Chapter Twelve
Grey watched Fanny stomp her way into the pine grove and disappear. Only then did he turn.
Dictate to him where he must go and whom he could watch, would she? The sun and the brisk breeze coming off the mountains had nearly dried his shirt, but his trousers and socks were still wet. And cold. And bloody uncomfortable. All of which he deserved for acting like such a raw, heated, untutored boy.
By God, he couldn’t believe the woman had actually made him blush.
Blush.
He hadn’t blushed since he was sixteen and a doxy purporting to be Cleopatra’s “spirit” had landed in his lap hands first. There had been nothing spectral about her fingers.
Now, let Fanny Walcott imply that he was reluctant to let her go and he pinked up like a virgin. Because he had been reluctant, damn it. Even though his ministrations had begun innocently enough, there had been little innocence left by the time she demanded he put her down in that crushing tone of voice.
His actions had started out noble. He had been walking past the small loch on his way to Little Firkin to further his “investigations” when he’d spied the dinghy bobbing low in the water. Thinking it had come loose of its mooring, he’d wandered down to offer his assistance, arriving at the shore just in time to see Fanny shoot to her feet in the center of the boat, sit down again, and promptly sink.
He’d shed boots and jacket and been in the water before he even realized what he was doing. His heart had thundered in panic as he swam, matching an inner litany suspiciously like a prayer
. No. No. Please. Not after I’ve finally found her. Please. Let me be in time.
And when she’d disappeared beneath the water, then abruptly resurfaced, and he’d snatched her to him, nothing save death could have wrested her from his grip. His preoccupation with the woman had become something more, something . . . potentially dangerous. He could not remember the last time he’d felt this sense of jeopardy. But jeopardy from what? And threatened by whom? That slender black-haired tartar? Though he periodically kept company with one of several intelligent and lovely ladies, not one of them had ever so fascinated him.
There was only one viable explanation: The excitement of the moment had led him, the least fanciful of men, to succumb to a fit of fancifulness. That was it. Her narrow escape from tragedy had produced in him a heightened emotional state. There was probably even some sort of biological imperative that could have explained why. There. A rational explanation. He liked rational explanations. He depended on them. He lived by them.
Satisfied, Grey turned back to Collier’s lodge. He doubted he’d have discovered anything about the threat to Amelie Chase in Little Firkin, anyway. But because he’d promised his efforts and he did not lie, he would go tomorrow.
He entered the lodge through the kitchen and met the startled stares of the middle-aged cook and her husband, both peeling vegetables at the sink. The pair, who worked for His Lordship, had come ahead of Grey and Hayden to open Collier ’s newly refurbished lodge.
Grey stripped his jacket off and tossed it across the table. “Twinnings, isn’t it?” he asked the man, hopping on one foot as he took hold of his boot heel.
“Yes, milord,” Twinnings said, setting down his carrot. “Can I be of service, milord?”
“Indeed you can, Twinnings.” Grey grunted as he tugged on his boot heel. “You and Mrs. Twinnings have been here a few weeks now. You must have had conversations with some of the locals.”
“Of a limited variety,” Twinnings intoned.
“What is the general feeling toward Miss Chase and”—he jerked the boot free and sent it spinning across the tile floor—“Mrs. Walcott?”
Twinnings, bless the man, was far more astute than McGowan. He understood at once what Grey was after.
“Resignation, sir. Nothing more, nothing less.”
“That ain’t so, Mr. Twinnings,” Mrs. Twinnings said. Not to be outshone by her husband, she spun around, a half-peeled potato in her hand. “There is also a dollop of chagrin about Miss Chase and a heaping spoonful of umbrage with regards to Mrs. Walcott.”
Ah.
Culinary metaphors. He liked the woman at once. “Why do you think that is?” Grey asked, yanking off his other boot.
“They’ve no doubt Miss Chase is a witch, but it makes them feel at odds with themselves. Not because she’s a witch, as they say there’s always been witches hereabouts, but because they must
harbor
her.”
“Harbor?” Grey handed his boots to Twinnings.
“There’s a line between ‘coexisting’ with a witch and ‘harboring’ a witch, and it’s clear it’s one they feel they’ve crossed,” Twinnings explained, patiently waiting for Grey to strip off his sodden socks. “But they’re practical folk, and the economic advantages to harboring witches are apparently considerable.” He waited for Grey to divulge a bit of gossip. Grey disappointed him.
