The Good Friday Murder (3 page)

I slept right through till six, a first in my adult life, having exhausted myself the night before. I dressed and went out for my morning exercise, too late, apparently, to run into Melanie Gross. I was happy to be alone. When I had made my
offer earlier this morning, I had done so without thinking of the consequences. Where had the Talley murder occurred? Might I have to fly to California or Montana to peruse police records? Although I had a comfortable income, it would not pay for such extravagances.

The phone started ringing before nine, just as I finished cleaning up my breakfast dishes. Happily, the first call was from Mrs. McAlpin.

“Miss Bennett,” she said, her businesslike voice almost emotional, “what a fine thing you've done. When I asked you to speak in our behalf, I never imagined anything quite so generous.”

I didn't want to say it hadn't exactly been generosity. “It seemed the right thing to do and the right time to do it. The people who don't want Greenwillow have practically abandoned all their other objections. If I can bring some persuasive evidence that James Talley didn't kill his mother, I think the council will accept the group and forget all those lesser gripes. But I'm going to need your help to get started.”

“Anything,” she said. “Anything at all. And as soon as you're ready.”

“I can be there in half an hour. I would appreciate it if you would try to find out all you can about where and when the murder took place.”

“I'll do that directly.” She hung up so abruptly that I almost felt slighted.

“Mrs. Talley was probably murdered on April seventh, 1950, in an apartment in Brooklyn, New York.”

I felt a surge of relief as she said this. Midtown Manhattan and Brooklyn were both about twenty miles from my Westchester County suburb and easy to reach by car.

“I must tell you, Miss Bennett, the day it happened was Good Friday.”

My heart did a little blip at that, but I said nothing.

“The body wasn't found until two days later, that is, the ninth, Easter Sunday. The twins had been alone in the apartment with her the whole weekend.”

“Do you know who found the body?”

“I don't, no. But the murder was front-page news, most especially in the tabloids. I'm sure you can find microfilm copies in many libraries, although probably not in Oakwood's. I have other information for you as well. The Talley twins were well-known within the medical community. I believe I told you yesterday that they were savants. While they could scarcely add two and two, they could somehow come up with successive prime numbers of great length. Although you don't recall that period of time yourself, I can tell you that computers were few and far between and much less sophisticated than they are today. Testing prime numbers the Talleys produced sometimes took mathematicians days of work. But they were always correct.

“And they had other gifts, too,” she went on. “They could remember every day of their adult lives, what they ate, what they wore, what the weather was like. Today poor James can't even tell you what he had for lunch.”

“You said he lost those gifts.”

“Sadly, yes. He's been in a high-security facility upstate since the judge remanded him there. The atmosphere, as you can imagine, is as far from Greenwillow as prison is from a private home. We had hopes, when he arrived, of seeing those gifts restored. Unfortunately, in the months he's been here, there hasn't been any noticeable progress.”

“And where is his brother, Robert?” I asked.

“I'm afraid I don't know that. Certainly not in the upstate facility that James was in. It's possible that my contact at New Hope will know. I'll call today.” She made a note on a pad in front of her.

“What about the father, Mrs. McAlpin? There must have been a Mr. Talley.”

“So there must, and that's something else I don't know. Perhaps the newspapers will say.”

I looked at my watch. It was ten o'clock. There was more than half a day during which I could work. I stood and started to say good-bye.

“Miss Bennett,” Mrs. McAlpin said hesitantly, “I don't
know quite how to say this. I don't know what your financial circumstances are, but if you run into difficulty, I'm sure I can find—”

“Thank you, but that won't be necessary. When I left the convent, I received what was left of my dowry, and Aunt Margaret named me as her sole heir. She was far from rich, but she left what seems to me to be a very substantial sum, as well as a house without a mortgage. And I'm quite used to going out with fifty cents in my purse.”

Mrs. McAlpin looked concerned. “That's only two phone calls nowadays. I'd put some folding money in that bag of yours. Just to make me feel happy.”

