Forgetting August (Lost & Found) (27 page)

“What is he doing here?” she seethed, her words barely audible from between clenched teeth.

“It’s nothing,” I said, frozen in place as I watched her eye him from across the room. “He just came to visit.”

“He came to visit?” she repeated, turning to me in horror. “And you allowed him inside?”

“Everly—so good to see you,” Trent smiled wickedly, making my fists clench greedily. I hadn’t tested out whether or not I liked making a good stiff punch to the face yet, and I was thinking Trent seemed like a good candidate to try that one out on.

“Why don’t you go upstairs and wait, while I say good-bye to my old friend,” I said calmly, even while rage and panic twisted and turned my gut, making me feel anything but calm.

She froze as my suggestion struck an obvious nerve. All I wanted was for her to be as far away from Trent as possible. I just wanted her safe. I always wanted her safe.

Seeing her standing so close to this man, bathed in fear, made me erratic. In my haste to protect her, her reaction told me I’d uttered the one thing that made her feel anything but safe.

“What did you just say?” she whispered, a tear already leaking from the corner of her eye. I could see her trust dissipating, receding as she took several steps back.

My gaze darted to Trent, who was watching our entire exchange with an expression of amusement painted across his fucking face. Then he focused solely on Everly as she backed away from us, his gaze slowly roaming up her body, and I saw red.

“Please, upstairs. Now.” She flinched at my harsh words, turning toward the door and running. I could hear her sobs echoing from the stairwell.

“I want you to leave. Get the fuck out of my house and leave,” I said, not bothering to look in his direction.

Trent walked to the slider and stopped. “I’ll have my secretary call you on Monday. Don’t disappoint me, Kincaid. You may not remember but I don’t take kindly to those who owe me a debt—even if that debtor happens to be a friend.”

“We are not friends.”

“We’ll see about that. Make sure you tell Everly I said good-bye—and take care of our girl…wouldn’t want anything to happen to her.” And then he disappeared inside. I listened for the front door to close before running up the stairs, two at a time to find her. I skidded to a halt in front of the master bedroom. It was the last place I expected her to be, but there she was, immobile as she stood beside the king-sized bed, looking down at the unfinished project I had yet to show her.

“What is all this?” she asked, focused on the black frames scattered all over the bed.

“A late birthday present. I wanted to give the room life again. When I took all the photos down and put everything in that box, the room lost so much. It lost its light. I just thought these would give it so much more.”

Her fingers traced the closest picture—a close-up of our faces as we kissed. The original portrait had been much more erotic, taken from one of the nights we’d photographed our lovemaking, but I’d cropped it because I’d loved her expression—the overwhelming need that seemed to consume her. That alone was eroticism.

“But why here? Why in this place?” she persisted, her voice distant and reserved.

“There were once good memories here. I want to make them again someday.”

Her eyes swept over the numerous frames, taking in the dozen or so pictures I’d picked of the two of us, before she silently moved around the room. Stopping at a bare spot on the wall, where the paint was slightly duller, she stared at the square where the last photo had rested. Tears began to stream down her face.

“You’re just like him. And I’m going to end up just like her,” she sobbed into her hands.

“No, no, we aren’t. We are what we make ourselves, Everly. Don’t you see that—our past has nothing to do with what we are today.”

“You’re wrong,” she cried, shaking her head. “It’s already happening. I can see it already beginning.”

She was pacing now, her eyes blazing as I tried to follow her rambling.

“See what? You’re not making any sense.”

“Why was he here, August? Tell me! What was Trent doing here?”

I opened my mouth to answer, but stopped short—my previous vow remaining true. I’d do anything to keep her safe. Even if it meant giving up my own future.

Even if it meant giving up everything.

“I can’t do that,” I said softly.

“Can’t, or won’t?”

“Does it matter?” I asked, feeling my heart falter with every false word.

“No,” she conceded, her gaze falling to the floor, like all of our hopes and dreams. “But I can’t be here if he’s back in your life. I won’t. That man singlehandedly ruined our life once already. I won’t stand around and watch him do it again.”

I simply nodded, accepting the fate I knew was sure to come. The fate I’d accepted the moment I realized I couldn’t protect her and claim her all in one breath.

