ROMANCE: Mr. Mystery: (New Adult Bad Boy Romance) (Contemporary Mystery Short Stories) (108 page)

Chapter 6

After her climax, Evelyn was blown away by the rest of the night.  The two men managed to give her something she had never experienced before.  Maybe Monica had been right all alone.  Maybe a different type of couple was all she needed to make the threesome scene work again. 

The best part was that the men seemed to be totally okay with the situation.  Evelyn couldn’t sense any jealousy coming from either one of them, but only time could tell if that green-eyed monster would once again rear its ugly head and destroy what she had.

The two men were sleeping on either side of her now.  They had cuddled and exchanged some pillow talk for a bit before they dozed off pleasantly exhausted.  Evelyn was too excited to really fall asleep as every one of her nerve endings buzzed with excitement.  She really hoped that this relationship would last. 

She hoped, in the least, that she would have breakfast with them when she woke up in the morning. 

******

However, in the morning, Evelyn was greatly disappointed.  Shortly after she fell asleep Evelyn was woken up again by the men moving.  She looked at the clock to see that it was 6 o’clock.  She wondered what they were doing. 

She looked at them sleepily and Terrell looked at her.  “I’m sorry sweetie, but we have to go to work this morning.  We are sorry you couldn’t stay longer.”  Evelyn understood quickly and got up putting on her clothes.  She sighed softly.  There would be no breakfast. 

******

When Evelyn got home again she plopped down onto her bed.  She was exhausted and disappointed.  While the sex had been great, Evelyn was scared that the romance wasn’t there.  She didn’t just want to be a sex object for some couple.  She wanted to be a part of the relationship and do things that couples do like cuddle in the morning and have breakfast. 

She wondered if she should break up with them before she got too attached.  Evelyn didn’t want to get hurt. 

But would Monica be disappointed if her matchmaking didn’t work out?  Evelyn frowned and looked at her ceiling trying to figure out what to do.  Did she please Monica or please herself? 

Evelyn eventually fell asleep with these pressing thoughts going through her mind.  At the restaurant, she had been hopeful about her new relationship but now as she fell into a fitful sleep she was skeptical about the future. 

Chapter 7

Evelyn reveled in her anger for a few weeks.  She retreated into herself and ended up staying at home.  Luckily she worked from home so she had an excuse to stay home in her pajamas all day eating ice cream.  She knew it was pathetic, but she really didn’t feel like doing anything else. 

She felt like she would never find true love.  She felt depressed and lonely.  She didn’t know what to do.  She just wanted to love and be loved, was that too much to ask for?  Evelyn sighed as she went back to work, a tub of ice cream on her desk by her laptop.

******

Eventually, however, Evelyn could not stay away from the two men.  Eventually, they were the only thing on her mind and she couldn’t get them out of her.  She knew that the only way she would get them out of her mind would be to see them again.

She didn’t know if this was a good idea or if it was a bad idea, but she knew that it was the only thing she could do that would take the edge off of things.  Worst case scenario she never saw the men again or best case she would have a nice night of sex. 

With this thought in mind, she shot Collin and Terrell a text asking to meet up.  The men were eager to see her again and they decided to meet on the following Friday night.  Evelyn for some reason was hopeful as she put her phone down and marked the date on her calendar. 

******

Friday came sooner than Evelyn expected and before she knew it she was getting ready for her date.  She decided to go more casually this time since they were only going to have a night in.  She wondered what they would do for their “night in.”  If it was just sex, Evelyn would be greatly disappointed.  She wondered when people would see her as more than just an accessory for their pleasure. 

As she looked in the mirror she sighed softly.  She prayed for the best but expected the worst. 

******

Evelyn was now ringing the men’s doorbell.  She waited a moment before Collin opened up the door.  She was instantly hit with the smell of home cooked food and she couldn’t help but smile as she looked at Collin. 

“Come in, come in,” Collin said politely before taking her coat from her.  He hung it up for her before leading her to the living room.  “Terrell is just finishing up our dinner, for now let’s wait here.”  Evelyn was impressed that Terrell was actually cooking their food and smiled before nodding. 

