He nodded jerkily. He couldn’t speak. The sound of her voice undid him, left him feeling bereft with the thought that he might be hearing it now and never again.
He thought of the sculpture in the cloister. Phelan’s offering, showing her as half gone from the beginning, even before time began its work. Eluding as she
emerged. He understood it now. You saw Ysabel as you stood before her, heard that voice, and you felt loss
in the moment
because you feared she might leave you.
Because you knew she would.
She was gazing steadily at him, appraising, more curious than anything else. Her eyes were blue, or green. It was difficult to tell, there were shadows behind her and above. There was no malice, no anger here, though he couldn’t see warmth, either. But why should he have expected that? What could he possibly have expected?
“How are you here?” she said.
That, at least, he should have been ready for. But it was difficult to form thoughts that made sense. Stammering, he said, “You . . . you said sacrifice. At Entremont. Not just killing.”
Amusement, the eyebrows arched. She was barefoot on the cold stone, he saw. Wearing a long, white cotton skirt and a blue blouse over it. Her hair was down, along her back, framing her face.
“I did,” she agreed, still studying him. “You were there?”
He nodded.
“Unwise. You might have died, had they known it.”
He nodded. Phelan had known it. He didn’t say that.
“There are many places of sacrifice,” she said.
They’d figured that out, too. He said, “My mother got the sacrifice part, when we told her. And . . . a boar gave me a clue.”
He didn’t tell about Melanie, the story she’d told him of the battle below. The sacrifice of the chieftains here. He was going to need to speak of Melanie, he had no idea how.
Her expression changed. “Your mother gave you that?” She was pointing at the bracelet. The stone was bright.
He shook his head. “My aunt. Her sister.” He hesitated. It wasn’t his, but, “Would you like it?”
She smiled, pleased, but shook her head, looking at him.
A long, still moment, quiet in the cave, the wind blowing outside, the sun going down. The living world so far from where they were.
Then Ysabel smiled again, but differently.
“Now I see,” she said, and the tone had altered as well, changes in her voice and face, like ripples in water. Ned wasn’t sure—he wasn’t sure of anything—but he thought he heard sadness, and maybe something else.
“What is there to see?”
She didn’t answer. She turned away—he felt it as a wound—then she lifted a hand, stilling him.
He heard it too, and was looking towards the entrance through which he’d come himself when Cadell jumped down and in.
He landed, noted Ned’s presence. Then he turned to Ysabel.
He didn’t speak, and the woman said nothing either, absorbing, accepting what was inescapable in his face. There was nothing hidden in him, nothing held back.
Watching the two of them Ned felt like the intruder he was: excluded, inappropriate, trivial. If he was right, if he understood this at all, Cadell had died more than two thousand years ago, in the chasm below this cave.
“You have a wound,” she said, speaking first.
“A knife. It is inconsequential.”
“Indeed. What would be of consequence?”
Ned remembered that ironic tone from Beltaine, after the fires and the bull. He realized his hands were shaking again.
Cadell’s deep voice carried a note that could only be called joy. He said, “Coming here to find the Roman before me. That would shatter this heart as much as would the sky falling at the end of days.”
“Ah,” she said, “the poet returns?”
“He never left you. You know that, love.”
“I know very little,” she said, in that voice that made a lie of the words.
“You know that I am here, and before your three nights have turned. I remember this place.”
“But of
course
you do,” said another voice, from behind Ned and below.
They all wheeled. But even as he did, Ned saw Ysabel’s face, and he realized she was unsurprised.
They watched as Phelan pulled himself up from the slanting plateau below the opening to the south.
He stood, unhurried, brushing dust from his knees and the torn jacket, using his right hand only. Then he, in turn, looked at the woman.
“A wound?” said Ysabel.
“Inconsequential.” Ned saw the bald head, the scar, the grey, cool eyes and then—with surprise—a smile.
“You heard that?” She was smiling, too.
“It is my proof of being present, love. I need to have heard that or you might not believe me.”
“You would lie to me?”
He shook his head. “Never in any life. But you have disbelieved before.”
