Authors: Nigel Green
We laughed. Soon the time for me to make a final circuit of the camp before nightfall was upon us.
âWe'll talk again,' I promised Henry, âand, since we are kinsmen, I will ransom you and you can go home again.'
But such an interlude was a rare moment of relief from my worry. Over the next few weeks we found no trace of supplies moving to Berwick. Obviously the Scots were gambling on supplying their garrison there with one large convoy escorted by all their reinforcements.
Two days later our scouts spotted it.
âMother of Christ,' Middleton muttered again. âWill you look at that?'
I ignored him. I gestured for him to be silent and concentrated on the enormous column below us.
I had to give the Scots credit. The long chain of wagons moved steadily along the track with the sea behind them and a protective screen of horsemen flanking the carts. Groups of men-at-arms marched alongside the wagons and a strong force of archers brought up the rear.
âThey've got outriders and scouts ahead,' Middleton pointed to distant figures on horseback. âThere will be no way of surprising them.'
I continued to count.
âMind you, it's not as if we could attack them,' he continued. âThere are thousands of them.'
The Scottish column was pushing hard. Wagons with broken wheels or axles were manhandled to one side and abandoned. Lamed horses were led away and replaced immediately. The loud and consistent cracking of whips indicated the pressure that the Scots were putting on their beasts to maintain the column's momentum. From our vantage point on the hilltop, we watched as the enormous column snaked below us generating clouds of dust. As far as I could see there were no Scottish cavalry shadowing the chain of wagons.
As the Scots passed our position and continued their march to Berwick, I rose from my prone position. Middleton leapt up and Captain Fennell groaned as he rubbed his cramped arm. I looked at each of them in turn.
â200 wagons or so. Several smaller carts. Sufficient replacement draught animalsâ¦' I began.
âProbably about 700-800 men-at-arms.' This was the estimation of our farsighted captain of archers. âMaybe another 100 or so archers.'
âThey could have more in the wagons. How many horse?' I asked Middleton.
By splitting out the counting we would arrive at a more accurate appraisal of the enemy's strength.
âIncluding scouts and outriders, I would say 400.'
So the Scots numbered around 1300 men. We had 600. They were prepared to defend themselves and the only area in which we held a slight advantage was that we had more horsemen. But the Scots could be reinforced, and we had not got the element of surprise on our side. To attack such a force would be to commit our small force to oblivion.
âWe'll return to camp,' I said heavily.
I found no surprise in the faces of either Fennell or Middleton.
We led the horses as we would need them fresh for the return to Berwick, but as I trudged along my feelings of disquiet began to grow.
On the face of it, the decision not to attack the Scots was sensible. They vastly outnumbered us and could be reinforced. To withdraw kept my small force intact. But then I stopped abruptly âintact for what? As soon as the Berwick garrison was reinforced and re-supplied, there was no way that the town could be taken. Slowly, I led the horse forward as I faced up to the sobering truth â if Berwick could not be taken, the English invasion could not take place, and Richard of Gloucester would be humiliated.
I raised my hand to halt the column. Anne Neville and her husband were relying on me. Somehow I had to defeat the Scots and wipe out their entire convoy. None of it could be allowed to get through to Berwick. I needed time to think of a plan, so I called a halt to allow the horses to be watered. Then I summoned Middleton.
âWill you take a number of your men and check that there are no other Scottish forces within the vicinity?'
He looked up surprised.
âEven if there are, they'll hardly attack us while we're mounted and moving away from the Scottish convoy. Is it really necessary?'
He saw my glare.
âWe'll be back in two hours.'
After Middleton's scouts had ridden out, I wandered away from the stream to think. I squatted down and drew endless diagrams in the dusty earth, discarding them one after the other until I came to see how the business could be managed.
A hand touched my shoulder.
âThere's no indication of any reinforcements in the immediate vicinity,' Middleton smiled down at me. âShall we resume the return to camp?'
I stood up slowly. We would have to attack the Scottish column before it could be reinforced.
âCaptain Fennell!' I shouted.
He raised his arm in acknowledgement and ambled over. I looked at the pair of them.
âWe are not going to retreat. We will attack the Scottish column and destroy it.'
Middleton gaped at me.
