Unlocking the Sky (10 page)

Read Unlocking the Sky Online

Authors: Seth Shulman

BOOK: Unlocking the Sky
5.13Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

Researchers like Lilienthal did not simply complete pieces of the airplane puzzle for themselves; they passed the information along to others. Before Lilienthal’s death, for instance, Samuel Pierpont Langley traveled to Germany to see Lilienthal’s gliders firsthand.
And the Wright brothers used Lilienthal’s data extensively, especially in their earliest aeronautical research.

Some scientists were equally influential even though their expertise stood considerably afield from the engineering problem of how to build an airplane. One good example is the French naturalist Louis-Pierre Mouillard whose seminal 1881 work
L’Empire de l’Aire
carefully analyzes the wing structure and weight of bird species to systematically study how they fly. His seminal work influenced a generation of aviators. In fact, Langley attended an 1886 lecture by Mouillard and later credited it as the impetus for his decision to pursue aeronautical work in earnest. Similarly, the pioneering French inventor Clement Ader—one of the world’s very first to build a heavier-than-air flying machine—was so taken with Mouillard’s approach that he trekked through the wilds of Algeria in search of large vultures, luring the huge birds with slabs of meat to personally inspect the way they soared.

But for all the rich exchange of aeronautical information, no one during this period would match the efforts of Octave Chanute. His 1894
Progress in Flying Machines
—still in print today—may well be the most important work in the history of aviation. It presents a panoramic picture of the emerging aviation field near the turn of the century, and was read by virtually all of the earliest aviation pioneers around the world at the turn of the century—including the Wright brothers.

Chanute’s book offered detailed and precise descriptions of the work of an extraordinary collection of no fewer than sixty-five inventors with glider or airplane designs as of 1894—from the path-breaking box-kite designs of Lawrence Hargrave in Sydney, Australia, to the rounded, birdlike gliders of the French ship’s captain Jean-Marie le Bris.

To anyone seeking to understand the origins and development of the airplane, then or now, the existence of Chanute’s community of researchers at the turn of the century is a source of wonder and fascinating technical information. These aviation pioneers whose work Chanute chronicles were often marginalized and subjected to ridicule. But they represented an emerging understanding of aeronautical engineering that was essential to the airplane’s development.

It is astonishing to remember that, even before the Wrights’ success at Kitty Hawk in December 1903, some seven stalwart experimenters (including Langley) each managed to build motorized, full-scale heavier-than-air flying machines, and get them into the air before witnesses for at least a hop. The list includes little-known names like the French engineer Félix du Temple de la Croix, Russian inventor Alexandr Fyodorovich Mozhaisky, and the Austrian piano maker Wilhelm Kress.

One member of this group, the expatriate American Hiram Maxim, famed for his invention of the machine gun, spent roughly $100,000 of his own fortune on a massive, four-ton flying machine at his estate in Kent, England. On July 12, 1894, Maxim briefly flew the gargantuan aircraft, powered by two hulking 180-horsepower steam engines that each turned a propeller nearly eighteen feet long. Maxim set the machine upon a steel rail and, in order to measure the machine’s lift, built a guardrail to prevent it from getting more than a few inches off the ground. But the machine had so much thrust that, with Maxim at the helm, it immediately rose high enough to break through the iron guardrail, twisted out of control, and crashed. Maxim was so unnerved by the experience that he soon abandoned the entire project.

Maxim never made a fully working aircraft. But his assessment in
1890 gives a clear sense of the way things stood in the field. As he put it, “I think I can assert that within a very few years someone—if not myself, somebody else—will have made a machine which can be guided through the air, will travel with considerable velocity, and will be sufficiently under control.”

 

After Baldwin’s wayward dirigible flight at the Dayton Fair, he invites the Wrights aboard the catwalk as thanks for their assistance. They eagerly accept the offer and reciprocate by inviting Baldwin and Curtiss back to their Dayton shop. The four aviation entrepreneurs strike up a natural conversation about the emerging field and talk late into the evening. They talk generally about the state of technological development in aviation. They talk about propeller design, a topic of considerable recent interest to Curtiss.

