God's Problem (40 page)

Read God's Problem Online

Authors: Bart D. Ehrman

BOOK: God's Problem
10.61Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

The Quest of the Historical Jesus
(Schweitzer), 219

“Rebellion” (Dostoevsky), 266–67

redemptive suffering: Israel’s restoration through, 78–83; Joseph’s story on redemptive, 132–34; other examples of, 134–38; Paul on, 148–53; positive benefits of, 151–57; salvation and, 138–44.
See also
salvation

resurrection: Paul’s teachings on the, 237–42; suffering until the time of, 244–46

Revelation.
See
book of Revelation

sacrifice: Christian understanding of atonement as, 83–86, 142–53, 235, 236;
the Jewish system of, 75–77; “offering of Isaac” as, 168–70; Second Isaiah’s substitutionary, 77–83

salvation: formula of, 85; suffering and, 138–44; through rejection, 144–51.
See also
atonement doctrine; redemptive suffering

Samaria, 46–47, 74, 97, 98

Samuel, 72

Satan (“the adversary”), 163, 165–68, 215–16, 251

Schweitzer, Albert, 219

Second Isaiah, 77–83

Second World War: death and suffering during, 57–58, 121; experience of author’s father during, 58–61; Holocaust of, 11, 21–27, 277

sin: atoning sacrifice for, 85–86, 142–53, 235, 236; Deuteronomistic History on consequences of, 100–106; New Testament on consequences of, 106–11; paradox of suffering and, 119–23; prophets on suffering caused by, 96–100; relationship between suffering and, 84–88, 96–100, 137–38.
See also
disobedience; evil

666 symbolism, 253

Solomon, King, 72–73, 106, 120, 138, 192

Son of Man.
See
Jesus Christ

southern kingdom (Judah), 42, 74, 202

Stephen, 108

stoning punishment, 108–9

Suffering: A Test of a Theological Method
(McGill), 272

suffering: book of Revelation’s description of, 254–55; Christ as solution to, 272–74; comparing Old and New Testaments on, 88–90; Enlightenment view of, 10, 26, 121, 269; finding solutions to world’s, 276–78; during First and Second World Wars, 11, 21–27, 57–61, 121–22; God as providing strength to deal with, 271–72; of natural disasters, 230–32, 259; New Testament’s view of, 83–88; paradox of sin and, 119–23; reactions to, 111–19; redemptive, 78–83, 132–57; relationship between sin and, 84–88, 96–100, 137–38; as test of faith, 164–68, 275.
See also
physical suffering; problem of suffering

suffering as punishment: additional biblical references to, 62–64; Deuteronomistic History of Israel on, 69–74; as fallacy, 96; Pentateuch theme of, 64–69; prophetic view on Israel’s, 27–31, 34–42, 61–62, 203, 264.
See also
punishment

“suffering servant,” 82, 281nn.8, 9

theodicy: apocalypticism as ancient king of, 256; assertions on God and suffering by, 8–10, 26; assumptions of, 121; insolvable philosophical problem of, 122–23; origins of term, 8

Third Isaiah, 77

Tilley, Terrence, 122

Torah: forbidden by Assyrian rulers, 208; law of sacrifice in the, 75–76

Trumbo, Dalton, 58

United Nations, 129

utopia,
89

vanity, 191–93

vindication (apocalyptic), 217–18

Voltaire, 11–12

wealth: ephemeral nature of, 191–92; inequality of, 97–100

When Bad Things Happen to Good People
(Kushner), 7, 8, 270

Whisenant, Edgar, 225–26

Wiesel, Elie, 7

 

T
HE
H
EBREW
B
IBLE

 

