The Intimate Lives of the Founding Fathers
Read The Intimate Lives of the Founding Fathers Online
Authors: Thomas Fleming
Thomas Fleming
Katherine Dolan Fleming
Alice Mulcahey Fleming
Alice Fleming
Susan Riley
Sharon Kivisto Fleming
Kathryn Feder
Helen Fleming
Lucie Fleming
Pauline Fleming
Madeleine Fleming
The heart has its reasons,
of which the mind knows nothing.
—
BLAISE PASCAL
George Washington
Benjamin Franklin
John Adams
Alexander Hamilton
Thomas Jeffferson
James Madison
Appendix:
The Erosion of Jefferson’s Image in the American Mind
A
book of this dimension leaves the writer indebted to a wide range of people. I want to express my gratitude, first, to the numerous librarians who have assisted me, beginning with my early work on the American Revolution at Yale University. More recently, Lewis Daniels, the librarian at the Westbrook Public Library in the Connecticut town of the same name (where I spend my summers), has been especially helpful in tracking down books in the state’s research libraries for me. Equal gratitude goes to Mark Bartlett and his staff at the New York Society Library. Another thank you in this regard is warmly extended to W. Gregory Gallagher of the Century Association library—and to the librarians of the New York Historical Society.
Special thanks must go to Mary Thompson, the research historian at Mount Vernon, who gave me several hours of her time during a visit. Also helpful was Washington scholar Peter Henriques, who generously shared with me some of his research. Several geneticists advised me on exploring the world of chromosomes and haplotypes, notably Kenneth Kidd, MD, of Yale University; Brian Ference, MD, formerly of Yale, now in private practice in Michigan; and Dr. Edwin Knights, who has written widely on the subject and practices in New Hampshire. Also helpful have been science writer Steven Corneliussen and his associates, biostatisticians William Blackwelder and David Douglas, who helped me probe the arcane world of probability.
Steven Bernstein, who is writing a history book of his own, found time to explore several collections in the Library of Congress and other libraries in Washington, DC. He also played a part in tracking down hitherto unknown facts about Samuel F. Wetmore, ghostwriter extraordinary. My son, Richard Fleming, with his computer skills and his access to the Columbia University Library, gave me significant aid on a variety of topics, ranging from Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin to Joseph Pulitzer. Another son, attorney Thomas J. Fleming, took time from his busy practice to advise me on the logic, legal and otherwise, of certain arguments in the text. Most helpful of all, with her mastery of computer research as well as her editorial experience, was the most important woman in my life, Alice Mulcahey Fleming. Also invaluable was the advice and counsel of my editor, Elisabeth Kallick Dyssegaard, as the manuscript evolved over the past two years.
—T
HOMAS
F
LEMING
W
ith leaks and wandering emails, talk shows and tell-all aides, the private lives of today’s politicians seem to have become public property. Whether this may eventually unravel the republic is frequently debated in the media. Not a few columnists and late-night gurus maintain that the best and brightest are now loath to enter politics.
Still, the number of politicians has not noticeably declined. Nor are we the first generation to take a more than passing interest in the personal lives of our elected leaders. Convinced that historical perspective might be the best answer to the Götterdämmerung tone that the discussion sometimes takes, I decided to explore the roles of women in the lives of the first group of American politicians to win fame—George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, Alexander Hamilton, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison. Collectively, most historians agree, these are the founding fathers, the men who made the greatest contribution to the birth of the nation.
I was soon watching a young George Washington riven with desire for the wife of his close friend. I stood with Thomas Jefferson at the bedside of his dying wife, Martha Wayles, as he sobbed a fateful promise that he would never marry again. I saw a youthful Alexander Hamilton imbibe a toxic mix of fear and anger in his psyche when his headstrong mother banished his hapless father from her bed.
As one Jefferson biographer has remarked, every man carries on a lifelong dialogue with his mother, sometimes in his conscious mind, more
often in his unconscious. Mothers have an especially strong influence in the shadowy realm of emotions. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson seem to have inherited their mothers’ temperaments. Some historians think John Adams’s mother, Susanna Boylston Adams, was a manic depressive, who passed on the illness to her favorite son.
Although the women in these famous lives spoke 150 years before feminism entered the American vocabulary, their independent voices will surprise many people. The men and women of 1776 were far more candid and realistic about sexual desire and marital relationships than Americans of the twenty-first century realize. They gave serious thought to the ancient conflict between the sexes and talked and wrote about it in ways that still have relevance today.
This was evident from the novels they read and the stories that were printed in the newspapers. Samuel Richardson’s
Pamela
was the most popular novel of the era. This story of a servant girl’s rise to wealth and power proved that virtue was rewarded and simultaneously delivered titillating descriptions of a young woman agonizing over sexual desire. When fifteen-year-old Betsy Hanford of Virginia married wealthy fifty-one-year-old John Cam, the local newspaper reported, “She is to have a chariot and there is to be no padlock put upon her mind.”