Curtiss is very much at home in the Wrights’ shop. With workbenches, tools, and bicycle rims hanging from the rafters, it is remarkably like his own in Hammondsport, only perhaps a bit more fastidiously kept. Curtiss himself bears such a resemblance to the Wrights he could almost pass as another Wright brother himself. And they share many features in background and temperament as well. All three ran bicycle shops. None of them attended college. All tend to be shy and reserved by nature, especially with strangers. Most strikingly, all three are expert at a hands-on kind of thinking—making adjustments and tinkering to improve their products. It is an indispensable trait in the young aeronautical field where so much still needs to be discovered by feel.

In hindsight, of course, it is equally notable how well their special talents complement one another. Curtiss excels at engine
design whereas Orville will later acknowledge that the engine was always the weakest component of the original
Wright Flyers.
But despite Curtiss’s formal offer to collaborate with the Wrights by building them a special engine, history will dictate otherwise.

Curtiss’s offer to collaborate—and the Wrights’ prompt refusal—also highlights a dramatic difference between Curtiss and the Wright brothers. Despite his shyness, Curtiss is also open and candid; he loves nothing more than to bounce ideas back and forth with friends and colleagues. His inclination is always to work in a group and he thrives when exchanging his ideas with others.

By contrast, Wilbur and Orville Wright operate as a self-contained unit. Sons of a bishop in the United Brethren Church, they have been trained from an early age to be scrupulously truthful but, throughout their lives, they tend to be guarded and mistrustful of outsiders. Even though theirs is now a three-year-old invention, legally protected by a U.S. patent, the Wrights never consider taking their interested visitors to the nearby shed where their airplane sits hidden. It is a testament to how positively they feel toward Curtiss and Baldwin that they let the two see a picture of their airplane in flight that evening.

Sadly, much later, when relations between Curtiss and the Wrights become strained, Orville Wright will offer the baseless charge that the chance meeting in Dayton began a systematic effort by Curtiss to steal the Wrights’ technology. The visit couldn’t have helped but to encourage Curtiss about the potential of heavier-than-air flight, but the charges otherwise couldn’t be farther from the truth.

Curtiss’s open eagerness to engage the Wrights shows in his correspondence immediately following the visit and for some time afterward as well. When he returns to Hammondsport, Curtiss
sends a warm and chatty letter to the Wrights offering details of his work on a new eight-cylinder motor and other exploits. “It may interest you to know,” he writes, clearly following up on an exchange in Dayton, “that we cut out some of the inner surface of the blades on the big propeller, so as to reduce the resistance and allow it to speed up, and it showed a remarkable improvement.” It is hardly the correspondence of someone trying to surreptitiously appropriate the Wrights’ ideas.

 

Baldwin’s last day in Dayton is the most successful. To the delight of many spectators, he makes a dramatic flight above the city, traveling from one end of town to the other and back, and making a perfect landing in time to beat an automobile that tries to race the same distance along the city streets.

Baldwin thus adds his feat in Dayton to a remarkable string of airborne accomplishments. Now mostly forgotten, Baldwin dominated the air in the brief era of the dirigible. And he continued to entertain crowds with his aerial feats as the airplane blossomed, becoming the first person to hold a complete set of international licenses to pilot all three types of aircraft: balloon, dirigible, and airplane. But Baldwin’s moment in the limelight of aviation soon faded as his showman’s sensibility was eclipsed. Aerial exhibitions continued for many years to come, but a new generation of aviators like Curtiss had even more ambitious goals for the airplane.

FIVE
SKY DANCING

The age of the flying machine is not in the future.

It is with us now.

—A
LEXANDER
G
RAHAM
B
ELL,
1906

W
ith one of his motorcycle motors safely packed in the baggage car, Glenn Curtiss gazes out the window of a northbound train at the open blue sky. It is a cloudless morning in early July 1907. Curtiss will spend most of the next two days on trains, including many stops and changes, but he is happy for the solitude. It is his first stretch alone for a while, and the remarkable nature of his voyage has put him in an uncharacteristically pensive mood. He is quite sure he is either losing his common sense completely or embarking on one of the most exciting adventures of his already eventful life. He just cannot decide which.

