The Darker Side (40 page)

They were asleep when the sound of voices woke Michael up. He glanced over and saw that Frances was still sleeping. Years later, he’d wonder why he’d been awoken. He’d come to understand that God had called him from sleep, because God had a plan.

The voices weren’t loud, but they had a sense of urgency to them. The fact of them was strange; it was 2:00 A.M. Father went to bed at 9:30 and woke up at 4:30.

Michael stood up and went to the door. He put his ear to it as he had done so many times to the wall of the confessional booth. He closed his eyes, and he listened.

One of the voices was female, and strangely familiar, though he couldn’t quite place it. The other belonged to his father.

“They don’t need to know!” his father whispered. “There’s no reason. This was our sin, our secret. They’re fine, they’re healthy, and they both plan to lead holy lives, devoted to God. Why burden them with this now?”

“God spoke to me, Frank. I’ve spent the last sixteen years praying to him, asking him for forgiveness. I have calluses on my knees from praying. He finally answered. Do you know what he said? He said just one word:
truth.
I heard it in my heart, clear as a bell. God is love, Frank, remember? Love can only come from truth. I agreed to hide this in the beginning because I was ashamed. I was certain God would never forgive me. But he spoke to me, he told me he will forgive me. All I have to do is obey him, to tell the truth.”

“You’re hearing things! Do you really think that God would want you to ruin their lives by telling them the truth, by telling them you are their mother?”

Michael’s head shot away from the door like he’d had his ear pressed against a hot iron.

What had he said?

Mother.
The word was
mother
.

How many times, in early years, had they pressed Father, had they asked him about their mother?

She died in childbirth, he’d told them. She’s with God now, she’s the reason I joined the priesthood. Let her be.

One day they stopped asking, but they never stopped wondering.

And why did her voice sound familiar?

“What is it?”

He started in the dark. His twin stood behind him. He realized he was shivering.

“Michael?”

She put her arms around his waist and hugged herself to him, cheek against his shoulder blades. He continued to shiver, but even in his fear he was aware of her small breasts against his back. He chastised himself in silence.

Lust is the devil’s work, and the devil is tireless.

“F-father is arguing with someone. A woman. I heard him say she’s our mother.”

He felt her stiffen against him.

“What?”

He wanted to turn around. He wanted to turn around and tell her to forget it, they should go back to bed and wake up the next morning and realize that it had all been a dream. He couldn’t turn around right now, though. She’d see his lust.

The devil is tireless…

“I heard him. Listen.”

She continued to clutch him as they strained to hear. He marveled at the dexterity of Satan. Michael was terrified of what they might hear, angered at what they’d already heard, he was a little bit dizzy, he was trying to hear more but didn’t want to hear more, and through it all, he was never unaware of those small breasts against his back, the hint of what might
(just might)
be her nipples. Lucifer could walk and chew gum at the same time, no doubt about that.

“I forbid it!” Michael’s father raged in a whisper.

Silence.

The woman’s voice was calm, sure, certain. He still couldn’t quite place it; the whisper was disguising it.

“You can’t forbid me to do what God’s ordered, Frank. I am their mother, and God has said it’s time they knew everything.”

Michael knew something was very wrong when Frances gasped. She buried her face in his back and moaned. It was a sound of horror. Her arms left him and he felt her back away. He turned around and saw that her face was milk-white, her eyes so wide he thought they’d pop out of their sockets, her fist stuffed in her mouth to stifle her moans. She pointed a shaking finger at the door, but couldn’t seem to say anything coherent.

“Frances? What is it?”

She pulled the fist from her mouth. He was shocked to see that she’d bitten it hard enough to draw blood in places.

“Her…” she whispered, still horrified. “Don’t you recognize her voice?” She began to pull her hair. Some of it ripped away from her scalp. “Don’t you recognize her voice?”

Michael grabbed her wrists to keep her from hurting herself more. He’d always loved her hair. Other than her eyes, it was the thing that made her the most beautiful.

