I Swear (10 page)

“The first one we have record of was in regards to Leslie having had breast implants.” Kellan’s face was stone. “Did you have knowledge of this rumor?”

“I . . .” Beth opened her mouth, then stopped, flustered. “It was three years ago,” she said, turning to Patrick. “Why are we talking about this?”

Kellan took a sip of water and offered a tight-lipped smile.
“Miss Patterson, we’re in the part of a legal case called discovery. We’re trying to discover the facts regarding any involvement you or your classmates may have had in the wrongful death of Leslie Gatlin.”

“But I . . .”

“Yes or no, Miss Patterson? Did you ever hear a rumor about Leslie Gatlin having breast implants? And might I remind you that you are under oath.”

Beth’s hand trembled as she unscrewed the cap on her water bottle and took a sip.

“Yes,” she said softly. “I heard that rumor.”

“Did you ever repeat this rumor to anyone else?”

Beth glanced over at the court reporter, who sat looking back at her, fingers poised over the black levers, waiting.

“I don’t see what this has to do with anything.”

“Miss Patterson, we are attempting to establish a pattern of unrelenting bullying over a period of time. I’ll ask you again, did you ever repeat the rumor you heard about Miss Gatlin?”

“I don’t know why you would accuse me of repeating a rumor like that three years ago. I was Leslie’s friend then.”

“So, do I understand that you did not repeat the rumor, Miss Patterson?”

“No—
no
! You don’t understand.” Beth was sobbing now, and as her tears fell harder, Patrick put a hand on her arm and requested a five-minute break.

Beth shook his hand off her arm. “I don’t need a break. I
need you to understand what it’s like,” she shot back at Kellan. “You have no idea what it’s like, do you? You can sit here behind your big white table and take your notes and try to trip us all up, but you don’t have any idea what it’s like to be a girl in high school, do you?”

Kellan took a different tack. “Miss Patterson, you’ve stated that you were friends. Did you ever have a romantic relationship with Leslie Gatlin?”

“Objection. Relevance.” Patrick was not happy.

Lauren Wolinsky slid an iPad across the table toward Beth.

“Have you ever seen this Facebook wall post, Miss Patterson?”

Beth glanced at the screen. “Yes,” she said.

“Please read it out loud for the record.”

Beth sighed, then read: “‘List Chick, I’m sorry I didn’t feel the same way about you. I could’ve been your friend. Anchors away.’”

“Beth, who is List Chick?”

“I don’t know!” Beth’s eyes were a little wild. She was desperate.

Kellan picked up a piece of paper and slid it across the table to Patrick.

“Exhibit twelve-A. This is a printout from Miss Patterson’s Gmail account. You’ll notice that it is a Facebook notification message sent to the email address [email protected].”

He turned back to Beth. “Miss Patterson, is this your email address?”

Beth hung her head. “Yes.”

Kellan nodded. “Beth, did you ever express interest in dating Miss Gatlin?”

“Objection! Relevance.” Patrick’s face was a storm cloud.

“Just trying to establish a motive for consistent slander and harassment of Leslie Gatlin via Facebook messages,” explained Kellan.

He handed a stack of paper to Patrick.

“Exhibit twelve-B. These are printouts of hundreds of messages subpoenaed from a Facebook profile with the name of Di Young. These messages were sent from several IP addresses traced to three different residences. One of them is Miss Patterson’s. Beth, did you ever send a Facebook message to Leslie Gatlin from this account?”

Beth was silent and stared at her hands.

“Miss Patterson?” Kellan leaned forward.

“Beth, answer the question,” said Patrick.

“Yes.”

“Did you set up the account under the name Di Young?” asked Kellan.

“It wasn’t my idea. I—”

“Yes or no?” Kellan interrupted her forcefully.

Beth paused and sucked in her cheeks. Her eyes filled with tears. She glanced at Patrick, who stared down at the stack of printouts, looking pale.

“Yes,” she sighed.

“Beth, why did you turn on Leslie Gatlin?” Kellan asked quietly.

“You don’t get it, do you?” Her voice was too loud for the tiny room. Tears streamed down her face.

“Beth.” Patrick’s voice was firm. “Let’s take a break. You’re getting emotional.”

“Yeah, I’m getting emotional,” she spat out in frustration. “Nobody understands how hard it is. If you’re a guy, you can be good at sports and get away with anything, but if you’re a girl in sports, it’s all different. You’ve got to keep the rumors at bay. If you’re too good, you’re a dyke or a bitch, plain and simple. And all it takes is one rumor—one wrong word by the right person—and your whole life is over.”

