The Girl with Braided Hair (A Wind River Reservation Myste) (2 page)

THE AIR TASTED
of summer—of dust and dried sage and brittle grass. Cottonwoods straddled a dry creek bed, branches splayed against the blue sky, and the lumps of sagebrush scattered about shimmered like water in the sun. There was a reddish tint to the bluffs that rose out of the earth. A hot wind knocked against the Toyota pickup and whistled through the cab, nearly drowning out
The Magic Flute
that blared from the tape player on the front seat. It was the last Monday in July, the moon when the chokecherries begin to ripen, in the Arapaho Way of marking the passing time. Father John Aloysius O’Malley shifted into low gear and pointed the pickup down a slight decline. He could feel the rear tires slipping. Pebbles and dust spewed from beneath the wheels and laid a thin golden film over the rearview window. The slope flattened into the gulley that trailed the base of a bluff. He followed the tire tracks that ran across the brown earth.

“Might wanna head out to the Gas Hills,” Thomas Whiteman had told him. The elder’s voice had cracked on the telephone, and for a moment, Father John thought the call was breaking up. “Somebody buried in a gulley out in no-man’s-land. Wild animal got to the bones.” The old man sounded like himself again, the voice strong with indignation. “Ain’t right, Father. Buried alone, nobody knows where you are, nobody prays for you, blesses your body.”

Father John had written down the directions, trying to picture the location: Gas Hills Road, east of Highway 789, just beyond the border of the Wind River Reservation, nothing much out there. He’d been at St. Francis Mission on the reservation now for almost ten years, seven years as the pastor—longer than the Jesuits usually left a man in one place, for which he was grateful; he could find his way blindfolded down the asphalt roads and the narrow dirt tracks and across the vast emptiness by the feel of the wind, the sound of the old pickup’s tires thumping on the hard-packed earth. He was familiar with the wild, remote areas around the reservation. So many times he’d hiked into the wilderness to think and pray and draw near to the silence. God was in the silence.

Whenever a body had been found in the wilderness—a rancher or a hiker spotting something protruding from the earth, something that didn’t belong—the phone had rung at St. Francis. And on the line, the Fremont County sheriff, the local FBI agent, the Wind River police chief or one of the Arapaho elders: “You might wanna come, Father.”

“Coroner’s out there now,” Thomas Whiteman had said. “They’re gonna be moving the bones pretty quick.”

He’d told the elder he was on his way, then he’d walked down the wide corridor in the old administration building to the office of his assistant, Father Ian McCauley. He’d found the man curled over a stack of papers on a desk marked by the rings of countless coffee cups that had rested on the surface through the decades. The sun bursting through the window gave a yellow cast to the other priest’s scalp beneath his thinning, sandy-colored hair. Father John told him he’d be out for a while.

“Emergency?” Father Ian hadn’t looked up.

“Dead body out in the Gas Hills.”

“Jesus.” He’d looked up then and shook his head. “I’ll hold down the fort,” he’d said, which had struck Father John as ironic. His assistant would handle the phone calls from the Arapaho parishioners and visit with anybody who happened to drop by—“You busy, Father? Got a minute?” In the Old Time, white men had defended the forts—held them down—
against
the Indians.

Father John had made his way back down the corridor, past the framed black-and-white photos of the past Jesuits at St. Francis, dark eyes trained on him through wireless spectacles perched on prominent noses. He’d jogged across the mission grounds to the old pickup parked in front of the redbrick residence. Years before he’d come here, somebody had donated the pickup to the mission; for some time now, the odometer had been stuck at one hundred and twenty-two thousand miles. He’d driven around Circle Drive, tires squealing, past the old gray stone building that had once been a school and was now the Arapaho Museum, past the white stucco church with the stained glass windows in the geometric symbols of the Arapaho and the white steeple that seemed to sway with the cottonwood branches shading the roof, past the two-story yellow stucco administration building. He’d turned down the tunnel of cottonwoods and headed east for 789, a route he’d taken so often that he half suspected the pickup could find the way on its own.

Now he could see vehicles parked ahead in the gulley. Sheriff’s deputies in tan uniforms were milling about with men in blue jeans and dark shirts, sleeves rolled to the elbows, wind plastering the shirts against their backs. Father John parked between a white SUV with Fremont County emblazoned on the sides and the gray pickup that Thomas Whiteman drove.