“Frances! Get hold of yourself!”

She yanked her wrists out of his grasp and sat down against the wall. She pulled her knees up to her chest and put her forehead against them. She began to rock, back and forth.

“Go and see. You’ll understand.”

He could barely hear her.

But something was starting to swim up from a very deep, very dark place. Something that caused a greasy sweat to break out on his forehead.

He took a last look at his twin and opened the door. He padded down the hall toward the voices, which were coming from the chapel. The sweat was really coming now and he started to run, because that dark thing was swimming with a vengeance, and he wanted to get there before it broke the surface, so he could prove it wrong, wrong, wrong…

He burst into the chapel barefoot, in his underwear, covered with sweat and shivering like a naked man in a snowstorm.

The thing burst through the surface. Laughing.

Do you see? it asks. Do you seeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee hee hee hee hee?

He did see. He saw his father, the great and honorable Frank Murphy, standing next to the woman who’d said she was their mother.

The woman was a nun, and he knew her well.

Aunt Michelle.

39

“MY FATHER AND MY MOTHER HAD BEEN BROTHER AND SISTER,
twins like my sister and I. They’d lain together and the result had been us.” His face is sad, somber, grave. “They conspired to hide my mother’s pregnancy. It wasn’t so hard. They were both eighteen. They’d gotten drunk and had let the devil lead them.

“How do I describe what that was like for us? The two people we respected most in the world had spent our lifetime lying to us. Our birthright was incest. We were the result of the forbidden coupling.

“I asked my father, that night, if he’d ever confessed this sin to another. He said that he had not.” Murphy’s expression is incredulous. “Can you imagine? He’d kept his sin to himself, had consigned himself to hellfire. Why? To protect us? No. Any priest he’d confessed to would have kept his secret. He did it because he was ashamed.

“Of all the things I learned and heard, that was the one that was unforgivable to me. Not the incest, though that was bad enough. Not the lying to my sister and me, I could even understand that. The one thing I could not forgive him for was his deception of God.

“They told us they’d devoted their lives to God and had raised us to fear God as penance for their sin. I couldn’t hear this, couldn’t see past that most basic deception.

“My sister and I fled the church that morning. Father tried to stop us, but I struck him down.” He smiles, once. “No, I didn’t kill him. He died of cancer ten years ago. I have no idea if he ever confessed to his sin. I like to think he did.”

“She never talks,” Alan says.

“He’s in charge,” I reply. “It’s his show.”

This is common in serial killer teams. One acts as the dominant, calls the plays, provides the rationalization for their actions. Kirby hadn’t been so far off the mark after all.

“We were troubled for a number of years, I will admit. We lost our way. The only thing we never lost was our love for each other.” His sister places a hand on his shoulder. He reaches up to hold it while continuing to speak. “It took us some time to come back to God. I won’t bore you with the ins and outs of that right now. There’s time for our full story later. All that’s important now is that truth: we did come back to God. I came to realize that the ruination of our lives was the result of a lie, a refusal to bare all to God, a refusal to confess in order to receive salvation.

“We have since applied this to ourselves, without mercy or restraint. I admitted to sexual longings for my sister. She did the same. We did our penance for our actions, for so nearly following in our parents’ sinful footsteps. And we came, once again, to understand what God’s purpose was for us.”

He glances up at her, she down at him, and they smile. It’s an image made terrible because it is beatific. Monsters with halos and blood on their teeth. They return their gaze to the camera.

“God had tested us, from the moment of our conception. He gave us every reason to give up on Him. He provided us with betrayal, doubt, and suffering. He wanted to be sure we were strong enough. God tests all His prophets thus.

“I came to understand that the face of my father was the face of far too many. The holy man, devoting his life to God and others. The admirable soul who is yet willing to consign himself to eternal damnation because he is willing to reveal some of his secrets, but not all of them. My father admitted to having children out of wedlock, but not to the ultimate truth—that it had been his sister he slept with.

