Read Editors on Editing: What Writers Need to Know About What Editors Do Online
Authors: Gerald Gross
Editors
on Editing
What Writers Need to Know About What Editors Do
Completely Revised Third Edition
Copyright © 1962, 1985, 1993 by Gerald Gross
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the publisher, except by a reviewer, who may quote brief passages in a review. Scanning, uploading, and electronic distribution of this book or the facilitation of such without the permission of the publisher is prohibited. Please purchase only authorized electronic editions, and do not participate in or encourage electronic piracy of copyrighted materials. Your support of the author’s rights is appreciated. Any member of educational institutions wishing to photocopy part or all of the work for classroom use, or anthology, should send inquiries to Grove/Atlantic, Inc., 841 Broadway, New York, NY 10003 or [email protected].
Published simultaneously in Canada
Printed in the United States of America
Due to limitations of space, copyright acknowledgments appear on page 379, which serves as an extension of this copyright page.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Editors on editing : What writers need to know about what
editors do /
[edited by] Gerald Gross.—3rd ed.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references.
eBook ISBN-13: 978-0-8021-9468-8 (pbk.)
1. Editing. 2. Editors—Correspondence. I. Gross, Gerald.
PN162.E36 1993
808′27—dc20 92-29806
Designed by Deidre Amthor
Grove Press
an imprint of Grove/Atlantic, Inc.
841 Broadway
New York, NY 10003
Distributed by Publishers Group West
To unsung editors everywhere,
past, present and future:
May these pages sing your praises
To published and unpublished
writers everywhere:
May these pages guide you
to a better understanding of the art
and craft of the editor
My thanks and deep appreciation to all the editors who stole precious time from their crowded days and nights and gave so generously of their talents by contributing such splendid original essays to
Editors on Editing
. Editing editors is a high-wire-without-a-net exercise in delicacy and diplomacy; therefore, I also want to thank the contributors for responding with such grace under pressure to my editorial suggestions.
For their advice, counsel, and recommendations of editors to invite to contribute to the book, I want to thank (in alphabetical order) Carole Abel, Richard Curtis, Anita Diamant, Mitch Douglas, Joyce Engelson, Herman Gollob, Bert Holtje, Gerald Howard, Evan Marshall, Ruth Nathan, Ms. Bobbe Siegel, Ted Solotaroff, Bill Thompson, and Tom Wallace.
(My apologies to anyone I’ve forgotten to mention, but be assured that my
heart
remembers
everyone
who helped—even if my memory does not.)
For sharing my vision for
Editors on Editing
and making important contributions to the focusing and realization of that vision, I thank my dedicated and creative editor, Bryan Oettel.
For his intelligent, perceptive, sensitive, and, yes, even affectionate copy editing, I thank my copy editor, Ed Sedarbaum. His skill has orchestrated this anthology of thirty-nine different voices into a mellifluous chorus of clarity and coherence.
Finally, I thank my best friend and beloved wife, Arlene, for the support and encouragement she has given me in this and each of my other endeavors for over thirty-six years.
All essays have been written especially for this collection except those prefaced by an asterisk (*)
.
P
REFACE
: Reflections on a Lifetime of Editing
BY
A
LAN
D. W
ILLIAMS
The Evolution of the American Editor
BY
M
ARC
A
RONSON
*An Open Letter to a Would-be Editor
BY
M. L
INCOLN
S
CHUSTER
*Are Editors Necessary? (revised for this edition)
AND
On the Decline of Western Literature
BY
R
ICHARD
C
URTIS
BY
J
OHN
F. T
HORNTON
*Breaking Faith: A Publishing Parable
BY
M
AXWELL
G
HERKIN
*Mistah Perkins—He Dead: Publishing Today (with a postscript for this edition)
BY
G
ERALD
H
OWARD
Doing Good—And Doing It Right: The Ethical and Moral Dimensions of Editing
BY
J
AMES
O’S
HEA
W
ADE
How Books Are Chosen: What Goes into Making an Editorial Decision
BY
R
ICHARD
M
AREK
What Editors Look for in a Query Letter, Proposal, and Manuscript
BY
J
ANE
V
ON
M
EHREN
The Editor and the Author at the Writers’ Conference: Why They Go, What They Do
BY
M
ICHAEL
S
EIDMAN
BY
M
ARTHA
K. L
EVIN
Editing for the Christian Marketplace
BY
J
ANET
H
OOVER
T
HOMA
Editing Books for the Jewish Market: A Commitment to Community
BY
B
ONNY
V. F
ETTERMAN
Developmental Editing: A Creative Collaboration
BY
P
AUL
D. M
C
C
ARTHY
The Copy Editor and the Author
BY
G
YPSY DA
S
ILVA
Line Editing: Drawing Out the Best Book Possible
BY
M
ARON
L. W
AXMAN
Line Editing: The Art of the Reasonable Suggestion
BY
J
OHN
K. P
AINE
The Role of the Editorial Assistant
BY
C
ASEY
F
UETSCH
Working with a Free-Lance Editor or Book Doctor
BY
G
ERALD
(J
ERRY
) G
ROSS
BY
C
HARLES
S
PICER
BY
R
UTH
C
AVIN
The Pleasures and Perils of Editing Mass-Market Paperbacks
BY
M
EL
P
ARKER
Editing Trade Paperbacks in Middle Age—Theirs and Mine
BY
M
ARK
A
LAN
G
OMPERTZ
Editing Nonfiction: The Question of “Political Correctness”
BY
W
ENDY
M. W
OLF
Editing Fiction: The Question of “Political Correctness”
BY
M
ICHAEL
D
ENNENY
Editing Scholars in Three Modes for Three Audiences
BY
J
ANE
I
SAY
Editing for a Small Press: Publishing the Way It Used to Be
BY
S
COTT
W
ALKER
Editing Fiction as an Act of Love
BY
F
AITH
S
ALE
On Editing Nonfiction: Multiple Majors in a University of Subjects
BY
F
REDRICA
S. F
RIEDMAN
Editing the Science-Fiction and Fantasy Novel: The Importance of Calling Everyone Fred
BY
J
OHN
W. S
ILBERSACK
BY
P
HYLLIS
J. F
OGELMAN
BY
L
INDA
H
ALVORSON
M
ORSE
BY
P
ETER
D
AVISON
Editing Popular Psychology and Self-Help Books
BY
T
ONI
B
URBANK
BY
L
INDA
M
ARROW
Editing Male-Oriented Escapist Fiction
BY
G
REG
T
OBIN
*An Annotated Bibliography of Books on Editing and Publishing