Authors: Brenda Jagger
One night at Thornwick it ebbed far enough to provide a moment of destiny, one of those small vital lapses into what may afterwards be seen as great folly or great wisdom, one of those short half-hours or less which can change, sometimes in one direction, sometimes in another, the whole course of lives.
The black marble bath was not quite big enough for two and so, whenever the day had been long and hot, they bathed quickly, separately, Benedict usually first, Claire second since it was then, in the expectation of making love, that she prepared herself with the sponges and creams, the paraphernalia of caution and commonsense which she kept, carefully wrapped and disguised, in his bathroom cabinet. But this evening, meeting her in the bedroom doorway as he came from the bath, finding her undressed and waiting her turn, he did not move aside but stood for what seemed a long while looking down at her intently, examining her body in a manner which suddenly embarrassed her.
She spoke his name in enquiry. He shook his head, dismissing, denying whatever had been in his mind and then, very suddenly, as if the thought had refused its dismissal and come rushing back again, lifted her onto the bed and, covering her body with the greater strength and heat and weight of his own, filling her nostrils with the particular scents of his skin and hair which could only be Benedict, began the slow process of possession to which she surrendered at once, until the memory of her contraceptive gadgetry still reposing in his bathroom cupboard caused her a thrill of alarm.
âDarling â I have to go to the bathroom â'
âAh yes â Doctor Marie Stopes is waiting is she?'
Yet still he held her.
âBenedict â?' Her voice, to her own ears, sounded small and bewildered.
âYes. I know.'
âThen let me get up.'
âYes.' But he continued to make love to her, his recklessness â and when had he ever been reckless in his life before? â producing no further alarm in her as it should have done but a warm, rapidly stirring excitement: a glow of wonder.
âShall we take the risk just once, Claire â and see?'
Had he really said that? She wound her arms around his neck and kissed him slowly, taking time as well as pleasure, because she wanted to think about it, to bask for as long as she could in this perilous, tantalizing madness. For of course it
was
madness. Wonderful and incredible but totally insane.
Her struggle, throughout her adult life, had been against pregnancy not towards it, but now, flooding her awareness, came his entirely primitive, entirely natural male desire to fertilize, as an act of perfect union and possession, his chosen woman. Of course he would not do it. But by allowing her to see that he desired it, he had given her a treasure. She would always remember it.
âOh Lord â what am I doing?' she said.
âLoving me.'
Yes. That was it. Loving him. And hazarding her future, as she had always done, on an act of chance or fate, risking herself, once again, on a throw of the dice and making the best she could, afterwards, of the way they fell. Loving him Trusting him. Giving herself in full. A mood of absolute abandon possessed her, going beyond sensuality, beyond all desire for such refinements as orgasm to a basic and far more primitive need. He wanted to make her pregnant. Her body was aching now and greedy to conceive. She had never, in her whole life, been so touched by madness, so aware of danger yet dazzled by what she recognized and continued to think of, long afterwards, as glory. And it was the glory that mattered. She belonged now entirely to him yet, at the same time, she had never felt so totally in possession of herself. She had agreed, by this act, to belong to him. She had consented. They had chosen to be together. All that remained to be decided now were the practicalities.
âLie still,' he said and she obeyed him, curled warmly against him while his seed completed its journey through her womb weaving, beyond any question, the irrevocable pattern of their lives. It was the seed, she realized, which would decide.
âHave we gone crazy, Benedict?'
âVery likely. One learns odd things about oneself. I ought to be ashamed, I suppose.'
âI suppose so. I ought to have stopped you.'
Hearing the clock chime she got out of bed feeling strange and shy, a little unreal, and, holding her for a moment in what seemed a delicate embrace, he began to dress her very carefully and thoroughly, fastening every button, smoothing every fold, tucking her into her clothes and keeping her warm as if she herself had been a helpless, precious child.