“Hey, Father.” Gary Coughlin, detective in the sheriff’s office, looked up from the carton he’d been rummaging through in the back of a van. He ducked his head through the strap of a black camera.

“What do you have?”

“Not much left but a skeleton.” The detective beckoned with his head as he started around the van toward the group of officers in a half circle near the base of the bluff.

Standing inside the circle was the gaunt figure of Thomas Whiteman, a black cowboy hat shading the elder’s wrinkled, brown face. With both hands, he slowly lifted a pan toward the sky. A thin wisp of smoke trailed out of the pan into the wind, leaving behind the faint odor of burning cedar.

Heito’eino’hoowuciixxokuno’.
The old man’s voice punctured the noise of the wind.
Woow heetneechoohun.
The Arapaho words seemed to hang in the air around the circle of officers standing with heads bowed. Father John understood some of the words; he could guess at the rest: Your relatives are nearby. Now you can go home.

The elder finished the prayer, then nodded at Father John. The half circle began to pull apart, the officers glancing back, waving him forward with their eyes. It was then that he saw the ocher-colored bones protruding through piles of brown dirt, as if they had been laid out. Except that he knew that wasn’t true. Whoever had left the body had probably pushed it into a shallow, hastily-dug grave, and the piles of dirt were the remnants of that grave.

The officers pulled apart to make a space for him, and he stepped closer. A raven rose from the side of the bluff and flapped away. The bones were small in diameter, yet long. Long femur, long humerus. Knobs of the long spine emerged from the dirt. The thin arm bones had been pulled back. Frayed pieces of rope were tied around the wrist bones. He could see the breaks in the bones. The skeleton was face down, so that the back of the skull was visible, and on the left side was a small, round bullet hole. And something else: a long rope of braided hair still attached to a piece of dried scalp. The braid wound over the spine, disappearing into the earth, then protruding again. It was black hair, faded with the brown dust of the earth.

Father John swallowed hard against the horror that rose inside him, the bitterness of bile. He got down on one knee and made the sign of the cross over the bones. “God have mercy,” he said out loud. “God, have mercy on this woman.” That it was the skeleton of a woman, he was sure. The delicate bones, the long black braid, and some inexplicable sense that this had been the body of a woman. Indian men wore braids, but there was something about the hair. It looked fine; it might have been silky once.

It struck him then, not for the first time, that God was not limited by time—by minutes and hours and days that passed into years. That God was eternal, and all time was present to Him. “God be with this woman,” he said again, praying for her
then
, when she had died this terrible death.

He noticed the debris scattered about, poking from beneath the bones—pieces of leather, faded scraps of calico and denim, the heel of a boot, pieces of metal that might have been buttons or snaps or rivets. The detritus of a life, he thought.

“Coroner agrees,” Detective Coughlin said, moving next to Father John as he stood up. “Skeleton’s most likely a woman.”

“How long has she been here?”

Coughlin shrugged. One of the other officers was pointing a camera toward the scalp and adjusting the lens. A series of clicking noises cut through the buzz of conversation and the whoosh of the wind, and for the first time, Father John was aware of the wind gusting. It didn’t surprise him; the Arapahos said the wind always blew when a body was disturbed.

“Forensics might be able to ballpark a date. Depends what they can get from the pieces of clothing and boot. Not much left. All we know for sure is that she was a homicide. Nobody ties his arms behind himself and shoots himself in the back of the head. Animals been digging here. Coyote or fox, maybe a wolf, dragged a femur about a hundred yards down the gulley. Couple of rock hunters come along this morning looking for rocks and arrowheads. One of ’em had a dog that got hold of the femur, and the men went looking for the source. Came upon the grave and called us.”

That would be the two men in Levi’s and black Stetsons, Father John was thinking, talking to another officer over by a green, four-door pickup.

“She’s Indian, that’s for sure.”

Father John turned around. He hadn’t realized that Thomas Whiteman had come up behind them.

“It’s possible,” Coughlin said. He exchanged a glance with Father John. They both knew that the skeleton was probably that of an Indian woman.

“Yeah, she’s Indian.” The old man was nodding, confirming his own theory. “Black braid like that. You don’t see no white people with that kinda hair. One of our own people,” he went on, still nodding, “left out here by herself for a long time. Well, now we found her, and we’re gonna get her buried proper so she can go to the ancestors in peace.”