“Still, makes their consciences wiggle a bit,” Mrs. Twinnings insisted.
“Wiggly enough to try to get rid of Miss Chase?”
“Get rid of Miss Chase?” Twinnings breathed, shocked.
Grey, who’d been musing over the matter on his way back to the lodge, held up his hand. “Do not let your imagination run away with you, Twinnings. I mean ‘get rid of’ as in frighten the girl away.”
This explanation for the letter struck Grey as being far more reasonable than the idea that someone actually meant to kill an innocent girl. Or even an innocent witch.
Mrs. Twinnings answered. “I don’t think so, sir. I’d say most of the folks hereabouts is too lazy to kill the goose what laid the golden egg. They been expectin’ a nice little golden egg for years, and with only a few more to go, it don’t make sense someone would choose now to get all morally affronted, like.”
“Morally affronted,” Twinnings scoffed. “How would you know?”
“I know people,” Mrs. Twinnings stubbornly declared.
“Then what is your opinion of Mrs. Walcott?” Grey said.
“Never met the lady,” Mrs. Twinnings said, adding before Twinnings could speak, “Neither has he.
“But,” she went on, “from what I hears tell, she’s a lady keeps her own company, has a right sharp tongue, and doesn’t take no guff from no one.” Mrs. Twinnings’s expression grew sympathetic. “Course, bein’ a woman alone up here and head of a household and then havin’ to get these Scottish heathen men to do for you would be a trick and a ’alf ’less you did have a tongue like a razor.”
“Anything else?”
Mrs. Twinnings shrugged. “A bit flinthearted. Won’t even let Miss Amelie keep a pet dog.”
“She’s unkind to Miss Chase?”
“No, you misunderstand. She’s loves that girl. It’s just not her nature to be all lovey-dovey. Why, from what I hear, this spring the girl and Mrs. Walcott both come over sick, and even though she were the sicker of the pair, Mrs. Walcott gets out of ’er bed to tend the girl through that night and the next. And when they’re well, she makes sure the girl has anything her heart desires. Anything money can buy. ’Ceptin’ livestock in the house. Can’t say I blame her. My sister had a rat terrier once that she kept in the house, and that dog peed all over—”
“That’s enough,” Twinnings said, returning from laying Grey’s socks by the stove. “Excuse her, Lord Sheffield. She forgets to whom she’s speaking.”
But Grey wasn’t paying attention. Another idea had occurred to him. Two pieces of information kept being repeated from various sources: Fanny Walcott was devoted to Amelie, and Fanny had been “beside herself” when the girl had fallen ill this spring.
If nothing else, he was convinced that Fanny’s affection for Amelie was real. And though logically he knew that affection did not preclude one from using another for one’s own purposes, he knew Fanny would never put the girl in harm’s way. He did not even pause to consider why he felt so strongly or even if it was rational. It was just true.
When Amelie had grown so gravely ill, Quod Lamia’s isolation and the town’s dearth of qualified medical care must have been borne in on Fanny with frightening significance. Had the episode so shaken her that
she’d
written the anonymous letter in the hope that Amelie would be removed from Little Firkin before something even more dire occurred?
Grey considered. The hypothesis fit with the known facts. It made sense. It even allowed for his unprecedented feeling that Fanny Walcott was not a heartless cheat and a fraud. True, she would still in effect have been perpetuating a deception, but at least her motive had merit.
But then he thought of her expression as she’d begged him for reassurances that Amelie Chase’s boat had not been sabotaged. Could she be
that
good an actress? He did not know.
He did not trust his own judgment where that woman was concerned. He was too close; there was too much past between them; she engendered too many things for Grey, and most of them at odds with one another: disapproval, empathy, condemnation, excitement, challenge, camaraderie. Desire.
Whatever was going on here, he knew in his bones that Fanny Walcott was at the center of it. But what was it? Only she knew. He had one thing working to his advantage: She still did not know that he recognized her. If he could provoke her enough, she might give herself away and in doing so reveal her plan.
It was worth a shot.
“Will there be anything else, milord?”
“What?” Grey looked up to find Twinnings waiting attentively.
“Can I be of further service, sir?”
“No, that will be—” Grey stopped and considered Twinnings.
“Milord?”
“Twinnings,” Grey said, “do you fish?”