The night had turned cold. He buttoned her coat, turned up her collar, wound his scarf around her neck, clicked his tongue in indulgent reproach because she had no gloves, tilted her chin and kissed her lightly on her nose and her forehead while she leaned, against him, weak and dizzy with this new depth of emotion. And, still safe in her sweet and wonderful madness, she believed that she was already carrying his child.
âIf you are so careful with me now,' she said, still leaning against him, still safely and warmly insane, âhow will you treat me in six months'time?'
And, his mouth against her hair, he made, gravely and precisely, his first and only declaration of love.
âI will look after you, Claire, and cherish you as much as I possibly can. It will be a great deal.'
Yet the folly, was not repeated. And when, after two weeks of suppressed agony, she was able to tell him that she had not conceived, she understood that they had reached the end. The sweet madness had become an act of gross irresponsibility for which â once he was quite certain that there would be no consequences for her to bear â he now felt able to apologize.
There seemed no longer the remotest possibility that he would ever lose his reason in that way again. They had taken their gamble. Had they won or lost? It made no difference now. He was going to Italy in a week or two with his sons to encourage their taste for pictures and statues and grand opera. Nola, just possibly, would go with them. Claire smiled. Yes. She hoped so. Quite definitely it would befor the best. And, as for herself, she would stay in Faxby until Polly's wedding at the end of September, and then � Well, as they had so often remarked, the world was full of opportunities for an independent and not precisely dull-witted woman. She would find plenty to do.
They were very careful with one another now, elaborately courteous, so anxious to be helpful and co-operative and never â in any circumstances â to blame or criticize each other for anything, that their reticence was sometimes deeply moving, while at others it grated on their nerves.
They no longer made love. This too, they both hastily and frequently agreed, was for the best. For if she had not conceived by intent on that strange wild night, it did not follow that she could not conceive now, by accident. The following âFamily Sunday' which now invariably included Roger Timms, also brought Elvira Redfearn to High Meadows at Benedict's invitation, her presence in his car that night preventing him from being alone with Claire. Yet the next time they were alone together, when he took her to Thornwick to collect the odds and ends which Mrs Mayhew could easily have packed and sent on to her, she was aware not only that he wanted her but that if she moved only half a step towards him, he would not resist.
But she experienced no feeling of power, nothing but a deep, damp sorrow clinging to her like seaweed, slowing her down as she went to the bathroom for her toothbrush, the bedroom for her black silk nightgown, her wispy
lingerie,
her perfume and powder, her discreet little embroidered wallet of contraceptive sponges and creams, all the essentials of a love-affair which, when hastily bundled together, did not even fill a small bag.
It was over. Five minutes to pack it away, zip up her bag, and go. She sat down on the bed, feeling the room around her, remembering almost to the point of seeing and hearing herself and Benedict together here, tense sometimes and often anxious, so often in that aching state of half-happiness, of not quite daring to be happy, that terrible sense of time lost, time running out, which had been the most unbearable of all.
They had been cruelly, mistakenly right for each other. Only the time had been wrong and the location; and the crowding demands of others. Left alone together they would have been perfectly and deeply content. He would have filled her life. She would have warmed and broadened and delighted his. In a world of half-unions and decaying unions, half-commitments and unwilling commitments, of falling standards and failing virtues, they could have been whole together, honest, and sound.
âI will look after you and cherish you as much as I possibly can. It will be a great deal.'
What a monstrous waste. What a criminal squandering of time which ought never,
never,
to be squandered; what an unpardonable throwing away of life and of the love which was its greatest privilege. She had seen too much of that. The door opened. âAre you ready, Claire?'
âYes.' She got up, feeling light and faintly unsteady, a note or two out of tune with herself, unable to remember just where she had put her bag. Yes â there it was, at her feet. She would never come here again. Somehow she must make herself believe it. She smiled, held out both her hands to him and, lifting her off her feet and onto the bed again, he made love to her like a man in deep water struggling for air, her body unresisting, passive, while he raged over it and then, his needs spent, shuddered and turned his back to her with a long sigh.
It had been for both of them a terrible experience, an act of extreme compulsion beyond any control she had ever learned to exercise and beyond his entirely, it seemed. He had not intended it and now, as in their first days together, he had turned away from her, leaving her alone.