“With cause?”
Phelan looked at her. Then shook his head again. “With a right to do so, but not with cause.”
The brief smile had gone. There was hunger in his face, and longing, so fierce they were a kind of light.
“You were below,” said Cadell flatly.
“A harder climb, yes, but I was south and had to come that way.”
“It doesn’t matter. You were not
here
.”
Phelan shrugged. “No? Tell me, what did she ask the boy, about his bracelet?”
Ned felt the weight of three gazes upon him. He wanted to be invisible, absent,
gone
.
Then he heard her laughter. “I see. You will say that you did hear, and so came to me first?”
Phelan was looking at the other man, his eyes cold as wilderness, waiting. The light in his face was gone. There was no reply from the Celt. Phelan said, precisely, “She asked him if his mother gave the bracelet to him. Shall I tell now his reply that you also did not hear?”
Wolf on a mountain peak.
Cadell’s blue gaze, returning, was as hard, though, unyielding. It never
had
yielded, Ned knew.
“It makes no matter how and where you climbed or what you heard below. You were not here to find her first.”
A silence in that high place. It felt like the last silence of the world, Ned Marriner thought.
Ysabel ended it. Ended more than stillness.
“He was not. It is true,” she murmured. “But neither were you, my golden one. Alas, that I am unloved, but neither were you.”
And as she stopped, as that voice fell away, the three of them turned to Ned again.
It might have been the hardest thing he’d yet done, to stand straight, not draw back. Face them, breathing hard, but controlling it. He looked from one man to the other, and ended with Ysabel. The long travel of her gaze, how far it seemed to go, to reach him.
“He is not part of this,” Cadell said.
“Untrue,” she said, still softly. “Did he not lead you here? Will you say he did not? That you found me yourself?”
“The boar guided him,” Phelan said. “The druid’s.”
No fire or ice now. A sudden, intense gravity that was, in its own way, more frightening. As if the stakes, with what she’d said, had become too high for fury or flame.
“It isn’t the druid’s boar,” said Cadell. “Brys served it, not the other way around.”
“I didn’t know that,” Phelan said. “I thought—”
“I know what you thought. The beast is older than any of us.”
Phelan’s thin smile. “Even us?”
Cadell nodded. The light from the south caught his golden hair.
The woman remained silent, letting them speak across her, to each other.
“And so it was the boar . . . caused this?”
Cadell shook his head. “It made this possible, at best. The boy could have died at Entremont, in Alyscamps, by the round tower. I could have killed him in Glanum where I killed you, once.” His turn to smile, lips closed. “You could have killed him many times. Is it not so?”
Phelan nodded. “I suppose. I saw no reason to have him die. I helped them get away, when the needfires were lit.”
“Perhaps a mistake.” The deep voice.
The other man shrugged. “I have made others.” He looked at Ysabel, and then at Ned again, his brow furrowed now.
Cadell said, “We could have been here ahead of him. I saw him fall, twice. The boar made this harder for him, showing us where he was going.”
“And your meaning is?”
Cadell’s teeth flashed this time. “My thinking is too hard for you? Really? You said the boar caused this. It isn’t so.”
And still the woman did not speak.
She stood as if barely attending to them, withdrawing even as she remained. Ned thought of the sculpture
again, sunlit in the sheltered cloister. It was cold here now, so far above the world.
Phelan said, “There is another way to see it, if you are right—the animal bringing us both.”
“Yes. I also have that thought.”
“I killed you once here, did I not? With some others.”
“You know you did. They were lost in the chasm.”
“Not you.”
“They were lost,” Cadell repeated quietly.
Phelan’s wintry smile. “You cling to that, among so many deaths.”
“It is more than dying, there.”
“Not for you, with me alive to hold you to returning. You would have known it even as you went down.”
“They didn’t. They were lost there.”
“Yes. Not you.”
“So I owe you my life?” The bite of irony.
They actually smiled at each other in that moment. Ned would remember that.
“As you said,” Phelan murmured. “We could have arrived ahead of him.”
“As I said.”
They both looked at Ned again.