Collin turned on the TV before making small talk with her.  Evelyn had expected the encounter to be awkward but for some reason she felt just as comfortable as she did the last time they were together.  She could feel herself pulling down her barriers the more she spoke with Collin. 

She ended up learning that they were both coaches for football teams in the city which meant that they always woke up early during the weekdays but during the weekends they were free to sleep in all they wanted.  Evelyn wondered why Collin was telling her this.  Was he implying something? 

Eventually, Terrell called out that dinner was ready and Evelyn and Collin moved into the kitchen.  Evelyn was surprised to see the dinner table set up for a romantic dinner for three and smiled.  She hadn’t expected them to do this for her, but she was happy that they did. 

“Wow… this is so thoughtful and beautiful…”  Terrell looked at her, an apron tied around his neck and waist.

“Well, we assumed that we had upset you the last time you were here so we wanted to make it up to you.”  Evelyn blushed deeply. 

“Oh wow… you guys didn’t have to do that.”

“Of course we did, we didn’t want you to stay mad at us!”  Collin said before giving her a kiss on the cheek.  She smiled before he pulled out her chair for her and seated her at the head of the table.  She smiled as the two men sat on either side of her. 

Dinner was amazing as Terrell’s cooking was delightful.  They spoke and made jokes throughout the whole time, making the time very enjoyable as all three of them had a lot of fun together. 

After dinner, the two men brought Evelyn back into the living room where they watched a movie together.  Evelyn ended up sitting between the two men and in the end she was leaning against Collin’s chest as Terrell had his arms around both of them.  At that moment, she felt like she belonged. 

She felt like she had finally found her niche with a couple of people and prayed that the night would continue to look as hopeful as it did. 

The movie was a romantic comedy and they ended up laughing and smiling the entire night.  By the time Evelyn expected to leave the men looked at her with puppy dog looks. 

“You aren’t leaving us, are you?”  Collin asked innocently as he watched Evelyn grab one of her shoes.  She looked at him curiously.  Did they really want her to stay the night? 

“Don’t you want to stay the night?  Did I make dinner for nothing?”  Evelyn looked at the two men and frowned a bit.  Had they only done all of this for the sex?  Evelyn was disappointed in herself for letting herself get caught in the trap.  They only wanted her for the sex.  They didn’t really care about her.  If they did, they would have treated her to dinner and a movie because they wanted to make her happy not to get in her pants. 

Terrell frowned as he looked at Evelyn.  “Hey… I didn’t mean it like that… Collin and I really do like you and we just want to show you…”  He said innocently.  Evelyn looked into his dark eyes and wondered if he was telling the truth.  She had heard that lie many times before and wondered if this time would be different than all the rest. 

Evelyn sighed a bit before nodding.  She would go with them and see where the night took her.  What was the worst thing that could happen?  If they dumped her, her heart had been broken so many times before, what was another crack? 

She numbly looked at Collin’s hand as he pulled her toward the bedroom.  He looked eager and Evelyn wished she could share in his excitement.  She wanted to be happy and excited, but there was something inside of her stopping her.  She feared the green-eyed monster.

Chapter 8

Nonetheless, Evelyn found herself dragged into the bedroom.  Even if the relationship would end when the night was over, Evelyn would still (hopefully) get a good night of sex out of the two men.

Collin looked excited as he pulled Evelyn into the bedroom.  Terrell grinned as he walked by their side.  He seemed to be excited as well. 

Soon they were in the bedroom and Collin was playfully pushing Evelyn onto the bed.  Terrell suddenly pounced on her and kissed her.  It was not like Terrell to make the first move with her.  Usually, Collin was the one that gave her the most attention.  Evelyn had the impression that Terrell liked men more than he liked women. 

And in fact, Terrell had been strictly gay for a long time. He had been gay when he was in a relationship with Collin.  Now, however, with the introduction of Evelyn into the bedroom Terrell was left to question his sexual orientation.  He found himself increasingly aroused by Evelyn. 

Even now he couldn’t help himself as he kissed her supple lips and rubbed his hands up and down her body before settling on her breasts which he groped eagerly now.

