Chapter Thirty-seven
“Where are Hayden and Amelie?” Grey asked. He stood on Quod Lamia’s porch, his hat in hand, and drank in the sight of Fanny like a man dying of thirst drank clear, cool water.
Except there was nothing clear or cool about her. The ultra-composed woman of a few days ago had vanished. She looked as exhausted as he felt. Dark circles bruised the delicate flesh beneath her eyes. Her hair settled like an ebony cloud on shoulders bowed by fatigue. Her skin held a grayish cast and her eyes were haunted.
“Fanny,” he said more gently still. “Where did they go?”
“Go?” She sounded confused. “Amelie is still in bed. . . . I . . . What do you mean, ‘Amelie and Hayden’? Why would you ask that?” She pinched the skin on the bridge of her nose, as though she were having trouble concentrating.
Wordlessly, Grey handed her the wire message. She bent her head over the single sheet, sweeping her hair back with one hand in an unconsciously elegant gesture. As forceful and opinionated as she was, there was still something of the woodland sylph about her, an otherworldly grace, an aura of fragility that everything else about her belied.
She looked up. “This says that Hayden and Amelie have eloped.”
“Yes,” he replied to her tone more than her words. “I don’t believe it either. Even if he doesn’t care whether or not he is disinherited by his father, Hayden has too much regard for the girl to jeopardize her reputation by eloping with her. I assume they are hiding here somewhere, waiting until I leave to reveal themselves. I also assumed you would know where they are.”
She flushed. “No. I know nothing about this. But I intend to find out.”
She turned, her hair whipping around lightly, her vibrancy returning as she strode along the corridor. He followed her, weaving through the cluttered hall, up the staircase, down another equally cluttered hall to a closed door. She pounded once on this portal. When no one answered, she opened the door. The room was empty. The window was closed, its drapes drawn, and the bed had clearly not been slept in.
Fanny looked, her expression concerned. “I don’t know where they are. I swear it.”
He didn’t know what to think. His thoughts were too colored by emotion to trust them. Part of him wanted to believe she was as surprised and dismayed by this empty room as she seemed. The cynic in him suggested that her reaction had been prettily orchestrated to convince him she was telling the truth. The truth. It always came down to that.
“I don’t care,” he heard himself say. “Far be it from me to interfere with whatever ruse you have plotted. Whatever it is, I am convinced Hayden is complicit. If he wants to stay here, so be it. He’s of age. About the rest, I don’t give a damn.”
It was a lie. A terrible lie.
“Tell my nephew I wish him well.” He began to turn away, but her voice stopped him.
“Wait. This is no scheme,” she said. “At least, not to my knowledge.”
“So, you are saying that McGowan really shot at Amelie yesterday?” he scoffed.
“No. I know Amelie made up the previous attempts upon her well-being and wrote that letter.” She frowned. “And I don’t think McGowan has done anything. But then, I also thought she was through lying before she said it.”
“I don’t care whether you know their plans or not. If Hayden is foolish enough to elope and the girl is foolish enough to agree, then good riddance to them.
“Who knows?” he said. “Were I younger, had I less knowledge of the world, and my history bore fewer abject lessons in deceit, I might have done the same thing in his situation.”
He was speaking of her. Of them. And she understood. It was there in her eyes.
“Would you?” she whispered.
His tone, having begun harshly, dissolved into regret. “Yes. Oh, yes.”
“But those days are long past,” she said, watching him closely.
He wanted to deny it. Instead, he said, “Fanny? Aren’t you tired? I am so tired of wondering what is and isn’t the truth.”
“I haven’t lied to you. Not once since you’ve arrived.”
Disappointment welled up inside him. “For the love of God, Fanny—”
“No,” she broke in forcefully. “I haven’t lied to you. The letter and the rest, it was all Amelie’s doing. I just found out myself. And I didn’t lie about anything else.” Her gaze did not waver. “I cannot explain everything. There are things I haven’t told you and things that are mine alone to reveal but I have not lied.”
He turned away from her, his reason and his heart estranged from each other. He raked his hair back from his temples with both hands, closing his eyes, trying to concentrate.
She’d claimed she hadn’t written the letter to Collier. Had Amelie? But Fanny hadn’t corrected Hayden’s charge that she had coerced Amelie into being part of a scheme she’d devised. She hadn’t substantiated it, either. Had she been protecting Amelie? Why wasn’t she now? He had never wanted to believe anything so much.
And now, finally, he understood his father’s mania, his obsession, and how wanting a thing could separate a man from his reason and make him a fool. And, dear Lord, he would gladly, happily give anything to become a fool for her. To make a leap of faith and trust his heart.
But he couldn’t.
He’d spent too many years revealing the truth behind the most cherished lies. He did not have faith; he needed proof.
“Will you tell me something?” He heard his heart in his throat.
She did not hesitate. “If in doing so I do not betray a confidence entrusted to me.”
“I can’t think that would be the case here.”
“Yes. Then yes.” It was a vow.
“In London. In Mayfair six years ago,” he said, “how did you manufacture the sound and sensation of what others described as angel wings in”—he hesitated, unable to bring himself to say
your husband’s
—“in Brown’s séance parlor? What brushed so many of your clients’ hair and cheeks?”
