A Raging Dawn (22 page)

Fact: Littleton did not kill Tymara. Question: Who did?

Fact: Littleton did rape Tymara. Question: Who else did?

Fact: Littleton did not poison the people at the school. Question: Did Sylvie Wysycki?

Fact: Littleton did not kill Wysycki. Question: Who did?

He stepped back. Not much help. Yet. He grabbed a different color and began scribbling random questions.

Who were Littleton’s partners? How did he contact them? How did they gain access to the school? All the people he’d seen walk in the front door were among the victims, so the killers had to be already waiting inside. Had they used the back entrance? If so, did they bribe someone to leave it open? How did they gain access to the security system? Did they work at the school? How did they know Wysycki? Why her? A random choice, or because she had access to drugs? Did they provide the drugs, or did she?

Another color. This time he focused on the crimes. Each scene felt personal; they knew the victims or, at the very least, wanted to see them suffer. There were voyeuristic and sadistic components to all the crimes, especially the PXA Jacob had been given after he’d already been beaten to a pulp. A
coup de grace
, knowing it was fatal and that he’d suffer until the minute he died.

He circled the word
personal
. Littleton or his partners had to be involved with their victims. How? Part of the NA group? Involved with Wysycki? Other cases with proxies?

That brought him up short. Before his transfer to the Advocacy Center last month, he’d worked Major Cases for years and had never seen or heard of a crime similar to this. Sure, he’d had suspects claim that someone else had done the crime or someone had made them do it, but never this weird power game of a group of men forcing someone else to act out a crime.

The level of commitment, coercion…hell, the risk. He could see it happening if they’d killed Littleton and Tymara with that first crime, but to let them both live for seven long months? It made no sense.

A third color. This time bright red. Was Tymara supposed to die seven months ago? If so, how did her not dying change things?

He read and reread his question. If Tymara had died, they’d have had nothing but a circumstantial case against Littleton. In fact, if anything, Littleton could argue that all the evidence against him—his prints, his DNA, his semen—pointed to a consensual sexual encounter. Why would he tie her up, duct-tape her mouth and eyes, and brutalize her
after
he’d already gotten what he wanted?

Not to mention the evidence that there was more than one perpetrator involved in the second assault. Evidence that came from Tymara’s recounting of the event and the size of the bruises left by their hands, not evidence that could actually identify the men. Which any good defense attorney would have also used, arguing that if Littleton was smart enough not to leave evidence during that second assault on Tymara, why didn’t he simply get rid of the evidence from his previous sexual encounter with her?

Soooo…Littleton
had
raped Tymara. They had her testimony that it was not consensual. Although if she had died, it would have boiled down to Littleton’s word alone. But had he called in a partner or partners for the second attack?

Or was he, like he said earlier at the jail, coerced into involving his partners, this Brotherhood? What blackmail threat was strong enough to keep a man silent during seven months of jail time? If his partners were that powerful, why not just kill him? The jail was overcrowded, easy enough to get to him inside. Or post his bail and take care of business once he was released.

Why all the drama? Littleton’s silence as they hammered at him to give up his partners. Tymara’s murder today.

And then there was tonight. Littleton leading Ryder to the school. Forcing him to act as his alibi witness. Thumbing his nose at Ryder and the criminal justice system like a petulant child.

Childish
. That was the word. This didn’t feel like the intricate, masterfully plotted scheme Littleton had suggested. Seriously? A brotherhood of power players that preyed on lesser criminals?

He’d almost believed it. Except for two things. Any “brotherhood” that would allow Littleton, the blue-collar skivvy-pervert exterminator, to join its ranks would not be the rich, powerful, well-connected elite of Cambria City. And even if this Brotherhood did exist, why had their only crimes been a botched rape-attempted murder and then today’s headline-grabbing, well-orchestrated killings? If crimes had personalities, these were as different as night and day.