Father John didn’t say anything. He could almost feel the detective swallowing his own comments. It would be a while before the coroner released the body—not until the investigation into the woman’s death was complete, and with a death that probably occurred years ago, the investigation would take a while. Still, the Arapahos would be anxious to bury her in the traditional way, anxious that until they did, her soul would be walking the earth.

Coughlin said, “Just as soon as possible.”

“We wanna know who she is.”

“So do we.”

The elder nodded at this and started to walk away. Then he turned back. “We’re not gonna forget her,” he said, before starting again for the gray pickup.

“Not gonna be an easy case to solve.” The detective was shaking his head. “Could be an old homicide, which is gonna make it a very cold case. Witnesses die and move away. Evidence evaporates. Killer could be dead.” He shrugged. “Sometimes they’re impossible, cases like this.”

“The Arapahos are going to want to know who she was and what happened to her.”

“Lot of murders never get solved, Father. It’s not a perfect world.”

“When will you have the forensics report?”

“Oh, man. Bad enough the elders are going to be on my case. Am I gonna have to put up with you bugging me?”

“Simple question, Gary.”

“Okay, simple answer. Could take a couple weeks before the coroner gets the full report.”

Father John nodded. “I’ll be in touch,” he said. Then he made his way through the officers still milling about and headed toward the pickup.

“I’m sure you will,” Detective Coughlin called after him.

VICKY HOLDEN SIPPED
at her coffee and let her gaze run over the handsome young man and beautiful young woman at her table, scarcely able to believe they were her children. Lucas, now twenty-seven, and so much like his father in the way he tossed his head, motioning for the waiter, that it made her heart turn over. The hum of traffic in downtown Denver hummed over the restaurant’s patio. Light from the lamps at the periphery flickered in his black eyes, and that reminded her of Ben, too, the pinpricks of light in his dark eyes. And Susan was truly beautiful, or was it her imagination? The fond hope of any mother for her twenty-five-year-old daughter? And yet, when they’d followed the maitre d’ through the dining room and out onto the patio, she’d seen the heads swiveling, the eyes following the slim, striking girl with the shiny black hair that swayed across her back.

And yet, Vicky couldn’t shake the image of the skeleton discovered in the Gas Hills last week; a girl, maybe Susan’s age, beaten and shot to death and left in a grave in a gulley. She’d read the articles in the
Gazette
before she’d left for a visit with the kids in Denver; the moccasin telegraph was loaded with gossip and rumors. Who was she? What happened to her?

“What, Mom?” Susan said, turning slightly in her chair.

Vicky shook her head. “You look great, that’s all,” she said, trying to force back another image now: the small, brown faces at the screened door the day she’d left the children on the reservation with her mother, after she’d finally summoned the courage to leave Ben to try to make a better life for them. She supposed that Susan resembled her. Wasn’t that what people always said? Susan was clean now. No more drugs and alcohol, and she’d lost the crowd she’d been hanging with. She was excited about a new job.

Vicky glanced across the table at Lucas. “You both look great,” she said. She was nineteen when Lucas was born. Not much more than a child herself, she was thinking. Two years later, Susan was born. But there had been ten years of dancing around Ben; the smells of alcohol and lipstick and the skin and hair of other women on his clothes, the shotgun temper, the hard thrusts of his fists in her face and stomach.

“Same for you, Mom.” Susan gave her a complicit smile, as if they’d been sharing secrets. Girl talk, huddled together over a water cooler. “So why don’t you come clean about Adam?”

“You’ve been waiting all weekend to ask?” Vicky shook her head and gave a little laugh despite the barb of barely camouflaged hostility in Susan’s question. There was always a sharpness in Susan, like the barbed wire you forgot about until it pricked you again. She didn’t blame her. She’d taken the girl from her father. It wasn’t something you explained to a child, and she would not explain it now and cloud the image that Susan held of her father.

There was the thump of hip-hop pouring out of a passing car, the ratcheting of a bus engine. The sounds seemed muted and far away, background noise to the memories that jostled one another. She’d tried to push the bad memories away. She didn’t want them, yet they’d had a way of intruding all weekend. Always the images of the small, brown faces bobbing behind the screened door as she’d backed out of the yard.

Tomorrow morning Lucas would return to a cubicle somewhere in a Denver skyscraper and do whatever he did to keep the computers operating in his company. Susan would fly back to Los Angeles and a new job generating the computer magic of special effects for some movie, and she would drive back to the Wind River Reservation and her own life.

