Silence: The Faces of Evil Christmas Prequel (10 page)

Since her interview with Claudia Brown, the first of the two rescued victims, hadn’t provided any additional information, Jess’s only remaining hope was that Melaney Lands, the woman lying in the hospital bed a few feet away, would remember something useful. Jess shifted again in the uncomfortable chair. So far, she hadn’t said anything at all.

Melaney, born and raised in Mobile and a nursing student at the University of South Alabama, adjusted her bendable straw with a shaky hand. She took a long draw of water from the plastic cup.

Enough time passed to have Jess’s already strained nerves frayed completely. Melaney placed the cup on the tray-table extended across her lap. She clasped her hands on the white sheet tucked against the faded blue hospital gown she wore, but still she didn’t speak. Jess wondered if she understood how very lucky she was to have survived a close encounter with Spears, the Player, a vicious serial killer who loved torturing his victims before ending their lives. 

Of the thirty some odd cases of abducted women attributed to him by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, there had never been a survivor.
Not one
. Detective Lori Wells of Birmingham PD had met the monster and lived to tell but then he hadn’t abducted her. One of his reckless minions, Matthew Reed, had taken her. That was the last mistake Reed would ever make and, in all likelihood, the only reason Lori was still alive.

It seemed impossible that Lori’s abduction had been scarcely more than a month ago.

The air stalled in Jess’s lungs as her heart flailed like a fish swept onto the bank and then deserted by the tide. Everything about her life had changed and gotten far more complicated in those few short weeks.

God Almighty, what was she going to do?

She adjusted her glasses as well as her attention. Right now, she couldn’t think about the other troubles stewing in her private life. There just wasn’t time to linger and she couldn’t afford the distraction.

“The man was smoking outside the Wash-n-Go where I do my laundry.”

Startled by the sound of the woman’s voice, despite having been on the edge of her seat in anticipation, Jess snapped to attention.

Melaney drew in a shuddering breath. “He was white, tall, kinda young—maybe twenty-five.” She shrugged and then winced. During the final hours of the horror that had overtaken her life, her hands and feet had been tied behind her back with one end of the rope around her neck. She was sore as hell with plenty of bruises and abrasions.

“He had on jeans and a tee-shirt,” Melaney continued. “There was a logo but it was faded. I didn’t look at him long enough to make it out.”

Jess jotted a couple of notes on her pad. “According to the statements you gave earlier, this man didn’t say anything to you as you exited the laundromat.”

Melaney shook her head. “He didn’t. When I glanced at him he did one of those nods. You know, the one people do instead of saying hello or what’s up?”

“Did you nod back?” Melaney hadn’t mentioned a response, not even a gesture, in her statements to the other investigators. Hopefully, as the realization that she was truly safe now sank in and she relaxed, more details of the past ten days would surface.

Another negligible shrug prompted a second wince of pain. “If I did, I don’t remember doing it. I think I just looked away.”

For several more seconds she didn’t speak. She was remembering. The horror of that night danced across her face as easy to read as the breaking news scroll on a cable channel.

“I put my laundry bag in the backseat and closed the door, that’s when I noticed the tire was flat.” She clamped her lips together and still they trembled.

“You drive a 1971 Toyota Corolla?” Jess knew the answer, but she needed to nudge Melaney past the shame she’d snagged on. For the rest of her life, she would question her every move from that night. Had she done this or that things might have turned out differently.

What Melaney Lands didn’t grasp was that she had been chosen. Her hair color was the one he preferred. She had the right figure. She fit the profile of the women the Player selected. Nothing she did or didn’t do would have made a difference.

“Yes.”

“The flat tire was on the…?” Jess held her pencil poised to take down the answer. It was the mundane that most often prodded forth the notable.

“The driver’s side. Rear tire. I said shit or something like that. When I looked up he was standing right beside me. I jumped, and he apologized for scaring me. He offered to help. There wasn’t anybody else around so I said okay.” Tears slipped down her cheeks. “I did what anybody else would have done… I didn’t—”

“If you had said no,” Jess stopped her, “he would have taken a different approach, but the end result would’ve been the same.” She held her gaze a moment more before moving on. “He fixed your tire and then what happened?”

