Read The Evening Spider Online
Authors: Emily Arsenault
Haverton, Connecticut
December 10, 2014
I
closed the journal pages. My eyelids were feeling heavy, and I needed a break.
Since Lucy was still napping, I tried Stephanie Barnett's number for the second time. The first time I'd left a message, explaining who I was and that her brother had given me her number.
This time it rang three times, and then a woman picked up with an exasperated-sounding “Hello?”
“Oh!” I said. “Stephanie?”
“Yeah?”
“My name is Abby Olson Bernacki. I called you earlier andâ”
“Yup. I recognized your number this time. You're in the Miller Avenue house, huh?”
“Yes. Can you talk right now?”
“I'm taking a smoke break at work.”
I wasn't sure if that was a yes or a no.
“Oh. Where do you work?” I asked, trying for a little small talk.
“I cut hair at GreatCuts. I've got a couple minutes. What's this about? I'm curious.”
“Well.” I took a breath. “I guess I'll get right to the point. I've been having odd experiences in the house. I implied as much to your brother, and he said that you had, too.”
“Odd experiences,” Stephanie repeated quietly.
Was she going to make me come out and say it?
“Creepy, like,” I said, using the same word her brother had used.
“Oh.” Stephanie didn't sound particularly surprised. “Like what?”
As Stephanie asked this, I heard a little cough and a sputter. A tiny sneeze, and then a cry. Lucy was awake.
“Hold on just a second?” I said, making my way quickly down the hall.
Lucy's door was wide open, as I'd left it. When I reached for her, she made a cute little squeak and stopped crying.
“Sorry,” I said, sinking into the rocker so I could put the phone back to my ear. “Stephanie?”
“You . . . have a baby?” Stephanie asked.
“Yeah,” I said.
“Oh.”
Stephanie was silent for a moment, but I could hear her breathing.
“Are you still there?” I asked.
“Um. Yeah. How old's the baby? Do you have any other kids?”
“Just her. She's five months old.”
More silence.
“Stephanie?”
“Yeah. Sorry. Which room is the baby's room?”
“The little one upstairs. Right at the top of the stairs.”
Stephanie didn't reply. I heard her exhaleâperhaps letting out a puff of cigarette smoke.
“Hello?” I said.
Lucy reached up and tapped the side of my face, saying “Oh! Oh!” in surprisingly imitative fashion.
“Hello?” I repeated.
“Oooohh!” Lucy gasped, her mouth forming a precocious little “o.”
“Hi. I . . . sorry.” Stephanie sounded hurried now. “I don't think I can talk about this right now. I'll . . . call you back. Bye.”
“But could weâ”
I was going to say
Could we set up a time to talk,
but a moment later my phone was beeping gently. The screen said, “Call ended.”
I tried calling Stephanie back but got her voice mail.
“Shit,” I muttered, and scowled at the phone.
Lucy slapped my chin and laughed.
Northampton Lunatic Hospital
Northampton, Massachusetts
December 20, 1885
T
he day Clara brought Martha back home to me was a hot and muggy one. I recall mopping my face with cold water as I waited by the window, struggling to appear cool and natural. Despite the obvious intensity of the heat, I feared looking anxious.
When Clara finally arrivedâclutching the bonneted MarthaâI sprang up from my chair. I wasn't sure, though, if I should run outside to greet her. Again, would that be natural? Would that be correct?
I do not know why I worried so, as Martha's and my separation had been so unnatural that surely nothing I did could top it. Still, I worried how carefully my behavior was being watched and analyzed. Matthew was not present, but my tedious nurse was, and I knew she reported the details of my behavior (that is, the ones that didn't make her look incompetent) directly to Dr. Stayer.
Dear Clara thankfully took things in hand.
“Frances and her girl should have a chance to reunite in private, don't you think?” she asked the nurse in a manner that
clearly communicated that she wasn't really
asking
at all. “I'm parched. Let's have a drink out back under that beautiful maple tree.”
“I will bring some water right out to you ladies,” Tessa added.
Clara thrust Martha into my arms, hustling the nurse out before she could protest.
The nurse was to leave on the following dayâunless she and Dr. Stayer dreamt up some reason for her to stay and keep drawing a wage from Matthew.
The ladies' voices faded from me as Clara drew the nurse toward the maple tree. For a glorious moment, Harry, it was all Martha's eyes again. They'd fluttered open from Clara's sudden movement, and there they wereâlike two secret gems kept from me the entire time I'd been “resting.” As familiar now as ever. And as beautiful.
I'd have stared into them all that afternoon had Martha not begun to fuss just then. I panicked, wondering if she'd forgotten my face. And as I lifted her to my shoulder, whispering my love to her, her weight felt unfamiliar to me. I stretched out my arms to look at her again. I panicked. Her face seemed wider than my Martha'sâher ears slightly pointier. I could not rememberâhad Martha's ears really been this pointy?
“My girl,” I said, perhaps trying to convince myself. “My sweet girl.”
She quieted more quickly than I expected, and I was relieved to think she had not forgotten me after all. I feared, however, that
I'd
forgotten something fundamental about her. What that was precisely, I couldn't determine.
I carried Martha up the stairs and looked at her and myself in the mirror. The sight of us together strengthened me and
pushed back the doubt. There were her eyes again, confirming a truth larger than that doubt: We belonged together, Martha and I. She'd still been in this world a shorter time than she'd been inside of me. This felt significant to me, even if the people and circumstances around us did not acknowledge its significance.
I whispered to our reflection, “I shall try again, my dear girl.”
I felt every word of that phrase, and feel it even now.
My dear girl.