Lucas looked up from the credit card slip he’d just signed. “Lakota, right?” He slipped the card into his wallet, then leaned forward toward the flickering candle and pushed the wallet into a back pocket. His hair was black and shiny, trimmed short and brushed back from a high intelligent forehead. There was a little hump in his nose, the mark of the Arapaho. The candlelight gave his skin the tone of honey. His smile reminded her of when he was a little boy and had just come upon a new discovery. “Should we expect a wedding?”

Susan looked away at this, as if the knots of people strolling past the patio on the sidewalk had demanded her attention.

“Adam and I are law partners,” Vicky said, wondering how they had managed to get through the zoo and the Museum of Nature and Science, the play at the performing arts center, and the hike into the foothills today without one of the kids bringing up the subject of Adam Lone Eagle.

Susan was still staring out over the sidewalk, and Lucas pressed on: “Come on, Mom, tell us what we don’t know.”

Vicky tried for a laugh. It sounded tight and forced. “If there were anything to tell, you would be the first to know.”

“We already know.” Susan’s head snapped around. “Moccasin telegraph works in Denver and L.A., you know. We’ve heard all about you and Adam.”

“He’s a good lawyer. I admire him very much.” Vicky wondered what other news the moccasin telegraph had delivered—that she and Adam were lovers? That Adam spent almost every night at her apartment?

“Maybe we should go to the rez and have a talk with him,” Lucas said. “You know, what are your intentions toward our mother?”

“His intentions? For heaven’s sakes, Lucas.”

“His intentions are honorable, of course.” Susan directed the comment toward her brother. “Isn’t that what every man wants a woman to believe?”

“Come on, you two,” Vicky said, reaching for a lighter tone. “I’d love to have you visit.” But not for a while, she was thinking. It wasn’t Adam’s intentions that she doubted; it was her own.

Vicky got to her feet and headed back through the restaurant, aware of the scraping sound of chairs on stone and the footsteps of Lucas and Susan behind her. The air was close and stuffy inside, unlike the warmth of the summer evening on the patio. She was aware of the way the few diners still lingering over coffee or dessert lifted their eyes as they walked by.

The nighttime streets of LoDo were busy. Sedans and SUVs crawling past the crowds that strolled the sidewalks and darted through the openings in the traffic. Lucas had to jam on the brakes to avoid two girls running across the street, waving and hollering at a knot of young people on the other side. Vicky felt her muscles tensing. She was no longer used to the congestion and traffic that had seemed normal when she’d lived in Denver. Then, after she’d gone home and started her law practice in Lander with the crazy idea that she could help her people, it was the open spaces that seemed normal. They had really never left her; they were part of her spirit. She was looking forward to the long drive tomorrow through the emptiness of Wyoming.

“We’re out of here,” Lucas said. The tires squealed into a left turn onto a side street. The hum of traffic receded as he drove on. There was only an occasional pedestrian hurrying along the sidewalk. A couple of more blocks, another turn, and they were back in a stream of traffic crossing the Platte River. Ahead, lights twinkled in the hills of Highland, the familiar neighborhood of century-old bungalows and Victorians where Vicky had once lived. Lucas had bought a house not far from the house she had rented.

On the other side of the viaduct, Lucas turned out of the traffic and into the side streets again. He drove slowly past the cars parked at the curbs and the dark tunnels of alleys. The headlights swept into the circles of light falling out of the street lamps.

“Whoa! What was that?” Lucas hit the brake pedal, and the car jerked to a stop. Vicky threw out one hand to brace herself against the dashboard; the seatbelt bit into her shoulder. Then they were rocketing backward.

“What’re you doing?” Susan shrieked from behind. Vicky could feel Susan gripping the back of the seat.

“You see that?”

“See what?” Susan said.

The street was suffused in the soft moonlight. The houses were dark, except for a dim light in the second-floor window of a house farther down the street. The car came to a stop, then Lucas backed up a few more feet and made a sharp turn into an alley. He drove past a small group of people—three or four men, a couple of women hunched next to the fence of a backyard. In the headlights bouncing ahead, Vicky could see two figures: the tall, thick-shouldered man in a white tee shirt and blue jeans; the girl crumbled against a garage. The man lifted a boot with a high heel and rounded toe and kicked the girl in the stomach. Then he grabbed a fistful of her long, black hair and yanked her upward against the garage door, his other arm pulled back, fist clenched.