She actually shivered, briefly closing her eyes against his question. When she opened them, sadness filled them. For a long moment she looked at him, her gaze traveling over his features with a sort of hungry resignation reserved for a man embarking on a voyage from which he knew he would not return.
“Fanny?”
She sighed. Her shoulders lifted in a little apology. She smiled unconvincingly. “Bats,” she said. “There was a colony in the chimney.”
He regarded her in disappointment. “You can’t train bats.”
“No,” she whispered. “You can’t.”
“Then how . . . ?” He let the question hang unfinished between them.
She lifted her hand in a gesture of entreaty, looked at it, and let it fall. She laughed and it turned into a soft sob. “What shall I call it?” she muttered aloud. “What word will make it palatable for you? What word will allow you to accept it? Accept
me
?”
“Fanny. What are you talking about?” he asked, profoundly concerned.
“Magic.”
“Magic,” he repeated. He could not believe she was saying this to him. He waited for her to explain, laugh, roll her eyes. She did none of these things.
“Magic,” he repeated. “You are saying you conjured the bats?”
“Conjured? No. I simply called them to me. They . . . felt my purpose, I suppose.”
Her gaze fluttered about the room. Whether she was seeking escape or inspiration, he couldn’t tell. She looked on the verge of tears.
“Not just bats,” she went on. “Every animal. If I feel something very strongly, if I feel the need of something very badly, they react. They answer that . . . inner communication.”
“Dear God,” he murmured.
A tear slipped from her eye.
He stared at her helplessly. He could not understand why she would do this. “Why are you saying this, Fanny? Why would you seek to provoke me this way? Knowing how much I loathe this sort of thing. Is it because I love you?”
“No.” She shook her head violently.
He did not stop. His heart was breaking. “Is it because you have decided that anything further between us is impossible? That you wish to send me away without a shred of hope? Is that it?” A horrible thought occurred to him. “Is this, perhaps, your version of
kindness
? Because if it is, I beg you, be unkind.”
“No!” Her voice was choked and hoarse. “It is because I do love you. Because you asked for the truth and I swore I would tell it to you.”
He sighed deeply, wearily. Whatever her reasons, she was not going to give them to him. “You are empowered with supernatural gifts?”
“Gifts?” Her laughter hurt to hear. “A curse. Yes.”
“You have some sort of empathic relationship with animals?”
“Yes.”
“You called the bats from the chimney in Brown’s parlor to simulate the presence of spirits?”
“Yes.” She nodded, a flicker of eagerness brightening her black eyes.
“Then call them now.”
Her body jerked as if he’d suggested she shoot him. “I can’t.”
“Of course you can’t.”
“You don’t understand,” she cried plaintively. “It was never something I cultivated. Only those few years with Alphonse, and I never mastered it. I could call the bats, but only because they were so near already. It took every bit of my concentration to hold them there, and as soon as I let up, they vanished back up the chimney.”
“Convenient.”
“Grey, please. I didn’t ask for this. I didn’t seek this thing. I don’t want it, and I have spent the last six years trying to suppress it. It isn’t like whistling for a dog.”
“It happens only when you are overwrought.”
“Yes, yes!”
“Then it’s too bad you can’t manufacture up a bit of emotion, isn’t it?” he said, gazing at her sadly.
For a second she stared at him, and then she tipped back her head, her eyes squeezed shut, her expression agonized. “It doesn’t work that way,” she whispered.
He took a step toward her. He couldn’t help himself. She was so sad and so lovely, and she was everything he’d ever love and was fated to lose. It didn’t matter whether she believed in this fantasy she’d spun or was simply trying to deceive him. Either way, she represented everything he could not believe in and everything he had fought against for his entire adult life.
He wished he could be angry. He couldn’t. He’d felt similarly toward his father, wanting to despise him and being incapable of doing so. He didn’t have the capacity to despise one whom he loved. It was his weakness; it was what made him vulnerable. He’d tried to protect himself, to hide the vulnerability beneath cynicism and caution. He’d done so well.
Until Fanny.
What hubris he’d possessed, thinking he could choose whom to love and when. But she’d swept into his imagination and then his dreams and finally his life, laying waste to all his self-assurance and peace of mind, destroying what he thought he knew and leaving him in a shambles.
“I love you, Fanny,” he said, tenderly brushing a lock of black hair from her damp cheek. She trembled. “But I cannot betray who I am, even for you.
“There is no magic, just magicians. And amongst their stratum, my beloved, you are unquestionably without peer. I am utterly enchanted. I doubt I shall ever recover.” He tried to smile. Failed.
“Grey . . . There is magic. I am sorry. I am so sorry. But there is.”
“Hush.” Gently, he cupped her face between his palms and lowered his lips to hers. Softly, sweetly, lingeringly, he kissed her. And when he finished, he rested his forehead lightly against hers until a shudder passed through him. He forced himself to step away and let his hand drop from her damp cheeks, tenderly bestowing a last caress as his fingertips fell from the soft curve.
“Tell Hayden—” He swallowed, looked away. “Tell Hayden I will wait for him until this afternoon, but I intend to be in Flood-on-Blot before dawn. I can’t stay here. I can’t. But if he chooses to stay, tell him—” He cleared his throat. “Tell Hayden to hold tight to his illusions. They are worth far more than reality. Good-bye, Fanny.”
He did not look back.