Authors: Thrity Umrigar
“I'm telling you, Sorab, you should learn to enjoy your Constitution-enshrined rights,” Percy continued. “That's why you're going to end up with an ulcer, bossie, from lack of fun. If I were you, I'd ditch Susan tonight and go out drinking with me.”
And that's probably why you're on your fourth wife, Sorab thought. He still couldn't believe it sometimesâhow Percy, who was no Gary Cooper, went through women the way other men
went through dinner. And the weird part was, each time he married a new women, Percy's happiness was so immense and infectious that he managed to convince all his friendsânot to mention himselfâthat this time he had found the real deal, his soul mate, his true love. And then, within a year or two, he would be moaning about alimony and divorce settlements. “You know what your problem is, bossie?” Sorab had once said to him. “You have the Elizabeth Taylor syndromeâyou don't seem to understand that you can sleep with someone and not marry them.”
Percy had shrugged. “Guilty as charged. Guess I'm a hopeless romantic.”
Now he heard Percy suck his breath on the other end. “Chal ne, gadhera,” Percy said. “You're going drinking with me or not?”
“I can't,” Sorab said. “Susan's waiting for me at Tropez. Speaking of which, I'll have to hang up as soon as I get there, okay? Thanks to my inconsiderate boss, I'm running late. And Susan hates to wait alone in restaurants.”
“Can't say I blame her,” Percy said. “So what happened with the she-devil today?”
“The usual bullshit. Acted all surprised that I'm taking the week after Christmas off. When even the cleaning lady knows that I do this every year. And to make matters worse, she said⦔ But the thought of telling his old friend about Grace's threat to refuse him the promotion was too shameful for Sorab. After all, they were Cathedral boys and Cathedral boys were always successful. The Indians that he and Percy socialized withâdoctors, lawyers, engineers, businessmenâhad all come to America and built their fortunes. Many of them were married to American women; many of their children attended Yale and Stanford; most of them had large homes in the suburbs. Sorab had long let it be known among this circle that he soon expected to head his department, and someday, the company. Until a blond-haired bimbo
with Bryan on her brain had decided to bust his balls. Shit. Now he was sounding like Percy, making alliterations.
“Hey. You still there?” Percy's voice came crisp and urgent on the phone.
Sorab exhaled. “Yup, I'm here. You know, bossie, I think you have the right ideaâworking for yourself, getting divorced when things don't work out, and trying your luck again.”
Percy had heard something in his voice, as he'd known he would. “What's the matter, Sorab? Everything not okay at home?”
“Oh no, I mean, everything is reasonably fine. It's just that, Susan and Iâ¦that is, it's hard, you know, having Mamma with us for so long. I mean, it's the first time she's been here by herself since Daddy's death. And, I don't know, it's just not as much fun as when he was around. And Susan keeps asking me what Mamma's plans are, whether she's going to settle here permanently or not, and I don't know the answer myself. It's like every time I try to pin Mamma down, it's like trying to spear a fish, you know? She just wriggles and moves out of my grasp. So, you know, well, sometimes it causes friction between me and Susan.”
Sorab could hear Percy frowning on the phone, as he did when he was concentrating on something. “Yeah, I've been meaning to ask you about this myself. Just was waiting for the holidays to get over. If she's going to stay, I need to file papers soon asking for an extension at least, depending on what she decides. You know what the damn INS is likeâthe continents will rejoin before we get an answer from them. She really must decide soon, Sorab.”
“I know. I know. But to be honest with you, bossie, I don't know what it isâwhether Mamma is depressed or something. Or maybe she was just used to Daddy making all the major decisions. But she seems paralyzed. One day, I get the feeling that she could live here, even be happy here. But the next minute she'll say something about her beloved Bombay and how she's looking forward to her bridge
parties when she returns in February and then I don't know what to think. It's driving Susan crazy, also.”
“Women,” Percy said. “Women. Just goes to show, at any age they're still the sameâindecisive, unpredictable, irresolute. And isn't it funny how everyone always misses Bombay as long as they're not living there? But listen. I'll talk to her, okay? You guys are coming to Homi and Perin's party this week, correct? I assume you're bringing Mamma to the party? Good. I'll try to say something to her then. As her lawyer, I need to know.”
“That would be great. Maybe she'll be less evasive with you.”
“Maybe I should have a talk with demon woman, also. Tell her to treat my best friend with more respect.”
Sorab snorted. “Respect? That woman wouldn't know how to spell the word.”
“Too bad you can't divorce your boss. I think they should start a whole new category of people you can divorceâbosses, teachers, immigration officials, parents, children, pets, landlords, Tom DeLay, Donald Trump, Wal-Mart greeters. After all, why should the joy of divorce be restricted to spouses?”