Curtiss is en route to Alexander Graham Bell’s summer estate on Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia. It will be one of the farthest voyages from Hammondsport that Curtiss, at age thirty, has ever taken. He has left his successful, growing motorcycle and engine manufac
turing business in the capable hands of Henry Kleckler and Harry Genung. The shop now boasts more than two dozen employees and its operations have steadied out considerably by this time; the orders keep coming at a startling rate, but now they are more speedily and reliably filled. Nonetheless, Curtiss wonders, is this a time to get involved in something new, risky, and untried?

As the train turns eastward from Montreal toward the Atlantic Ocean and Canada’s easternmost province, Curtiss lets his mind wander. He thinks about his entry into the motorcycle business. Years earlier, Curtiss had first sent away for a set of castings with which to make a gasoline engine. They had arrived with no instructions. Through trial and error, Curtiss had machined the pieces and assembled his first makeshift engine. Tomato cans had served as both carburetor and gas tank.

An almost imperceptible smile crosses Curtiss’s face as he remembers his first trip to the post office after rigging the engine to a bicycle, using a leather strap to drive the wheels. He had to pedal all the way across town while Hammondsport shopkeepers stood in their doorways and laughed at his awkward contraption. But, as he liked to recount later, the engine finally began to spark and pop; then it was his turn to laugh. Before long, everybody in Hammondsport wanted a motorcycle from Curtiss, and orders began pouring in from all over the country.

If Curtiss prides himself on anything, it is his readiness to adopt and work with new technology. In 1901, in the days before electricity had come to town, Curtiss had installed acetylene gaslights in many of the shops around Hammondsport’s town square. And he had designed a clever system with tin cans and a few dabs of solder to make them burn more efficiently.

For as long as he could remember, Curtiss had never sat on his
hands in the face of opportunity. As early as age fourteen, he displayed this trait, in one of his first jobs at the Eastman Kodak works in Rochester. Along with many other boys his age, Curtiss stenciled the numbers on the film that would show through the red window in the camera’s back. Soon after taking the $4-per-week job, Curtiss went to his boss with a plan. He asked the company to pay him and his coworkers by the piece, at a rate of 25 cents per 100 strips. With the workers averaging 250 strips a day, the piece rate he proposed was roughly equivalent to their $4 wage.

As soon as the company accepted his proposal, Curtiss brought in a rack he had designed that could hold a pile of a hundred strips, a hinged mechanism to hold the stencil, and a fat new brush with which to dab on the ink in one stroke. He then showed his mostly teenage coworkers the way to riches. Before long, Curtiss had upped production tenfold. He and the other boys were going so fast, they earned more than some Kodak managers. Even when the company renegotiated the deal down to 9 cents per 100 strips, Curtiss’s ingenuity still meant that the team had almost tripled their weekly wage.

Now the eminent inventor Alexander Graham Bell has asked Curtiss to join forces to engineer a heavier-than-air flying machine. But Curtiss wonders whether he can bring his ingenuity to bear in any meaningful way in a complex and unknown field like aeronautics. His engines helped Thomas Baldwin and his dirigibles in ways Curtiss never anticipated. Bell might open similar new horizons. But the prospect of making heavier-than-air flying machines a practical reality seems far-fetched, despite the Wright brothers’ claims and Bell’s enthusiasm.

There is also the question of Bell himself. He and Curtiss first met a year and a half before, in January 1906, at the New York City
Auto Show. It was hard not to be impressed with Bell, a charismatic and warm man with bushy, white whiskers, a booming baritone voice, and a gentle, learned demeanor.

For years, Curtiss had found the auto show a good forum for drumming up motorcycle business. That year, though, the show had notably changed when organizers invited the city’s fledgling Aero Club to participate. Curtiss had prepared his customary exhibit, adding emphasis on dirigibles in honor of the new participants. But, if anything, he had underestimated the crowd’s newfound interest in aviation. The exhibits committee had appealed to Langley, Chanute, and Bell for examples of their aeronautical work, and all had lent gliders or models to the exhibition. No fewer than four dirigibles, including Baldwin’s latest, hung suspended from the ceiling of the large exhibition hall. The committee had also appealed to the Wrights, but, not surprisingly, the brothers sent only the tiniest offering: the exceedingly plain crankshaft and flywheel of their 1903 engine. “It would interfere with our plans,” they wrote the committee, “if we should make public at once a description of our machine and methods.”