Genesis 2:17, 64

Genesis 3:14–19, 65

Genesis 4, 101

Genesis 6:5, 65

Genesis 6:6, 65

Genesis 9:11, 66

Genesis 19:24–26, 66

Genesis 21:1–7, 169

Genesis 22:1–14, 76

Genesis 22:12, 169

Genesis 22:13–14, 169

Genesis 22, 168

Genesis 37–50, 132

Genesis 37:1–11, 132

Genesis 37:18–20, 132

Genesis 39, 113

Genesis 41, 133

Genesis 50:15–18, 134

Genesis 50:19–20, 134

Exodus 1:8, 102

Exodus 4:21: 10:1: 14:17, 135

Exodus 4:21, 135

Exodus 8:15, 32, 135

Exodus 10:1–2, 135

Exodus 14:17–18, 136

Leviticus 1–7, 75

Leviticus 1:4, 76

Leviticus 4:35, 76

Leviticus 5:16, 76

Leviticus 18:5, 20:12, 37

Numbers 13–14, 67

Numbers 14:22–23, 67

Deuteronomy 21:23, 142, 236

Deuteronomy 28:1–6, 68

Deuteronomy 28:16–28, 68

Deuteronomy 28, 67

Joshua 1:5–8, 70

Joshua 6, 70, 102

Joshua 7, 71

Judges 10:6–9, 72

Judges 19:1, 105

Judges 19:22, 104

Judges 19:23–24, 104

Judges 20–21, 105

Judges 21:25, 72

1 Samuel 9, 32

1 Samuel, 72

2 Samuel 10:1; 16:12–13, 149

2 Samuel 11, 105

2 Samuel 12:15, 138

2 Samuel 12, 32, 137

2 Samuel, 69, 72

1 Kings 5:13–18, 106

1 Kings 6–9, 106

1 Kings 9:4–7, 73

1 Kings 9:15–22, 106

1 Kings 11:1, 73

1 Kings 11:3, 73

1 Kings, 69, 72, 73

2 Kings 17:5–18, 74

2 Kings 22:16–17, 74

2 Kings 25, 77

2 Kings, 42, 64, 73–74

2 Kings, 69

Job 1:1, 164

Job 1:5, 76

Job 1:11, 165

Job 1:20, 166

Job 1:22, 166

Job 2:3, 168

Job 2:5, 166

Job 2:7, 166

Job 2:10, 166

Job 3:1-3, 11–12, 16, 174

Job 3, 112

Job 4:1–2, 7–9, 175

Job 6:24–25, 28, 30, 178

Job 7:13–16, 19, 180

Job 7, 165

Job 8:1–7, 176

Job 9:13–20, 182

Job 11:1–6, 177

Job 14:11–12, 181

Job 16:12–14, 16–17, 179

Job 21:7–9, 12–13, 181

Job 22:4–7, 9–10, 177

Job 23:3–7, 183

Job 27:3–4, 182

Job 30:18–21, 179

Job 31:35–37, 183

Job 38:2–7, 184

Job 38:12, 16–18, 22, 33–35; 39:26–27, 186

Job 40:1–2, 186

Job 40:3–4, 186

Job 40:6–9, 186

Job 42:2, 5–6, 187

Job 42:11, 168

Psalms 22, 149

