Tempted by Two Angels [Notorious Nephilim 3] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour) (17 page)

Aislinn and Maire wanted to know who Hugh and Sterling were, but her parents were more concerned about whether she was all right living in Chicago. After explaining three times she was actually fifty miles north at a private resort, she finally gave up and told them she was being careful to lock her doors at night and had befriended other female singers so she always had someone to walk through the city with. They’d never listened to details where Caleigh’s singing career was concerned, and Caleigh didn't expect them to start now. She was grateful when she was able to make her excuses and return to Babs, Hugh, and Sterling.

“Has Babs told you two all my childhood secrets by now?”

“Absolutely,” said Hugh. “And we promised her we’d tease you mercilessly as soon as we get back.” Something about the way he said the word “mercilessly” sent a jolt straight to Caleigh’s pussy. An image of being held down and paddled by him and Sterling raced through her mind.

Babs looked from one man to the other. “It was very thoughtful of you not to let her come here alone.”

Sterling squeezed Caleigh’s hand. “We never would have done that to her.”

Babs sighed out loud. “When do you have to leave?”

“We’re catching a train back to Chicago tonight,” said Caleigh.

“I wish I could come with you.”

“So do I, Babs.” Sterling released her hand, almost as if he knew she wanted to hug her best friend one more time.

* * * *

Rehearsals started the day Caleigh, Hugh, and Sterling returned to the resort, and this time both men showed up. Caleigh hadn’t been sure she was ready to start working again, but she found it helped take her mind off the sight of Madge crying in her husband’s arms and the look on George’s face when he’d told her that Harold had thought the world of her. Had they known he proposed? Had they known she turned him down?

Hugh and Sterling had dinner sent up to Caleigh’s suite and surprised her with a Silvertone and phonograph records.

“Now you can listen to all the great songs you sing,” said Sterling, beaming as he held up the dust jacket of a Benny Goodman record.

“I can’t believe you did this.” Caleigh rifled through the records, making cooing noises as she came across many of her favorites. “This was so thoughtful.”

“We didn’t want you to be bored up here, all by yourself,” said Hugh, stroking her hair. Caleigh’s nipples tingled and her clit throbbed. It had been far too long since she’d made love to her two fallen angels.

“Well, then, perhaps the two of you would join me for dinner? You’ve sent up enough food to feed at least five people.”

“That was the plan.” Hugh grinned, then walked over to the wet bar and poured them each a glass of whiskey. “I think Sterling has developed a taste for this stuff.”

“Not really. I’d rather have this.” Sterling opened a bottle of white wine and offered some to Caleigh.

“Um, if I mix drinks I’m likely to dance naked on tables or something.”

Sterling waggled his eyebrows while Hugh laughed. “We can’t have you doing that, now can we?”

Caleigh clamped a hand over her mouth as she joined their laughter. She had no idea why she’d said that, but now that the image was in her mind, she couldn't think of anything else. “Let’s put on a record and have dinner,” she said, selecting an album she knew contained no love songs. It was going to be impossible to keep from touching them tonight.

Dinner was fabulous, just like every meal Caleigh had eaten at Lilith’s Playground. Hugh and Sterling kept both her wine glass and whiskey glass filled, teasing her about how long it would take for her to start dancing. By the end of the meal her stomach hurt from laughing so hard, and she was quite drunk.

Gone were thoughts of the funeral and her parents’ cold response to seeing her again after so many months. She missed Babs, but Hugh and Sterling were here, and they were going out of their way to entertain her tonight. She wanted to be with them again. She needed to feel their skin against hers and to be taken by them.

When the album finished, Caleigh selected another one and sat between Hugh and Sterling on the sofa. “Okay. Now tell me what Babs
really
said about me.”

“She said you run through men like water, and we’d better watch out,” said Hugh, grinning in a way that made her panties flood.

“And she also said it isn’t fair that you have two men while she currently has none,” said Sterling.

“She did not say that.” Caleigh couldn’t help but laugh because she could picture Babs saying
exactly
that. Babs had a lot of nerve saying Caleigh ran through men like water. Babs had broken if off with more men in the past few years than Caleigh had done in ten years.

“She most certainly did,” said Sterling, giving her a fake pout.

