Authors: writing as Mary Westmacott Agatha Christie
It was a statement, not a question.
Llewellyn gestured to a waiter who came.
He ordered a Curaçao.
âMay I order you something?'
âThank you,' she said. And added: âHe knows.'
The boy bowed his head in assent and went away.
They sat for a moment or two in silence.
âI suppose,' she said at last, âyou were lonely? There aren't many Americans or English here.'
She was, he saw, settling the question of why he had spoken to her.
âNo,' he said at once. âI wasn't lonely. I find I'm â glad to be alone.'
âOh, one is, isn't one?'
The fervour with which she spoke surprised him.
âI see,' he said. âThat's why you come here?'
She nodded.
âTo be alone. And now I've come and spoilt it?'
âNo,' she said. âYou don't matter. You're a stranger, you see.'
âI see.'
âI don't even know your name.'
âDo you want to?'
âNo. I'd rather you didn't tell me. I won't tell you my name, either.'
She added doubtfully:
âBut perhaps you've been told that already. Everyone in the café knows me, of course.'
âNo, they haven't mentioned it. They understand, I think, that you would not want it told.'
âThey do understand. They have, all of them, such wonderful good manners. Not
taught
good manners â the natural thing. I could never have believed till I came here that natural courtesy could be such a wonderful â such a
positive
thing.'
The waiter came back with their two drinks. Llewellyn paid him.
He looked over to the glass the girl held cupped in her two hands.
âBrandy?'
âYes. Brandy helps a lot.'
âIt helps you to feel alone? Is that it?'
âYes. It helps me to feel â free.'
âAnd you're not free?'
âIs anybody free?'
He considered. She had not said the words bitterly â as they are usually spoken. She had been asking a simple question.
â
The fate of every man is bound about his neck
â is that what you feel?'
âNo, I don't think so. Not quite. I can understand feeling rather like that, that your course was charted out like a ship's, and that you must follow it, again rather like a ship, and that so long as you do, you are all right. But I feel more like a ship that has, quite suddenly, gone off its proper course. And then, you see, you're lost. You don't know where you are, and you're at the mercy of the wind and sea, and you're not free, you're caught in the grip of something you don't understand â tangled up in it all.' She added: âWhat nonsense I'm talking. I suppose it's the brandy.'
He agreed.
âIt's partly the brandy, no doubt. Where does it take you?'
âOh,
away
⦠that's all â away â¦'
âWhat is it, really, that you have to get away from?'
âNothing. Absolutely nothing. That's the really â well, wicked part of it. I'm one of the fortunate ones. I've got everything.' She repeated sombrely: âEverything ⦠Oh, I don't mean I've not had sorrows, losses, but it's not that. I don't hanker and grieve over the past. I don't resurrect it and live it over again. I don't want to go back, or even forward. I just want to go
away
somewhere. I sit here drinking brandy and presently I'm out there, beyond the harbour, and going farther and farther â into some kind of unreal place that doesn't really exist. It's rather like the dreams of flying you have as a child â no weight â so light â floating.'
The wide unfocused stare was coming back to her eyes. Llewellyn sat watching her.
Presently she came to herself with a little start.
âI'm sorry.'
âDon't come back. I'm going now.' He rose. âMay I, now and then, come and sit here and talk to you? If you'd rather not, just say so. I shall understand.'
âNo, I should like you to come. Good night. I shan't go just yet. You see, it's not always that I can get away.'
It was about a week later when they talked together again. She said as soon as he sat down: âI'm glad you haven't gone away yet. I was afraid you might have gone.'
âI shan't go away just yet. It's not time yet.'
âWhere will you go when you leave here?'
âI don't know.'
âYou mean â you're waiting for orders?'
âYou might put it like that, yes.'
She said slowly:
âLast time, when we talked, it was all about me. We didn't talk about you at all. Why did you come here â to the island? Had you a reason?'
âPerhaps it was for the same reason as you drink brandy â to get away, in my case from people.'
âPeople in general, or do you mean special people?'
âNot people in general. I meant really people who know me â or knew me â as I was.'
âDid something â happen?'
âYes, something happened.'
She leaned forward.
âAre you like me? Did something happen that put you off course?'
He shook his head with something that was almost vehemence.
âNo, not at all. What happened to me was an intrinsic part of the pattern of my life. It had significance and intention.'
âBut what you said about people â'
âThey don't understand, you see. They are sorry for me, and they want to drag me back â to something that's finished.'
She wrinkled a puzzled brow.
âI don't quite â'
âI had a job,' he said smiling. âNow â I've lost it.'
âAn important job?'
âI don't know.' He was thoughtful. âI thought it was. But one can't really know, you see, what is important. One has to learn not to trust one's own values. Values are always relative.'
âSo you gave up your job?'
âNo.' His smile flashed out again. âI was sacked.'
âOh.' She was taken aback. âDid you â mind?'
âOh yes, I minded. Anyone would have. But that's all over now.'
She frowned at her empty glass. As she turned her head, the boy who had been waiting replaced the empty glass with a full one.
She took a couple of sips, then she said:
âCan I ask you something?'
âGo ahead.'
âDo you think happiness is very important?'
He considered.
âThat's a very difficult question to answer. If I were to say that happiness is vitally important, and that at the same time it doesn't matter at all, you'd think I was crazy.'
âCan't you be a little clearer?'
âWell, it's rather like sex. Sex is vitally important, and yet doesn't matter. You're married?'
He had noticed the slim gold ring on her finger.
âI've been married twice.'
âDid you love your husband?'
He left it in the singular, and she answered without quibbling.