The court reporter was wide-eyed and her fingers were dancing on those levers like the feet of the organist at our old church in Atlanta.

In the silence that followed, Lauren Wolinsky pulled some tissues out of her attaché case and gently handed them across the table to Beth.

“No further questions,” said Kellan with a smile.

The video ended on Patrick holding his head in his hands.

15. BETH

After my deposition, Patrick walked me to the empty front lobby.

“Is your mom picking you up?” he asked.

“No. She’s hosting Bible study tonight,” I said. “Why?”

“Just wanted to touch base with her. Where are you off to now?”

“The gym.” I laughed a little bitterly. “Nothing’s as good for your floor routine as a deposition.”

Patrick plopped down on the couch by the door and rubbed his temples. “Have a good practice,” he said.

I stood there waiting for him to move, but he didn’t.

“That’s it?” I asked quietly.

He looked up at me. “What?” he asked.

I threw my bag down. “That’s it? Just ‘have a good practice’? We aren’t going to discuss what just happened in there?”

Suddenly he was sitting up, his forearms on his knees, leaning toward me. “I don’t know, Beth. Are we?” he shot back. “Let me explain something to you. The only thing I’m interested in discussing is the truth here. Your parents are potentially on the hook for hundreds of thousands of dollars here—and that’s if this thing settles out of court. If we go to trial, the number goes up.”

I stared at the floor.

“I’m waiting,” he said.

“For what?” I asked.

“Look, you want to discuss what just happened in there, I’m all ears. But I don’t have time to dick around unless you’re going to tell me the truth. You all but perjured yourself in there just now, and even though you didn’t technically lie, you gave Dirkson exactly what he wanted—you on the ropes, covering up God knows what for God knows who. So, go ahead, have a great practice. Nail that dismount tonight. Because when this thing winds up in court, you’re gonna be walking a balance beam you’ve never trained for. And the only way I can help you is if you get real and tell me what the hell is going on here.”

“I’m late for practice,” I said, picking up my bag.

“Beth.” The way he said my name stopped me in my tracks. “Look at me.”

I turned and faced him.

“I know that this wasn’t all you. I know that you were
actually Leslie’s friend at some point. What happened?” He was begging me to tell him the truth.

“What could possibly be so horrible that you’d have to keep it a secret?”

“I have to go,” I said, and I pushed through the office doors and outside.

By the time I got to the gym, Coach Stevens had already started practice. When he saw me come out of the locker room, he shouted some instructions at an assistant coach and headed toward me.

“Had your deposition today?”

I nodded.

“How’d it go, Beth?”

“Fine,” I said, wrapping my left wrist.

“I don’t know how this started, Beth,” Coach Stevens said quietly. “I wish I knew.” Then he walked me over to the uneven parallel bars and gave me a lift.

•  •  •

It all started after the cookout at Coach Stevens’s place. After we met at her uncle’s place, Leslie and I started spending a lot of time together. One Saturday before school started, she insisted that I come with her to Jake’s for guitar lessons.

“C’mon.” She smiled as we rolled our bikes out of her garage. “It’ll be good for you to know
somebody
besides me on the first day.”

“Well, yeah,” I said, “but . . . isn’t this sort of like your
once-a-week guitar date?” I giggled. “I don’t want to be a third wheel.”

Leslie rolled her eyes. “This is not a date. We’re just . . .”

“Making beautiful music together?” I smirked.

“Enough. Ride.”

And we did. And she was right. I’d never met anybody like Jake. He was so good-looking and so nice at the same time. No one could feel like a third wheel around him. When he smiled, you felt like you belonged.

“Where’s Jillian?” Leslie asked when we got there.

“Pro’ly at Macie’s,” Jake said.

“Who’s Macie?” I asked them.

“You may remember her from such election-night coverage as last year’s race for the state senate and the previous race for the mayor’s mansion,” Jake quipped.

Leslie giggled and playfully punched him in the shoulder. “Be nice!”

“You mean Macie . . . Merrick?” I asked. “She goes to school with you guys?”

“Oh, yes,” sighed Jake. “We’re truly blessed. She and Jillian are planning a wholesale takeover of student government even as we speak, one class presidency at a time.”

“Really?” asked Leslie through her laughter.

