First Time with the Fraternity (2 page)

“Sorry,” Lexi said, with a sweet flutter of her eyelashes. “All of you, or none of you. That’s the deal. After all, a girl’s first time should be
special
.”

~~~

Tonight’s the night
, Lexi thought, slipping into a polka-dotted pair of panties and matching bra. They weren’t new, but she hoped they’d be sexy enough, and in any case, she hoped she wouldn’t be wearing them for very long. Then she put on a floral skirt, a pink sweater set, a pair of strappy sandals and a string of pearls—because she wasn’t exactly sure what else to wear to a defloration. 

She was so excited that the crotch of her panties was already wet by the time she hopped up onto the porch and rang the bell at the frat house. The party was already in full-swing, the big hall filled with dancing, beer, and cigarette smoke. A part of her worried that they didn’t remember she was coming, or that they’d forget the bargain, or that—

“Hey, kinky girl,” Drew said, coming up behind her and wrapping his arm around her waist. He pressed against the back of her and she was immediately reassured by the feel of his arousal. He was hard; she’d never felt a hard cock before, but feeling this one pressed into the small of her back nearly made her wilt.

“Hi,” she said, biting her lower lip.

Drew growled just behind her ear. “Why don’t you and I blow this party off and go upstairs—”

“Don’t even try stealing her for yourself, buddy,” Gabe interjected. “You drew the short straw, remember?”

The short straw? Had they
drawn straws
for her? 

Wouldn’t that piss her father off…

It was crude and vulgar, and yet, Lexi shivered with pleasure when Gabe put his hands on her hips. For a moment, trapped between both guys in the doorway, Lexi felt nearly faint with arousal. She barely knew them, but the fact that they were game to make her fantasies come true made her want them badly. The only thing that worried her was that she wasn’t going to get what she wanted. “So…how is this going to work?”

“Eager for a virgin, aren’t you?” Drew asked, his breath warm on her nape. 

Again, she wasn’t sure if Drew was pleased or not. But Gabe leered in a way that made his freckles bunch up on his nose. “Don’t worry, babe. You’re going to have a great time tonight. In fact, in the bathroom we’ve got a surprise to start you off. Open the second drawer.”

Lexi made her way past partiers with cups of beer in their hands, hoping she wasn’t just imagining the occasional sexually heated glances of fraternity brothers as she passed. Did they know who she was? Did they all want to fuck her? Just the idea of it made her crazy.

Inside the tiny bathroom, Lexi leaned against the door to catch her breath. Then she reached into the second drawer and found a little pink bullet shaped device with a note. The note said:

This is a wireless vibrator. Put this in your panties…if you’re wearing any. Then try to guess which one of us has the remote control.

Lexi’s body pulsed with the awareness that she was holding a sex toy. More importantly, she
was
a sex toy. Their sex toy. And the fraternity brothers obviously intended to play with her. 

The vibrator started buzzing against her clitoris the moment she tucked it into her soaking wet panties and walked out the bathroom door. Maybe it was tall and dark Drew who was doing it to her; maybe it was the grinning, ginger-haired Gabe. Maybe it was the third frat brother whose name she’d never even learned. Or maybe it was a guy she hadn’t even met. 

The thought nearly made her climax right there, her back pressed against the wood-paneled wall.

When she joined the party, someone gave her a drink. She was usually wary of drinking anything a stranger gave her, but the guys tonight wouldn’t have to slip her anything because she
wanted
to be taken advantage of.

So she drank it down. It burned all the way. It was booze, something else her father had forbidden her to have. She was only a freshman, so she shouldn’t be drinking, but the toy in her panties buzzed twice as fast as if to reward her for breaking the rules.

“Wanna dance, Lexi?” one of the frat brothers asked, sliding his hand to the small of her back. He was short, and stocky, and not her type, but the fact that he knew her name and might have the remote control to the toy in her panties made her attracted to him anyway.

“I’m not sure I know how to dance,” she said, worried that she’d be awkward. Fortunately, her body seemed to know what to do, her hips rolling to the beat, and she let the guy press close against her while she did so. She hadn’t ever danced with a guy before and it was heady to rub against his chest. Then she danced with another guy, and another, until her nipples were hard and her knees were weak. 

Boys were paying attention to her; she felt popular for the first time in her life. But when she stopped dancing, the toy stopped buzzing. 

“You don’t want to orgasm even before we get your clothes off, do you Lexi?” The question came from Gabe, who ran his hand down her side, then slid it over her ass, pulling her close against him as the rock music pounded through the frat house. 

She loved the way he just touched her any way he pleased. “You have the remote, don’t you?”

Gabe slicked back his red hair with one hand, and his grin evaporated. He stared at her a little more intensely than before. “What if I do?”

“Then…then I want to kiss you,” Lexi admitted, feeling the swirl of liquor in her head, but not so much that she wasn’t sure of her answer.

Gabe made no move to kiss her, but ran his thumb over her lower lip. “I’d like to kiss you, too, but you should save that for last. Because
you
get to choose who gets to give you your first kiss, Lexi. But tonight me and my brothers are all going to fuck you. And you’re not going to know which of us did it first.”

