Awkwardly Ever After (3 page)

Part of me couldn't believe that anyone would fall for his lines, especially at a small high school where everyone knew
exactly
what you did last summer because they were probably there with you—or they knew someone who was. Maybe that explained his sudden interest in me, though: He was expanding his dating pool to include freshmen because he had already hooked up with everyone else.

Or at the very least dated everyone else's best friend, thereby invoking the Girl Code. Although I suspected plenty of girls would be willing to overlook the code for a shot at Spencer King. And that an equal number of girls felt gut-wrenchingly foolish when he launched into his whole
I don't do serious relationships speech.
Everyone at Smith High School knew about his talk, and yet somehow heartbroken girls still ended up crying in bathroom stalls while they crossed out the hearts they had drawn around their linked names.

Dylan's
smile, on the other hand . . . yeah, his name was something worth etching into the ugly chipped blue paint on the stall doors.

Not that I ever would.

Probably.

“I don't care if other girls would be interested in him. I need you, Izzie. Please say you'll go with me.
Please
.”

She picked up her pace and pretended to consult an imaginary watch. “Oh, will you look at the time? I've got to—”

“One night, Izzie. We'll watch a stupid movie with them and then head to your house for our classic Sunday night sundaes.”

“I don't want to go.”

I shoved back a strand of long brown hair that had somehow found its way into my mouth. “But you'll do it, right? For me?”

Izzie groaned. “You owe me one for this. And you better believe that I'll be collecting.”

“Deal! You're the best, Izzie!” I fought the urge to do a celebratory fist pump as other students began swarming the hallways around us. Instead, I did an abrupt turn and hurried against the flow of traffic in the hallway, pausing only to call over my shoulder. “The absolute best!”

But not even the promise of Izzie's stalwart presence lessened my panic when my phone vibrated with a text message from Mackenzie.

Which meant that not only was I going to be avoiding the advances of a smug,
I can get any girl I want
jock; I'd also be stuck navigating around the one guy I wanted but couldn't have.

Just freaking great.

“L
et's go over this one more time. If I start coughing . . .” Izzie glanced around the parking lot outside the high school as if she expected Logan to appear at any second and whisk us away to Mackenzie's house. “Then I change the subject.”

“And if I glance down at my watch?”

“I explain that we should probably head to your house because we promised your mom that we'd help her paint the living room.”

“Right again. Okay, last one.” Izzie shoved her glasses higher up her nose as she waited for me to spit it out. “If I say, ‘Oh, hi, Dylan? Fancy seeing you here.' ”

She screwed up her face in mock concentration. “Let's see . . . I call the cops and hustle you out of there, right? Or do I take it all the way to the feds?”

“You're hilarious. Now answer the question.”

“I pull you out of there by any means necessary. We've been over this, Mel. I've got it. You're not exactly asking me to solve Fermat's Last Theorem here.”

“Okay, I'm going to pretend like I know what that means.” I took a deep breath as I felt anxiety begin creeping up my back, one vertebra at a time. “You know, if you could come up with a few brilliant ideas for a preemptive escape, right now would be a great time to share them. So . . . feel free.”

Isobel lowered her voice as Mackenzie approached the pair of us. “Don't you think you're blowing this out of proportion? It's a movie with some friends. How bad can it get?”

Oh, I don't know . . .
nuclear fallout bad!

Hey, it could happen. Theoretically . . . I decided not to mention it, though. The last thing I needed was to be on the receiving end of another one of Izzie's
are you actually saying that out loud?
looks.

“Hey, Isobel!” Mackenzie said, conveniently interrupting our conversation as she drew within speaking distance. “Are you meeting up with Sam?” She swiveled around as if expecting to see the most unconventional of our mutual friends come striding over in a fifties style dress and a pair of motorcycle boots.

Izzie shook her head. “Nope, she's in detention. Again. I don't think she'll be free to hang out for a while. As in, she might stage a jailbreak in time to catch the tail end of this year's graduation. Maybe.”

Mackenzie grinned. “What did she do this time? Oh wait, let me guess . . .”

“Did she toilet-paper the principal's office?” I suggested.

“Maybe she submitted a strongly worded letter to the editor for
The Smithsonian.
” Mackenzie pursed her lips thoughtfully. “I wouldn't blame her. The article Lisa Anne wrote about her was total crap. Then again, the only people on the staff of our school paper who would give Sam even an inch for a rebuttal is Jane.
Maybe
Scott. And since Jane's focused on getting her fiction publication up and running, and Scott's primary interest centers around his camera . . . I can't see that happening anytime soon.”

