The First Time is the Sweetest (22 page)

“Why do I have the feeling this is what you planned all along?” Jimmy said with a resigned look, his eyes laughing at her.

She didn’t say anything, just cocked the camera at them and quirked her mouth to one side. She loved the way Gabriel laughed as he shoved his jeans down over his hips. She got a few shots of him in the middle of taking off his pants with Jimmy laughing down at him. It was sultry and awkward at the same time. She knew they would kill her when they saw those particular shots, but Sabrina didn’t care. Once his jeans were gone, she stared balefully at his boxers. Gabriel angled an eyebrow at her, and she nodded hopefully. As Gabriel slowly began to slide his boxers off his lean hips, Sabrina’s breath stuttered. Then the tip of his cock came into view and she snapped a picture almost unconsciously.

“Jesus, Gabriel,” Jimmy whispered, staring at the other man. The look on his face was taut, aroused, and Sabrina captured the light slanting over Gabriel’s nearly naked body and Jimmy’s eyes, lit with desire. The stubble on Jimmy’s jaw caught the light and glittered with touches of gold. Gabriel threw his head back, showing her a smooth line from his neck down to his chest as he used both hands to ease his underwear down. Then he lay down on the rug, crossing his arms under his head as he stared at her. She could barely breathe. And Jimmy! Jimmy’s nostrils flared as his hands hovered above Gabriel’s body, almost touching but not quite.

Sabrina cleared her throat, trying to work some moisture into her mouth so she could speak. “Jimmy,” she began. He didn’t hear. “Jimmy!” He slowly turned his head to see what she wanted. He looked drunk. Sabrina didn’t think she’d ever seen him look that way, his lust barely contained as the two men waited for her to tell them what she wanted next. “Would you take off your pants, too?” she asked him, not really believing he would do it, but hoping nonetheless. He stared at her for a moment and then slowly his hands moved away from Gabriel. Sabrina clutched her camera convulsively as Jimmy popped the top button on his jeans. She remembered she was supposed to be taking pictures and lifted the camera to her face. Through the viewfinder, the camera framed them perfectly, and she pressed the button again and again, dry-mouthed as Jimmy slowly moved his zipper down, then shimmied out of his pants. His cock was hard, the head a ruddy pink. She guessed he’d gotten over his uncertainty about letting her photograph him. He didn’t seem in the least bothered, lying there on the rug as her heart pounded. Sabrina stared, trying to figure out what she wanted them to do next.

Jimmy shifted on the floor, his right hand moving to stroke himself. She swallowed. “What do you want, Sabrina?” Jimmy asked huskily as his hand moved up and down. Gabriel was also watching, and she saw his sex twitch when Jimmy’s hand twisted around the tip of his cock, rubbing his thumb over the sensitive slit already seeping moisture. “Sabrina, what do you want?” Jimmy asked again, eyes heavy with arousal.

“Lie down behind Gabriel,” she said, trying to think. “Put your arm around him.” He did as she asked, and Sabrina could see him fitting his cock into the groove of Gabriel’s ass as Gabriel tilted onto his side. Both men shuddered when Jimmy reached around and grasped Gabriel’s erection firmly in his hand, holding him so that the head just peeked out from between his fingers. Gabriel groaned and moved his hips. Sabrina snapped a picture of them like that, the sun falling on their hair and skin, lighting them up as Jimmy pleasured Gabriel in front of her.

Jimmy stroked his hand on Gabriel slowly, once, twice, then stopped and looked up. “Sabrina, aren’t you hot in all those clothes?” She nodded absently and moved closer, zooming in on the curve of Gabriel’s hip and the strong bones of Jimmy’s hand. Sabrina heard Gabriel chuckle.

“She’s distracted, Jimmy.” Gabriel laughed again as Jimmy kissed his shoulder. Sabrina shivered and snapped a photo.

“Sabrina, take off your clothes,” Gabriel told her. She saw Jimmy nodding behind Gabriel’s tousled hair and put the camera aside. She couldn’t concentrate anymore anyway and Gabriel was right: she was hot. She was so hot she couldn’t open the tie of her sweatpants. Her skin felt flushed and sensitive as she struggled to undo the knot in the string. Then Gabriel groaned thickly because Jimmy began moving his hand again and she had to see. Sabrina licked her lips and stared, watched Jimmy thrust against Gabriel’s ass. Another trickle of sweat rolled down between her breasts, and she pulled off her tank top. She wasn’t wearing anything underneath, and Gabriel’s eyes opened when she tossed the shirt aside. Her nipples hardened as the cooler air hit them and Sabrina rubbed them absently, trying to relieve the ache. Both men groaned. Startled, her eyes flew to theirs, and she saw that they were watching her touch herself.

