Authors: Ian Douglas
“A suggestion, sir?”
“Go ahead.”
“The cuttlewhales are . . . electrical in nature. So are we, of course, but not in the same way. Humans generate what is essentially weak electrical currents through chemistryâÂthrough exchanges of positive or negative ions at neural synapses or in muscle fibers, for instance. That's what we're reading with an EEG or an EKG.
“But cuttlewhales seem to work because of actual electrical currentsâÂmoving electronsâÂthroughout their bodies. I don't know how that would work, but the ferroelectric effect of the Ice IX strands would support a fairly high voltage.”
“Great,” Hancock said. “Not only can they crush us, they can electrocute us! Is that what you're saying?”
“Probably not
that
much voltage, Gunny. But enough to create a pretty strong electrical field in the water. Especially in saltwater. I haven't analyzed it yet, but I suspect that Abyssworld's ocean is pretty salty.”
Salts, I thought, would be spewed into that ocean through volcanic vents. The minerals I'd detected inside the cuttlewhale sampleâÂthe sulfur and all the restâÂproved that there were a
lot
of other elements in the ocean, even though there was so much of it.
“What's your point, Carlyle?” Walthers asked.
“Our most important senses,” I replied, “are vision and hearing, okay? Cuttlewhales live in absolute darkness. They probably rely on soundâÂI like your idea about them being attracted by the sonar pulses, by the way, sirâÂbut they might also rely on the electrical sense.”
“Electrical sense?” Walthers asked. “What's that?”
“Some animals on Earth can sense electrical fields,” Ortega explained. “Or they can passively sense other animals moving through them. Electric eels can do this, for instance. Sharks and rays. Certain dolphins. Even a funny little animal called the platypus. It's called
electroreception
, and it's as important to those animals as any of our senses are to us.”
“If cuttlewhales can detect electrical fields,” I added, “maybe that's how they communicate. Not by sound . . . or not entirely, but by modulating electrical signals in the water.”
“That,” Montgomery said with feeling, “is
brilliant
!”
“I wonder if Selby and his Âpeople on Europa have thought of that,” Ortega said. He laughed. “You need to write that up in a paper, Carlyle. Publish it in the
Journal of Exobiology
. I think you're onto something big here. . . .”
“Well, we need to detect those signals first,” I said. The sudden burst of attention from the two scientists was a bit embarrassing.
“Easy enough to do,” Ortega said. “We have a submarine . . . a means of approaching a cuttlewhale in its own environment.”
“Dr. Ortega, you have got to be crazy!” Walthers exclaimed. “You saw what they did on the surface. . . .”
“Our entire reason for making this journey,” Ortega said, “was threefold. We were to look for Sub-Âzero survivors, to rescue them if necessary, and we were to attempt communication with any intelligent Abyssworld inhabitants. At this point, I submit, we are still oh for three. Young Carlyle, here, has shown us a means of improving our score.”
“It seems unlikely at this point that we will find survivors from the base,” Walthers pointed out. “And I have the safety of the ship and passengers to consider.”
“Ortega's right,” Garner's voice said over the electronic link. “I thought Marines were supposed to
fight
. . . not turn tail and run!”
“I object to that, Chief,” Kemmerer said. “We are here to provide security for the operation, not involve ourselves in pointless bloodshed.”
“ âVisit exotic, distant worlds,' ” Garner said, “ âmeet strange, alien life forms . . .' ” He laughed, a chilling sound.
Visit exotic, distant worlds, meet strange alien life forms, and kill them
. . . .
I decided that the chief's arm was hurting him. It was a joke dating back in a slightly different form to pre-Âspaceflight days. It did an injustice to the Corps, I thought, maintaining the ancient and vicious fiction that Marines were only interested in killing.
It's true that they are very, very good at killing, certainly. But another ancient adage referring to the Marines holds that while there are no worse enemies, there are no better friends.
“Lieutenant Kemmerer?” Walthers said. “What do you think about returning to the surface? Or trying to contact cuttlewhales?”
She shrugged. “The Marines will go where you send us,
Captain
,” she said. She emphasized Walther's position as ship captain, rather than his rank of lieutenant. Until Summerlee returned to duty,
he
was the one with the final say. Not the Marines, not the doctors, and not the science and technical staff.
“D'deen? D'nah?” Walthers called, raising his voice. “You are the closest we have to xenosapient experts on board. What's your opinion?”