Psalms 6:2–4, 6–10, 115

Psalms 22:14–21, 119

Psalms 22, 83

Psalms 137:1–9, 117

Psalms 137, 116

Proverbs 2:11–12, 264

Proverbs 3:33, 62

Proverbs 10:3, 62

Proverbs 11:8, 63

Proverbs 11:19, 63

Proverbs 12:21, 63

Proverbs 13:21, 63

Ecclesiastes 1:1, 190

Ecclesiastes 1:2–6, 8–11, 191

Ecclesiastes 1:16–2:23, 192

Ecclesiastes 2:11, 192

Ecclesiastes 2:17, 192

Ecclesiastes 2:20, 192

Ecclesiastes 2:24, 192

Ecclesiastes 2:26, 192

Ecclesiastes 5:18–19, 194

Ecclesiastes 6:1–2, 192

Ecclesiastes 7:15, 193

Ecclesiastes 8:14, 193

Ecclesiastes 8:15, 194

Ecclesiastes 9:1–3, 193

Ecclesiastes 9:4, 193

Ecclesiastes 9:5–6, 194

Ecclesiastes 9:11–12, 193

Isaiah 1:4–9, 49

Isaiah 1:21–25, 49

Isaiah 1:23, 99

Isaiah 3:14–15, 99

Isaiah 3:24–26, 50

Isaiah 6:1–2, 50

Isaiah 6:11–12, 50

Isaiah 10:2–3, 50

Isaiah 10:20–27, 51

Isaiah 40–55, 77

Isaiah 40:1–2, 78

Isaiah 40:2, 78

Isaiah 40:3–5, 79

Isaiah 40:29–31, 79

Isaiah 41:8–10, 80

Isaiah 41:8; 49:3, 82

Isaiah 47:6, 11, 78

Isaiah 49:3, 80, 139

Isaiah 52:13–53:12, 80

Isaiah 53:3, 83

Isaiah 53:4–5, 139

Isaiah 53:5, 83

Isaiah 53:7, 83

Isaiah 53:9, 84

Isaiah 53:10, 84

Isaiah 53:12, 83

Isaiah 53, 83, 139, 140, 149

Isaiah 54:7-8, 79

Jeremiah 5:15–17, 51

Jeremiah 5:26–29, 100

Jeremiah 7, 112

Jeremiah 9:11, 52

Jeremiah 11–20, 112

Jeremiah 11:19–20, 113

Jeremiah 15:19–21, 52

Jeremiah 16:4, 52

Jeremiah 19:8–9, 52

Jeremiah 20:14–18, 113

Jeremiah 31:15, 103

Jeremiah 52, 77

Hosea 1:6, 43

Hosea 1:9, 43

Hosea 2:3–4, 44

Hosea 2:8–12, 44

Hosea 9:1–3, 45

Hosea 10:14–15, 45

Hosea 13:4–9, 46

Hosea 13:16, 47

Amos 1–2, 36

Amos 1:1, 34

Amos 1:3–4, 35

Amos 1:6–8, 36

Amos 2:6–7, 98

Amos 2:6–15, 37

Amos 3-5, 214

Amos 3:1, 38

Amos 3:3–6, 38

Amos 3:11, 38

Amos 4:1, 98

Amos 4:2–3, 99

Amos 4:6–11, 264

Amos 4:6–12, 40

Amos 5:1–11, 98

Amos 5:21–24, 41

Amos 7:14, 34

Amos 9:10, 41

Amos 9:14–15, 42

 

N
EW
T
ESTAMENT

 

