Authors: Nadine Gordimer
There was a tea table near the woolly sofa, now, with a couple of
black leather airport chairs for talks less formal than those conducted across the desk. They came to rest there.
Bray said, out of the warmth and ease, “That seems to have gone off splendidly. But what bothers me is the other. Last night.” It seemed a piece of cruelty to speak. Mweta's eyes winced. He folded his arms to recapture the ease. “I don't understand, James.”
“Doesn't it bother you?”
Mweta's eyes continued to flicker. He said, smiling, “You heard what I said.”
“Oh that. What you had to say. But what you think about it? The real reasons why you've found it necessary? I wasn't coming to talk to you about this at allâ”
Mweta made an eager, dismissing gesture; Bray came to see him because he was Bray.
“NoâI had a reason”âa rebuff for them bothâ “there was a young man I picked up on the road to the Bashi last week. I discovered later that he'd been in detention at Gala prison for almost three monthsâhe didn't need to wait for your new law. I was going to talk to you about him, I didn't know whether you knew, though of course I could tell that Onabu knew, this sort of authorityâI don't know what to call itâcame from up there, from Onabu.⦠But that's not what matters. I mean, it matters enormously in itself, but there's something much more important, and now, since last night, even more important. The boy, the Detention Bill, they're the effect.”
Mweta sat back in himself, arms still crossed, in the determined, flexed attention that Bray knew so well. His face had smoothed momentarily as if he were to be let off; then the flick in his eyes came again. Bray was aware of it all the time.
“âThat's not what matters. Because it seems clear to me that what happened to the boy, the Detention Billâthey're inevitable, essential, you can't do without them, your reason being what it isâ”
Mweta came in quickly but distrusting: “Yes, my good reason. I'm not going to stand by and let this country be ruined by troubleâmakers.”
“What do you call troubleâmakers, Mweta?”
“You get people who see Independence right from the beginning as a freeâfor-all. Grab what you can ⦠They're always there. You have to deal with them. You know that. I don't like it, but I have to do it.”
“You're better off than most, here. You've got a good chance of giving people what they lack.”
Mweta said, “James, that's not the point. You could give them all a house with electric light and a cleanâhands job and you'd still have trouble from some people.”
“Then there's something else that's bothering them.”
Mweta gave a little snorting smile. “You're quite right, it's power, that's what they want. Somebody wants power and there's only one way for such a person to try and get it. He must use every poor fellow who'll listen to him, he must stir them up with talk they don't understand, so they'll be only too ready to believe we've bamboozled them, too, and from this it follows so easily to convince them that if this country isn't the Garden of Eden, that's got nothing to do with their inadequacies and our difficulties. âJamesâwe'll clean up that young rubbish and show the people behind them it's no good. You can believe me. I don't want the Detention thing a day longer, after that.”
An irritable spark like static electricity ran between them. “There won't be an after that. You'll need to keep that bill forever, if you don't do something about the reason why you need it in the first place. If you'd do that you wouldn't be obliged to âdeal' with it. The way you have to deal with it now. This way you don't like, Mwetaâ”
Mweta was about to answer and did not. He smiled at Bray to shut him out. “Well, go on.”
“I believe some of those ants of yours are nibbling under their own benches in the House.”
Mweta's mouth moved and settled.
“ âThey are being watched,'” Bray said, “Well and good. And who else? Who else is being watched? And why? Mweta, why? What for? I can't help feeling convinced that if you'd given him a ministry there'd have been no trouble. From him. He'd have dealt with the trouble.”
“He's the one who's always made it,” Mweta said. Then suddenly, like an actor going out after his audience he turned shining eyes and eagerâhunched body, all gathered up in a stalking intensity and burst out, beguiling, gesturingâ “Shinza! From the day of selfârule he began to turn his criticism on us. From that day. Always looking at me and shaking his head inside. Whatever it was we were discussing.