What’s your girlfriend’s name again?
Trent’s cold words wormed their way back through my mind, making me suddenly very aware of just how similar I might be with my past self. Was this how the old August had felt? When he’d locked her away all those times? Was what he’d done really a desperate attempt to save her, rather than a sick plot to keep her in chains?

“Why are you doing this?” she asked. “Why would you trade everything we have just like that? Just like…before?”

I shook my head, hating myself. Hating that she truly believed I was choosing a life of power and wealth over her. “Sometimes it’s not about one or the other, Everly. Sometimes it’s just what’s meant to be.”

“There’s always a choice,” she said softly.

I watched her gaze around the room in silence, almost as if she was reliving pieces of the past. Each brush of her hand against the furniture felt like a good-bye. Every touch of her fingertips along the bed linens was a farewell. She was leaving and I wasn’t going to stop her.

No more shy smiles and coffee-flavored kisses. The memory of her skin would be nothing more than a ghost I wrestled with in my sleep. She would be gone. Forever.

How would I go on? How would I survive?

“Why do you think he did it? Locked me in here? Was it out of cruelty or some twisted fascination—”

“I think maybe he did it out of love,” I said, softly interrupting her, as I stepped forward and took her hand. I watched as she flinched but didn’t step out of my grasp. “I don’t think he ever stopped—how could anyone ever stop loving you?”

“Loving me destroyed you,” she sobbed, a salty trail running down her cheek.

“Loving you brought me back to life,” I corrected.

“But not for long enough.” Her eyes met mine as she tried to pull back.

“Love me one more time,” I begged, “Please.” I took a hesitant step forward as my thumb slowly skimmed her damp cheek. Her eyes fluttered closed and her breath faltered. It was exactly what I needed to know—she wanted this as much as I did.

I might be letting her go, but first I would drown in this love…this promise of so much more, for one more night.

Before reality set in and I lost her forever.

Pushing back fiery strands of her hair, I cupped her chin and kissed away her tears, which only made her lips quiver and fresh tears appear.

“I want to hate you. I want to push you away and scream and yell. I shouldn’t want this—I shouldn’t. But I do—God, I do. If this is my last few hours with you—this is how I want to spend them with you. What is wrong with me? We aren’t right, August. This isn’t right,” she cried, her face burrowing into my chest. “I’m so angry,” she sobbed.

“I know. I’m so sorry,” I said over and over, meaning it more than she could ever know.

“Take it away—take the pain away,” she begged, her gaze lifting to mine in a desperate plea for escape.

As my fingers dug their way through her hair, our foreheads touched and I found myself taking a deep breath as I silently asked whoever might be listening for strength. Strength to make it through the night with her body wrapped around mine, knowing it would be the last time. And courage to let her walk away the next morning, knowing she was walking away with my heart in her hands.

This wasn’t how this was supposed to end.

My lips met hers as I took my time kissing her, trying to memorize every single moment. Every moan, the color of her lips, the way she arched her neck when I pressed my body against hers—it soon would be all I had.

My life had been a never-ending quest into the past, and now it seemed, I would have only that.

Nothing but a handful of memories.

As my hands slid around her waist, I lifted her, feeling her strong legs wrap around me. Carrying her to the bed, I paused, remembering the photos scattered about. Knowing they’d only cause us pain later, I carefully sat Everly on the edge of the bed and began the task of making room. The photos I’d carefully exposed and printed fell to the floor in a heap, along with their custom-made frames.

They didn’t matter anymore.

None of it mattered.

All I had was this one night.

I ignored the fluttering sound as the photos fell and the frames clattered to the ground. My focus was solely on Everly. It had always been Everly.

Kneeling before her, my hands trembled as I drew her blouse above her head, letting it fall to the floor with the forgotten pictures. Her baby blue eyes met mine as she slowly undid the buttons of my shirt, one at a time, letting the tips of her fingers brush against my bare skin.

“I’ll always remember how this feels,” I whispered.

“Don’t.” She shook her head. “Don’t make promises. You never keep them.”

I didn’t say anything more, but I knew that it was one promise I’d never break. She’d branded me permanently. I may not have had specific memories of her when I awoke in that hospital room, but my soul and my body had known her instantly.

She might not be mine after tonight, but every piece of me would always belong to her.