“God, don’t stop, Sabrina,” Gabriel rasped. Jimmy held him loosely, teasing the other man with his thumb. Gabriel shuddered. “I want to see the rest of you.”

Jimmy nodded in agreement, rubbing his face against the back of Gabriel’s head. Sabrina gave up trying to untie her sweats, standing up and slowly sliding them down over her hips, grabbing her panties at the same time and pushing both off in one motion. Jimmy’s hand stopped moving as he watched her bare herself. Sabrina saw him thrust against Gabriel, pushing his cock into the other man’s warmth. Both seemed to be barely breathing as Sabrina kicked her clothing away and settled down on the edge of the rug. She was close enough to smell them, close enough to touch them, but she wanted to watch them more than she wanted them to touch her. Both men scooted back as she sat near them.

“Jimmy, don’t stop,” she said, moving her hands to her nipples again. Gabriel sighed and Jimmy slid his hand over him again, smiling as Jimmy gasped against his neck.

“Jesus, God, Sabrina, you are so fucking beautiful,” Jimmy rasped and Gabriel nodded, his hands clutching at the rug and Jimmy’s thigh, his erection swelling even more. Sabrina moaned. She’d heard Jimmy swear before, but the way he said those few words—she shook her head.

“And you, Gabriel, I want—” Jimmy began again, then broke off.

Gabriel pushed lightly back against the other man, rubbing his ass against him. “What do you want, Jimmy?” he murmured. Sabrina watched, fingers still on her breasts. Gabriel tipped his head back and rubbed his lips against Jimmy’s mouth, not kissing yet, just teasing. “What do you want?”

“God, Gabriel, I want, I…you…” Jimmy began again, then groaned and dipped his tongue into Gabriel’s mouth, giving up on words.

After a moment, Gabriel pulled back, undulating his hips beneath Jimmy’s hand. Sabrina tried to swallow. Gabriel looked at her and she froze. “Sabrina, what do you want? Would you like to see Jimmy make love to me?” he asked in a husky voice, and she inhaled sharply, imagining it. “Would you like to see him fuck me?” he whispered, staring with hot eyes straight at her. Jimmy bucked against him and Sabrina found herself nodding even though she wasn’t quite certain how they would manage it. Jimmy groaned, his hand gripping Gabriel’s as both men stroked Gabriel’s cock. It was so hard it curved up to touch his stomach.

“Gabriel?” Jimmy began, then cleared his throat. “Are you sure?” Gabriel nodded and smiled, beckoning to Sabrina with his hand. “You’ve never done this before,” Jimmy said, sounding concerned.

“I know, but I trust you. And I want you.” Gabriel turned his head briefly and kissed Jimmy lightly. “I want all three of us to do this, together.” Jimmy swallowed convulsively and kissed Gabriel on the back of his neck passionately before looking back at Sabrina.

“Sabrina, honey, would you get something for me?” She nodded. “Upstairs in my black bag I have lube and condoms in the inside pocket. Would you get them?” She jerked to her feet, somehow managing to stand, then dashed upstairs. She fumbled in Jimmy’s bag for a minute, trying to calm down and think.
Where did he say it was?
Then her hand closed over the small bottle.

Three minutes later, she was back on the rug with them, pressing the lube into Gabriel’s hand. She tossed the strip of condoms on the rug beside Jimmy. Gabriel lay on his back as the other man tongued his cock lightly, not sucking, just teasing. Sabrina’s mouth watered. She wasn’t sure Gabriel even realized she’d given him the lube, judging from the way he tossed his head back and forth, sweat dampening his hair. Then Jimmy sat up and looked at her, ignoring Gabriel’s moan of protest.

“Sabrina, come here and take over, would you?” She smiled and scooted closer, then lay down next to Gabriel, eager to feel him on her tongue, eager to taste him.

He opened his eyes. “Sabrina,” he breathed. She leaned in and kissed him, loving the way his lips immediately parted to let her in. She could feel him trembling as she licked inside, then he took control of the kiss.

Sabrina moaned as Gabriel thrust his tongue into her mouth and threaded his fingers into her hair, holding her head still so he could lick into her. She threw her arms around him and rubbed her breasts against the springy hair on his chest as he urged her to straddle him. He bucked as her sex brushed against his cock, and she almost fell off. Then she twisted around to see what Jimmy was doing and saw him crouched between Gabriel’s legs. He had one of Gabriel’s thighs thrown over his shoulder. He looked up and winked, then leaned his head down and licked one of Gabriel’s balls, making the other man writhe. She slid off to the side and kissed Gabriel’s open mouth before working her way down his chest, enjoying the way his breathing stuttered. When she bit his left nipple, he groaned; then she felt his hips shift, and she turned to see Jimmy staring intently between Gabriel’s legs, his right arm flexing. What was he doing?