No trust any more for anybody. He made up his mind he had to watch the rest of us the way he used to watch
them.
Yes! You remember? At the talks in London, he was always the one would come out and say, afterwards, âI don't think soâand-so means what he says, he's playing for time.' âSo-and-so's going to do what the Colonial Secretary says.' âThis one must be made to back downâ¦.' He watched them for us while we were too busy thinking what point to make next. He found out things I hadn't noticed, often he was right, he could warn you. But among ourselves! Our own men! In the Central Committee, among the ministers! How can you work like that? James, James”âhis voice dropped to patient reasonableness, soft and dramaticâ “I can tell you, his eyes were on the back of my head. I ask him somethingâI went to him as I always did, you understandâhe was my father, my brotherâhe listens with a smile on his face and his eyes closed.” Mweta was standing over Bray. He hung there, paused, breathing heavily, gasping, almost, like a man about to sob, deserted by words. “âI hadn't understood the issue properly.' âDid I realize who I was dealing with?'âWith his eyes closed. To smell me out. Yes, like he did the Englishmen in Lancaster House, making the noises in the throat and looking like they're falling asleep just when they're ready to get you. It was mad, eh? All right. I said to myself, he's your father, your brother.
All right.
But let him come out in the open. Let him speak what he thinks at the time for these things, like anybody else. This is a government, not a secret society. Open your eyes and look at me, Shinza. But I kept quiet. A long time, a long, long time. Did I ever say anything to you? That last time in London? You never knew what it was like. I was ashamed, you understand, I didn't want you to know how he was behaving. I didn't want to believe it myself. But I can't think about myself any more. If I do, I must get out”âhe strode to the window and flung away the park, out there, rippling in the still heatâ “We're not in the bush in Gala any more, with nothing but each other. Eight million people are in this country. I can't be tied by the hind leg like a cow. When Clough and the British Chief of Staff met for the defence agreement and the question of a base on the southern border came up, Clough starts outlining what he âbelieves' I'd agree to, and, my God, it's clear to me that he's got a pretty good idea before where we'll make a concession and where we'll stick fastâthe missile base question, for example. Clough obviously knew
we were going to bargain with that, he was prepared, he made no bones about itâand so I said to himâthat is, I made a point of raising an objection to something that we really had no objection to at all, just to see what his reaction would be. And he came out with it just like that: âBut I understood that this would be acceptable to your government.'âFrom
where
did you understand, I said. Who gave you to understand? Of course, he got out of that one somehow. But later on I asked him, alone. âI was given to understand.' He looked at me as if I was mad, as if I didn't know. You can't blame him. Who gave you to understand?
âHe
had had talks with Clough: âOf course, Shinza knew my predecessor well.' It was often useful to chat beforehand. Much progress had been made quietly, in the past. And so on. What could I say? Well, that time no damage was done. Luckily. But that's the kind of thing. Look at the minority report he put in. And that's something you knew about. You know what you thought of that. Yes, well, a bit tactless, that's what you said to me. But you're not one to say much, and I know you were worried, whatever you said. I have eight millions on my hands, James, and I can only look after them my own way.”
“You've forced him into a kind of opposition that isn't there, between you.”
Mweta's hands dropped, swung helplessly. “Not there! If you give him
that much,
he'll swallow your arm. You only think of him years ago.”
“Yes, he has changed,” Bray said. “But you know I've seen him.”
“No,” Mweta said. “No, I tell you I didn't know.”
It was the first time, the first time since he was that boy with a guitar, on a bicycle, that Bray didn't know whether Mweta was speaking the truth.
“When?”
“That was where I was goingâlast week, on the Bashi road.”
“Oh. I see.”
“No you don't see. I wrote something to youâdidn't send it, the business about the boy bothered me.⦠But I wanted to tell you, I can't believe Shinza would make a move to oust you
if he were with you.