“I came to understand that it was our duty to bring others to the full light of God by ensuring they understood that God accepts only absolutes in His truth. Be truthful about all, be factually contrite, ask Him to forgive, and He will cleanse the sin from you. Admit to nine sins of ten, hold back the one, and you will burn forever.

“We have devoted our lives to this work. It has been difficult. Thou shalt not kill, one of God’s most basic dictates. But all those we killed had confessed to their sins, and all save one were truly contrite. How else could we know about them? We only took souls who had admitted their sins to a priest in holy confession. They were martyrs, all but one, pierced in the side as Christ on the cross, and the contrite now sit at the right hand of the Lord.” He pauses. “The child is the exception, of course. I have no doubt that she is burning as I speak. She died to illuminate the other half of the sacred agreement: contrition. Because of these deaths, millions more will understand that they are not alone, that we all have shameful things inside us. We all have a darker side we must admit to if we’re to experience the fullness of the love of God. And oh, how wonderful that love is. God is many things, but most of all, God is love.”

The first visible hint of insanity reveals itself. It’s subtle. A certain shine to the eyes, a higher pitch to the voice. But it’s there. Behind it will be the truth of what he’s doing and done and why. Shame at the circumstances that caused their birth, betrayal by those they trusted, all of it wrapped in the religion in which they were raised. I don’t care how flowery the phrases are, how carefully thought out the rationalizations; serial murder is sublimated rage. There are no exceptions.

I consider, again, the fact that the victims were all women and realize that Callie had been correct when she spoke about the Madonna and the whore. Michael Murphy blamed his aunt/mother more than he blamed his father, and the women he murdered had paid the price.

“That stage of our work is done. We’re ready now, to move forward, to take the next step on the path God has laid for us. Come find us. We are ready. We will go willingly, and will not fight back.”

Fade to black.

“Isn’t that nice of them?” Callie says, scorn in her voice. “Poor babies, boo-hoo for them. Daddy was an asshole, join the club.”

I tend to agree with her sentiments; we all do. Life is rough, even cruel and unjust. That’s no excuse for turning on your fellow man. The nature versus nurture argument has raged for years, and will rage for more. I think there is truth in the need for a good environment. Our future is informed by what we experience as children. Statistics bear this out too often to be discounted.

Approximately one-third of the abused go on to become abusers. But what about the other two-thirds? All those abused, mistreated, beaten, and betrayed, who went on to lead normal lives? Haunted forever by their experiences, maybe even permanently damaged, but—and here’s the point—still decent? For every victim of molestation who goes on to offend against children as an adult, we can find examples of victims who went on to become kind and loving parents. What is the difference between the two? Are some of us just born able to carry bigger burdens than others?

Michael and Frances had been dealt a bad hand, true, but it was hardly crippling. Not even close to the worst I’d ever heard. The fact that they’d managed to spin their misfortune into a rationalization for twenty years of murder is, for me, more a testament to their weakness and their guilt than a reason to sympathize.

“I don’t really care why,” I say. “I just want to put them in jail.”

“I can get behind that,” Alan agrees.

In the end, this is the simplicity that saves us. Looking for reasons why, trying to get down to that deep, dark bedrock, is just a serpent eating its own tail. In the end, you won’t find truth, you’ll just devour yourself. At some point we have to stop trying to understand why and accept that our only job is to remove them from society. It’s easier with some than others.

“Let’s get a current address,” I say, “and give them their wish.”

AN HOUR HAS PASSED SINCE
the discoveries began to come so fast and furious. AD Jones is in our offices, along with my team and the FBI SWAT.

The head of our SWAT is Sam Brady, Callie’s fiancé. Brady is in his mid-forties and he’s a tall, lanky man, standing around six-four, with close-cropped hair and a face that can be as grim as his profession calls for. I’ve seen other sides to him and have come to know a man at peace with who he is. He loves Callie quietly, but he loves her deeply and he seems to bring this approach to everything in his life. He’s solid and all man and utterly unintimidated by Callie.

Brady has watched the last video clip of the Preacher.