“Damned thing wouldn’t start.” She knotted her fingers in the sheet, her eyes bright with the fresh tears brimming there. “It was running fine… before. I guess I must’ve been so upset I didn’t lock the doors when I got in the car. Another stupid mistake. Then suddenly he was in the passenger seat next to me.” Her lips trembled. “He used a hypodermic needle to inject a drug into my shoulder.” She drew her right shoulder into her body. “When I woke up I was in a cage. There were two others… we were all in cages.”

The ketamine, Spears’s drug of choice, worked fast. There would have been little time or strength for a struggle. The story from both women was basically the same except for the setting. Claudia Brown, a graduate student at A&M College, lived in Somerville. She was taken by a different man from the alley behind her apartment. Her cat hadn’t come in for dinner. At bedtime, Claudia had gone outside to look for the missing pet that, as it turned out, was alive and well ten-blocks away.

The woman Spears had kept, Rory Stinnett, was from Orange Beach. She was a student at the same university as Melaney but the two hadn’t known each other until they ended up in those cages in a white room with glaring fluorescent lights. They had described the cages as being made of heavy gauge metal wire, similar to the ones used to crate large dogs. The cages allowed the women to see one another and to communicate.

Some memory Jess couldn’t quite grasp nudged her. Something to do with cages.

“Once you were in the cage,” Jess asked, moving on, “you never saw anyone other than the masked man?” According to their statements, a man wearing a ski mask had checked on them daily.

Melaney shook her head, corroborating the answer Claudia had given. After viewing catalogs of mug shots, including photos of Spears, both women had confirmed what everyone else suspected: Spears was not one of the abductors and he wasn’t the masked man. There was a strong possibility that he hadn’t been anywhere near these women.

His presence was irrelevant, in Jess’s opinion. This was his doing whether he was at the scene of the crime or not.

He had started a new game and Jess was way behind the curve.

She blinked away the distraction.
Stay on the facts. You already know his motive
.

The women were dehydrated, bruised and emotionally wounded but that was the extent of their injuries. During those ten long days of captivity the man wearing a mask had dropped a bottle of water and a container of nuts and dried fruits into their cages daily. Not once had he attempted to touch the women or even to speak to them. But then torturing or murdering anyone at this stage in the game wasn’t the goal—wasn’t even on the agenda.

Spears had other plans.

“Since he didn’t speak,” Jess ventured, “how can you be certain the person wearing the mask was a man?” There were numerous reasons to make the assumption but she wanted to hear each woman’s rationale for coming to that conclusion. The smallest new insight might make a difference.

“His hands.” Melaney’s brow furrowed as if she were concentrating hard on the question. “He had big hands with thick fingers.”

“He didn’t wear gloves?”

Another shake of her head confirmed he had not. Just went to show the level of confidence the man had in the hiding place used for holding the women. Claudia had mentioned his broad shoulders and muscled arms, as well as his hands. She’d also said he had dark eyes. Jess suspected Melaney had kept her gaze lowered whenever their keeper entered the room. Claudia, on the other hand, had studied his height, six feet at least, and his build—a little on the stocky side.

According to the descriptions provided by Melaney and Claudia, different men had abducted them at approximately the same time on the same night. Both insisted Rory had described yet a third man. All three women had received a phone call about winning a weekend getaway. That ruse had served a simple purpose, ensuring no one who knew the women grew suspicious when they disappeared. The abductions were a carefully choreographed series of untraceable steps in various locations for achieving the singular goal of a madman. The organized operation confirmed the Bureau’s theory that Spears had built a network of followers ready to do his bidding.

“What happened when you were finally moved from the cages?”

“He drugged us again.” Melaney looked around the room as if searching for a safe place to rest her gaze. “When we came to, we were on the side of the road. Naked and all tied up so we couldn’t go for help.” Her lips trembled. “But we were alive.”

She fell silent for a time. No doubt reliving the horrors and the relief.

