Die Twice (19 page)

‘She died from a single wound,' I said, not mentioning anything about the mutilation.

‘Why?' The question hung in the air for what seemed like a long time. ‘Do they know, these people who commit these terrible crimes? Do they know the hurt they cause? To the ones who are left behind?'

I ached for a cigarette but knew without asking that this would be a non-smoking household. ‘I think,' I said, ‘that most really don't have a clue of the suffering they inflict. If they did, I'm sure a lot of them would think twice before doing what they do.'

‘And do you think that this man … the one who killed my Miriam … do you think he knew what he was doing?'

I thought suddenly about the families of the customs officers and the accountant. I knew what I'd been doing. Had always known. ‘I'm not sure, Mr Fox. It could well have been a spur-of-the-moment thing.'

‘It doesn't matter. People like that should be put down. Like dogs.' Maybe he had a point. ‘I never believed in the death penalty. I thought it was barbaric for a society to put to death its citizens, whatever their crimes. But now … now…' His face, still only visible in profile, was contorted with a terrible frustration. ‘I'd pull the trigger myself. I really would.'

Before I could give him my standard police spiel that these feelings were understandable but ultimately counter-productive, Mrs Fox thankfully returned with the tea. Fox slipped into a sullen silence. Doubtless he'd been venting his spleen to her in similar vein all week. She sat down at the opposite end of the room to her husband so that we were between them, and poured the tea from a china teapot.

‘The reason we're here,' I said, thinking that I really didn't have a clue what it was, ‘is to update you on what's happening with the inquiry, and let you know what'll happen now that we've arrested someone.'

‘Who is the man who's been charged?' asked Mrs Fox.

I told her who he was and what his relationship was to their daughter, careful not to give away too many details. Pre-trial, police officers have got to watch what they say in case they blurt out anything that might prejudice a fair hearing for the suspect.

‘You think he's the one, then?' she said, when I'd finished.

‘Bastard,' Fox added, with a violent snarl. Mrs Fox gave him a reproachful look, though she must have felt the same.

It was a good question. I was 50 per cent certain at best. Malik, from the conversation we'd had on the way down, was closer to 80 per cent. Like Knox, he couldn't see any viable alternative, which made drawing conclusions easier for him.

It was Malik who answered. ‘We're very sure it's him, Mrs Fox. As sure as we can be. There's substantial physical evidence linking him to the scene of the crime.'

‘Good. I don't think I could stand an acquittal. Not on top of everything else.'

‘We can't predict the future, Mrs Fox,' I said, ‘or juries. We can only do our best. But I think the case is very strong.'

‘Bastard,' said Fox again, still not looking at us. I think he meant Wells, but it was difficult to tell.

‘Mark Wells will spend a considerable part of the rest of his life in prison if he's found guilty, Mr Fox,' Malik told him. ‘And we're going to do everything in our power to make sure that happens.'

‘It's not enough. No prison sentence is good enough for him. Not after what he's done.'

It was, I thought, amazing how socially liberal people like Labour councillors soon changed their tune on crime when it actually had an effect on them. At that moment, Fox looked to be only a couple of steps away from becoming a Charles-Bronson-type vigilante, although without the guns or the menace. Or, it seemed, the energy.

Mrs Fox looked across at her husband and gave him a brave smile. ‘Come on, Martin. We've got to stop trying to be so bitter. It doesn't help.'

Fox didn't say anything. I took a sip of my tea and decided to try to finish this interview as swiftly as possible. But before I could continue my spiel about how there was going to be a long wait for the trial and how we would keep in touch regularly in the meantime, Mrs Fox suddenly burst into tears.

Malik and I sat there respectfully. Fox continued to sit in exactly the same position he had been in for the previous ten minutes, staring at an ill-defined point somewhere in the middle distance. I thought he was being ignorant. I know he'd had an immense trauma, but sometimes you've just got to be strong.

‘I'm sorry,' she said, dabbing her eyes with a handkerchief. ‘It's just…'

I put on a stoic smile. ‘We understand. You've had a terrible loss. You've got to let it out.'