At the 1906 show, no one was more in demand than Bell. He mounted a large exhibit of the striking, multi-celled, tetrahedral kites with which he was experimenting as a way to carry humans into the air. Bell also gave the keynote address at the Auto Club’s banquet, declaring that the age of what he called “the aerodrome” was at hand. It wouldn’t be long, he said, before aircraft would fly across the Atlantic. The day will come, he told the mostly skeptical crowd, “when we will leave New York City in the morning and be in London at night.”

During the show, Bell visited Curtiss’s exhibit. He was deferential and enthusiastic as he closely inspected the motors on display.
The machinery clearly captured the older man’s interest, and he would make special note of them in his diary following the show. Not long after, he began to refer to Curtiss as “the greatest motor expert in the country.”

Curtiss was unaware of it, but Bell was hatching a plan to gather together a team to try to build a workable flying machine. Sixty years old, Bell had learned a lot about the process of technological innovation, but, given his age, he also knew any team he established would have to include the best young and energetic talent he could find.

Bell hinted at his plan when Curtiss met him the following spring at Bell’s stately home in the Georgetown section of Washington, D.C. In town on business, Curtiss had come calling and received a warm and enthusiastic reception. Bell treated him to a long and animated discourse on heavier-than-air flight that left Curtiss fascinated despite himself. Curtiss had long been wary of believers in flying machines, and even his experience with Baldwin hadn’t fully shaken him of the prejudice. Yet Curtiss was enticed by the encyclopedic Bell and his mostly unfamiliar, firsthand stories of the aviation pioneers Maxim, Langley, and Chanute.

Curtiss had been exposed to the world of aeronautics through Baldwin, and he had even met the reclusive Wright brothers. But he had little idea of the extent of flight research that was being conducted around the world. It was hard not to be seduced by Bell’s enthusiasm for the subject. To hear Bell tell it, the airplane’s time had come, and it would soon burst upon the world the way the automobile and the telephone had only a few years before.

Not long after their visit in Washington, Bell came to Hammondsport to try to clinch a deal with Curtiss. As he purchased one of Curtiss’s most powerful engines, he formally requested that Curtiss
hand-deliver it to his summer laboratory in Nova Scotia. That way, he said, Curtiss could see his operation and help him and his assistants learn to operate and maintain the engine and adapt it to their needs. As a further enticement, Bell offered to pay Curtiss $25 per day, plus expenses, for his services, a handsome consulting fee at the time.

During that brief, introductory visit to Hammondsport, Bell thoroughly charmed Glenn and Lena Curtiss. Bell was a notably unpretentious person, especially considering his extraordinary accomplishments. That quality particularly appealed to Lena. She was both proud and a little taken aback that such a famous inventor would think so highly of her husband’s motors that he would come to buy one personally for his aeronautical experiments. After all, this was a man who had utterly transformed the world once already with his invention of the telephone. Might he do it again, she wondered, with a Curtiss motor at the heart of his invention?

Bell’s enthusiasm and generosity left little question that Curtiss would accept his invitation. He felt honored by Bell’s interest and he would be well paid for his time. No harm could come, Curtiss decided, from taking a few days away from business to see for himself what Bell was up to. Like Lena, Curtiss enjoyed Bell’s attention and appreciated his worldly experience. The effect of his visit was much like that of Baldwin’s several years before, but even more heady. Where Baldwin was flamboyant, Bell seemed substantial. Ever the showman, Baldwin, when he prepared to leave town, liked to broadcast the fact that he was off to perform at some distant fair or exhibition. Bell was different. Upon his departure from Hammondsport, he only reluctantly divulged that he had to make a detour to England before returning to his beloved estate in Nova Scotia. When Curtiss asked about the British trip, Bell explained,
almost sheepishly, that Oxford University was awarding him an honorary degree.