Clothes were shed and as I joined her on the bed, I tried to commit to memory every single inch of her body. The soft curve of her hip, the scattering of freckles over her collarbone that reminded me of confetti, and even the winding tree branch that disappeared over her right shoulder.

My fingers instinctively traced the intricate tattoo, following it toward her back, where the birdcage hung. She turned, letting my hands lightly explore her skin.

“It’s time for this bird to fly, Everly,” I said softly. “It’s time for her to dream and explore and find her own path.”

Resting her head against the pillow with her eyes trained ahead, she asked, “But what if she’s too scared?”

“She’ll find her way. She’s stronger than you think.”

“I don’t know if you’re right about that. I once said I’d never shed another tear over you,” she whispered, her voice breaking as I held her in my arms for the last time. “I guess I don’t keep my promises either.”

She turned toward me, her eyes wide with doubt as I bent down and kissed away the tears, until our mouths fused together and no more words were spoken for the rest of the night. We lost ourselves in one another over and over, stoking the fire that would no doubt burn for each another until the end of time.

But sometimes love and passion isn’t enough.

When I awoke the next day, she was gone.

And I was left with a pile of pictures and a lifeless house of memories.

T
hey say time heals all wounds.

But can it forgive?

It was the one question running through my head over and over again as I climbed the steps to Ryan’s apartment that fateful day. After my world had crumbled around me, I’d spent weeks in hiding. Refusing to leave Sarah’s house for days at a time, I’d nursed myself back to health after walking away from August for good this time. I should have seen it coming. I should have known.

No one ever changes.

Not that much.

Not for good.

Sarah had taken her role as best friend seriously, never uttering an “I told you so” or blaming me for my own heartbreak. She did, however, threaten bodily harm to various parts of August’s anatomy, an offer I’d turned down.

This was as much my fault as his.

At least he had lack of memory as an excuse. I remembered everything and yet I’d still gone back begging for more.

August had always managed to bring out the senseless side of me.

But in those quiet weeks, as I cried myself to sleep in her tiny apartment, remembering the feel of his body against mine, the words and promises he’d spoken, I realized things about life and about myself. Loving August had been easy. Falling for him had been one of the simplest things I’d ever done. But when it came down to a fight, he always walked away.

There was always something better, bolder or brighter waiting for him on the other side, and I was never enough. Even after he’d changed—became someone else, he’d chosen wealth, power, and prestige over love. He’d chosen Trent.

And I’d been left with nothing.

Again.

When would I ever learn?

Ryan had once told me loving someone should be simple—as easy as breathing.

I’d had that. Now I wanted someone who would fight for me. And Ryan had been quietly fighting for me all along…waiting for me as I came to the conclusion he’d known all along.

I finally took the last step, my heart running like a bullet train in my chest, on the short walk to the front door. The little purple door decoration I’d made with acrylic paint and a wood cutout from the craft store was still attached. It had been my first attempt at painting and I had pretty much failed at it. The poor little flower looked like something from the kindergarten junk pile, but Ryan had loved it so much he’d proudly stuck it on the door and never allowed me to take it down.

He’d always loved me. Even when it hurt.

Even when it had been nearly impossible to do so.

Holding my hand up, I knocked several times and waited as my heart threatened to catapult out of my body at any second. The door opened and there he was. Gentle brown eyes and a warm curious smile.

“Took you long enough,” he said.

“Yeah.” I smiled as I fell into his loving arms, finally feeling like I’d come home, safely in his embrace.

It seemed time really was the cure to healing even the deepest of wounds. With each passing day, the damage August had done seemed a distant memory and I felt myself falling more deeply in love with Ryan.

Time moved on.

Love grew once again.

But there were still dark days when I couldn’t help but pick at that scar, like a disobedient child picking at a scab. Sometimes I just needed to remember.

To mourn.

On days like this I would disappear and take the long drive to the other side of the city, and submerge myself in the memory of him. The little spot under the bridge was no longer mine. No longer private. When I came here, all I could see, all I could feel was him. The memory of the smooth cadence of his voice haunted me; thoughts of his lingering touch gave me chills.

Did he ever come here to remember? Did he still mourn the loss of my touch?

As much as I loved Ryan, a part of me would always love August. Two vastly different lives and yet I would have been happy in either. How could one heart love two completely different souls?