He stepped back from the board, rapping the marker against his teeth as his vision blurred the colors from both sides into a collage. Not a fraternity. A pair. One impulsive screw-up, Littleton. And one compulsive planner, able to patiently wait seven months and put all the moving pieces together.

They knew each other. More than that, they trusted each other.

If he was right, then who were the men who attacked Jacob? Thugs hired by Littleton or his OCD partner? What was the point after he’d already staged the massacre at the school? Could be the partner had a grudge against Jacob just like Littleton did.

Grudge.
That word felt right. Petulant. Childish. Tit for tat. Winners, losers. Tag, you’re it.

A game.

He wrote the words, drew a bold box around them.

Players taking turns. First, Littleton’s impulses got the best of him and he attacked Tymara, called his partner to help clean up the mess, and together they’d attacked Tymara again, the game’s opening move. Only they’d screwed up, leaving Tymara alive to go to the cops.

Then his partner had to wait until Littleton was freed for his turn. He’d helped things along by killing Tymara.

Were they keeping score? Ryder couldn’t bring himself to write the odious question on the board. Instead, he kept following the emotional entanglement, trying to make sense of the chaos.

Littleton had chosen Tymara. Which meant Wysycki had also been handpicked. Her role in the school massacre was designed to torment her in the worst way possible, to degrade not only her life but her memory after she was killed.

Torment. Pain. Stripping her of control.

He grabbed his phone and dialed the ME. “Any results on the tox screen for Sylvie Wysycki?”

“Just preliminary. Final will take two to three weeks.”

“What did it show?”

“Scopolamine, Rohypnol, and PXA, same as her victims.”

“Maybe they weren’t her victims.” Ryder hung up. These actors wanted to take credit. That’s why they hadn’t been content to allow Wysycki die like the others. She’d been the true target—he needed to find out why.

Rossi’s theory felt right. Someone had been there, in the room, watched the poison take effect, given the orders for the victims to rip off their own faces—probably after Wysycki had been isolated and restrained, forced to watch, powerless to do anything, writhing in pain. And once they knew there was little to no hope of anyone surviving, they’d finished Wysycki by slicing her throat and firing the shot designed to bring Ryder running.

Wysycki’s name would forever be associated with the poisonings, tabloid headlines, doomed to become an urban legend.

Worse than humiliation.

Tymara’s rape and murder had the same feeling of overkill. Personal.

He spun to the computer on his desk, not bothering with the chair. If they were that close, odds were Mr. No-Name Brother-In-Crime would be in the system, linked to Littleton. Known associate, arrested together. Someway, somehow, there’d be a trace. More than that, there’d be a path connecting Mr. No-Name with Wysycki, just as there was a connection between Littleton and Tymara.

Now all he had to do was find it.

DEVON DROVE US
over to the restaurant the Lees managed for Kingston Enterprises. I thought of their grandson and the other sick kids from the Tower. It seemed like ages ago that I’d met them, but it’d only been a few hours. “I can go with you to the clinic, help sort things out with Louise,” I offered.

“That would be helpful. A lot of these parents are uncomfortable with authority figures.”

I’d noticed that tonight, but they trusted Devon, opened up with him there. He was younger than most of them, yet they treated him with the reverence of a father figure.

“We’ll meet at the clinic at eight o’clock,” he said.

“There’s no way I can get you an appointment that soon.” I was thinking maybe I could convince Louise to give up her lunch—or Tommaso’s.

He said nothing, simply raised an eyebrow in my direction. “Who said anything about an appointment? I show up with a dozen kids, their distraught parents, and the Kingston checkbook, who’s going to do a damn thing about it?” His grin flashed in the headlights of oncoming traffic. “I never much cared about money before, but have to admit, it’s kind of fun always getting what you want just because of your father’s name.”

“Yeah, well, don’t let it go to your head. All that money didn’t do Daniel or Leo much good in the end.”