âI loved him more than anything in the world.'
âWhen you look back on your life with him, what are the things that come first to your mind, the moments that you will always remember? Are they of the first time you slept together â or are they of something else?'
Laughter came to her suddenly, and a quick enchanting gaiety.
âHis hat,' she said.
âHat?'
âYes. On our honeymoon. It blew away and he bought a native one, a ridiculous straw thing, and I said it would be more suitable for
me
. So I put it on, and then he put on mine â one of those silly bits of nonsense women wear, and we looked at each other and laughed. All trippers change hats, he said, and then he said: “Good Lord, I do love you ⦔ ' Her voice caught. âI'll never forget.'
âYou see?' said Llewellyn. âThose are the magical moments â the moments of belonging â of everlasting sweetness â not sex. And yet if sex goes wrong, a marriage is completely ruined. So, in the same way, food is important â without it you cannot live, and yet, so long as you
are
fed, it occupies very little of your thoughts. Happiness is one of the foods of life, it encourages growth, it is a great teacher, but it is not the purpose of life, and is, in itself, not ultimately satisfying.'
He added gently:
âIs it happiness that you want?'
âI don't know. I ought to be happy. I have everything to make me happy.'
âBut you want something more?'
â
Less
,' she said quickly, âI want
less
out of life. It's too much â it's all too much.'
She added, rather unexpectedly:
âIt's all so
heavy
.'
They sat for some time in silence.
âIf I knew,' she said at last, âif I knew in the least what I really wanted, instead of just being so negative and idiotic.'
âBut you do know what you want; you want to escape. Why don't you, then?'
âEscape?'
âYes. What's stopping you? Money?'
âNo, it's not money. I have money â not a great deal, but sufficient.'
âWhat is it then?'
âIt's so many things. You wouldn't understand.' Her lips twisted in a sudden, ruefully humorous smile. âIt's like Tchekov's three sisters, always moaning about going to Moscow; they never go, and never will, although I suppose they
could
just have gone to the station and taken a train to Moscow any day of their lives! Just as I could buy a ticket and sail on that ship out there, that sails tonight.'
âWhy don't you?'
He was watching her.
âYou think you know the answer,' she said.
He shook his head.
âNo, I don't know the answer. I'm trying to help you find it.'
âPerhaps I'm like Tchekov's three sisters. Perhaps I don't really want to go.'
âPerhaps.'
âPerhaps escape is just an idea that I play with.'
âPossibly. We all have fantasies that help us to bear the lives we live.'
âAnd escape is my fantasy?'
âI don't know.
You
know.'
âI don't know anything â anything at all. I had every chance, I did the wrong thing. And then, when one has done the wrong thing, one has to stick to it, hasn't one?'
âI don't know.'
âMust you go
on
saying that over and over?'
âI'm sorry, but it's true. You're asking me to come to a conclusion on something I know nothing about.'
âIt was a general principle.'
âThere isn't such a thing as a general principle.'
âDo you mean' â she stared at him â âthat there isn't such a thing as absolute right and wrong?'
âNo, I didn't mean that. Of course there's absolute right and wrong, but that's a thing so far beyond our knowledge and comprehension, that we can only have the dimmest apprehension of it.'
âBut surely one knows what is right?'
âYou have been taught it by the accepted canons of the day. Or, going further, you can feel it of your own instinctive knowledge. But even that's a long way off. People were burned at the stake, not by sadists or brutes, but by earnest and high-minded men, who believed that what they did was right. Read some of the law cases in ancient Greece, of a man who refused to let his slaves be tortured so as to get at the truth, as was the prevalent custom. He was looked upon as a man who deliberately obscured justice. There was an earnest God-fearing clergyman in the States who beat his three-year-old son, whom he loved, to death, because the child refused to say his prayers.'
âThat's all horrible!'
âYes, because time has changed our ideas.'
âThen, what can we do?'
Her lovely bewildered face bent towards him.
âFollow your pattern, in humility â and hope.'
âFollow one's pattern â yes, I see that, but my pattern â it's wrong somehow.' She laughed. âLike when you're knitting a jumper and you've dropped a stitch a long way back.'
âI wouldn't know about that,' he said. âI've never knitted.'
âWhy wouldn't you give me an opinion just now?'
âIt would only have been an opinion.'
âWell?'
âAnd it might have influenced you ⦠I should think you're easily influenced.'
Her face grew sombre again.
âYes. Perhaps that's what was wrong.'
He waited for a moment or two, then he said in a matter-of-fact voice:
âWhat exactly is wrong?'
âNothing.' She looked at him despairingly. âNothing. I've got everything any woman could want.'
âYou're generalizing again. You're not any woman. You're you. Have
you
got everything you want?'
âYes, yes,
yes
! Love and kindness and money and luxury, and beautiful surroundings and companionship â everything. All the things that I would have chosen for myself. No, it's
me
. There's something wrong with
me
.'
She looked at him defiantly. Strangely enough, she was comforted when he answered matter-of-factly:
âOh yes. There's something wrong with
you
â that's very clear.'
She pushed her brandy-glass a little way away from her.
She said: âCan I talk about myself?'
âIf you like.'
âBecause if I did, I might just see where â it all went wrong. That would help, I think.'
âYes. It might help.'
âIt's all been very nice and ordinary â my life, I mean. A happy childhood, a lovely home. I went to school and did all the ordinary things, and nobody was ever nasty to me; perhaps if they had been, it would have been better for me. Perhaps I was a spoiled brat â but no, I don't really think so. And I came home from school and played tennis and danced, and met young men, and wondered what job to take up â all the usual things.'