Sorab grinned. “I feel a new lawsuit coming on.”
“Yeah, a class-action suit, representing ninety percent of all Americans.”
Sorab pulled into the circular driveway of Tropez and parked his car in front of the black sign that said
VALET PARKING
. “You know something? You have the same idiotic sense of humor that you did in high school. Remember how you used to drive poor Mr. Singh nuts with your limericks and puns?” He handed his car keys to a young man in a tan shirt.
“Hey, you just made a pun yourself. Singh and nuts, get it?
Singh
means âpeanut' and you saidâ”
“I get it, I get it,” Sorab groaned. “Ae, listen, I'm at the restaurant. I'll call you later, okay?”
“Go. Have a good time with your lovely wife. And tell her about my standing invitationâif she gets sick of you, she can always marry me instead. I'm sure Julie won't mind me taking another wife. I mean if the Muslims and the Mormons canâ”
“I'll tell her,” Sorab interrupted. He cast an eye around the restaurant for Amy, the dark-haired girl who usually seated him. “And hey, Percyâthanks for everything. As usual.”
“No mention. Us guys have to stick together against these wicked women with their wily ways. Listen, don't worry. I'll talk to Tehmina mamma. We'll get things sorted out, okay?”
As he hung up, Sorab's eyes fell on Susan at a table near the window. As usual, she had brought a book to read while waiting for him. On their first official date, he had been stunned when Susan had shown up at the restaurant carrying a novel, and had misunderstood her reasons. Did you really think the date would be so boring you'd have to read? he'd asked her. But after all these years together, Sorab knew how shy Susan could be and how she hated waiting alone in a restaurant or in any public place. The book provided a welcome escape.
Susan looked up and spotted Sorab across the room. Shutting the book, she waved. Inexplicably, Sorab felt his throat tighten. Good old Susan. How solid, how substantial she felt after the brittle superficiality of Grace Butler. Susan would never use a word like
brilliantastic.
Susan was home, a harbor, a refuge from the gaudiness of the world.
As he crossed the restaurant to meet his wife, Sorab felt his body relax for the first time all day.
H
i, hon,” Sorab said, bending down to kiss his wife on the cheek. “Sorry to keep you waiting. I was all ready to leave when Grace decided she had to talk to me just then.”
Susan smiled. “It's okay. I figured you were running on Bombay time.”
Was that a slam? Sorab gave his wife a closer look. These days, it was impossible to know what Susan was really thinking. That old closeness, where he could read Susan's thoughts and complete her sentences for her, seemed elusive now. And suddenly he felt the loss of that intimacy acutely, as strongly as he still felt the loss of his father, eight months after Rustom's death.
“Oh, for Christ's sake, Sorab. It was a
joke
. I told you it was okay. Stop being so damn sensitive.”
This was not the way he had envisioned this evening going. The whole point of the dinner with Susan had been to spend some alone time together, away from his mother's benign but obtrusive presence. But two minutes into it, and already he was on the defensive,
feeling much the same way as he did at home these days. Shit, he thought. Might as well have stayed home and saved myself fifty bucks. Cheaper to be miserable at home. He remembered his earlier encounter with Grace Butler and had the same feeling of the conversation galloping away from him. How did women do this? he wondered. How did they make a man feel guilty about taking a much-deserved vacation? How did they make a man who was about to shell out good money for dinner feel like a piece of shit for arriving five minutes late? He looked around for a waiter, unwilling to let Susan see how much her words had upset him.
“Hon,” Susan said, cupping his hand in hers. “Listen, I'm⦔
But just then the waiter, a new guy whom Sorab didn't recognize, came over to take their drink order. “Margarita, on the rocks,” Sorab said. “With salt.”
“Make that two,” Susan added. Her hand still covered Sorab's.
She turned to him as soon as the waiter left. “Listen, let's just start again, okay? I feel like we got off on the wrong foot.”
He made a conscious effort to shake off the gloom that hovered around him. “Okay.” He smiled. “So picture me entering the restaurant, okay? And here's me bending down to kiss you. And I'm saying, âSorry, hon. Traffic was a bitch this evening.'”
“And I say, âGod, Sorab, you look drop-dead gorgeous tonight. Say, how about if we skip dinner and you know, um?'”
“Your place or mine?” he said, happy to play along.
Susan's eyes were green and golden in this light. “I'm afraid it will have to be my place. Your place has a little boy and his elderly grandmother and a goldfish.”
His voice was husky. “And what will we do at your place?”
Susan licked her lips. “Anything you want. Anything. Satisfaction guaranteed.”
Despite Susan's playfully exaggerated slutty impression, Sorab
felt a slight stirring in his groin. “Darling,” he said. “I'm beginning to think that skipping dinner is a great idea.”