“That’s my point. I’m going to do a lot of good with it before it’s me lying in that big old bed, waiting to die. I can promise you that, Angela.” He touched my arm to emphasize his point. “Starting with nailing the bastards who did this.” He meant Jacob.

We pulled to the curb. The lights in the restaurant leaked through drawn blinds, hiding the occupants waiting inside. Devon was relaxed, but I let him go first—this was his territory, his game. I was only there to help get information from Littleton. And to help ensure that no one ended up dead.

As we approached the door, Gena Kravitz opened it, the light from behind her silhouetting her body so she appeared even taller than she was. “My client has asked to speak to you in private,” she told Devon, ignoring me.

The restaurant was empty, but all the lights were on, making the red leather booths and gaudy oversized paper flowers appear forlorn and abandoned. She waved to a booth halfway down the wall where Littleton sat, glaring at us like a child waiting outside the principal’s office. “I’ll wait here, out of earshot but ready to advise him as necessary. He will not be leaving with you, and I have the police on speed dial if you attempt to threaten him in any manner.”

All this was directed at Devon. An expression flitted across his face, and I knew he wanted nothing more than to drag Littleton down into the privacy of the tunnels and beat the truth out of him. Which is exactly why he’d brought me. He knew I would never let that happen, as much as I was tempted.

We joined Littleton in his booth. I was in the corner, Devon on the end where he could quickly leave or react to any threat. Ryder always positioned himself that way as well.

Littleton bounced in his seat. “Gena told me what happened. With that lawyer and all. I just want to be clear up-front. I had nothing to do with anyone getting hurt.”

How quickly he’d forgotten Tymara. And the people at the school. I dug my fingernails into my palms, wishing they were claws. “Of course not,” I said, my voice sounding shrill. “It wasn’t you. Just the four goons you or your so-called Brotherhood sent to beat up Jacob.”

“Angela.” Devon’s tone was a warning. I raised my hands in surrender.

Devon sat up straighter, the table between the two men suddenly becoming inconsequential. He said nothing. Didn’t have to.

“Look, you gotta understand.” Littleton rushed to fill the silence. “I had no choice. I never would have done that to Tymara, let them hurt her like that, if I could’ve stopped it. And no way would I have hurt that lawyer. That’s just asking for trouble. I’m a lover, not a fighter. Check my jacket. Ain’t no collars for anything violent.”

Devon’s glower erased Littleton’s simper. Littleton jerked his head in a nod, like a marionette, acquiescing to Devon’s unspoken threat. “Right, right. I got it. You want to know about those jerks in the Brotherhood. They think they’re so tough, bossing people like me around, ruining our lives.”

I noticed it was solely his ruined life he was worried about. My fingers curled into fists, and I marveled at Devon’s restraint. I wasn’t a violent person, but it was taking everything I had not to hit Littleton, give him a small taste of what Tymara and Jacob and the others had suffered because of him.

“See,” he continued, “they were watching me, knew about my girlfriends.” Translation: stalking and tormenting innocent women. “They caught me with Tymara. Told me if I didn’t give her to them, they’d send the video to the police. What choice did I have? I had no idea they were going to do that to her—I loved her and she loved me. But,” he shook his head in sorrow, “they made me their bitch. After they were done, they said it was up to me to keep her from talking because I was the one the cops would find all the evidence on.”

Littleton glanced up at us, looking at each of us in turn, his expression earnest. I glared back at him, not buying any of his oh-so-convenient story. Funny how he’d never mentioned a video before now. And what exactly had the Brotherhood caught him doing?

“I knew they wanted me to kill her,” he went on, “but I couldn’t, I just couldn’t. So I talked to her, explained things, told her I’d protect her if she only kept quiet. She said she would.” His anger broke through. Not for the first time, I wondered if he had a mood disorder, given his volatile emotions. “Bitch lied. Gave me up to the cops. I didn’t kill her, but she got what she deserved.”