'd be a fight.

Okay. Virgil shut his notebook, turned to Susan Boehm, and said, I'm going to call this fellow Rusty Jones and confirm that Jared was there but I really don't think Jared would be dumb enough to lie about it . . .

He isn't, she said, still cold, but relaxing.

. . . and since we believe it's the work of one person, that would rule Jared out. At this point.

So are we done? Jared asked.

Not quite, Virgil said. I'd like to talk to you for a minute, privately.

Susan Boehm snapped, No way.

Virgil said to Jared, If you're eighteen, you can ask your mom to step away.

Okay, Susan Boehm said, standing up. That's enough. Out of the house.

Virgil shook his head. This is why you should have had a criminal attorney, Virgil told her. I need to finish my interview with Jared. The law says I can do that. You invited me in. Time is of the essence. I would like to talk to Jared privately. If you both refuse, I'll talk to him with you in the room. It's up to you two.

About what? Jared asked.

I think you might know, Virgil said.

Jared looked at him for a moment, then turned to his mother and said, I think you better leave.

No fucking way, she said.

Mother and son dueled for a minute, and Jared caved: I can't do anything without you getting all over me.

She said, It's for your own good.

No, it isn't, he said. It's because you're a fucking control freak.

She recoiled: You can't speak to me that way!

Jared ran his hands through his hair: Ah, God. Then, to Virgil: Go ahead.

You had a sexual relationship with Miss McDill?

Susan Boehm looked as though Virgil had slapped her. She stared at her son: What?

With perhaps a glimmer of satisfaction, Jared said, Yes.

Did you . . . see her often?

Twice. She came in on Saturday, and I went over there on Wednesday and Thursday evenings.

Was anybody else there when you were? Virgil asked.

No. Just us.

Susan Boehm's head was going back and forth like a spectator's at a tennis match.

Did you hear that she'd spent time with anyone else? Virgil asked.

I heard that like on Tuesday, she was there with Wendy Ashbach. Tuesday night.

Who'd you hear it from?

I don't know, really. I was working the dock and I heard these two women talking, joking, about Wendy and Erica, Jared said. I don't even know that Wendy was there, just that they were hanging, you know, but I got the impression that Wendy was there. But I'm not sure about that.

What's going on here? Susan Boehm asked her son. You were dating this woman? Wasn't she a lot older than you?

Virgil: Mrs. Boehm

Don't Mrs. Boehm me, she said to Virgil. To her son, Why would he ask you if there was anybody else there while you were, were . . .

Virgil said, Listen, I don't think we need

Jared said, Because, Mom, she paid me three hundred dollars a time to fuck her.

This time, Susan Boehm went down for the count, standing there, her mouth flapping. Jared said to Virgil, You knew that, right?

Yup. You have to kick any of that back to Margery Stanhope? Virgil asked.

No . . . jeez, she'd kill us if she found out about it.

Okay . . . was Miss McDill paying anyone else?

I don't think so, Boehm said. She picked up on me right away, and she was flirting with a couple other women there.

Susan Boehm, still flapping, Other women?

Yeah. She was a bi, Jared said. To Virgil: I'm telling you the truth. I don't know what happened. I don't have any ideas. I sat around thinking about it, but I couldn't think of anything. If I had, I would have come to talk to you, or somebody. As it was, I decided to keep my mouth shut and see if I could slide through.

Wasn't going to happen, Virgil said. People joke about the boys.' You were toast.

Didn't know that, Jared said.

Virgil asked, Were there any other women interested in you, who might have become jealous when you went with Miss McDill?

No . . . there was a woman the week before, named Karen something or other, but she was gone, Boehm said.

Okay. Did you see or hear anything about Wendy Ashbach or her band when you were hanging around with Miss McDill?

Boehm jabbed a finger at Virgil. Yes. She talked about that. They had a deal. She asked me what I thought about Wendy's band, and I told her I didn't like country music, but that Wendy had a good voice and I thought she could go somewhere. And she told me she was going to take Wendy there. She patted some papers. Like, she had some papers there, and I thought they might be a contract or something, but I didn't ask. But: she was deep with Wendy.

Have you ever had any kind of relationship with Wendy?

No. Nope. If I had a chance, I wouldn't, Boehm said. You ever seen her brother? The Deuce? There's one scary guy. He's goofy, and he could pull your arms off, and I think he's hot for Wendy. I'd like to know what that's all about. . . .

Hot for Wendy. Is this a rumor, or something you know, or what? Virgil asked.

Just from school. He dropped out as soon as they'd let him, and they were happy to see him go. Didn't make any difference, he wasn't going to graduate anyway. He was a couple years behind me, so he must be about sixteen? People used to say, you didn't want to mess with Wendy or the Deuce would kill you. They meant it: kill you.

Tell me one person who said that.

He thought a minute, then grinned and said, Tommy Parker. He's still here, he works at Parker Brothers motors in the summer, for his dad. He goes to the U. I saw him yesterday. You catch him, ask him what happened when he asked Wendy to go to the prom.

Virgil made a note of the name. Anything else?

Jared shook his head. No. Who are you going to tell about all this?

Virgil stood and said, At this point, nobody. I'll tell you, Jared, I'll check your alibi for the time of the murder, but right now, I believe you. And if I were you, I'd keep my mouth shut about your summer job. You really don't want to be in the newspapers.

So you're not going to do anything? he asked.

Not at this point, Virgil said, I was mostly concerned about whether there might be a sexual conflict involving the boys that led to the murder. You don't seem to think that there was.

I don't think so, he said. She showed up, she let me know she was interested, I don't think any of the other guys were cut out, or anything. She didn't seem interested in a three-way . . . and that was about it.

Okay. Listen, you take care of yourself, Virgil said. We don't know what's going on here, but . . . be cool. Watch TV. Go to Duluth. Don't go wandering around by yourself until we get this guy.

AS VIRGIL WAS LEAVING, he heard Susan Boehm ask, A three-way? and he thought to himself, I just said this guy. That feels right. The killer's a he. So who made the Mephisto prints?

He was getting in his truck when Susan Boehm blew through the front door and shouted, Wait a minute! Wait!

He got back out and she steamed up and said, Something has to be done.

Virgil shrugged. I don't know exactly what.

But this is . . . sexual exploitation. This might be statutory rape.

It's prostitution, is what it is, Virgil said. My problem is, I know one boy your son, and he certainly wouldn't testify against himself and one patron, Erica McDill, who was murdered. So who do I charge?

You mean . . . ?

I thought about going after Margery Stanhope, but she denies knowing anything about it, and your son confirms it. I don't necessarily believe Margery that she doesn't know anything about it but if everybody agrees she wasn't part of it, what am I going to do? None of the women will testify against themselves, and none of the boys would. All we could do is send in a woman agent, get one of the boys to proposition her and mention a price, and then bust him for prostitution, but . . . I don't even know if that would work. Or if we could get a conviction.

So nothing's going to get done, she said.

If a group of parents had a quiet word with Margery, it might end. Or maybe not. You're talking about a bunch of horny college boys who need the money, and you heard what Jared said: three hundred dollars a time to have sex with her. Who knows? He might make thirty thousand dollars a year, tax free, if he works at it. . . . Of course, he's a prostitute.

She started to blubber and he patted her on the shoulder. Listen, talk to your husband. Figure something out. Tell me what you want to do, if anything, and I'll try to help out. But I'm not sure this is a problem the law is very well equipped to deal with.

Still blubbering, she headed back toward the house.