T
H
E
G
Y
K
R
A
R
E
A
R
O
G
U
E
I
N
T
E
L
L
I
G
E
N
C
E
,
D'deen wrote, from a rogue world between the stars. T
H
E
Y
D
O
N
O
T
F
O
L
L
O
W
.
Â
.
Â
.
Y
O
U
W
O
U
L
D
C
A
L
L
T
H
E
M
.
Â
.
Â
.
T
H
E
R
U
L
E
S
.
T
H
E
Y
M
A
Y
H
A
V
E
THEIR OWN MOTIVES
F
O
R
A
T
T
E
M
P
T
I
N
G
C
O
N
T
A
C
T
W
I
T
H
T
H
E
N
A
T
I
V
E
A
B
Y
S
S
A
L
L
I
F
E
.
W
E
S
U
B
M
I
T
T
H
A
T
Y
O
U
M
A
Y
W
I
S
H
T
O
E
S
T
A
B
L
I
S
H
S
U
C
H
C
O
N
T
A
C
T
F
I
R
S
T
.
“I'm more concerned about the Gykr as a military force,” Walthers said slowly, “than I am about talking with the native life. They
will
be back. The question is when. What do we do about that?”
“Not really a major problem, sir,” Garner said. “If we land at a different area . . . build a nanomatrix habitat, then we could keep
Haldane
in orbit. With nanoflage on the outer surface of the base, the Guckers shouldn't see us if they do show up . . . and it
is
a damned big planet. If they show up,
Haldane
could run for Earth, maybe come back with reinforcements. And we stay on the planet and try to talk to Carlyle's electric whales.”
My
electric whales.
But most at the table agreed then, that trying to communicate with the beasts was vitally important. The Gykrs had turned it into a race.
We would stay.
And we would try to make contact with the locals.
Â
H
aldane
touched down once again on the icecap about twelve kilometers from the former site of Murdock Base. We used robotic vehicles to unload about forty tons of rawmat onto the ice and spread it out in a thin layer. RawmatâÂraw materials for nanotechnic constructionâÂis a balanced mix of basic elements: iron, aluminum, silicon, copper, gold, carbon, tungsten, and a dozen other elements in powder form to give it the greatest possible surface area. The most critical problem was keeping all of that fine-Âgrained powder from being blown away by the blustery winds gusting out of the west. We managed that by mixing the stuff with water as it came out of the robots' hoppers. The water froze and nailed the rawmat down in a thin, black carpet over the ice. Nanobots don't care if their raw materials are loose, or frozen inside solid water.
Once the powders were down, we released a few trillion nanobots programmed for materials construction, beamed them an architectural plan, and in about two hours they'd grown our new base from the component atoms. On Earth, we build four-Âkilometer-Âtall towers of spun glasstic or ferrocrete from the carbon, hydrogen, silica, and metals right there in the dirt and rock of the construction site. The only native raw materials here, though, were the oxygen and hydrogen of the water ice, plus some traces of carbon and nitrogen from the CO
2
, CH
4
, and NH
3
in the atmosphere or trapped within the ice. When the main dome was up, though, we used drilling bots inside to tunnel down through the ice to reach the seawater below, and were able to reach quite a few more elements dissolved in the water.
We began manufacturing the base's interior gas mix then. The oxygen came from the water, of course . . . but the nitrogen was tougher, since the only source we had for N
2
was the ammonia that made up about 3 percent of the planetary atmosphere. We grew the atmosphere processing machinery for that, and seasoned the mix with three hundred parts per million of CO
2
. As counter-Âintuitive as it seems, too little carbon dioxide in the bloodâÂa medical condition called
hypocapnia
âÂcan be as bad as too much.
We continued to wear breathing masks inside the base for a time, however, just to be on the safe side. There was a danger, a small one, that toxins or organic molecules had been mixed in with the surface ice, and we were taking no chances with toxic fumes or anaphylaxis. The base atmospheric regulators would continue to scrub the gas mix until we were sure there was no chance of contamination.
While some of us worked on making the new facility habitable, another team from the
Haldane
melted a hundred-Âmeter-Âwide hole in the ice outside, extending it to connect with the open water beyond the edge of the icecap.
Haldane
lifted on her spin-Âfloaters and slowly lowered the
Walsh
from her cargo bay and into the dark water.
Walsh
, with her compressed-Âmatter construction, was designed to fly through the water, rather than control her depth with ballast tanks. To keep her from sinking as soon as they dropped her into the water,
Haldane
's Âpeople had rigged her with quantum floaters that were kept running continually, holding the
Walsh
steady at her moorings.