Lucas was out of the car. He launched himself past the onlookers and threw his weight into the man, who stumbled backward, grappling for purchase on the chipped concrete apron of the garage, the twisted features of his face bobbing in the headlights, his mouth opened in a mixture of rage and surprise. Lucas grabbed the raised arm, but not before the man let go of the girl’s hair and drove a fist into Lucas’s middle. He twisted away, then reared back, head lowered. His fist caught the man’s jaw, knocking him off balance for a half second before the man came back, both fists pounding Lucas.

Vicky managed to get the glove compartment open, then the console box, frantic to find a flashlight, anything she might use, barely registering the sound of Susan screaming behind her. “Call 911,” Vicky yelled, throwing open the door and running her hand under the edge of the passenger seat as she slid out. Finally her fingers found a cool, hard plastic object. The screaming stopped. She could hear Susan shouting that they needed help as she gripped the flashlight and ran toward Lucas who had managed to back the man against the garage door. She was aware of the girl’s soft cries of pain through the sounds of boots scraping the concrete, the hard thrusts of fists against muscles and bones, the quick gasps of breath. Lucas threw another fist toward the man’s jaw, just as he dodged sideways and butted his head into Lucas’s chest. In an instant it was Lucas backed against the garage door, the man gripping his throat with one hand, winding up for another punch into Lucas’s stomach.

Vicky screamed and swung the flashlight into the side of the man’s head. He whirled toward her. Lucas dived for him with more force and anger than she could have imagined was in her son. He started pounding on the man, not letting up, until the man doubled over, dropping onto one knee, then the other, and finally folding onto the concrete, arms outstretched, unconscious. Even then she wasn’t sure that Lucas wouldn’t jump on top of him and continue pounding.

“The girl, the girl,” Vicky shouted.

Lucas took in a series of quick breaths, still standing over the prone figure, staring down at him. “Bastard,” he said. He swiped the back of his hand across his mouth. “You filthy bastard.”

Out of the corner of her eye, Vicky could see Susan moving through the headlights like a wisp of smoke. There was no one else in the alley; the little crowd had disappeared. Vicky knelt down beside the girl and wrapped her hand around the thin wrist, her fingertips probing for the sign of a pulse. She was unconscious, bruises welling on her face and arm, grip marks on her throat. The noise of a siren swelled in the distance, the only sound apart from the sharp in and out of Lucas’s breathing.

“Is she dead?” Susan’s voice was hushed, barely a whisper.

“No,” Vicky said. She had the pulse now, faint and erratic. She was almost dead, she was thinking. If they hadn’t gotten here, the girl would have been dead.

Lucas turned back to the man, and for a moment Vicky thought he might lift his foot and kick at the prone figure, but Lucas remained still, peering down at him, and she marveled at the restraint in her son, the control over himself, so unlike his father.

A cacophony of sirens filled the air. Vehicles were approaching from both ends of the alley, headlights flashing over fences and garages and power poles. Lights had switched on in the houses behind the fences and dark backyards. She could hear a dog barking, doors slamming. The vehicles ground to a halt: three police cars, an ambulance. Doors opened and slammed shut and a group of officers in dark uniforms moved into a half circle around them.

“What’s going on?” One of the officers tossed out the question. He glanced from Lucas to Vicky, his gaze passing over Susan.

“This girl needs help.” Vicky was still crouching beside the unconscious girl. The shaking had started. She felt it moving through her arms and across her back, down her legs. She wasn’t sure she could stand up, that her legs wouldn’t give way beneath her.

A couple of medics broke through the half circle and went down on their knees beside the girl. Vicky tried to scoot away to give them room, steadying herself with one hand against the ridged wood of the garage door.

“What about him?” The officer stepped over to the man stretched out on the asphalt, still unconscious. Another medic knelt beside him and probed at his neck a moment before his fingers came to a rest. He glanced at his watch.

“He was beating the hell out of her,” Lucas said.

“And you took care of that?”

Vicky pulled herself upright along the door. She found the handle and leaned onto it. “My name is Vicky Holden and I’m an attorney,” she told the officer. “My son, Lucas. My daughter, Susan.” She gave a nod in the direction of each of her children. “We were on our way to Lucas’s house when we passed the alley and saw that man beating up on this girl. We drove into the alley to help her. There were other people here, just watching. They’ve left.”

“Okay.” The officer took in a long breath, then let it out slowly, as if he were letting go of a different scenario he’d been constructing in his mind: alley fight between Indians and whites. It happened in this neighborhood, except that it would have been more usual if the fight were between Mexicans and whites.