âBenedict â' She had not expected him to answer her.
She had eased his bodily tensions, his inbred guilts and remorse so many times after making love with little more than the soft pressure of her fingertips. Dare she touch him now? Gingerly she reached out a hand, feeling the muscles of his shoulder contracting hard and rigid beneath her pahn. âLeave me alone,' he snarled and she drew back her hand as if his skin had burned her.
He got up without a word, dressed, went out of the room and after a while, her head and her bones aching, her skin sore in patches, hot in others, she put on her clothes very neatly she thought when one considered how badly her hands were shaking, and followed him.
He was sitting by the great stone hearth, no fire in the grate, the lamps unlit, the room, without its familiar illumination of jewelled glass, the glow and crackle of pine logs burning, looking shadowy and vaguely sinister, feeling chill, giving her the uneasy impression of a stage set when the audience and the players are gone.
This was not the house she knew. Nor the man. Or had the house ever been more than an illusion which had now lost its point and its purpose, which he was just too weary now to create?
Had
she
done this to him?
He did not speak to her.
âAre you blaming me?' she said, sitting down in her usual place by the burned-out fire.
âYou?' He looked up, hard-mouthed and stern, although his contempt, as it turned out, was not for her. âOf course not. I have been at fault in every respect from the start. You have done nothing against your nature, Claire. I have violated everything I have ever valued in mine.'
She heard him and understood. She knew exactly what he meant. But all she saw, with the shock of knowing she ought to have seen it much sooner, was the greyness in his face, the loss of colour and energy and substance.
âBenedict, you're not well are you?'
âNo.' He seemed surprised that she thought it necessary to ask.
âWhat is it?'
âMy disease?' He shrugged. âOf the mind, I suppose. One could call it irresponsibility, indecision, self-disgust â the inability to do what I know to be right. One could call it loss of faith, in myself and my own judgement â or loss of control. A damnable set of symptoms for a man like me. Loss of resolution. Misery. Take your pick. But I rather think â¦'
He paused. And when he spoke again his voice seemed to be rising from a chasm. âI think that it will very likely â. No, Claire, I think
you
are killing me.'
She heard her own breath catching somewhere in her chest, a startled strangled sound, soon over, and then, folding her hands, she bowed her head a little and sat quietly, back straight, ankles neatly together, with nothing more to say or to do, with nothing to hope for and nothing to offer him now but the strange gift of her absence.
âDon't you know what has happened to me?'
He had not said, âDon't you know what you've done to me?' But she understood.
âI was not unhappy when we met. I was not happy either. Few people are. I had everything I wanted, or everything I allowed myself to want, which amounts to the same. I was â
satisfied.
I don't expect to be satisfied again. But what I must do is function. It is essential to me â imperative. Perhaps you will believe me if I tell you that without that ability I am like a child in the dark. And I am not functioning, Claire. Because of you. I am not as I intend â and must â and wish â to be.'
He was speaking through clenched teeth, painfully, the effort beading his forehead with sweat, the veins at his temples swollen and blue, his voice still rising to her from a hollow distance. âI can't resist you, Claire. And I doubt if you can comprehend how much that appals me. Please â
resist me.
If you force me to go on like this, then I believe you will break me. I know you don't want to do that.'
The possibility had never occurred to her. The danger â of discovery, of disgrace â had always seemed to be hers. The likelihood of heartache had seemed hers too. But now ⦠âI will look after you and cherish you as much as I can.' He would have kept his word. It was much too late for that. Too late even for the blue room at High Meadows. And it was her nature to heal, not to hurt. She closed her eyes, clasping her hands tight together, bowing her head still further, as she took into her mind the stark knowledge of how much she had hurt him. âYou have done nothing against your nature,' he had said to her. But by wounding him, by reducing him to this despair, she too had violated everything within herself she valued. She had believed love, any kind of love, to be a blessing, well worth the price one had to pay. Or the sacrifice. But she had loved him and harmed him.