I was just grateful that Jane had seemed to mellow out around me. Maybe it was because Mackenzie and I had bonded so quickly post-YouTube video and Jane's nose got a little out of joint, but I'd been getting a serious
back away slowly
vibe from her for weeks. It was only when Scott began dogging her every move that she'd eased up around me.

Probably because her photographer boyfriend was keeping her preoccupied.

A guy who
wasn't
related to our mutual best friend.

Some girls have all the luck.

I quickly tried to move the subject away from Jane. “Maybe Sam vandalized the boy's locker room with anti-rape pamphlets?”

Mackenzie positively lit up as she yelled, “I've got it! Sam was busted trying to organize a protest for prom! Now she's stuck making glittery signs for the school dance during detention.”

Izzie shook her head, but I could tell she was enjoying our little guessing game too. “Um, none of the above, actually. She was caught passing out condoms in the hallway.”

“
Again?
Either she needs to mix things up a little or she needs to get a whole lot sneakier.” I crossed my arms. “She's going to get suspended soon.”

Izzie merely shrugged. “That's up to her, Mel. She told me yesterday that she has no intention of letting abstinence-only education send her fellow classmates out into the world with an inadequate understanding of sex. So . . . I'm guessing she's not going to be easily swayed from her mission. Although I'll be sure to mention all of these suggestions to her; I bet she'll love them.”

“They weren't really intended as suggestions,” Mackenzie pointed out, but Izzie's smile only widened.

“Uh-huh. Yeah, you can try explaining that to Sam. Let's see how far you get.”

I doubted Mackenzie would even make it a foot. Our school principal could personally attest that when Sam cared about something, she would go to great lengths to take a stand, even if that meant forming a one-woman picket line or roping us into joining her.

We'd be the ones stuck making glittery signs . . . about various means of contraception.

“So, if you're not waiting for Sam . . .” Mackenzie let her voice trail off, probably because she realized halfway in that it might sound as if she didn't want to be involved in Izzie's plans. “Um, do you want to come to my place? We're just getting together to watch a movie, but I'd love to hang out. If that works for you.”

Mackenzie might have a habit of sticking her foot in her mouth, but at least her heart was always in the right place.

“Izzie would love to join us,” I announced, just in case she tried to weasel her way out of it. “Isn't that right, Iz?”

“Um . . . right. I'd love to join in,” Izzie parroted back weakly, and I knew that I was the worst friend ever. When it was just the two of us, Izzie was all snarky and self-confident, but with most other people, she sort of crawled into her shell. The shoulders would go up, her glasses would be adjusted, and my brilliant, sarcastic friend would shrivel up into a little ball. And even though Mackenzie on her own might not produce the full hermit effect, the addition of the two hottest juniors on the Smith High School hockey team definitely would.

If the roles had been reversed, Izzie wouldn't have pulled me into her mess. She would have faced the freaking
gallows
alone, nervously pushing up her glasses the entire time, but on her own nonetheless. She never would have roped in anyone else along the way.

I should have let her back out.

But Izzie's chin was jutting out, and despite a rigidity in her shoulders that hadn't been there before, it looked like she really wanted to do this. Okay, she didn't
want
to do it, exactly. More like she felt she had something to prove to herself.

I was selfish enough to feel relieved—and proud. Really freaking proud of my best friend for pushing beyond her normal comfort zone.

“Are Jane and Scott coming too?” she asked Mackenzie.

“They can't make it. Something about the school paper. Again.”

Izzie looked disappointed and I felt a quick surge of guilt. Jane and Izzie were no longer just bus buddies with a casual friendship created by a mutual desire not to sit alone. That had all changed when Alex Thompson, the biggest jerk at Smith High School—one who made Patrick look like nothing more than a vaguely irritating moth—ridiculed Izzie's weight in front of everyone in the school cafeteria. He'd been under the impression that neither of the girls would protest too loudly.

He had been wrong about a whole lot of things that day.

I would have given anything to see his expression as good-girl Jane Smith hauled back and slammed her fist right in his face.

Actually, I would've given anything to be there five seconds earlier so that I could have beaten Jane to the punch.

But I had been stuck trying to come up with a good explanation for Mrs. Paralov as to why I'd been late for her class eight times that semester without mentioning the fact that each morning my daily ritual included making sure my dad wasn't still so drunk from the night before that he was unable to drive me to school. Or that my dad insisted he was merely coming down with a case of the flu when the binge the night before left him with a particularly nasty hangover.

