The Perfect Mix (Keller Weddings Book 1) (3 page)

But the only reason Anna knew when Eli was coming back was because she’d seen his email this morning after sending a response to her old college roommate. Celeste had emailed her yesterday with the same thing she’d been asked all day.
How are you doing?

Anna actually vented to Celeste, however. It seemed safer over email. Less chance of her breaking down.

“Next week,” Beckett said. “That’s when Eli said he’d be here.”

He stretched his long legs beneath the table, and one corner of his lip quirked when he caught her looking at him. He was the only one without a notebook–probably the only one Jillian would even let in here without some way of taking notes.

“What are you thinking for samples?” Jillian asked her.

Anna snapped her attention to her sister. “Uh…red velvet and probably something with a raspberry filling. Opposites.”

Jillian made a note. “Good. And a cake alternative–”

“For the unconventional customer,” Anna said, nodding and catching Poppy’s grin. “Yeah, I got it. I’ll start prepping this afternoon. Leah is going to come in to help.”

“Oh. No.” Jillian shook her head.

“What?” Leah always came in to prep for their open houses. She knew the routine and they got things done. In fact, she was beginning to think it made sense for Leah to take on more of the baking, learn the ropes. Just in case.

“She called this morning. Something came up,” Jillian said. She tapped on her tablet as though searching for a solution. “I’m sure there’s someone else who can help.”

Anna looked at her mom, reading the confusion there. And then the amusement. What was going on?

“I can help,” Beckett said.

Anna opened her mouth, but nothing came out. Seriously?

“That’ll work,” Jillian said, eyes lighting. “Are you sure you can spare the afternoon?”

“No problem.”

Anna didn’t miss Poppy’s snicker or the way Summer seemed overly fascinated with her own notebook.

“But…” Anna stared at Beckett. “Do you even know how to bake? I mean, I’m pretty sure I saw you burn pancakes once.”

Poppy laughed into her hand. “Sorry,” she said when everyone looked at her. “But it’s true.”

“See?” Anna asked. “No offense, Beckett, but are you sure you really want to help? I think‒”

“You can teach me.”

“What?”

“Show me what you need me to do.” Those dimples flashed again, dumping a load of confusion on her. “I’m a fast learner.”

Anna slid her gaze to Jillian and tried to read something there. Anything that would give her a clue what was going on.

And then it hit her. They felt sorry for her. They were looking out for her and making sure she was handling things okay by sending Beckett to help her.

She started to protest again, but Jillian nodded and stood. “Great. That’s settled. We have another meeting with a newly engaged couple in ten minutes, so everyone needs to clear out.”

Beckett turned to her and extended a hand to help her up. “Ready?”

Anna stared into his hazel eyes, reading nothing but genuine helpfulness there. But she knew he was in on it, and she wasn’t going to let them get away with it.

She’d show them all just how capable she was of handling herself and her problems. And if that meant playing along a little to make her point, she planned to do just that.

Putting her hand in Beckett’s, she held back a smile. “You want to learn how to bake? Then I’m going to teach you.”

Anna went easy on Beckett the first day. She let him crack eggs and stir batter and wash dishes. But when Leah continued to need time off and Anna was left without an assistant, she was through playing nice. Instead of confronting her sister and Beckett, however, she decided to teach him a lesson.

Anna was waiting for him at the back door of the bakery when he arrived that afternoon. Her stomach wobbled a little when he flashed his dimpled smile at her, but she stood firm. Beckett was in on this just like the rest of her family, that’s all. She had to stick to her plan.

He carried two Styrofoam boxes to the door with him. “Hey.”

“I’m so glad you’re here.” She inserted a little breathiness into her tone for effect.

He set the boxes on the counter. “Everything okay?”

“Yes,” she said, unfolding an apron. “But we have a lot of work to do and we need extra cookies for additional guests.”

“But I brought lunch.” He eyed the apron with uncertainty.

“No time for that. Here, put this on and wash your hands.”

He took the apron, holding it gingerly between two fingertips. It was red, a perfectly reasonable color. But it had polka dots. And a ruffle at the bottom.

She bit her lip to keep from smiling. “Problem?”

“No…”

Anna reached for the apron. “Forget it. I know you have a lot to do. I’m sure Summer can help me. Or Poppy–”

“No.” He held tight to the apron. “I’m up for it. I can do whatever you need me to do.”

Her lips curved. She gave the apron a little tug. “You sure?”

Laughter lit his eyes. “Bring it on.”

She released the apron, and to her surprise, he put it right on and turned to the sink to wash his hands. She watched the way his shoulders moved, the play of muscles pulling tight against the too-small apron as he hunched over at the sink.