âBut that's madness!'
âCaptain Fennell, take your men to the end of the moor. Cross the river past that abbey, and keep your men in concealment until I come to you.'
âYou're going to attack the Scots without archers?' he stuttered. âCorrect. I want you to be a surprise for the second phase of the battle. Now Dick, get your men ready.'
They hesitated.
âThat's an order!' I barked. âNow move, both of you.'
Ahead of us the rising dust denoted the steady progress of the Scottish column. Presently, they would spot Middleton's approach. He had been helpful, I reflected. Once he had got over his initial shock, he had been quick to make improvements to the plan. It had been his idea to make his force's appearance as obvious to the Scots as possible.
âYou want the Scots to see us coming a long way off. That gives them more time to move their cavalry and bowmen against my horsemen. But you'll have to work hard to ensure that your own angle of approach is concealed. Use every scrap of cover you can find.'
âThey might be expecting a diversionary attack,' I agreed. In fact, they would probably have more men-at-arms at the end of the column to compensate for having moved their archers up to the head of the column to protect the Scottish cavalry. All right then, we'll try and stay concealed so that they think you're their only threat.'
Hopefully, Middleton's approach across the open moor would have been spotted by now and we could bring our men out of the old riverbed. I estimated that the rear of the Scots forces was not more than a mile away, but the further the Scots moved away, the greater the chances of our being detected as we moved up on it. Next to me, Sergeant Haxx glanced up at the sun.
âMaster Middleton should be in position now, sir.'
To attack prematurely would be a disaster, but all the time the Scottish column was moving away from us. We would be best to move in a moment.
âYou remember the order of battle?'
His eyes were steady on mine.
âWe attack their rear, sir. You takes the right. I takes their left. If that doesn't work we makes a further attack to provoke that Scottish cavalry to come at us.'
âVery good. Now the Horse Dance.'
âTo be done when you orders it, sir.'
There was no expression in his eyes.
âYou've got volunteers?'
âWith the bonus you've offered them, I've got volunteers, my lord.'
âThey know the risk they're taking? Not many will survive.'
âThose bastards will do anything for money, my lord.'
âThen get the men mounted.'
And then it was back to a familiar routine. We eased into a trot, which turned into a canter, as we met the dust billowing from the Scottish column. We were galloping as we reached the end of the Scottish wagons and crashed into the men-at-arms guarding them.
T
he surge was devastating. Razor sharp lances tore into the flanks of their bellowing oxen and frenzied draught horses. There was no time to cut the beasts free and allow them to escape. There were simply too many animals.
In front of me, a driver leapt from his high seat to flee. Instinctively my horse swerved to the left as I drove my spear through the man's chest. I glanced around quickly; panic was spreading fast as men desperately sought to avoid the tide of death and destruction that was engulfing them.
Maddened by the smell of blood, the horses pulling the wagons tried to flee. Their ears pulled back and, flanks heaving, they strained at the traces which bound them. Many wagons were without drivers and guidance now â they careered into one another. I saw two carts overturned and heard the frantic neighing of trapped horses.
Around me, our men chased the few men-at-arms that showed themselves. Some tried to fight, but a sword is poor protection against men on horses armed with long lances. As they fled, they found themselves colliding with each other or caught between wildly moving wagons. I saw a man-at-arms knocked down by a maddened draught horse and another was trampled by stampeding oxen.
Frantically, I urged our men forward. We had to force the Scottish horse to turn on us; this was the whole essence of the plan. My divisionary attack force was the bait. Once the Scots were tempted to turn on us, then Middleton could attack them without fearing the Scottish archers. Our spears tore into the backs of screaming men-at-arms as they sought to evade us. Panic was spreading up the column now, but where was the Scottish horse?
The plucky Scots fought back though. They must have had archers concealed in their wagons for I could hear the whirring of arrows. Protected by overturned carts, their bowmen began to find their targets.
I guessed that in a moment we would lose the impetus of our attack. The horses were beginning to tire and we could not afford too many casualties. It was time to attack further up the column. I had the trumpet blown three times and as the men reformed I led them through the shattered convoy to Haxx's force.
âCasualties?'
âAbout a quarter, my lord. And you?'
âThe same. We'll try again further up.'