‘I know. That's what the counsellors have been saying.'

‘Don't worry about us,' said Malik.

‘You know,' she said, looking at both of us with an expression of disbelief, ‘it's such an awful, awful waste. That's the hardest part. When you think what she could have been. What she could have achieved if only she'd stayed here with us … people who loved her. Instead she ended up dying such a lonely and degrading death. Why?' This was the second time that question had been asked this morning. ‘Why did she have to run away and leave us like she did?'

‘Leave it, Diane!' snapped Fox, swinging round in his seat and fixing her with a rage-filled stare. Malik and I looked at him, surprised at the violence of his outburst, and his features relaxed a little. ‘Just leave it. There's no point going over this again.'

But Mrs Fox clearly had matters to get off her chest. ‘Do you know, in the three years she's been gone she never once tried to make contact with us? Not once. Not even a call to let us know she was all right. Nothing. Do you have any idea how that made me feel?'

‘We have evidence to suggest that Miriam was taking quite a lot of hard drugs,' I said. ‘Sometimes that can take over a person's life to such an extent that they lose track of what their priorities should be. Maybe that's what it was like for her. It doesn't mean she didn't care. It's just that the lure of the drugs may have been stronger.'

‘She could have called, Mr Milne. Just once. If not for our sake then for her sister's. Chloe was only twelve years old when Miriam left. She could have contacted her.'

‘Leave it, Diane. Please.'

‘No, Martin. I've suffered as much as you. I should be allowed to say my piece.' She turned to us again. ‘I miss Miriam terribly. I have done since the day she walked out of this door. I loved her more than anything I can describe, but that doesn't detract from the fact that what she did was unforgivable. To put us all, the whole family, through three years of living hell. That was … it was so selfish. I loved Miriam, I really did. But she was not a nice person. I'm sorry to have to say it, I really am, but it's true. It is, Martin. It's true. She was not a nice person.'

‘Shut up! Just shut up!' His voice reverberated around the room, the slack, hollow face now fiery red with emotion.

‘Calm down, Mr Fox,' I said firmly. ‘Your wife's just trying to speak.'

‘She doesn't need to say that. She doesn't know what she's saying. It's our daughter you're talking about, you know…' He faltered, slapped his head in his hands, and began sobbing loudly.

Mrs Fox stared at him for some time, her bottom lip quivering as she fought for control over her emotions. For a moment, I thought I saw a hint of contempt in her eyes, but I couldn't be sure. The atmosphere was thick with tension and I could see that Malik had sweat forming on his brow. It had been a difficult few minutes, but this was what the job was all about. This was what we were paid less than double-glazing salesmen for.

I broke the silence by briefly explaining the process for the next few months: the magistrates appearance today, the pre-trial preparations, the possibility of adjournment, et cetera, but I didn't think either of them was really listening. They looked lost; beaten by the whole thing. Fox had taken his head out of his hands, but once again he declined to look in our direction. Finally, I put my empty teacup on the table and asked them if they had any further questions.

There was a long pause.

‘I don't think so, Detective Milne,' Mrs Fox said finally. ‘Thank you both for coming.'

We all stood up, including Fox, who looked as though he might fall back down at any time.

‘Is there anything else you need?' I asked them both.

‘No, we're receiving plenty of support from family and friends, and we've had some counselling.'

‘Good. It's important you talk to people about your feelings.' I looked at Fox when I said this, but he looked away. ‘It helps.' This was bollocks, of course. It didn't. Recovery comes from within, not from people who don't know you.

They both nodded, and we all shook hands again. Mrs Fox turned towards the door, then suddenly turned back towards us.

‘One thing,' she said. ‘You never mentioned the reason why this man … why he killed Miriam.'

Malik got the answer in first, which was probably for the best. ‘As DS Milne mentioned, the suspect hasn't admitted his guilt yet, so we're not entirely sure. However, since there were no signs of sexual assault, we believe it was the result of an argument between the two of them. Probably about money or drugs.'