They were laughing as the waiter set down their drinks and took their meal order.
“Boy, this place knows how to make margaritas.” Susan sighed. She took a long, hard gulp. “You know, I kinda wish I did have a place of my ownâjust a getaway place when Cookie andâand everything elseâgets too much to handle.”
He had heard what she hadn't said. “Mamma was being difficult today?” he asked quietly, dreading the answer.
“No, not really. I mean, she was gone shopping most of the day with Eva Metzembaum. Turns out they went to the farmers' market. God knows why. She came home loaded with fruits and vegetables. As luck would have it, I went grocery shopping after work today. So now we have bushels of tangerines and about five hundred pounds of okra at home.”
Despite Susan's valiant attempt to keep her tone light, Sorab heard the frustration in her voice. He felt a moment's irritation at his mother. Why on earth did she have to go to the market on her own? She was forever telling Sorab that Cookie didn't eat enough fruits and vegetables. Was this her way of rubbing it in? His mother could be passive-aggressive, he knew that. All bloody Parsi women were.
To Susan he said, “She was probably just trying to be helpful. You know how much she wants to pull her own weight within the family.”
Susan sighed heavily. “I know. Sorab, I know. It's just thatâwhy can't she help in ways that are useful? I mean, the things I expect her to doâlike clean the bathtub after a shower or vacuum on occasion, those things she won't do. Do you know that I have to rinse out the tub every day before I can take a shower? And I've told her so many
times, âMamma, if you want to help, please take over the vacuuming.' But she waits until I finally bring out the machine. And then she insists on pulling it away from me.”
Sorab felt the familiar rush of heat in the back of his neck that he felt each time Susan said something critical of Tehmina. He heard the frustration in his wife's voice, but behind his eyes there was another, older imageâof his mother bent over the kitchen counter chopping onions, her face flushed from the steam from the pressure cooker and the sting of the onions. Do you realize that my mother spentâwastedâher entire youth cooking and taking care of five other people? he wanted to say to Susan. Dad and myself, my grandparents, and later, Percy. And that's not counting all the street urchins and stray dogs that she fed. Surely she has earned the right to relax in her own son's home? As for not rinsing out the tub each time, my mother lives in an apartment that has not seen a fresh coat of paint in twenty years. It's not meanness, Susan, it's just that the thought doesn't even occur to her. And I'm too embarrassed to tell her to do it. Besides, I hate the thought of my mother, with her bad hip and all, bending over that tub, looking for every telltale gray hair. I don't want her to feel like she is a guest in our home. I want her to believe this is her home.
“What?” Susan said. “You think I'm being a bitch?”
Not for the first time, Sorab marveled and bristled at his wife's perceptiveness. Even as Susan became more shrouded in mystery to him, she could still read him like a book.
“No, not a bitch. Not that at all. It's just that⦔
It's just thatâ¦there are some things, some thoughts so elusive that they wiggle like fish out of the web of words. Some differences were so great that they were beyond language, beyond explanation. How envious Susan had been when he had first told her that his mother had always had servants. That the fisherwoman and the newspaper boy and the baker and the butcher all made their morning
rounds to the house, delivering their wares. How easy, how luxurious Susan had imagined his mother's life to be. And yet that's not how he remembered her life, at all. What he remembered of his childhood was a blur of ringing doorbells and raised voices and his mother's tired, flushed face and the complaints of neighbors and the haggling with the vendors and the arguments with the servants and the chain of unexpected visitors and demanding relatives who dropped in without calling first. And somehow, like the conductor of a mad orchestra, his mother had to manage it allâhad to tame the crashing protests of the cymbals, hush the under-the-breath rumblings of the percussion, console the aggrieved wail of the violin. He had never asked and his mother had never said, but Sorab knew that Tehmina would have willingly traded in the servants and the vendors who came to her door for a dishwasher that didn't complain, a vacuum cleaner that didn't ask for a raise, a supermarket where the prices were fixed, a clothes dryer that didn't talk back, a food processor that chopped onions without leaving a trail of tears in its wake.
He looked at Susan, trying so hard to understand him, and he felt the gap between them as enormous as the distance between Bombay and Ohio. How to explain to his wife the rift that opened up in his heart each time there was a conflict between the two women he loved most in the world? How to describe to her his first few years in America, when he had felt that rootlessness that only immigrants feel, so that he felt as if his head was touching the skies of America while his feet were rooted in Bombay, as if he was straddling two continents. He had looked forward to his dreams in those days, because in his dreams he could look out of his apartment window and there would be his father's old Ambassador parked on the snowy street. Or Mamma was cooking him fish curry rice in the tiny kitchen of his Ohio apartment. In his dreams, his fingertips still touched his old life. Sorab wanted to tell Susan about how, for years, he had longed for his life to be seamless, how he yearned to have all his loved ones
under the same roof. And how, after his mother and father began to visit him in Ohio, he had finally felt whole, complete, seamless.