The women of 1776 had high expectations from marriage. They wanted not only affection but respect as persons. For a lucky few, these essentials could blend into near adoration. One Virginian began his letters to his wife, with “My dearest life” and declared that she “blessed the earth” with her presence. At the same time, essays and letters about unhappy marriages frequently appeared in the newspapers. One correspondent in the
Virginia Gazette
blamed these misfortunes on women who spent too much of a man’s money on luxury, and on men who for the sake of beauty or wealth married “a fury” or an “ideot [
sic
].”
We will see how strongly the founders, especially those primary political rivals Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, stressed the importance of a happy marriage in a man’s life. Thanks to his five years in France as America’s ambassador, Jefferson was able to compare American and European marriage customs and found America’s far superior. Fidelity was virtually unknown among the French upper classes. Jefferson advised young Americans to abandon dreams of a grand tour, lest they acquire the Old World’s attitude toward women.
Recent decades of scholarship in herstory have made us aware of a dark side of women’s lives in the eighteenth century. Other than from private tutors, they had almost no educational opportunities. Divorce was seldom granted by the courts, and a woman’s property was legally controlled by her husband. On the eve of America’s independence, we will see protofeminist Abigail Adams protesting these inequalities in a famous letter to her husband, John—and his less well-known, extremely unsatisfying reply.
A woman also had little control over her reproductive life. Pregnancy and childbirth were dangerous. Equally troubling was the awful infant mortality rate. The primitive medicine of the era made childhood almost as perilous. By late middle age, Martha Washington had lost all four of her children to death. Martha Wayles Jefferson lost four out of six children in ten years. Benjamin Franklin’s marriage was poisoned by his wife’s bitterness over the death of their four-year-old son, Frankie, while his hated illegitimate half-brother, William, thrived.
As Franklin’s story makes clear, the founders’ marriages were not without controversy. Did George Washington recklessly pursue other women after he married Martha, as the British and later his American political enemies claimed? Is there convincing proof that Thomas Jefferson had a long-term sexual relationship with his mulatto slave, Sally Hemings? Why did the curvaceous well-off widow, Dolley Payne Todd, marry pintsized, sickly James Madison? As first lady, Dolley had to deal with vicious rumors about her sex life. She met them with a shrewdness that wives of contemporary politicians might well emulate.
All the women in the founders’ lives had to confront and cope with fame. This little-understood phenomenon transformed many aspects of their private lives into public dramas. The fame that the founders sought and won was not the same as our modern version of it, mere celebrity. For them, fame was an enormously serious matter, involving a man’s place in history. It was reserved for founders or rescuers of nations or givers of laws and required the approval of men of judgment and intelligence.
All the founders were aware that the Revolutionary upheaval and the task of creating a nation gave them unique opportunities to win this ultimate accolade. “You and I,” John Adams wrote to a Virginia friend in 1777, “have been sent into life at a time when the greatest lawgivers of antiquity would have wished to live.” In 1778, Alexander Hamilton wrote a pamphlet attacking certain congressmen who were using their positions
to get rich. Hamilton could not understand how a man could succumb to such a “mean pursuit” when he had a chance to be THE FOUNDER OF AN EMPIRE [Hamilton’s capitals]. “A man of virtue and ability, dignified with so precious a trust, would rejoice that fortune had given him birth at [such] a time.”
Washington, debating whether to risk his fame by endorsing the dubious idea of a constitutional convention in 1787, told a friend, “To see this country happy is so much the wish of my soul, nothing on this side of Elysium can be placed in competition with it.”
For some women this kind of fame could be a stimulant. But it could also be a beast in the jungle, almost an evil spirit. This was especially true of Abigail Adams, who had to endure years of agonizing loneliness while her husband pursued diplomatic fame in Europe. Even worse was Elizabeth Hamilton’s ordeal when her husband defended his fame as the creator of the new nation’s financial system by making a public confession of his infidelity with a Philadelphia temptress.
When we explore the wives’ influence on these famous lives, we discover evidence so strong, it can easily be asserted in some cases—that of John Adams, for instance—that the great man would never have earned his place on fame’s ladder without the woman at his side. The same conclusion is even more true for James Madison. While Martha Washington destroyed all but a handful of the personal letters she exchanged with George, there is evidence that she was by no means a mere fellow-traveler on Washington’s journey to fame.
Knowing and understanding the women in their lives adds pathos and depth to the public dimensions of the founding fathers’ political journeys. We do them no dishonor when we explore how often public greatness emerged in spite of personal pain and secret disappointment. Far from diminishing these men and women, an examination of their intimate lives will enlarge them for our time. In their loves and losses, their hopes and fears, they are more like us than we have dared to imagine.