Her throat dried. She swallowed hard to moisten it. No getting off track. And definitely, definitely
no
thinking about Beckett’s muscles. Ones he’d gotten from working hard at the barn. From growing up being part of the outdoors. From running around with her and her family.

The complete opposite of Tom.

She tried to scrub those thoughts from her mind, and squared her shoulders to prove she was perfectly composed. He grabbed a towel and straightened again, standing at his full height.

Beckett was all man. And he was helping her bake. She gave a choked laugh at the flutter in her chest. Damn, this was a problem. She wasn’t supposed to be thinking about men at all, let alone an old family friend.

Besides, he could have any woman he wanted. Sure he spent most of his time at home or with her family, but maybe he was shy. Maybe he just needed a little push.

He’d make any woman happy.

“Now you’re staring,” Beckett said, setting the towel aside.

Anna’s eyes snapped to his. “What? No. Just thinking. Ready to start?”

“Yes.”

“Good.” She flipped on some music and pointed to the counter. “Let’s do this.”

{}{}{}

Beckett was pretty sure his plan wasn’t working. As funny as it had been to see Anna’s face when Jillian agreed to let him help prepare for the open house, she’d seemed suspicious. Not only that, she’d spent the last few days teaching him words like fondant and piping, and stuck to business as she instructed him on how to bake cookies and layers and stir the filling. Totally out of his comfort zone. He’d gone home each evening covered in flour and sticky dough and no closer to telling Anna how he felt.

Now he was starting to get the feeling Anna was enjoying bossing him around.

“We’re going to practice decorating these cookies so you can help me finish the rest tomorrow morning. And then we’ll move onto the cakes,” she said.

He nodded easily. “Sure. Just tell me what you need me to do.”

Eventually she’d get sick of him screwing things up, but he’d give it a decent try first just to keep up the ruse.

Anna pulled over a tray of cookies, her delicate fingers moving deftly as she transferred several to the surface they were working on. “I baked these this morning and they’re already cool and ready for us to work with.”

With her hair tucked into her bandana, the long line of her neck was exposed, and he imagined brushing his fingers over the flawless skin. He imagined leaning in, breathing in deep the scent of her. Sugar and spice. And then he’d set his lips on hers and–

“Beckett.”

He jerked his eyes from her neck. “Huh? Yeah?”

“Are you focusing?”

“Yes.”

Her lips twitched. “What did I just say?”

“Uh…” He squirmed in the tiny apron, resisting the urge to take it off. He had to play along for this to work. “Roll out the fondant stuff and something about embossing something.”

She laughed, the throaty sound of it hitting him right in the gut.

“Close enough,” she said. “Here, you try.”

She passed him a rolling pin and pointed to the off-white doughy blob on the surface of the table. It looked like a lump of clay.

“Just roll it?” he asked, distracted by how close she stood to him.

“Yes. But not too thin.”

How did he know how thin too thin was? He pressed the rolling pin to the fondant and rolled it lightly on the surface.

“A little more pressure. It’s going to have to be thinner than that.”

She set her hands on his, pushing them down so the rolling pin pressed into the fondant. Her skin was like silk, soft and smooth, and covered in flour. Had she ever touched him like that before? No way. He would have remembered.

“Good. Right. A little more pressure,” she said.

It didn’t help that she smelled so good. Or that her arm kept brushing his. How was he supposed to focus?

She let go and he stopped rolling.

“How’s that?” he asked.

She angled her head at him.

“What?”

Those eyes said a lot. Held questions and answers and so much more he wanted to hear. Conversations he had with her every once in a while and wanted more of. He opened his mouth to ask her to dinner, but she moved away.

“You did good,” she said. “Now we need to emboss the fondant.”

She handed him another tool that looked like a clear rolling pin–or a thick magic wand. It was smaller than the rolling pin he’d used to flatten the fondant, and this one was decorated with a design all around it.

Then she brandished a cookie cutter and made small a circle in the large piece of fondant. She set the smaller piece in front of him. “Roll it gently over the top, enough to transfer the design.”

It was such a delicate process; he was afraid he was going to smash the whole piece. Too much pressure, not enough pressure. But Anna was a natural.

It had to be hard on her, preparing for weddings day in and day out after missing her own.

“Good,” Anna said, leaning in to see his progress. She glanced up and in that moment, all he could see were her brown eyes and happiness.

And he wondered how Tom could have treated her the way he had.

“Perfect.” She held up the piece of fondant gently. “See? Just right.”

Right there it clicked. He needed to make this work with Anna. And he just needed
her
, plain and simple.

“You place it on the cookie, right in the center.” She demonstrated, making the whole process look simple when he probably would have fumbled it. “And now we decorate.”

“No, that’s not–” He stepped back and held up his hands. “I think you should do that part.”