~~~

All of you, or none of you. That’s the deal.

She’d had no idea what she was saying when she threw down that condition. Oh, she’d wanted a wild sexual encounter with more than one man. But she’s secretly hoped that the man to take her virginity would be Drew. In chemistry class that week, she’d given him a heated glance over the top of her notebook and fantasized about his hands on her. 

But as Gabe led her downstairs to the basement game room where plaques and fraternity paddles lined the walls, she remembered that Drew had drawn the short straw. What did that mean?

A few guys hooted at her when she came down the stairs. One of them was just a sophomore—a baby faced kid who hadn’t yet grown into his gangly limbs. He looked at her like she was a piece of meat. She wasn’t used to any kind of attention, much less this kind and it made her unsteady. 

Lexi nearly stumbled down the stairs, but Gabe caught her by the arm and steadied her.
Oh, god
. Lexi gave a little bit of a start to see a cheap air mattress in the middle of the floor. For some reason, she’d always imagined she was going to lose her virginity in a bed. A real bed. Not a shabby air mattress covered by a sheet, surrounded by a dozen half-drunk guys. 

She almost backed up the stairs, having second thoughts, but Gabe was behind her, heat coming off his skin in waves. Meanwhile, Drew was sitting in the corner, a beer casually tilted in one hand. “Sure this is what you want, kinky girl?”

Drew might not be the first one she had sex with, but she was at least going to kiss him first, she decided. So she gave him what she hoped was a seductive smile, and nodded. “I’m so hot right now.”

“Yeah you are,” one of the frat brothers called out, with a whistle.

“Take it off, baby,” said another one.

With the eyes of a bunch of horny college guys on her, Lexi unbuttoned her sweater and slipped her skirt off. But once she was standing in front of them in nothing but her shoes, her polka dotted bra and panties, she froze. She turned and looked to Drew for help, but he coolly nursed at his beer, taking in the sight of her body. 

She wished she knew what he was thinking.

Gabe didn’t make her have to guess. “You’re so sexy, Lexi. In fact, I think that’s what we’re going to call you. Sexy Lexi.”

Some of the other guys took up the chant.

Sexy Lexi. Sexy Lexi. Sexy Lexi!

“Need some help?” Gabe asked, and when she nodded, he unsnapped her bra and her breasts tumbled free.

The guys loved that.

“Oh, yeah!” one of them cried. “That’s what I’m talking about.”

“Fucking A.”

“Aw, come on. She’s at least a B cup…”

Lexi squeezed her eyes shut, embarrassed, but too turned on to stop Gabe when his fingers went to her nipples and squeezed them. Good girls didn’t let guys do this to them; certainly not with an audience. Good girls didn’t like it. But Lexi didn’t want to be a good girl anymore.

Gabe clearly liked touching her. Pressed against her leg, she could feel his hard on. He was breathing fast, groping her as if he was doing it only for his own pleasure, and not for the amusement of his friends. Finally, Gabe hooked his thumb into the waistband of her panties and helped her step out of them. That made her have to catch the toy in her hands, still sticky with her own wetness. “You won’t need that anymore, Virgin Girl,” Gabe said as she squirmed at her own nakedness. “You’re about to get the real thing.”