“What're you thinking, honey?”
Sorab shook his head briskly. “Nothing. I mean, that is, well, I am just sorry that things are not smooth between you and Mamma this time, you know?”
Susan's lips disappeared in a thin line. Had she always worn this icy expression of displeasure? Sorab wondered. Or was it simply more frequent and noticeable these days?
“I'm sorry, too,” Susan said. “IâI just don't know what's gotten into her during this visit. She's just soâI don't knowâobstinate or something this time. Like I try to help, but she just doesn't seem as free and outgoing as she has in the past.”
“Or maybe she's just hurting,” Sorab snapped. His voice was hard but he didn't care. “Did you ever think of that? After all, the woman's just lost her husband of almost forty years.”
Susan stared at Sorab openmouthed. Her eyes glittered with tears. “That's so not fair. That's a real low blow, Sorab. You think I'm not aware of the loss that she's suffered? Hell, you think it's been easy living with you the last eight months, the way you've been moping around? Oh, I know you try to hide it, honey, but I know you miss your father. And here's a news flashâI miss Rustom daddy, too.”
“Susan,” Sorab started. “I'm sorry.”
“You-all ready to order?” It was the new waiter, and for a moment Sorab hated his guts. Bloody interrupting idiot.
“Go ahead,” he said to Susan. “What would you like?”
He turned to his wife as soon as the waiter had left. “Honey, listen to me. I know things are rough now. Iâ¦I honestly don't know what to do to make anything easier on anybody. It's just such a hard time. You know, I wish Mamma would decide what she wants to do, once and for all. It's the bloody uncertainty that's killing me.”
“Speaking of which,” Susan interrupted. “If she does decide to settle in America, we're going to have Rosalee come to clean every week, instead of our usual every two weeks, okay? This is the one thing I'm going to insist on, Sorab. I don't care ifâ”
“I thought we'd already decided we'd do that,” he said, hearing the coldness in his voice. “Why are you bringing that up again, Susan?”
“Because I know you think I'm being too nitpicky about the house. I know you don't get it, my need for a clean bathroom and a neat house.”
“Susan, please stop treating me like I'm some third-world bumpkin. What do you think, I don't appreciate a clean bathroom? It's just that other thingsâlike peace at home, f 'instanceâmatter as much to me. You don't know how you come across with Mamma at timesâlike you're some white-skinned princess ordering her underlings around.”
“Listen to you. Just fucking listen to yourself.” Susan's voice was loud but he resisted the urge to ask her to lower the volume, knowing it would only infuriate her more. “We were talking about the house and suddenly you've brought race and global politics into it. Honey, I married you knowing you were aâhow'd you put it?âa third-world bumpkin, okay? And what the color of your skin has to do with my not wanting hair in my damn bathtub when I take a shower, I don't know.” Susan was choking on her words now, using the cloth napkin to wipe away the hot tears hovering below her eyes.
“Dammit. This is the last thing I want to do tonight, get into a fight with you. All I was trying to tell you is⦔ He stared at her dumbly, miserably, not sure of how to salvage the evening. “Maybe asking Mamma to live with us is not a good idea,” he mumbled finally. “Maybe she needs to go back home at the end of her six months.”
“So that she can be lonely in that big flat all alone? And so that you can go crazy with worry each time she has a cold or something?
Or are you planning on rushing back each time something's wrong there? Remember how you almost went out of your mind during the Bombay riots? And that was when your dad was still alive.” Susan's voice softened. “Sorab, I love your mother, you know that. At least, you
should
know that after all these years. We'llâ¦we'll manage something, okay? If she decides to live in the U.S. we'll make it work, I promise. Part of the problem is, with the holidays and all, we're all so stressed out. Let's just get through the next few weeks.”
Sorab sighed heavily. “That's the other thing. Grace called me in her office today and acted all shocked that I'm taking the week after Christmas off. Asked me to reconsider my plans.”
Susan's eyes blazed. “She asked you what?”
He felt a spurt of gratitude for Susan, for how instinctively she leaped to his defense. That's the advantage of being married, he thought. There's someone always on your team when you're battling the world. “Yeah, she wants me to consider not taking the week off. Seems as if she has a ski trip planned the week after Christmas.”
“I'll tell you what you should reconsider. You should reconsider whether you want to keep working for your asshole boss. The woman's making your life miserable, Sorab. Maybe it's time to look for a new job.”
His earlier gratitude turned into irritation. “Good jobs don't grow on trees, hon,” he said. “Just the stock options in this job alone areâ”