Forward and backward.
My. Dear. Girl.
Girl. Dear. Mine.
For I felt in that moment the sad importance of her being female. And she was indeed dear to me. More dear than anything had ever been before. And she was mine.
That
everyone seemed to have forgotten in the month that had separated us. She was
my
daughter.
Mine.
          Â
May 7, 1879
              Â
I haven't sewn a stitch since my last entry. Yesterday was such a brilliant sunny day that Martha and I walked all the way to Beebe's store, where I was delighted to find a new selection of fabrics. There will be more summer dresses and bonnets for Martha, as I purchased a yard of each of the three prettiest.
              Â
As we arrived back home from Beebe's, I noticed the beginnings of the tulips peeking out from beneath last autumn's leavesâthe patch by the side of the door, which Mrs. Lawton helped me plant when I was a new bride. Because Martha was sleeping contentedly in her carriage, I busied myself clearing away the old leaves and pulled up two tiny saplings that were trying to establish themselves among them. And as Martha was still sleeping after that, I fetched my old sketchbookâwith some effort, as I hadn't seen it in many monthsâand attempted to draw the charming little plants. There is something about that flower's first unfurling that is most beguiling. I could not capture it with my pencil. My drawings looked like soiled fingers with ragged nails, reaching up from the dirt. (“They look a bit frightful, ma'am,” Tessa admitted when I showed her my work. “But wasn't that how you intended it?”)
              Â
My attempt today was considerably better, and dear Martha slept through all of my sketching, but the effort delayed my supper plans by an hour or two. I had to serve Matthew bread before the soup was ready, as his stomach was growling so viciously.
          Â
May 12, 1879
              Â
Clara made an unexpected visit yesterday. I was surprised to see she had her carpet bag with herâbulging with clothes for several nights. It appears Matthew wrote Jonathan and suggested I'd appreciate a visit. I certainly am enjoying the company, but it is out of character for Matthew to forget to tell me something like this. I would have done some special baking for my sister. Now that she is here, we are baking cider loaves together. She so enjoys holding Martha and singing to her. Her voice is so much lovelier than mine. I wonder if Martha notices the difference. I sing to her when I am certain nobody else can hear. Soon she will understand the distinction between a sweet voice and an unmelodic one. I like to think, however, that in the earliest days, her mother's was nonetheless her favorite.
          Â
May 14, 1879
              Â
I have tucked in here my last attempt I made at drawing the early tulip leaves. I drew it on the first day Clara was here. She held Martha while I went outdoors after Matthew had gone. This will be the last drawing until
next year, as they have all bloomed now. I don't have as strong a desire to draw the actual blooms. They are perhaps too ostentatious. The early leaves, just emerging, are like impish little secrets, every one. That is what I most wanted to capture. I don't know if I've done so very successfully, but I'll save the attempt until next year and compare the two.
              Â
Clara asked, when she saw what I had done, if I had recently taken up botany more seriously. I told her no and tried to explain to her the singular attraction of the early tulip leaves, rolled up so coyly. She replied with a doubtful smile, as if I'd said that I expected winged fairies to crop up from the soil.
              Â
I did not show her my drawings. I don't begrudge her her older-sisterly airsâI simply wish my drawing skills matched her musical ones.
          Â
October 14, 1879
              Â
Professor Johnson is to testify soon. On our walk yesterday, Harry answered all of my questions about his colleague's experiments and their place in the trial. It was a pleasure to have my brother all to myself. Matthew is, of late, so intent on cushioning my mind from anything so interesting.
              Â
This is my understanding of the significance of the experimental stomachs. It is to show that the poor girl's stomach was not tampered with unlawfully after her death! There was no denying that her stomach had poison in it, but what is likely to be argued by the defense is that it
was deposited there by someone on the prosecutor's sideâsomeone intent on convicting Rev. Mr. Hayden.
              Â
The Stannard girl's stomach had, as a result of the arsenic, enlarged blood vessels in the postmortem examination. Under the direction of Professor Johnson, Harry and his colleagues obtained two stomachs for experimentation, and applied a similar amount of arsenic to them. After some time sitting in jars in the lab, with the arsenic inside of them, it was found that the stomachs did not have the same enlarged condition of blood vessels as the girl's stomach. These results will make it more difficult for the defense to make their accusation regarding the arsenic's introduction after the death, rather than before.
              Â
I gather that the physical evidence will be much more complex than what I've described here, but this explains Harry's part. I inquired whether he would be taking the stand, but he said no. Dr. Johnson will be speaking for his own work, including this part in which Harry assisted. It would be exciting if Harry testified! Mother would be beside herself, however, so perhaps it is best he has a quieter role.
          Â
October 18, 1879
              Â
Harry has fulfilled his promise of late. He finally came to visit me at homeâspent an hour with Martha on his knee and gave me more than a week's worth of New Haven newspapers. I'd have liked to have read them right away and asked him questions about what he's seen and heard, as he was present in the courtroom for one day of
Dr. Johnson's testimony! I stashed them in my chest in the bedroom, however, while he and Matthew were chatting.
              Â
It was altogether a clandestine affair. Harry brought the newspapers in a basket of sweet breads made and sent, he said, by Mother. Harry had given me a tiny wink as he'd said this, and when I brought them to the kitchen, I saw the newspapers stuffed beneath them.
              Â
I have only managed to read two so far. They involve the selection of the jury and Herbert Hayden's plea of not guilty.
              Â
I gather, from peeking, that the further articles involve the details of Dr. Johnson's testimony. I am saving those for tomorrowâwhen Matthew won't be present, and I won't be so tired.