“We started yelling for help. We kept screaming and crying, hoping someone would hear us. I don’t know how much later—hours I guess—a trucker stopped. The guy was headed into the woods to pee when we managed to get his attention.” She exhaled a shuddering breath. “Our voices were so weak by then it was a miracle he heard us.”

Jess had interviewed the truck driver who discovered the women on that Tennessee mountain road. Otis Berry was short, bone thin, and sixty-eight years old. He had a bad knee that caused him to hobble and a bad back that kept him stooped over, making him easy to rule out as a suspect.

“Can you tell me anything else about Rory?” Rory Stinnett was the third woman, the one Spears had chosen to keep.
Victim number one
. Jess worked at calming another bout of churning in her stomach.

Something awful was coming. Spears had some twisted finale planned. She could feel it. And, dammit, she couldn’t seem to do anything to stop it.

“We cried and talked a lot. Tried to figure out ways to escape but none of them worked.” Melaney scrubbed at her tears with the backs of her hands. “We didn’t know whether he was going to kill us or what. He never told us anything. Until Claudia and I were with the police we had no idea what was going on.”

“I’m sure you’d seen the headlines about Eric Spears, the serial killer called the Player, before your abduction?” Just saying his name out loud changed the rhythm of Jess’s heart. She tightened her grip on her pencil.

“I’m a nursing student. I don’t have time for the news or anything else. But Claudia had heard of him and all those women he killed.” Melaney’s voice quaked on the last.

Not just women
. Jess didn’t bother correcting her. Eric Spears had murdered a federal agent who’d graduated from the Bureau’s training academy with her. The truth was, there were likely far more victims than they suspected. They might never know just how many lives Eric Spears had taken… or would take before he was stopped.

Just let me close one more time
.

“A few more questions, Miss Lands.” Jess resigned herself to the fact that she’d gotten all she was going to at this time. “Do you remember how the place where you were held smelled? If there were any windows? Any other furniture? Could you hear any noises from the outside?”

Melaney shook her head in answer to each question.

Okay, go back to the beginning
. “Do you recall anything different or strange that happened in school or at home in the week or so before you were abducted? Besides the phone call about the weekend getaway you’d supposedly won?” Jess qualified.

The young woman stared at Jess as if she were completely overwhelmed and totally lost. Finally, she shook her head yet again, more tears shining in her eyes as renewed defeat clouded her face.

Enough
. Jess stood and moved to the side of her bed. She placed a business card on the tray table. She wasn’t usually the touchy-feely type but she gave Melaney’s hand a gentle squeeze just the same. “Anything you remember or need, no matter when it is, day or night, tomorrow or weeks from now, you call me. Don’t hesitate.”

A jerky nod was her answer.

“Thank you, Melaney.”

Jess turned and started for the door. She was thankful these two women were safe and unharmed for the most part. As grateful as she was, she wished something—anything—one or the other remembered could help them find Rory Stinnett.

How much time did they have before Stinnett became a statistic in the massive case file on the Player?

“Wait.” Melaney’s tinny voice resonated against the sterile white walls of the room.

Jess stopped, turned, and waited. Adrenaline pumped through her. There was something different in the other woman’s tone now… a new kind of fear or desperation crammed into that one word.

Melaney visibly struggled as if she feared her words would somehow change what happened next. She toyed with the card Jess had left for her. “I wasn’t going to mention it.” She made an aching sound in her throat. “The drug was sucking me into the darkness, and I wasn’t sure if I really heard what I thought I heard. Claudia said she didn’t remember anyone saying anything. I figured maybe I imagined it.”

Jess’s thoughts, the very blood flowing through her veins, hushed.

Melaney moistened her chapped lips. “But, when you came in here and introduced yourself, I knew I hadn’t imagined it.”

A chill crept into Jess’s bones. “You may have seen me or heard my name on the news.” Her own voice sounded strained. Her chest seemed to be rising and falling too rapidly, yet she couldn’t draw enough air into her lungs.

Melaney shook her head. “Told you I don’t watch the news.”