Matthew, Gospel of 1:6, 138

Matthew, Gospel of 2:18, 103

Matthew, Gospel of 4:1–11, 234

Matthew, Gospel of 5:17–20, 142

Matthew, Gospel of 5, 223

Matthew, Gospel of 13:40–43, 222

Matthew, Gospel of 18:4, 223

Matthew, Gospel of 19:28, 222

Matthew, Gospel of 24:32–34, 226

Matthew, Gospel of 25:26, 88

Matthew, Gospel of 25:31, 87

Matthew, Gospel of 25:34–35, 87

Matthew, Gospel of 25:41–43, 88

Matthew, Gospel of 25, 87

Mark, Gospel of 1:15, 219, 220, 255

Mark, Gospel of 8:38, 221

Mark, Gospel of 9:1; 13:30, 219

Mark, Gospel of 9:1, 205, 255

Mark, Gospel of 10:31, 223

Mark, Gospel of 10:45, 86, 143

Mark, Gospel of 13:23–29, 221

Mark, Gospel of 13:24–27, 222

Mark, Gospel of 13:30, 205, 255

Mark, Gospel of 13:33–37, 224

Mark, Gospel of 14–15, 143

Mark, Gospel of 14:22–24, 86

Mark, Gospel of 14:36, 170

Mark, Gospel of 15:24, 107

Mark, Gospel of 15:31, 233

Mark, Gospel of 15:34, 143

Mark, Gospel of 15:38–39, 143

Luke, Gospel of 3:7–9, 220

Luke, Gospel of 6:24–26, 224

Luke, Gospel of 6, 223

Luke, Gospel of 7:22–23, 235

Luke, Gospel of 9:48, 223

Luke, Gospel of 12:45–56, 225

Luke, Gospel of 14:11, 223

Luke, Gospel of 17:24, 26–27, 30, 221

Luke, Gospel of 21:20–24, 110

John, Gospel of 1:29, 250

John, Gospel of 3:3, 257

John, Gospel of 11:4, 137

John, Gospel of 11:25, 136, 234

John, Gospel of 11, 136

John, Gospel of 14:1–3, 257

Acts 1:8, 146

Acts 3:12–15, 145

Acts 4, 5, 7, 146

Acts 7, 108

Acts 8:1, 147

Acts 9, 145, 153

Acts 13:44–49, 147

Acts 14:19–20, 109

Romans 1:18, 85

Romans 3:23–25, 85

Romans 3:24–25, 139

Romans 7, 142

Romans 8:18–23, 245

Romans 9:2–3, 151

Romans 11:11, 151

Romans 11:25–26, 151

1 Corinthians 1:23, 150

1 Corinthians 2:2, 107, 140

1 Corinthians 15:3–5, 239

1 Corinthians 15:3, 85, 140

1 Corinthians 15:6–8, 239

1 Corinthians 15:51–53, 242

1 Corinthians 15:54–55, 242

1 Corinthians 15, 239–41

2 Corinthians 1:2–7, 152

2 Corinthians 1:7–10, 153

2 Corinthians 1:8–10, 119

2 Corinthians 11:23–26, 110

2 Corinthians 11:23–29, 246

2 Corinthians 11, 245

Galatians 1–2, 237

Galatians 3:1, 107

Galatians 3:13, 142, 236

Galatians 3:21, 141

Galatians 6:11, 153

1 Thessalonians 2:14–16, 148

1 Thessalonians 4:15–17, 243

1 Thessalonians, 243

Philemon 2:7–9, 170

Philemon 2, 237

Hebrews 3, 84

Hebrews 4–5, 84

Hebrews 4:12, 249

Hebrews 9–10, 84

Hebrews 10:10, 84

Hebrews 10:12, 84

Hebrews 9–10, 76

1 Peter 2:22–24, 140

1 Peter 4:12–13, 19, 170

1 Peter, 170

2 Peter 3:8, 247

Revelation 1:1,7, 248

Revelation 1:1, 248

Revelation 1:12–13, 248

Revelation 1:19, 249

Revelation 2–3, 249

Revelation 4–22, 249

Revelation 4:1, 249

Revelation 5:1, 249

Revelation 5:6, 249

Revelation 6:12–13, 250

Revelation 8:1–2, 250

Revelation 16:1–2, 250

Revelation 17:6, 252

Revelation 17:9, 252

Revelation 17:18, 252

Revelation 18:2, 250

Revelation 19:11, 251

Revelation 19:17–21, 251

Revelation 20:1–6, 251

Revelation 20:11–15, 251

Revelation 21:9–27, 251

Revelation 22:12, 251

Revelation 22:20, 247, 251

 

A
POCRYPHA

 

1 Maccabees 1:11–15, 207

1 Maccabees 1:20–23, 208

1 Maccabees 1:24, 208

1 Maccabees 1:29–31, 208

1 Maccabees 1:42, 208

1 Maccabees 1:44–50, 208

1 Maccabees 1:59–61, 208

Other books

We Are the Ants by Shaun David Hutchinson
Avenged by Janice Cantore
The Dogs of Winter by Kem Nunn
The Insect Farm by Stuart Prebble
Horse Capades by Bonnie Bryant
Deliver Us by Lynn Kelling
Turncoat by Don Gutteridge
Creating Harmony by Viola Grace
Mad Skills by Greatshell, Walter