“And you weren’t the least bit tempted?”

“I’ve always preferred dark-haired women.” Sterling stroked her arm, sending waves of desire straight through to Caleigh’s fingertips and toes.

“So have I,” said Hugh, snuggling closer to her. “Unless Babs isn’t a real blonde. Then I might be tempted.”

“Oh, I see how it is now. You only like me because I’m a brunette.”

Hugh gave her a smoldering look. “No, I like you because you’re intelligent and funny, and because when you sing my dick gets rock hard.”

“Oh, that’s so romantic, Hugh. You’re sweeping me off my feet.” Caleigh’s entire body trembled. She couldn’t look away from his eyes. “How about you, Sterling? Does your dick get rock hard when I sing?”

Sterling actually blushed. “Um, yes, it does, but that’s not the only reason I like you. You’re the most beautiful woman I’ve ever seen, and I never get tired of your company.” Caleigh gaped at the love pouring out of Sterling’s emerald eyes.

She didn’t know if they were using their powers on her right now, and suddenly she didn’t care. This had been the worst week of her life. She’d had to face the reality that she had been using men and taking their affections for granted since high school. One of them had died knowing she didn’t love him enough to marry him, even though she’d strung him along for years. She couldn't go back and undo any of that, but she could move forward. She could try to love these two men who were perfect and who treated her like something precious.

“Your turn,” said Hugh, quietly.

She glanced at him. “What do you mean?”

“Your turn to tell us why you like us. And don’t tell me you’re only using our bodies for great sex.” The grin was in place, but the expression in his eyes was serious and vulnerable. He really wanted to know, and he was uneasy about her answer. Caleigh recalled how she’d often wondered if they could read her mind, but apparently their powers didn’t include that ability.

If there was ever a time for her to tell them how she felt, it was now. But Caleigh wasn’t ready for that. She’d never been the first one to say “I love you,” and she wasn’t entirely sure they felt the same way. She’d be a damn fool if she told them she’d fallen in love with them and they didn’t feel the same way.

“Well, you are both amazing in bed, but no that’s not the only reason I like you. You’re charming and fun and easy to talk to. I’m comfortable with you.”

The answer seemed to satisfy Hugh. The look of trepidation left his eyes, and he bent his head to kiss her. Caleigh opened her mouth to let his tongue inside and moaned in the back of her throat. Her body exploded like a thousand tiny fireworks had gone off under her skin. She wrapped her arms around Hugh’s shoulders and thrust her tongue deeper inside his warm mouth.

Behind her, Sterling reached around and cupped her breasts, teasing her nipples through her clothing. “Caleigh…I’ve missed you so much.” He nuzzled her neck, sending shock waves of desire straight to her soaking-wet pussy.

Caleigh moaned in response as Hugh’s tongue continued its sweet torture inside her mouth. When Sterling began to unbutton her blouse, she leaned back against him and tangled her fingers in Hugh’s hair. She’d missed the silky feel of it against her skin.

Hugh released her mouth to let Sterling remove her top, then he licked her nipples through her bra. Caleigh pushed his head closer and didn’t protest when he lightly nipped at them. Sterling unhooked her bra, and both he and Hugh removed it, then Sterling moved to the edge of the sofa and Hugh pushed gently on her shoulders until she lay on her back with her head in Sterling’s lap.

The bulge in the front of his trousers pushed against her face as Sterling fondled her breasts, teasing the nipples until Caleigh thought she’d go out of her mind with desire. Each time he twisted one between his thumb and index finger it felt like an electric spark zinging through her body.

Hugh removed her skirt, stockings, and shoes then spread her legs and licked her pussy through her soaked cotton panties. “I’ve missed this taste,” he purred.

“I’ve missed your mouth on me.” She looked up into Sterling’s beautiful eyes. “I’ve missed you, too.”

“Beautiful Caleigh,” he whispered. “I can’t get enough of you.”

Caleigh kept her gaze on Sterling’s face while Hugh continued to tease her pussy through her panties. The more her desire grew, the deeper the emerald pool that was Sterling’s eyes became. Caleigh wanted to fall in and never surface.

Finally Hugh pulled off her panties and clamped his mouth on her clit. When he slipped two fingers inside her pussy, Caleigh arched her hips and covered Sterling’s hands with her own.