“Come on, Beckett, I need your help. We’re going to have to do a few dozen of these tomorrow.”

“A few dozen?”

Her lips curved. “I take that back. Probably several dozen. Including the cakes. And we have to set up beforehand, too.”

His brain immediately scrambled with excuses. Okay, so it
had
been a good idea to offer to help Anna, but he hadn’t known it would involve so much work.

“You look scared, Beckett.”

He laughed, though it didn’t come out as smooth as he intended. “Not at all. I like work. The more the better.”

“Mmm hmm.” She smiled. “And how about the apron? Do you like that?”

“Uh…” Damn. What was he supposed to say? No, he didn’t like it. It wasn’t manly. It was for a girl. But he wasn’t going to tell her that. “It’s…a nice color.”

“How about icing cakes? And flowers?”

Her eyes twinkled with mischief, and he crossed his arms. “What are you talking about?”

She poked him in the shoulder. “I
know
something is going on.”

He kept his expression even. “What do you mean?”

“You don’t
really
want to be here decorating cookies with me and wearing a girly apron. Whose idea was it?”

Another trick question. “Nobody’s idea. I mean, my idea because Leah wasn’t going to be here. I’m happy to help. Really.”

“I appreciate it, Beckett. I do.” She sighed. “But I have a feeling all this has been orchestrated.”

She knew. How did she know? Had Poppy told her? Did that mean she knew how he felt, too?

“I…” He didn’t know what to say. It was even harder to find words when he wore a polka-dot apron and had a rolling pin in hand.

“You guys think I can’t handle it, right?” Anna’s eyes looked wounded. “I know you guys care, but I’m okay. I don’t need the extra help. I don’t need you all checking in on me to make sure I’m okay. It’s been more than six months. I’m moving on, and I’m okay.”

He released a breath. She thought they felt sorry for her or that they were keeping an eye on her. That’s all. It should have relieved him, but it didn’t because of how she was looking at him.

“It’s not that,” he said.

“Sure it isn’t.”

“Really, Anna. Shit, I–” He broke off. Was he just supposed to come out with it? Tell her how he felt? Tell her the plan? It would probably make this better. But what if she didn’t feel the same way?

Her cell phone buzzed from inside her pocket. She pulled it out and pressed the screen. He watched as her eyes zoomed over a message, then flashed up to his.

“Something wrong?” he asked.

Anna tucked her cell phone back in her pocket. “No, nothing. It’s fine. Just an email from a friend.”

It didn’t feel true, but he accepted her answer. None of his business. But damn, now the moment had passed and he was stuck again. She didn’t bring up him helping anymore and seemed lost in her own thoughts, instructing him about the decorating with an almost robotic voice.

{}{}{}

Anna had already opened a bottle of wine by the time Poppy got home. Their two-bedroom apartment was only a few blocks from Main Street, on the top floor of a modern complex built within the last five years. Despite the apartment being small, it had a balcony with a view that made the whole place worthwhile.

Mountains. Trees for miles.

Probably the only other spot in town that had a view better than hers was Beckett’s place.

As she listened to the jingle of Poppy’s keys from her place on the couch, Anna rubbed a hand over her eyes. Why was she thinking about Beckett again? She sighed. It was just because she’d been spending so much time with him. Jillian probably put him up to it. Or her mother. Maybe even Poppy.

But she couldn’t get that image of him wearing an apron out of her mind. Or the idea of all the muscles beneath it. And more, the crinkle of his eyes when he smiled or the way he always seemed to be there when she needed someone.

She always went for the guys like Tom. Confident. Bordering on cocky. Sometimes even flashy. Why hadn’t she ever thought about someone like Beckett before now?

“Please tell me you saved some for me,” Poppy said, leaning over the back of the couch to give Anna a smile.

Anna pointed to their tiny kitchen, one not nearly big enough for the baking she enjoyed doing there. “On the counter.”

Poppy’s short heels clicked on the floor as she walked to the kitchen. “All set for the open house?”

“Good enough.” Anna stood and carried her wine to the sliding door, and exited to the balcony. The sun sank close to the mountains, warm on her cheeks and arms as she stared at the trees and listened to the wind whisper through them.

It didn’t take Poppy long to join her. She’d taken off her shoes and her sweater, and she leaned on the rail like Anna.

“What’s wrong?” she asked.

Anna shrugged. “Nothing really.” And everything. The email she’d gotten from Celeste this afternoon still weighed heavy on her mind.

“I’m calling B.S.”

Anna sat in one of the colorful wooden chairs, propping her feet on the balcony rail. A few pansies Poppy had planted waved in the soft breeze. “I got an email from Celeste today.”

Poppy sat in the chair next to hers. “Oh yeah? How’s she doing?”