The First Time is the Sweetest (28 page)

“Lift her up, Jimmy,” Gabriel instructed.

Jimmy obeyed, grasping her arms and pulling her up as he leaned back until he lay on the bed with her riding him. He flexed his thighs and spread his legs. Sabrina shivered and leaned down over Jimmy’s chest, kissing him softly. This position left her ass exposed, and she wasn’t surprised when she felt Gabriel’s slick finger rubbing around her sensitive hole. She gasped and clutched at Jimmy.

“Easy, Sabrina,” Gabriel whispered, shifting closer. “You asked us for this, remember?” She nodded, thinking about the request she’d made a week ago.

“Just relax, sweetheart,” Jimmy murmured, running his hands up and down her arms. Then he tweaked her nipples and she bucked, shoving herself down further onto his cock just as Gabriel’s finger slipped inside.

“Mmmm, you feel so hot inside,” Gabriel rasped into her ear. She felt him ease out and then his hand returned. “I’m going to try for two fingers, okay?” She didn’t say anything because Jimmy chose that moment for his hands to wander down and slip into the wet heat at the apex of her thighs. His thumb grazed her clit, and Sabrina groaned as he teased her in front and Gabriel teased her in back.

“Easy now.” She felt the thick crown of his cock nudge at her opening. “It’ll be very tight at first, then it’ll get better.” She nodded, moaning and close to coming.

Jimmy continued to stroke her clit gently but not enough to send her over the edge. She didn’t know how he held so still because she could feel him swelling larger and larger. She opened her eyes as Gabriel pressed into her, the burning getting stronger. She looked at Jimmy, afraid this wouldn’t work, but he was staring over her shoulder. Then, just when she knew Gabriel wouldn’t fit, Jimmy closed his eyes and gasped as she felt Gabriel’s cock suddenly slip in. It hadn’t occurred to her until then that the two men would be able to feel each other. The thought sent another surge of heat throughout her body. She heard someone moaning and realized it was her. The sensation of Gabriel easing inside her body, feeling his cock rubbing against Jimmy’s was almost too much for her to handle. Tears streamed down her face as Jimmy continued to finger her. All three of them were shaking when Gabriel finally stopped.

“I’m in,” he whispered hoarsely. Jimmy nodded, squeezing his eyes shut as Sabrina squeezed her muscles experimentally, stroking both men at the same time.

Gabriel groaned. “Oh hell, Sabrina, I’ve got to move, I’ve got to, okay?”

Sabrina nodded. He sounded desperate. She felt pretty desperate herself by now. He slid out just enough so she could feel the tip of him pressing against her and then slammed back in. Jimmy groaned and rocked beneath them. Sabrina felt Gabriel’s hands on her shoulders as he shoved into her almost violently while Jimmy rested his hands on her hips, holding her immobile. She couldn’t move, couldn’t do anything but feel. At this angle, every time Gabriel pulled back Jimmy’s cock knocked against her clit. She was so close! She wanted more and gripped Jimmy’s forearms, holding on as both men finally lost control and began thrusting erratically. Gabriel buried his head in her nape as he shoved in one last time and Sabrina came, sobbing with the pleasure. Her climax sent Gabriel over the edge and he jerked, groaning. Jimmy gasped, then arched his back, and she felt him shiver and come, too. Everything was so tight. She felt both men orgasming inside her, the throbbing of their cocks stroking her enough to make her climax again. The pleasure seemed to go on forever.

When Sabrina finally opened her eyes, she realized that they’d collapsed on the bed in a heap. She hoped they weren’t crushing Jimmy, who was on the bottom, but when she lifted her head he was smiling. She laughed, and both men shivered as her movements made their softening cocks rub against each other inside her body. She had never felt so intimately connected with anyone ever before. Their love was the most precious thing in her life. She felt Gabriel shift, then slip out. He got rid of the condom and then settled down on his side. Jimmy lifted her up and over and she lay down between the two men, cuddling into their warmth.

“Well, we finally did it.” Jimmy stroked his finger down her face. Sabrina smiled.

“Yes,” Gabriel said, his long arm hugging both her and Jimmy. “I’ve never felt anything like that.”

“Me neither.” Jimmy sighed.

“I’m so happy,” Sabrina murmured and felt both men agree with her. Then she remembered what she’d wanted to tell them before she got home. “Oh! I almost forgot!” she exclaimed and opened her eyes. Both men groaned and pretended they were already sleeping. Gabriel made snoring sounds. She heard Jimmy snorting, pretending to yawn. “Hey!” She poked them both. She saw Jimmy smiling beneath the arm he’d thrown over his face. She poked him again, and he opened his eyes and growled at her as she laughed. “Guess what?” She sat up and shoved at Gabriel.

Gabriel propped his head up on his elbow, smiling indulgently. “What is it?” he asked, sighing dramatically.

Sabrina poked at him. “I got the opening for the show!” Jimmy sat up and whooped, kissing her soundly and hugging her as Gabriel did the same.

“You got the show? That’s awesome Sabrina!” Gabriel said, and then he kissed her, too. “I know how much you hoped…” he tried to say when she interrupted.

“—but I knew there were five hundred other students competing,” Sabrina said, smiling and hugging both men at the same time.

“Does this mean we get to come to the opening with you?” Jimmy asked, smiling at her.

“It sure does,” she replied. “I have no intention of hiding you away. I’ll be damned if I’m going to pass up the opportunity to show the two of you off to everyone.”

Both men grinned, and Sabrina felt a surge of happiness so great she nearly burst into tears. She laughed, thinking of how surprised her new friends would be when she showed up with Jimmy and Gabriel. No one really believed her when she told them she had two boyfriends. Everyone thought she was kidding. She was going to seriously enjoy showing them off at her show. Then Gabriel kissed her, and Sabrina realized that she was happy not just because they were both gorgeous, but because of how much the three of them loved one another. They’d been through hell and back together and that meant everything to her.

Sabrina smiled, her heart full. She was in school for photography just like she’d always wanted and had just won the coveted show offered to one photography student each year. And she’d done it in her first year! She was living with the two men she loved. Jimmy was doing well as a freelance journalist while working on a book about his time in Afghanistan. Gabriel’s private security firm was doing very well. Everything she’d ever wanted was happening, and she couldn’t be more delighted with her life. She kissed both men one more time before lying down between them again. Jimmy pulled up the covers and kissed them both good night. Gabriel murmured a quiet
I love you,
and soon she felt herself drifting off, content to lie there between the two of them. She knew they loved her. She knew they loved each other. And there was nowhere she’d rather be than nestled safely in their arms.

THE END

www.erinmleaf.com

Siren Publishing, Inc.

www.SirenPublishing.com