Sterling twisted her nipples almost to the point of pain while Hugh finger fucked her and sucked her clit. Her orgasm was so close. She writhed and moaned, welcoming the competing sensations and giving over to the passion. She no longer cared what they were or if they were human. She wanted them inside her, on top of her, all around her, and she never wanted to let either one of them go.

When she climaxed, she screamed. Sterling let go of her breasts and stroked her hair until the contractions finally stopped. Hugh took off his clothes, lifted her hips and plunged his thick cock inside her pussy. Sterling gently moved out from underneath her and took off his clothing then teased her breasts with his slick cock.

Caleigh took her breasts and pushed them together so Sterling could touch both nipples at the same time with his dick. She moaned as he grazed them while her pussy contracted around Hugh’s dick. When Hugh pulled out, Sterling took his place, easing in gently.

Hugh turned Caleigh’s head to the side, and she opened her mouth to take his cock inside. He tasted like her pussy juices mixed with his warm saltiness. Caleigh wanted to devour him. She couldn’t get enough. Sterling increased his thrusting and massaged her clit, and soon another climax was building.

How could she have believed she’d be able to stay away from these two? They were her drugs, and she had to have them. It wasn’t just the sex, although that was beyond incredible. She needed their company. She craved their humor and the way they always seemed to know what she wanted and needed, made her feel safe and protected.

They took turns inside her, one in her mouth and the other in her pussy, and when another orgasm crashed over her, Caleigh closed her eyes and just let go. She’d never experienced such arousal and complete bliss with any other man. She suppressed a giggle when she recalled how she and Babs had fantasized about what it would be like to fuck two men at once, after they’d sneaked into a porno movie one Saturday afternoon. What would Babs think if she could see Caleigh now?

Hugh and Sterling stood over her and stroked their cocks until they both came on her breasts. Caleigh smiled up at them, knowing she’d do anything they wanted tonight. As long as she could taste them and have them in her arms and inside her, she didn’t care what they did.

“Be right back,” said Hugh, his voice raspy and thick.

He walked toward the hallway that led to the bedroom while Sterling poured her a glass of water. Caleigh gulped it. “Do you need another one, my songbird?”

“Yes, thank you. Sterling, I love it when you call me that.”

The look he gave her in response was so tender tears welled up in her eyes. “You’ll always be my songbird, no matter what.” He stroked her cheek before rising to pour her another glass. After she drank it, Hugh returned with the paddle he’d used on her once before. She had no idea how it had ended up in this suite, and she didn’t ask. She wasn’t going to ruin this night by thinking about their supernatural powers or what would happen in the future. All she wanted to do was enjoy them while she had them.

“I have an idea,” said Sterling. He walked toward the same hallway while Hugh pulled her into his arms and gave her a bear hug.

“I’ve missed you, Caleigh.”

Caleigh squeezed his hard body tighter. “I’ve missed you, too.”

“Sterling and I were afraid if we let you go to Philly alone you wouldn’t come back.”

Something in Hugh’s voice tugged at her soul. She realized how difficult it was for him to verbalize deep feelings and that saying what he’d just said had taken a lot of courage. She pulled away to look into his eyes. “I wouldn’t have done that to you two.”

“Are you happy here with us?” There was a note of desperation that she’d never heard before.

“Yes. I am.” It was on the tip of her tongue to tell Hugh she’d fallen in love with both of them, but the words simply wouldn’t come. They stared into each other’s eyes until Sterling’s voice broke the spell.

“All right, my lovely songbird. Time for you to be completely at our mercy.” Caleigh moaned when she spotted the ties Sterling held in his hands. Again, she didn’t ask where they’d come from. Could they summon inanimate objects out of thin air? Nothing would surprise her.

Her nipples began to tingle and her pussy contracted as Hugh draped her over sofa cushions so her ass was in the air. He and Sterling moved furniture around so they could tie one leg to a table behind the arm of the sofa, and the other to a table next to it. They put her arms over her head and tied her wrists together.

“Just tell us if you need to take a break or if this hurts, okay?” Sterling’s voice was warm and tender. “We don’t want you too uncomfortable.”