By that time, we were putting the finishing touches on the baseâÂone large dome with four smaller subsidiary domes evenly spaced around the perimeter. After laying down an airlock cylinder extending some distance from the main hab dome,
Haldane
was able to pull up several million liters of water and dump it over the outside of the facility, letting it freeze in uneven masses to disguise the regular and artificial look of the place. A molecule-Âthin film of specially programmed nanoflage went over that, breaking up the outlines and bending incoming light in order to create the illusion of completely natural pressure ridge.
If the Gykr came by now, they wouldn't be able to see us.
We spent another five hours transferring tons more rawmat off of the
Haldane
and into both the hab modules and the submarine. This was mostly carbon, raw material for the nanufactories on the sub and in the base. Combined with hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and numerous trace elements taken from the sea and atmosphere, this would become our food supply for the next several months. If
Haldane
had to abandon us, we would be on our own for at least a month before she could return with reinforcements.
Quite apart from that, however, it would take time to descend into the depths. Sierra Five was at a depth of around a thousand kilometers. With a maximum descent rate of around ten meters per second, it would take us a bit less than thirty hours to reach Sierra Five. If we wanted to venture into the
real
depths of Abyssworld, though, it was going to take a whileâÂmore than twelve days to descend eleven thousand kilometers, and longer to come back up.
The chances were good that we would not be going that deep . . . and the experts weren't even certain that
Walsh
would survive such a dive. But we would need to take plenty of food along just to be on the safe side. Fortunately, air and water were easily enough pulled from the surrounding ocean.
The
Walsh
was large enough to carry seven ÂpeopleâÂten or twelve if they were
very
friendly. How many of us would actually be descending into the abyss was yet to be determined.
And that was the purpose of our final meeting on
Haldane
's mess deck, a few hours before we would be ready to make the descent. Eleven of us were in physical attendance this time, and quite a few more were virtually present, listening in over the ship's computer Net. The three Brocs were on-Âline . . . and so was Chief Garner, who was still recovering from his burn in sick bay.
“Doc! How is the captain doing?” Walthers asked with no preamble.
“We're bringing her up out of deep sedation,” I told him. “That'll take a Âcouple more hours. Aside from that, she's fine . . . but we don't have the medical tech on board
Haldane
to deal with her prosthesis failure.”
“You mean we have to get her back to Earth.”
I nodded. “We could give her a rough-Âand-Âready implant, the sort of thing we'd do for someone who'd lost all connectivity with a bad accident or something like a severe stroke. But for full function, she'll need to have her implant traced almost molecule by molecule, and a lot of it will have to be dissolved, then rechelated as new circuitry.”
That kind of work was incredibly delicate and fussy, not the sort of thing you want to try in the field at all. Fortunately, there was no need. I knew Walthers was uncomfortable being in command, but he could run the ship until we got the captain back home.
He sighed. “Okay. I guess I'm it. What about Kirchner?”
That was a tougher question. Kirchner had been worrying me more than anything else in the department. Before his final break, I'd been doing more private research, trying to plug in psychiatric symptoms. For a while, there, I'd begun wondering about Asperger's disorder, and the AI had been throwing that out as well. I'd doubted that diagnosis, however. Asperger's is part of the autism spectrum, tends to have a gradual onset, and is characterized not only by problems with social interaction but by restricted patterns of interests or behavior as well. And though we don't know yet what causes Asperger's, it appears to be a developmental problem, probably with genetic roots. You're not likely to develop it at 108.
Which had brought me back to schizophrenia. That diagnosis had been looking unlikely as well. He had the problems with social responsiveness and interpersonal dysfunction, but there'd been no sign of the usual disorganized thinking or speech. And we couldn't get inside his head to tell if he was delusional, truly paranoid, or suffering from auditory hallucinations . . . the “voices in the head” so characteristic of the disease. Besides, classic schizophrenia usually begins manifesting before the age of 30, not in old age.
But then he'd gone and pulled a gun, used the gun, and started spewing word salad.
That pretty much confirmed the schizophrenia diagnosis . . . but not completely. Damn it, we were still so
helpless
in the face of psychiatric pathology. Broken legs, epidural hematomas, even a spinal fracture . . . that stuff is child's play compared to figuring out what's gone wrong inside a person's mind.
“The doctor,” I said, “is in a tube down in Medical. We'll be keeping him in a deep coma until we can get him back to Earth for proper treatment.”
“Yes, but what's wrong with him?”