“I'll do that.” I started for the door and stopped. “Is James Talley Catholic?” I asked.

“Let me see. Yes, I believe he is. He's taken to mass every weekend.”

“Thank you. I'll keep in touch.”

By ten-thirty I was driving south to New York. My first stop would be the public library on Fifth Avenue at Forty-second Street. I had no idea where I would park, but I assumed something would turn up. I had fifty dollars in my wallet, more cash than I had ever had on my person in my life.

Mrs. McAlpin's concern about my finances had been a good and generous one, but in my case, misplaced. When I had entered St. Stephen's that terrible, rainy night fifteen years ago, I brought with me my inheritance of twenty thousand dollars, more money than I had ever heard of, but not
much as inheritances go. A few months later, a check for my mother's life insurance of ten thousand dollars was forwarded to me and added to the dowry. Some of that money had been used to buy the first year's toiletries that a novice must supply herself—soap, toothpaste, hand lotion, and other personal necessities. Later, when I was given permission to own a car, the dowry had paid for it and had subsequently paid for gas, oil, and periodic maintenance.

But the car was used little aside from the monthly trip to Oakwood, and bank interest covered the car's expenses. There was still a sizable chunk on deposit when I left the convent.

In September I would start to teach at a local community college. The letter from the chairman of the English Department still brought smiles when I reread it:

“As part of our continuing effort to offer a wide range of courses by a staff of diverse backgrounds, I am pleased to offer you the position of associate to teach Poetry and file Contemporary American Woman.”

The idea of teaching poetry had filled me with sheer delight, but if Professor Caldwell thought that fifteen years in a convent teaching English to nuns and secular women in a Catholic college qualified me as a contemporary woman, I had to wonder at his judgment. But I was so thrilled at the offer that I had telephoned my acceptance and followed it with a letter that I had personally mailed at the post office the following morning.

The pay was probably low for college teaching, but for me, it was bountiful. It would more than pay for a winter wardrobe and probably take care of my utility bills as well. I was ecstatic.

The cost of parking my car left me dumbfounded. Mrs. McAlpin had been right to warn me. Lunch took another unexpectedly high toll. In future, I would take a sandwich with me on my travels. My former vow of poverty would stand me in good stead for my summer's work.

But the microfilm of the newspapers gave me so much
information that I quickly forgot about the expense of acquiring it.
EASTER MASSACRE
! the Monday front-page headline of one tabloid shrieked at me. “Retards Slash Mother,” the subheadline at the bottom of the page continued. I moved the screen to the next page.

BLOODY APARTMENT YIELDS GRISLY SECRET
, the inside headline read.

Retarded twins James and Robert Talley, 29, apparently slashed their mother to death in the kitchen of their Brooklyn apartment over the Easter Weekend, leaving bloody fingerprints in every room. Horrified police, acting on a phone call, entered the apartment before noon yesterday to find the body of Mrs. Alberta Talley, 61, on the floor of her kitchen, her throat slashed and multiple stab wounds throughout her body. “Only a madman could have done this,” police Detective Kevin O'Connor said as the body was being removed from the apartment. The murder weapon was believed to be a serrated bread knife about ten inches long which was found near the body. The twins, whose hands and clothes were stained with blood, were nearby.

I began taking notes in the steno book I had taken with me, but soon abandoned the task. I was able to make hard copies of the microfilm by positioning the screen to the section of the page I wished to copy and depositing quarters. A reader in the reference room and a helpful librarian added to my supply of coins, but the librarian admonished me to bring plenty of quarters with me next time. I agreed to do so.

I read days of articles in the first newspaper, then moved on to other papers to see if any one of them might have a different slant or some new nugget of information. I was surprised at the number of papers available in New York in 1950. The
Herald Tribune
was still alive, as were others I had never heard of: the
World Telegram and Sun,
the
Journal American,
and the
Daily Mirror.
It became a task of diminishing returns, but by the time I felt that I was finished, I had
accumulated a collection of names, dates, times, and suspicions. When finally I looked at my watch and saw that it was nearly five o'clock and felt an incipient headache from staring for so many hours at the screen, I gathered my papers and notes, returned the last film, and went to ransom my car.