“They’ve turned the study at the Merrick mansion into a war room,” Jake said.

“Shut up,” I said, giggling. “Really? That’s hilarious.”

“Oh, it’s no laughing matter,” Jake said. “Serious as flesh-eating bacteria. Wait till you meet her at the Frosh Bash.”

“The what?” Leslie and I said it at the same time.

Jake laughed. “Two weeks. Sunday afternoon, Labor Day weekend. Brad Wyst’s place. His older brother, Derek, is a senior this year. He’s inviting everybody who’s anybody. My mom will drive. I’ll pick you two up.”

•  •  •

When we got back to Leslie’s house after her guitar lesson with Jake, she bent over to hoist her bike up onto the hook in her garage, and the necklace she’d shown me the first time we met fell out of her tank top, the tiny silver anchor dangling over her chest. I stared at it for a moment, swinging there, and when she glanced up, I looked away a moment too late. I felt myself blush. Hard.

“Ugh.” She laughed. “I know. I had to go buy all new sports bras for volleyball with my mom last week. It’s like I’ve got grapefruits slamming me in the chin now when I run.”

I laughed nervously. “Sorry, I didn’t mean to stare. Your necklace fell out, and then I . . . noticed.”

“Yeah, no shit.” Leslie rolled her eyes. “The busboys at Marv’s have suddenly realized I’m alive. Guys are so stupid like that.”

“Jake doesn’t seem so stupid,” I said.

“Yeah.” She smiled. “He’s nice. And he really liked you, I could tell.”

“So, have you kissed him since the beach?” I asked.

“No!” Leslie laughed. She said it like we were in fourth grade and boys had cooties. She shook her head with a little shiver. “It’s not like that with us.”

“What do you mean?” I asked her. “He seems pretty smitten.”

“We were at a beach in the moonlight on vacation,” she said matter-of-factly. “He’s like my brother.”

“He doesn’t look at you like you’re his sister,” I said. “And you guys have those necklaces.”

“We all got one,” Leslie said, tucking the anchor back into her tank top and adjusting her straps. I followed the curve of her shoulder and felt a twinge in my chest—my much smaller chest. “Jillian’s has a ship’s wheel. Jake’s has a sailboat. We got them at this little tourist shop on the shore.”

“Well, you’re lucky that you’ll have something to show off at that pool party,” I said.

She frowned. “My . . . necklace?”

“No, silly. Those great big
boobs
!” I lunged at her and tickled her. She shrieked and spun around, trying to wiggle away from my hands. We tangled up against her mom’s Audi and stopped when she was finally able to grab my wrists. Leslie’s back was up against the car.

How did I get so out of breath from trying to tickle her?

“All I know is that if you sprouted those things on the gymnastics team, you’d have to retrain on all the apparatus,” I said.
“Gymnasts have tiny racks for a reason. It’s a blessing and a curse.”

“Whatever, Beth.” Leslie laughed. “You’re perfect.”

It was suddenly very quiet. Her lips were close enough to my face that I could smell her coconut lip balm. I felt the warmth of her body, the nearness to mine.

I wanted to be closer to her. All at once, I felt a rush in my heart and my chest, and I leaned in and touched my lips to hers.

“Whoa! Beth—wait. What are you doing?” Leslie giggled and spun away from the car, away from my kiss.

Away from me.

I felt my cheeks flush a deep crimson, and the back of my neck felt hot. I stared at the floor, frozen. My heart was racing and I felt dizzy, like I needed to sit down before I fell down. I slowly sank down onto the concrete floor of the garage, overwhelmed by the twist of fear in my stomach.

“Beth.”

It was Leslie. She was slowly kneeling next to me on the garage floor.

“Beth?”

I couldn’t answer her. I couldn’t look at her.

“Beth, it’s okay.”

It’s not okay. You were never supposed to see that part of me.

We sat in silence. I stared at the floor. I made a list. A list of the people who could never know about this moment. I would never reach the end.

“Beth, are you a lesbian?”

She asked it quietly, and like it was no big deal, but when she said that word, something in me snapped.

“Don’t say that word,” I hissed.

I leaped to my feet. She tried to stop me and I pushed her away. I ran toward the door that led into the house. I wanted to get my things and keep running as far away as I could. All the hope I had felt since that night at Coach Stevens’s cookout, when I lay next to Leslie on the hood of her dad’s truck and looked at the stars, vanished.