“Our provisional diagnosis is paranoid schizophrenia . . . but I need to emphasize that that's
provisional
, meaning we're really not sure. His genome shows none of the usual markers predicting that disease, he has no family history or personal record of either schizophrenia or schizoid personality disorder, and those diseases are just not that likely to come out of nowhere.”
“Does it make a difference?”
“In his treatment, yes. Of course it does.”
“But not in how we care for him until we get him home.”
“No, sir.”
No, the difference it made had to do with me and my mind, not Kirchner's. I was still kicking myself for not having picked up on his illness sooner. Dammit, I hated that kind of responsibility . . . having the training to spot something like that and failing to pick up on the clues that were there. The real problem was that diseasesâÂespecially mental illnessâÂsimply didn't present a one, two, three listing of signs and symptoms. The human body and, even more, the human mind, were incredibly complex, and they steadfastly resisted being shoved into narrow little boxes with labels on them.
And just maybe that's why I wanted to leave the relative safety of the
Haldane
for the uncertain but deadly darkness of Abyssworld's deeps. While I'd be there in case someone got hurt, of course, my real purpose would be as a science technician, taking readings, running the nano programming, and just maybe getting to meet a new intelligence in the deeps.
“So,” Walthers said, “we need to make some final decisions on sending the Walsh into the Abyss.”
“Why do we need to send
anybody
?” Gunny Hancock demanded of the group. “We have Double-ÂR-ÂEss twelves. We can teleoperate them from here.”
It was a valid point, at least within limits. On Niffelheim-Âe, I'd helped teleoperate a small submarine into the depths of that ice world's ocean . . . and lived to tell about it when something the size of a city flattened the robot against the underside of the ice. The RRS-Â12 was a basketball-Âsized teleoperated submarineâÂthe alphabet soup stood for remote reconnaissance submersibleâÂrunning on the end of a hair-Âthin fiber-Âoptic cable.
“Yes,” Montgomery said, “we can. But if we have the opportunity to actually meet the whales . . . or whatever is behind them, don't you think we should do it in person?”
“But what's the point?” Chief Garner asked. “I mean . . . seriously. If the person making contact is locked up inside a twenty-Âmeter CM cigar, he's not exactly going to be able to step outside and shake hands or tentacles or whatever, right? Not at those depths.”
“There's another issue too,” I pointed out. “A practical one. I think the maximum cable length on an RRS is . . . what? Something like fifty kilometers? Beyond that, we wouldn't be able to control them.”
Radio signals do not propagate more than a few meters through water before they're absorbed and lost. Blue-Âgreen lasers can penetrate perhaps a hundred meters of crystal-Âclear water before they're lost. Sonar can be used to teleoperate remotes, but it doesn't pack anywhere near the information density of electromagnetic radiationâÂradio or light. Besides, there was the possibility that the cuttlewhales were angered by our sonar.
Remotes like the one I'd piloted beneath the ice on Niffelheim-Âe were tethered to their base by fiber-Âoptic cables transmitting laser light, signals carrying electronic commands from the base to the probe, and returning sensory data. They worked quite well . . . but even cables as thin as a human hair were limited in how long they could be grown before they broke under their own weight. Sierra Five was more than a thousand kilometers down, well beyond range of a cable-Âdirected remote.
“He's right,” Ortega said. “If we're going to go down there at all, it
has
to be in person.”
“We could take along a small fleet of Double-ÂR-Âesses,” Lieutenant Kemmerer suggested. “Remote-Âoperate them from the
Walsh
.”
“
If
we can do that without compromising the
Walsh
's hull integrity,” Lieutenant Ishihara observed. “Under tons of pressure per square centimeter, the slightest weakness in the hull would be fatal.”
“So how many of us are going?” Lieutenant Kemmerer asked. “The
Walsh
is big enough for eightâÂmaybe tenâÂÂpeople.”
“We could manage fifteen or twenty if we're
very
friendly,” Montgomery said. “Food, water, and air supplies won't be a concern, since we'll be making our own as we go.”
“But do we need that many?” Walthers said. He shook his head. “I'm with Gunny Hancock. I'm still skeptical about this whole idea.”
“Right!” Garner's voice said over our in-Âheads. “Paying a personal visit may be a luxury we can't afford.”
“What
luxury
?”
“A suicide mission, of course. How many lives can we afford to throw away?”
“It won't be suicide,” Montgomery told him. “And there are way too many opportunities for misunderstanding if we try to make contact long distance.”