If you were still in it together. The differences you had in the Party, just before independenceâthat's not to be taken as conclusive. He'll fight you there because he believes that the Party should stand
for certain things, the Party shouldn't take account of the government's limitations, even if they're enforced by circumstance: that's what the Party's there for, in a state like this one. To keep in front of the government the original idea of what Independence should mean, to oppose that idea all the time against the government's acceptance of what is expedient, consistent with power. The dialectic, in fact. That's what his opposition within the Party really means.”
“Oh we all know about his early Marxist training. His six weeks in 1937. We've heard all about that from him a dozen times. We all know he was the intellectual of the Party while we were the bush boys. We've had all that.”
Bray said, “What I'm getting at is there's something in him that would always make him want to be a power, but not
the
one ⦠that's more or less what I said. You'd distrust a moral reason why I think he wouldn't threaten you, just as I should myself.⦠But this isn't a moral reason, it's a matter of temperament. Temperament exhibited and proven over a long, long time.⦠He wants only to be known to the few people in the know. That's enough for him. He enjoyed helping to âmake' you; why didn't he employ the same energy to make himself?” (He thought, do I touch on vanity there; no, Mweta knows he didn't need making in any sense implying inadequacy.) “Because he hasn't the will to lead, really, he doesn't want it. He didn't want it. It's a weakness, if you like, a kind of arrogance. Let someone else be out there handled by the crowd.”
Mweta had the weary obstinacy of one who is following his own thoughts. “He'd have done exactly the same in my place.”
“If he were with you,” Bray said, “If you were together, Mweta ⦠you'd both be in the same place. He'd be seeing things from where you are, and that makes all the difference. Power compromises,” he added, with a gesture of embarrassment for that sort of phrase. “He wouldn't have so much fire in his belly if he were sitting at table in this house.”
Mweta folded the fingers of one hand over the knuckle of the other and pressed it, testingly. Bray suddenly saw that he was fighting for control, holding together some trembling part of himself. I have hurt him, I hurt him by so much as acknowledging the other one's existence. They couldn't change the relation in which they had stood to each other, heâBrayâand Mweta; he must have endorsement from
me, that is my old role. Anything else is betrayal. It was stupid; and Mweta was not. But the boy on the bicycle; when Mweta's with me he can't get away from the boy on the bicycle.
The President
wants love and approval, unrelated to the facts, between us. When it comes to us.
Bray felt a hardening distaste for the arrogant bare feet, the cigar at the centre of the brokenâtoothed grin in the thick beard. He said, “If I were you I'd send for Shinza. Now.”
Mweta's voice cracked his own silence. “But you disapprove of preventive detention. If Shinza came in with me you'd see both of us backing it.” He gave a cold and patronizing laugh.
“There'd be no need.”
Mweta was looking at the big frame he knew so well, as if for a place where it would give. “You think so? What about Shinza's crowd? They'd follow him?âThere'd always be need.” He got up and walked round the desk, glancing at the papers there like halfârecognized faces waiting to attract his attention; turned abruptly and came and stood near Bray's chair. “I've got no message for Shinza,” he said.
“I'm not a messenger.”
“But the best thing you can do is make him understand that what he's doing isn't any use. He's not going to bring it off, whatever he thinks he's aiming at. He's making a fool of himself. Or something worse. Really James, if you are worried about Shinza, tell him to leave it alone, don't encourage him.”
It was a hit. “Encourage?”
“As you said, the friendship of the old days, and so on.”
“I didn't say, Mweta,” said Bray, gently. “And the pastâwell that's what it is. You two, you and Shinza, it's a matter of state, now, and I can't have any part in it. I can only tell you what I think about you two; but that's all. What I think, what I believe, urgently believe.”
“All right, all right. All the same, when you see him you'll tell
him
what you think.”
Bray said, “Don't you want me to see Shinza?”
Mweta said sadly, with a touch of the politician's deftness at the same time, “James, I would never tell you what you should do. Good God.”