 

After endless stops and changes of train, Curtiss arrives at a little wooden station in a town that makes Hammondsport seem like a metropolis. Two ruddy, casually dressed young men greet him heartily, full of smiles. They are F. W. “Casey” Baldwin—no relation to Captain Baldwin but rather the son of former Canadian Premier Robert Baldwin—and Douglas McCurdy, the son of a neighbor and old friend of Bell’s. As Curtiss soon learns, both young men are Bell’s technical assistants, recent graduates of the University of Toronto with master’s degrees in engineering. Much like their mentor, they are filled with enthusiasm, intellectual curiosity, and technical knowledge. They make a winning welcoming committee and, from the start, ply Curtiss with all manner of questions about himself and his motors.

The two eagerly help Curtiss haul his engine off the train and carry it a few blocks to a rickety pier. From here, a small steamer ferry takes them across the vast Bras d’Or Lake to Bell’s one-thousand-acre estate called Beinn Bhreagh (from his native Gaelic for “beautiful mountain”). The boat sets off as soon as they board.

The Bras d’Or, a large, salty inland sea, covers much of the interior of Cape Breton Island. Even though he grew up in the beautiful Finger Lakes region, Curtiss can’t help but marvel at the scale of the unspoiled scenery. After about a half hour, the ferry approaches a small pier that juts out from pine woods into the lake. Through the trees, Curtiss can see the windows and gables of a great rambling house rising high on the hillside above him like a big, shingled castle with turrets and parapets.

On the path leading up to the house, Curtiss passes some of the buildings that make up Bell’s summer laboratory. Long, equipment-filled sheds stand close behind the boathouse. A long, narrow building is called the Kite House. Through its barn doors, Curtiss sees a baffling assortment of large kite-like structures hanging from the rafters, many covered in deep red silk.

Leaving the motor on the pier, the three make their way farther up the hill to the great screened-in front porch of the mansion, a lovely, breezy room with a majestic view across the water. Casey Baldwin and McCurdy introduce Curtiss to the household. All its members have gathered and now rise from comfortable wicker chairs to welcome him. Curtiss is greeted warmly first by Bell and his wife, Mabel. Also visiting are Lieutenant Thomas Selfridge, a U.S. Army aviation expert, invited by Bell to observe his aeronautical experiments; Bell’s two daughters, Elsie May and Daisy; Daisy’s husband, a botanist named David Fairchild; and their two lively grandchildren.

They graciously set Curtiss up in one of the finest guest quarters, a circular room in one of the corner towers. Baldwin and McCurdy escort the visitor and his small suitcase up to his room, and, as he sets it down next to the bed, Curtiss pauses to gaze wordlessly at the breathtaking view of the huge, sparkling lake below.

That evening, after an animated dinner in the Bells’ cozy, wood-paneled dining room, the group gathers before the immense front hall fireplace for a lively session of talking and singing the likes of which Curtiss has never before encountered. Bell loves to sing and has an excellent voice; both he and Mabel play the piano. But even more than the jovial atmosphere, Curtiss is taken with the breadth and erudition of the conversation.

In this regard, no one amazes Curtiss more than the lady of the house, Mabel Gardiner Bell. Mabel is every bit as intellectually alive
as her husband, and she fully holds her own on almost all the wide-ranging topics of the evening. She is also a suffragette: as early as 1901, she helped convince Alec, as she calls her husband, to champion the idea of universal suffrage—for women and blacks. And she is as adventurous as she is well educated. Some years earlier, she even went underwater in a diving bell as Alec watched in admiration from the surface, flatly refusing to try it himself.

Curtiss can see that Mabel clearly adores her husband and humors him in many ways. But she also teases him mercilessly, a trait that only adds to the evening’s relaxed intimacy. At one point she humorously warns the others about their host: on their honeymoon, she recounts, her new husband took all the sugar cubes at the table and dropped them, one by one, into his coffee because he got curious about the tiny bubbles they produced.

Other books

New York Valentine by Carmen Reid
The Suitors by Cecile David-Weill
The Ape's Wife and Other Stories by Kiernan, Caitlín R.
On the Edge by Pamela Britton
Infected by V.A. Brandon