The gravel crunched behind me, and I turned to see approaching headlights. I wasn’t the only one who knew of this spot. In a city of millions, it was impossible to have a place of your own, but this car I recognized. This intruder I’d requested.

The lights dimmed and the car door creaked open. I stepped forward and met him halfway.

“It’s been a long time,” Brick said, a warm smile creasing his aged face.

“It has,” I said. “Too long.” I closed the gap, wrapping my arms around him in a long embrace, holding back the tears that threatened to make an appearance.

“It’s okay,” he soothed. “I won’t tell.”

A strangled laugh fell from my mouth as the floodgates opened up and moisture gushed from my eyelids.

“I’m happy now,” I managed to say through the sobs. “But why does it still hurt?”

He pulled back, his kind eyes finding mine. “It will always hurt. It never stopped the first time. You just had anger to replace the pain.”

“I want to be angry at him. It would be so much easier if I hated him,” I confessed.

“I know. Me too.”

“He’s shut you out, too?” I asked, curiosity piquing as I turned to him in the darkness.

“For the most part. Every time I call or visit, he’s busy or has an excuse. He’s changed and not for the better.”

“It’s Trent. He’s like a parasite. The moment he came into our lives, everything changed. And now he’s back, and our August is gone for good.”

“August chose his path,” Brick said, rubbing my shoulders to ward off the chill in the air. “Now, all you can do is chose yours. The pain will lessen with each day and soon it will feel more like a distant memory instead of a sharp burning ache in your gut. Live your life, Everly. Let him live his.”

“You won’t tell him about this, will you?” I asked as we both turned toward the bridge. I wrapped my hands protectively around my chest as the breeze whipped around us, making me very aware of the late hour.

“He’d have to return my calls to even make that a possibility…but no,” he answered. “What is said between you and me is confidential.”

“So, should I expect a bill in the mail?” I joked, nudging his shoulder. He chuckled. It sounded like the gravel had when he’d parked his car next to mine, deep and ragged.

“No. You know I only make house calls for my non-clients. This was strictly one friend visiting another.”

“Good,” I answered. “Because I’m pretty sure my therapist is strongly against house visits.” I looked around, and laughed. “Or bridge visits,” I corrected.

“That wouldn’t surprise me in the least,” he answered, a slight smile tugging at his lip. His arm curved around my shoulder as we made our way back to our vehicles. He stopped short, taking my hand in front of the driver’s side door.

“The next phone call I get from you will be a happy one,” he said with confidence.

“How can you be so sure?” I asked.

He squeezed my hand and smiled. “Because you are a survivor, Everly. You’ve been surviving one bad break or another ever since you were little. You will survive August Kincaid as well.”

I nodded, knowing he was right. Knowing I’d already taken the first steps. That agonizing pain in my gut that had doubled me over for weeks no longer ruled my life. Slowly, it had reduced itself to a dull throb that flared up from time to time.

And during those flare-ups, I would mourn.

Mourn a life I would never have.

Mourn a man I had lost—not once, but twice.

And then I would move on again and celebrate the new life that had just begun.

Because life was once again full of possibilities. And Brick was right. I was a survivor.

And nothing could take that away from me.

“If you bring another feather dress in here, I will kill you!” I hollered over the dressing room door.

“Hey, you brought me. That was your first mistake!” Sarah yelled back as the attendant began helping me out of another monstrosity of a dress.

It felt like
déjà vu
: Sarah handing me horrible dresses in a never-ending store of white.

I could have avoided the entire episode. I had a perfectly good dress in the back of my closet at home, but somehow it felt tainted now.

Ruined.

After reuniting with Ryan, and after months of getting to know each other once again, he’d got down on one knee and proposed once again.

And I’d happily said yes.

This time, we were going to make it down that aisle and when we did, I was going to give my whole heart to the man who’d believed in me…even when I couldn’t. Ryan truly was the best of us. He saw love in an unconditional, never ending way. Somehow he knew by letting me go, I’d eventually find my way back to him.

And now I was determined to find the perfect dress to say my “I do’s” in. But Sarah was making it almost impossible, as usual. Deciding to try several stores rather than just one, Sarah had dragged me all over the city today, finally stopping at a shop I recognized from my drive to work. As I stepped out of the latest disaster of a dress, adding it to the huge pile of discards, I began to feel discouraged. Taking a seat in the corner while the attendant made ready the next dress, something much simpler she’d picked out based on my specifications, not Sarah’s, I awkwardly waited in my white underwear and strapless bra, trying to do my best not to seem awkward at all.