It happened quickly after that. 

One of the other guys grabbed her arms while Gabe tied a blindfold on her. Then she felt herself being pushed down to her knees on the air mattress while the guys all cheered. “Get in there, get in there!” she heard one of them shout.

Before she could make sense of what was happening, someone flipped her onto her back, and pinned her. It wasn’t Drew. She knew this only because she heard his voice from somewhere farther away. “Hey, Lexi, spread your legs for him if this is really how you want to get your cherry popped.”

Some part of her thought things had gotten out of control. She’d put herself in a bad position. She was going to do something that she might regret all her life. The guy on top of her was unfastening his belt with one hand while holding her down with the other. 

“Wrap it up!” someone else said, and Lexi almost choked to realize that she hadn’t even asked about protection. She hadn’t even thought about it. She heard the sound of a condom wrapper tearing, and she wished she wasn’t blindfolded. She shouldn’t get a cock shoved into her before she’d even seen one or touched one with her hands, should she?

But every doubt, every fear, and every hesitation was crowded out by her own arousal when the stranger moved between her legs. He was going to take her virginity while everyone watched and she had no idea who he was. She’d hoped it would be Drew, but suddenly, she was more turned on by the idea that it might be a brother she’d never even met before.

She spread her legs wide for him, and then she was rewarded by the sharp, searing pain of a penis thrust up inside her. Her hymen broke on that one thrust and she let out a scream of pain, writhing underneath the heavy body atop her. But her scream was drowned out by the cheers of the fraternity brothers who erupted like the home team at a sporting match at their favorite player making a winning score.

The wrongness of it hit Lexi at once. She was naked in a room full of guys, one of whom was fucking her now, and in spite of the pain, it made her want to come. But the guy inside her came first. Two, three, four more strokes and he began to grunt, spurting his seed into the condom.

“Next!” someone shouted.

Lexi started to sit up, but strong hands shoved her back down, grabbing at her ankles to put her into position for the next guy. She felt another cock push its way inside her, this one thicker than the one before, and she realized she was going to come this time. She’d been close, before, because of the toy. But now as the mysterious man worked above her, driving her down into the air mattress, she wrapped her legs around his waist, and started to moan with an orgasm that rolled over her in shuddering waves.

The guys cheered even louder for that. “Yeah, she fucking loves it!”

She was not only naked and getting fucked with an audience nearby, she had orgasm for them too. She was the star of their own sex show. And she was loving it. 

“Harder! Give it to her good.” If the guys hadn’t been into it before, they were now. She could hear some of them undressing, encouraging each other. “She wants it, man. Look at the way her legs are wrapped around his waist. She
wants
it.”

The third guy to fuck her squeezed her breasts the whole time with his fingers, milking at her nipples, and sucking at them too. That made Lexi come again. The fourth guy flipped her over and pushed her head down to the mattress, making her take it deep, doggie style. By the time the fifth guy stroked into her, slapping her cunt with his sweaty balls on every stroke, she was starting to get sore.

She was too excited to admit it, but to keep her easy to enter, the guys would drizzle lube into her just before passing her on. The sixth or seventh guy told her to open her mouth, and next thing she knew, he was shoving his cock into her mouth. She’d never sucked cock before, and had to be told to cover her teeth with her lips, and to suck deep. It almost choked her, but she couldn’t stop because she was getting it from both ends, jostled between two guys, feeling total used.

And loving it.

She’d lost count of the number of guys who had fucked her by the time her blindfold slipped. Probably ten. And when it did Lexi was nearly blinded by the flashes of camera phones. 

Oh god
, they were filming her. She never said they could film it! But before she could protest, she found herself looking at freckled skin, and realized that she was straddling Gabe. “Sink down on me,” he instructed, and she lowered herself onto his long, curved member. It filled her deeply, like it was made to give her pleasure. She was ready to come for him right away, but he didn’t seem to be in a rush. She realized that he might have already fucked her before and, because of the blindfold she’d been wearing, she didn’t know. 

Either way, he gripped her hips hard and said, “Show us how you can fuck, Sexy Lexi. Ride my dick.”