Jimmy looked up and motioned her down beside him. Sabrina moved down, sliding her body along Gabriel’s as she went. His skin was so hot, and she shuddered in pleasure. He had his eyes tightly closed now. When she got nearer to Jimmy, she licked at Gabriel’s cock, dying to taste him. He trembled beneath her tongue and Jimmy breathed, “Yeah, that’s it, Sabrina.” She slid the hot crown into her mouth, lightly sucking for a moment before moving off again. Gabriel moaned in protest and grabbed at her hip, so she clasped her fist around him. When she looked down to see what Jimmy was doing, to her surprise, she saw him sliding his index finger in and out of Gabriel’s hole as he squirmed and shoved himself up into her hand and then back down onto Jimmy, over and over.

“Oh,” she breathed. She felt heat flash through her at the sight of Gabriel spread open like that. When she glanced back up at Jimmy, she found him looking at her; then he smiled and kissed her as Gabriel’s thick sex slid up through her hand again, slick with her saliva. She moaned into Jimmy’s mouth. When she pulled back, she noticed that Jimmy’s cock was as hard as Gabriel’s. She leaned down to suck it in, making Jimmy gasp. He tasted slightly sweeter than the other man, and she pulled off to slide Gabriel back in, comparing the two. She was so aroused she couldn’t think.

“Sabrina, wait, here…” Jimmy said as she moved off Gabriel again. She saw him sliding his two fingers out of Gabriel and shivered.
Did that feel good?
she wondered. “Let me have your fingers, sweetheart.” She gave Jimmy her hand as Gabriel opened his eyes and propped himself up on his elbows. He looked dazed and she couldn’t help smiling at him as Jimmy squeezed a dollop of lube onto her hand, then brought it to Gabriel’s opening. Her eyes flew up to Jimmy. He smiled.

“Don’t worry, it feels good,” Gabriel said, voice husky. She turned to look at him as Jimmy gently urged her inside. Gabriel’s eyes half closed when she let her fingers slide in, the slick lube making it easy. He moaned, and she rubbed up inside him, feeling how hot he was and how strongly the muscle around the opening clenched at her hand. She had no idea this would excite her so much. She loved feeling him shake as she moved her fingers, loved hearing his breathing change.

Jimmy sighed in her ear and Sabrina shivered again. “Slide in as far as you can and crook your fingers up.”

“Why?” she breathed, fascinated that Gabriel seemed to be enjoying this so much.

“You’re looking for his prostate. It feels like a small bump and when you stroke it, it feels incredible,” Jimmy explained. Sabrina moved her fingers deeper into Gabriel; then suddenly his entire body clenched just as she brushed over something. “Again,” Jimmy urged her, kissing her neck and sucking lightly behind her ear. She trembled and did as he instructed, loving the way Gabriel’s body shook. Then Jimmy moved to Gabriel’s other side, and she saw him roll on a condom and slick himself with lube. She stopped moving, and Gabriel protested, his hands clutching at her as she stared at Jimmy. Both men were so beautiful, their muscles flexing as they shuddered and moved, their cocks thick with heat. She wanted them desperately and didn’t know what the hell to do about it. She was grateful when Jimmy gently motioned for her to lie down. She pulled her fingers free and complied, her head falling next to Gabriel, who immediately turned and kissed her before pulling away.

“No—” Sabrina started to say, reaching for him, but he was already kneeling up over her and urging her to open her legs. He settled in between, gently rubbing his fingers through her soft curls before taking his cock in hand and rubbing the head against her clit. She groaned, so hot that a few more strokes like that and she’d come. Sabrina squirmed, trying to get him to thrust inside as he kneeled over her when Jimmy ran his hands down her hips and to her thighs, parting them even further so that Gabriel could spread his legs, too. Gabriel’s cock inadvertently slid against her clit with the motion. Sabrina was crazy with lust, and it took a moment before she realized Jimmy was speaking.

“When you fuck Sabrina, I’m going to fuck you, Gabriel,” Jimmy muttered hoarsely, his head near Gabriel’s ear, making them both shiver. Jimmy flexed his hips, and Gabriel’s cock slipped inside her entrance as he moaned. He felt so huge she almost doubted he would fit, but slowly, oh so slowly he shoved himself inside, working hard to move even a little bit. He was thicker than he’d been the last time. Sabrina loved the way his face tightened as he pushed his way in, loved the way his breathing hitched with every thrust. She licked his cheek as she felt herself stretching and arched her back, reveling in how good he felt, but finally he stopped, completely seated in her body, his soft pubic hair brushing against her. His cock throbbed but he wouldn’t move. Sabrina squirmed against him, desperate.