Evelyn moaned loudly as she felt the large hands grope her tits, sending shivers down her spine. 

Suddenly Evelyn felt herself being picked up by strong arms as Collin picked her up and wrapped her legs around his waist as he kissed her hard.  They started to make out as Evelyn loosened up and got into the mood.  She wrapped her willing tongue around his as she tasted his sweetness on her tongue. 

They continued to make out for a bit as Terrell started to jerk himself off to the sight of the two of them making out.  For some reason, the sight of them was very sexy to him.  Terrell would never have thought that he could be this turned on by a man and a woman getting together.

He bit his lip and continued to watch until Collin grinned and said, “Let’s get the real show on the road, shall we?”  With this, he gently lowered Evelyn onto Terrell. 

Evelyn ended up straddling Terrell, her ass facing him, and her legs spread wide and her pussy on full display. Collin looked at her and the glistening wetness between her legs.  He smirked to himself as he watched Terrell’s dick throb in anticipation. 

She quickly figured out what was supposed to happen and moved forward slowly.  She rubbed herself against him. Terrell moaned in pleasure as he felt her wet pussy against him.  Terrell had never felt anything like this before.  It was new and exciting for him and he liked it. 

He reached up and gently fondled her tits as she continued to tease his member with her pussy.

“C’mon that’s enough teasing…”  Collin looked at Evelyn who blushed at the comment.  She looked at him before she moved into position.  Slowly she lowered herself onto his member and shivered in pleasure.  He was much bigger than Collin and Evelyn bit her lip as she felt him fill her to the brim. 

She shivered and started to ride him slowly.  She moved up and down on his member as she got into the act of fucking him.  It felt good being in control as she moved the way she wanted varying the speed and roughness of the ride. 

As Evelyn got more and more into what she was doing Collin continued to watch them.  His hand was around his rock hard dick and he shivered in pleasure as he watched this beautiful woman fuck his boyfriend.  He knew that realistically he should be jealous right now, but he didn’t feel jealous at all. 

Instead, he was wholly excited by the idea of sharing the bedroom with these two beautiful people.  He smirked before leaning down, getting between Evelyn’s legs.  His tongue suddenly darted out and licked her wetness.  Evelyn moaned out loudly when she shivered in pleasure.  She looked down at him biting her lip. 

She felt amazing with a rock hard dick her in her pussy and a skilled tongue lapping away at her clit.  In pleasure, she reached down and placed her hands on Collin’s head.  She forced him into her crotch a little bit more and moaned loudly as she felt him press his tongue deep inside of her.

She moaned in pleasure as she felt his tongue move around inside of her.  She felt amazing.  This was even better than the first time. 

As she continued to ride and as Collin continued to eat her out Evelyn knew she wouldn’t last long.  With this amount of pleasure coursing through her body, it wouldn’t be long before it exploded. 

Collin started to fondle Terrell’s balls as he licked Evelyn harder and faster.  Soon enough he felt the tell-tale signs of both their orgasms as he felt Terrell’s balls tighten and Evelyn’s pussy quiver against his tongue.  He continued to lap at her juices hungrily, knowing that an ocean was about to flood his face. 

Suddenly, Evelyn exploded in a fit of passion all over Collin’s face and he moaned in pleasure as he started to lap up the juices greedily.  Not long after, Terrell pulled out just in time to cum all over Evelyn’s body. They were all now a mess.  Evelyn giggled. 

After Evelyn and Terrell helped Collin orgasm all three of them collapsed onto the bed and cuddled.  They didn’t care that they were covered in cum, all they cared about was being next to one another. 

Evelyn snuggled against the two men happily, once again prayed that this time things would work out. 

Chapter 9

The trio ended up falling asleep soon after their climaxes.  They cuddled a bit before exhaustion took over and they were all cozily sleeping together.  Terrell was snoring softly as Collin had his arm wrapped around Evelyn. 

Evelyn dreamt pleasant dreams as she laid between the two men and had anyone been awake to watch her face as she slept they would have seen her smiling in her sleep.  For once in a very long time Evelyn was happy.  She didn’t want to be anywhere else but in bed with these two men.  She just prayed they were truly what she was looking for. 