He said, in a small voice, “I’m sorry, I think.”
Cadell laughed aloud.
“No, you aren’t,” said Phelan. “You’ve been refusing to leave this from the outset.”
A small, maybe a last, flare within. “You don’t know me well enough to say what I feel,” Ned said.
A moment, and then Phelan—stranger, Greek, Roman—nodded. “You are right. Forgive me. It is entirely possible to need or want something, and be sorry it is so.” He hesitated again. “It appears I did more than I intended when I brought you into this. I could not say, even now, what made me do it. What I saw.”
“No? I can,” said Ysabel, breaking her stillness, returning to them. Then she added, with sudden passion, “
Look at him!”
The two men did so, again. Ned closed his eyes this time, his mind racing, lost. He opened them. And saw, in both men at the same moment, a dawning as of light—and then a setting of the sun.
Neither spoke for a long time.
Cadell made one quick, outward gesture with his good hand that Ned didn’t understand. Then he pushed fingers through his long hair. He drew a deep breath. Lifted the hand, and let it fall again. He turned to Phelan.
“You truly didn’t know,” he said to the other man, “when you drew him in?”
Phelan hadn’t moved. Or taken his gaze from Ned. He still didn’t. “I knew something. I said that. Not this. How would I know this?”
Know
w
hat?
Ned wanted to scream. He was afraid to speak.
Cadell, quietly, said, “We might have realized, when we saw the mother and her sister.”
Phelan nodded. “I suppose.” He was white-faced, Ned saw. Shaken to the core, trying to deal with it.
Cadell pushed a hand through his hair again. He turned to Ysabel. She was standing very straight now, extremely still, gathered to herself: a beauty near to stone, it might seem, but not truly so.
The big man looked at Ned for a moment, and then back to her. He said, wonderingly, the deep voice soft, “The mother has your hair, even, near enough.”
At which point, finally, very late, overwhelmed as if to a cliff’s edge of stupefaction, feeling that waves were crashing there against his mind, Ned Marriner understood.
Who are you
?
The repeated question, over and again. The one he’d hated, having no answer. Now he did. Ysabel had given it to the three of them.
The world rocked and spun, unstable and impossible. Ned made a small, helpless sound; he couldn’t stop himself. This was too vast, it
meant
too many things, too many to get your head around.
He saw Phelan looking at her.
The wide, thin mouth quirked sideways. “When?” he whispered. And then, “Whose?”
Ned stopped breathing.
She smiled, grave and regal, not capricious or teasing now. She shook her head slowly. “Some things are not best told. Even in love. Perhaps especially in love. Is it not so?”
More questions than answers in the world
, Ned thought.
Phelan lowered his head.
Her smile changed a little. “You knew I would say that?”
He looked up. “I never know what you will say.”
“Never?” Faint hint of irony, but a sense she was reaching a long way for it.
“Almost never,” he amended. “I did not expect this. None of this. Not the searching you decreed, forbidding battle. Not the boy being . . . what you say he is. Love, I am lost.”
“And I,” Cadell said. The other two turned to him. “You altered the story. He led us here. The boar guided him, and us. This means?”
This means?
Ysabel turned to Ned. The clear, distant gaze. The eyes were blue, not green, he saw. And something was unmistakable now. You would have to be blind, or truly a child, not to see it: the sadness that had come. She looked steadily at him and said, more softly than any words yet spoken, “What must I answer him, blood of my blood?”
He didn’t reply. What could he possibly say? But he saw now—he did see—an answer to the one question, about his being here and his aunt and his mother, and their mother and hers, fathers or mothers back to a distant presence of light down a long tunnel from the past.
Where the woman before him waited in a far, faint brightness.
She turned from him, not waiting for an answer. Looked to one man and then the other. “You
know
what it means,” she said. “You know what I said beside
the animal that died to draw me into the world again. Neither of you found me first. You know what follows. The chasm is here. It is still here.”
What will follow, you should not see.
Phelan had said that to him, at Entremont. But Ned had stayed, and seen, and led them here to this.
“You never said there was a child,” Cadell murmured.