She shook her head. ‘It seems such a petty reason to end someone's life; to destroy every dream they've ever had.'

‘There are no good reasons for murder,' said Malik. ‘They all leave the same amount of pain.'

She managed a weak smile. ‘I think you're probably right.' She led us out to the front door and stopped in front of it. ‘Thank you both for coming. It's very much appreciated, I promise you. Even if it's not that obvious. And I do apologize for getting so emotional. It's very difficult…'

We both told her once again that we understood entirely. With that, the door opened and we were out of there.

There was a pub a few miles down the road and we stopped for a drink and an early lunch. It was empty. We ordered our drinks from the bored-looking landlord and took a table in the corner.

‘What did you think of it in there?' Malik asked, sipping his orange juice.

I knew what he was getting at. ‘I detected a bit of an atmosphere and I got the feeling that maybe Mr Fox felt a little guilty about something.'

‘Yeah, that crossed my mind. Do you think, you know, anything ever went on between him and Miriam?'

‘It happens. It happens in a lot of families, rich and poor. And I suppose it would explain a lot: like why she went away in the first place, why she put up with a life as an underage prostitute, why she never made contact with them. But we might be completely wrong. I get the impression she was a difficult kid anyway. Anne Taylor called her a real bitch when she was talking about her, and not even to phone your mum or your sister through all that time…'

‘It makes me think that maybe now we've got a motive for Wells. If she had that sort of difficult personality, and it looks like she did, then she could easily have had a major falling-out with him.'

‘It's possible.'

‘Maybe he thought he was being clever by making it look like a sex crime.'

‘It's certainly a viable theory.'

‘But you're still not convinced?'

I sighed. ‘Not entirely, no.'

‘There's a lot of evidence building up, Sarge.'

‘Yeah, there is, but there are unanswered questions too. Stuff that puzzles me. Like why Wells came back to the flat.'

‘Maybe he's just thick. Plenty of criminals are.'

I told him about the phone records. ‘It looks like she and Carla had at least five conversations in the last weeks of Miriam's life. What I can't understand for the life of me is why Carla would pretend not to know her, when it's clear she did. Not unless she had something to hide.'

‘And you think it might have something to do with the murder?'

I shrugged. ‘I don't know. All I know is that I don't like unanswered questions, and I don't think there's an innocent explanation for it.'

‘I told you there was something dodgy about her. I could see it right from the first minute. So, what do you intend to do about it? There's no way Knox is going to want any extension of the inquiry. Not now he's got Wells.'

‘I'm going to go and see her, Asif. Make some excuse why we need to talk, then spring it on her.'

‘Are you sure that's the reason why you want to see her?'

I gave him a withering look. ‘It's definitely the most important reason.'

‘Well, let me know what you find out. Although, I still think it was Wells who did it.'

Our food arrived. A tired-looking ploughman's lunch for me, a chilli con carne that bore more than a passing resemblance to dog food for Malik. The landlord gruffly ordered us to enjoy our meals, although I didn't think there was much danger of that.

‘Don't say anything about this thing with Carla Graham to anyone else,' I told him, taking a bite of stale bread. ‘Capper got wind that I was getting the phone records off Hunsdon and he told me to leave it alone. I don't want to give him any more ammo to fire at me. Not now he's the boss.'

‘Don't worry, I won't say anything.' He spooned down a few dollops of chilli, then looked at me seriously. ‘You know, I thought it was bad them making him acting DI instead of you. You could do that job one hell of a lot better.'

‘It's all politics, Asif. If you play the game, you go places.'

‘Then why don't you play the game, Sarge? Forgive me if I'm speaking out of turn, but you're wasted at DS level. You should be running murder investigations, not just being a little cog in them.'

I forced down a fatty lump of ham, then pushed the plate away. I wouldn't have enjoyed that meal if I hadn't eaten for a week. ‘I play it,' I said, lighting a cigarette, ‘I just don't play it with the same enthusiasm any more, now that the rules are always changing.'