At home, I ate quickly and sat down in the dining room, which I had never used and could be conveniently converted to a makeshift workroom. I took a package of typing paper, the photocopies of the newspapers, my steno notebook, and some pencils and pens. On the first page of the notebook, I had printed a favorite line from Keats: “Heard melodies are sweet, but those unheard are sweeter.” As always when I read it, I felt the poet speaking directly to me. I smiled and began my work.

On a page of typing paper, I started a chronology of events, beginning with the morning of Friday, April 7, 1950.

At a little before nine, as she always did on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, young Magda Wandowska, an immigrant from a Baltic country (variously described by the papers as Estonia, Latvia, and Poland), arrived at the apartment of Alberta, James, and Robert Talley. She would spend three hours cleaning the apartment, allowing Mrs. Talley the freedom to leave, to shop, occasionally, it appeared, to have her hair done (as she did that morning), without having to worry about the welfare of her sons. “They were good boys,” Magda was quoted as saying in two of the papers, a somewhat amusing comment because the “boys” were eleven years older than she.

It was an ordinary morning. She cleaned up the kitchen and chatted with the boys. Mrs. Talley put her hat on and left a little after nine. She had a nine-thirty appointment at the beauty parlor—in honor of Easter, Magda explained—and then she would shop for food and return home.

During her three hours, Magda took the boys for a walk along Ocean Avenue, where their apartment house was. (One paper mentioned that Mrs. Talley paid $74.50 for the two-bedroom apartment, and I was not sure whether that was a
great deal or practically nothing, but the reporter seemed surprised at the amount.) The three of them walked to Quentin Road, over to East Seventeenth Street, and up to a park that was a favorite spot of theirs. There they sat and talked and played the kinds of games the boys liked to play, word and number games that gave Magda the feeling that, although they were not normal in the sense that they could function in society (she didn't use those words), they had been selected by God for greater gifts. On that day Magda asked them about the day she had been born eighteen years earlier (in one of those Baltic countries), and they had told her the weather—in Brooklyn—what they had eaten for lunch, and the color of Mama's dress (purple). Even though she had been born some five thousand miles away, it had given her a closeness to the boys, knowing they remembered the day.

About eleven-thirty they had started back, this time going along Avenue S to Ocean Avenue, a slightly longer walk, but they were in no hurry. Mrs. Talley had arrived promptly at noon with her bags of groceries and her freshly coiffed hair and had paid Magda for the week, nine dollars for the nine hours (a generous sum for the time), and thirty cents for carfare. Magda had promised to return on Easter Sunday to help Mrs. Talley take the boys to church—not that she needed help, the boys were so good, but it didn't hurt to have an extra person along. Generally when they went to church, Mrs. Talley would sit at one end and Magda at the other so that the boys were enclosed between them. Magda never accepted payment for attending church with the Talleys, which was only about once a month; it was her gift to God. But Mrs. Talley always gave her ten cents for carfare and often placed a dollar in the collection basket, a princely sum for the time.

When she left the Talleys, she went to church for Good Friday services. The Talleys would not go. Services were long, and the boys sometimes became restless.

Magda spent the evening quietly with her parents and sister. On Saturday she had a special job cleaning a house for a lady who was having a large group over for Easter Sunday.
She was paid well, but she worked hard and she came home tired.

Easter Sunday morning, she dressed and took the bus to Ocean Avenue and Kings Highway.

Magda had the key to the Talley apartment. It had not started that way. At the beginning, when she was still in high school and came to work a few afternoons after school, Mrs. Talley would give her the key so that she could go walking with the boys. But Mrs. Talley sometimes forgot, preventing their outing. Finally, when a great deal of trust had grown between them, Mrs. Talley had given Magda her own key, and that was how she got in that terrible Easter morning.