Unlike the first time, there was no alarm to wake up the two boys so all three of them slept until morning.  However, when Evelyn woke up she was disappointed to see Collin gone. 

She turned around and saw Terrell still sound asleep in the bed.  She wondered where Collin was but was glad that they hadn’t completely abandoned her.  She snuggled closer to the man and smiled.  Something about the whole situation felt right.

As she got closer to Terrell he started to wake up.  She smiled up at him and he smiled back.  “Morning beautiful.” 

She blushed a little at him before saying, “Morning... do you know where Collin went?” 

“What? Am I not good enough for you?”  Terrell teased lightly as he gently caressed her face. 

Evelyn frowned, thinking she had upset him.  Terrell chuckled before sniffing the air, “Well… by that smell I would say that he is downstairs making breakfast.” 

Evelyn looked amazed as she looked at Terrell.  “Breakfast?  Really?”  Waking up to breakfast with her lovers had been on Evelyn’s criteria for a perfect threesome.  She smiled and suddenly kissed Terrell. 

“What was that for?”  He asked, a little shy. 

“Well… for making last night special and for making this morning special as well,” she said honestly as she wrapped her arms around him.

Suddenly, Collin entered the room and smirked.  “Hey… no loving without me!”  Both of them chuckled.  “Breakfast is ready,” Collin announced.  He was now the one wearing the apron as he smiled. 

Terrell and Evelyn quickly tossed on some clothes before making their way downstairs.  Collin had outdone himself with the breakfast because on the table was pancakes, bacon, eggs, muffins, fruit, etc.  Evelyn’s eyes went big as she looked at all the food. 

“A buffet fit for a Queen!”  Collin said cheekily before kissing her cheek.  Evelyn could feel herself blush as she looked up at him.  These men seemed to be straight out of her dreams and she smiled in pleasure. 

Eventually, they all sat down and ate breakfast happily.  Evelyn couldn’t help realizing that this was just like her perfect threesome.  She smiled happily as she took a bite of her bacon.  

“Why are you smiling so much?”  Terrell asked. 

“Well… I have been thinking about a perfect relationship for a very long time… and I have to admit that you guys are coming pretty close to fitting the bill.”  Evelyn blushed darkly as she admitted this to the two men. 

Collin chuckled but looked proud.  “I’m glad.  So does that mean you are going to date us now?”  Collin asked hopefully. 

Evelyn was a little taken aback by the offer and blushed in response.  She could feel her face become bright red at his words, but eventually she nodded.  She wanted nothing more than to have a serious relationship with these men.  They were everything she ever wanted in a pair of lovers.  She smiled and before she knew it they were in a group hug together. 

“But… we are all pretty dirty from last night… Shower anyone?”  Terrell offered as he looked at his two lovers.  When he had gotten into a relationship with Collin he had assumed he would always be with Collin and only Collin but now that he had experienced a love life with Evelyn he knew he couldn’t continue without both of them in his life. 

Evelyn smiled happily and nodded as the men ticked another aspect off her perfect threesome dream.  They were just getting better by the minute. 

She was giddy as they went into the bathroom together.  Soon enough they stripped off the minimum clothing they had on and managed to squeeze into the shower together. 

They were very good about washing one another.  It seemed all three of them were getting equal attention and Evelyn was glad for it.  She had been so terrified of the green-eyed monster, but she felt that this time he wouldn’t show his ugly head.  For some reason, she couldn’t see the men getting jealous.  For some reason, she pictured her life with these men.  She imaged herself growing old and happy with them. 

As Evelyn daydreamed about these things she felt Terrell’s hands on her chest.  He was washing them with a lot of soap and Evelyn moaned loudly in response to his groping.  He was very good at messaging her tits. 

“I never thought you would be a tit kind of guy Terrell,” Collin commented as he watched his lover fondle Evelyn’s tits.  Terrell smirked and looked at Collin. 

“Neither did I but these things are great!”  Evelyn chuckled as Terrell continued to make her moan.  In the end, the shower was an amazing experience that just brought them even closer together.  Evelyn couldn’t have been happier.