Which was proving difficult…because who isn’t awkward in a bra and underwear?

Underwear models, I guess.

But definitely not normal people. Normal people with flaws and blemishes that showed like neon flashing signs under the bright lights of the three-sided mirror that adorned the large bridal dressing room. I may have been just skinny but I felt like a bean pole sitting there, as my eyes critically picked out each scar I’d managed to pick because I’d never had a parent around to tell me otherwise, every boney rib poking out because I’d always been the last one to receive dinner, and the scared little bird who still sat in her cage on my shoulder because she was too frightened to take the first leap.

I think it’s time for the bird to fly, Everly.

Easy for him to say. He didn’t bother hanging around to see if I made it off that first rickety branch. Or whether I was still peeking out of the cage door, waiting for the right opportunity to take that first step.

He’d once promised he would never hurt me ever again.

Nothing but a bunch of empty, useless words.

“Okay, ready to try another?” the bridal attendant asked cheerfully, clearing the moody cobwebs from my mind.

“Yes,” I answered brightly, bouncing up from my chair as I stepped up to the dress.

No dark thoughts, Everly
, I chided myself.

“This is very elegant, but understated. I know you said you were wary about lace, but I saw this and it had the shape you like. I thought you might like it.”

As the fabric fell around me and I got that first look, I had one of those silly moments everyone speaks about. Tears welled up in my eyes as I tried to keep my emotions at bay.

“So, this is a yes?” the attendant asked with a sliver of a laugh.

All I could do was nod as I stared at my reflection, waiting for her to finish lacing the back. The gown gave me curves where I had none, cleavage where there was little, and accentuated my small waist, making it appear feminine rather than boyish. I felt beautiful and glamorous and about a dozen other adjectives in between.

“Do you want to go show your friend?” she asked, moving back to allow me access to the door.

“Yes, please,” I answered, taking one careful step at a time behind her as she guided me toward the larger mirrors at the front of the store.

“Oh. My. God!” Sarah shrieked the moment she saw me enter. “If you don’t buy that dress, I will beat you over the head with it and force it on you the day of your wedding.”

“That’s so sweet,” I crooned. I rolled my eyes and took a hesitant step up onto the pedestal. The lovely attendant held out a hand and helped me the rest of the way as I took center stage.

“I know this may sound a little self-absorbed, but I think I might just marry myself dressed in this gown.”

Sarah chuckled, rising from her chair to stand next to me. She looked small and short as I towered above her on the carpeted pedestal, and the realization made us both instantly laugh. Turning to her, I took her hands in mine and pulled her up to stand shoulder to shoulder with me.

“Now we just need to find your dress,” I said.

“I think we need to spend a bit more time staring at this one,” she pressed, holding my fingers up high in the air in an attempt to awkwardly twirl me around. We laughed and giggled as we tried to mimic a horrible rendition of a waltz.

“Maybe we should leave the dancing to you,” I suggested.

“Or maybe you just need a man.” A familiar voice cut through the silliness of the moment like a knife, freezing me in place instantly.

He couldn’t be here
, I chanted in my head over and over as I turned. I kept my eyes squeezed tightly shut in a desperate attempt to rewind time.

I’d walked away. I’d chosen the safer path and this time, I’d been happy with that decision.

He needed to stay away.

I needed him to stay away.

“What the hell are you doing here?” Sarah’s icy voice rang out as my eyes betrayed me and opened, and I came face to face with the one person who could tear my entire world apart.

Again.

“I just came to wish the bride congratulations,” he said smoothly.

Everything about him was different. From the way he dressed, in a crisp black suit, to the rigid posture he held. Even his gaze was different—cold, heartless, and almost cruel.

Where did you go, August?

“You need to leave,” I managed to say, my voice shaking with sheer effort.

“We need to talk.” His eyes briefly traveled toward Sarah. “Alone.”

Sarah’s hand tightened around mine. “If you think I’m going to leave you alone with her…”

“It’s fine, Sarah,” I said softly, my words barely above a whisper.

Her wide eyes turned to me. “You’ve got to be insane. Why would you agree to this?”