Yeah, I had no intention of mentioning any of that.

Which was why I was stuck making evasive,
mm-hmm
noises and promising to be more punctual while Jane Smith was defending my best friend.

The only part of that catastrophe that I witnessed was the aftermath. The way Isobel spent the next few weeks listlessly moving her food around with a fork instead of actually eating it. Izzie still wouldn't be caught dead at the ice skating rink. Not when that would only increase the risk of encountering Fake and Bake (Mackenzie's rather fitting nickname for two of the most popular girls in school) along with a whole horde of their Notable cohorts.

Izzie barely managed to curl her mouth into a lackluster excuse for a smile when she spotted Spencer and Logan walking right toward us. We both knew that she wanted to jackrabbit out of there. I subtly nudged her with my shoulder in what I hoped passed as a silent show of support, while I mentally reviewed the game plan one last time. Isobel's advice had seemed so simple earlier.

Distract him with a bet or a dare—some kind of feat to prove his manliness—he'll probably forget you even exist.

Brilliant in theory. A whole lot harder in execution with Spencer grinning broadly at the three of us. Especially since I was already smiling back, and not because I had any interest in flirting with him either. There was just something infectious about him. Maybe it was knowing that we could have been ninety-year-old nuns and the megawattage wouldn't have wavered an iota. Spencer was a natural charmer who enjoyed putting everyone at ease with a few casual jokes. Well, everyone except Izzie. She only appeared more tightly wound than ever as she shoved her glasses higher up her nose.

“Hey,
Melanie,
” he said, not even trying to disguise how impressed he was with himself for remembering my name. Then again, for all I knew, the golden boy had enough girls in rotation to make my head spin. “How's it going?”

“Um, fine. Have you met Isobel?” I practically shoved my friend forward in my haste to distract him. “She enjoys, um . . . reading, solving difficult math problems, and—”

“Long walks on the beach?”

I grimaced. So much for playing it cool and keeping it casual. I was introducing Izzie as if she were entering a pageant. An absurd image of my best friend strutting over to a raised podium in a bikini had me fighting not to laugh. Izzie would rather take her finals three times in a row than enter one of those competitions.

And she would probably come up with some incredibly brilliant way to avoid the thing completely even if someone tried to railroad her into it.

Izzie glared at both of us and her chin jutted up ever so slightly. “She likes the beach just fine. But you know what she
really
enjoys? Speaking for herself—without using the third person.”

Spencer blinked in surprise, probably because he had written her off the instant she had fiddled with her glasses instead of making eye contact. His smile kicked up at one end, revealing a dimple that should have been at odds with his bad-boy reputation. The slight tinge of pink I noticed flushing Izzie's cheeks also made me wonder if maybe she was enjoying herself after all.

That fleeting thought probably jinxed everything.

Because any trace of good humor—in Spencer, Izzie, Logan, or Mackenzie—vanished as soon as Fake and Bake, better known as Steffani Larson and Ashley McGrady, rounded the corner and locked their sights on our little group.

“Okay, can we move this to Mackenzie's place?” Technically, it was a question, but Spencer didn't give any of us an opportunity to refuse before he began hustling us toward the parking lot. “Now. Move it along right now.”

“But I was going to—”

“Keep walking, Mackenzie,” Spencer ground out, “one foot in front of the other.”

Logan rolled his eyes at his best friend. “Running scared already, Spence? Prom isn't for another two weeks. If you can't deal with this now, how do you expect to handle it when things really heat up?”

“Later.” There was nothing even remotely resembling a smile on Spencer's face now. Nothing in his eyes except deep frustration, and if I wasn't mistaken, a dash of panic as well.

It answered one question of mine, though: Spencer had definitely lied about his leadership abilities the day before. If the guy was half as good at exerting his will on others on skates as he was on foot, he would have no trouble keeping his teammates in line. One gruff order from him and the four of us were instinctively fleeing from the two reigning queens of evil.

“Almost there,” he murmured encouragingly. “We're almost there . . .”

Mackenzie twisted, probably hoping to see if the Axis of Evil were drawing close, lost her balance, and tripped. One second she was keeping pace with the rest of us and the next . . . not so much. Logan was instantly kneeling on the pavement next to her.

“You okay, Mack?” His voice was soft with concern, although I thought I detected a hint of amusement in it too. “Need a hand up or are you, um, practicing yoga again?”