She had rung several times and could hear footsteps inside, but no one answered the door. Perhaps, she thought as she stood waiting, Mrs. Talley was in the bathroom, readying herself for church. The boys had been told never to answer the doorbell, much as one would caution a child, and Magda knew they would be obedient. And since it didn't really matter whether Mrs. Talley opened the door or whether she let herself in, she took the key out of her bag and used it to enter the apartment.

She could see that something was wrong the minute she got in. The twins were there, disheveled, dirty—she didn't realize it was blood until later—and when they saw her, they began to cry.

“Mama, Mama,” one of them said.

“What happened?” Magda said, frightened. “And then I thought,” one of the newspapers quoted her, “ ‘Mother of God, Mrs. Talley has had an accident.' I ran to the bathroom, thinking she had fallen.”

But Mrs. Talley was not in the bathroom. There was blood in the bathroom, in the sink and on the tile floor and on the towels. More frightened than ever, Magda ran to Mrs. Talley's bedroom. It was neat, the bed made as it always was—“She was such a clean person,” Magda told the police—but Mrs. Talley was not there. She ran into the boys' room, which was in disarray, the beds not made, blood on the sheets. But no Mrs. Talley.

Magda then ran through the living room into the kitchen and stopped herself at the door. There it was. “It” was the ravaged body of Alberta Talley, lying on the kitchen floor, covered with blood, blood congealed on the floor about it, blood on the cabinets, blood splashed on the window and the pretty white curtains.

“I crossed myself,” Magda said.

It must have been horrible. Reading the accounts, I wondered that so young a girl had comported herself so bravely. First she took Robert by the arm and walked him to Mrs. Talley's bedroom. She told him to stay there and closed the door. (She explained that Mrs. Talley sometimes locked one of the twins in her bedroom when she was too busy to look after both of them. Magda didn't have the key to the bedroom, but, she said, she thought Robert would believe he was locked in and would stay there. He did.)

She then called the police. They came very quickly, she said, and they were very kind.

I put all this into my chronology and then looked further for reports of the autopsy and the questioning of possible suspects. The autopsy reports were in the Wednesday papers, having been made public on Tuesday. Mrs. Talley had died of multiple stab wounds covering almost all her body. Some of them were fairly superficial—as if the killer didn't mean it, one newspaper said—but the slash across the throat was probably the mortal blow.

Fingerprints from James and Robert Talley were found everywhere—on the bread knife that had killed their mother, in the blood that had congealed on and around her body, and throughout the apartment. Both twins had handled the knife; in fact, they had held the blade as well, leaving me to believe that they had picked it up out of curiosity or horror but not as a weapon. The police removed the twins from the apartment in handcuffs. There were photos of them being led away. I could not tell one from the other in the pictures, but I could see the resemblance between the twenty-nine-year-old twins and the old man at Greenwillow.

I suppose the police questioned them for hours, perhaps
overnight. The year 1950 was long before the famous Miranda case and the subsequent Miranda warnings that everyone nowadays takes for granted. Heaven only knows how they abused those two poor young men, but apparently to no avail. Neither twin admitted anything. In fact, they were quite silent, asking frequently for “Mama” and for each other.

The tabloids kept the story alive in that grotesque manner that is not common nowadays,
I KNEW THEY WERE KILLERS
, one headline screamed on Wednesday, quoting a neighbor who lived in another building on Ocean Avenue and who sometimes saw the twins walking with Mrs. Talley or Magda. There was little behind the headline, and I felt disgusted both by the sentiment and by its publication. I am not always a lover of the good old days.

Separate from my chronology, I made a list of all the people mentioned whom I thought it would be useful to interview. There was Magda, of course, if I could find her. There was Sergeant Kevin O'Connor, who had told one newspaper that only a madman could have done such a killing. I hoped he had been young in 1950 so that he might still be on the force or perhaps retired somewhere in the area. There were people living in nearby apartments who were mentioned by name. I knew that New York's rent-control laws made it disadvantageous to move, and I thought there might just be a slim chance that someone who remembered that Easter Sunday might still live in the same building. And I wondered very much about the missing Mr. Talley.