The Liar Society (21 page)

If I was a normal girl, I would have spent hours picking out the perfect dress and coordinating accessories for Homecoming. If I was a normal girl, I would have booked an appointment to get my hair done with friends and then headed over to someone’s house to jockey for a spot at the mirror and giggle over eyeliner and body glitter. If I was a normal girl, I’d have had butterflies in my stomach as I waited and wondered what type of corsage my date would bring and whether or not he’d kiss me good night.

But I was not a normal girl.

I spent the Saturday of the Homecoming dance rearranging the letters in the words
Audi, Vide, Tace
in an attempt to create a comprehensive list of possible passwords. I couldn’t ask Liam for help, because Grace had specifically said to come alone. Besides, this was something I had to do on my own. Feeling fairly confident about my list, I folded it into my clutch and decided to focus on my next problem. Finding something to wear.

I pulled on a pink strapless dress from our Sadie Hawkins dance two years earlier. Not only did it clash with my hair, but apparently I had grown, because it barely covered my butt. I tried rearranging Grace’s pearls a few times in an effort to bring the eyes up. Not happening. The slutty look worked well for Hollywood starlets and girls hanging out on street corners, but I decided it might be best to attempt a slightly more subtle fashion statement for my first Homecoming dance.

After yanking the pink dress off, I dug into the back of my closet for the dress I’d worn to the New Year’s Eve gala my parents had forced me to attend the year before. I bent over, pleased that my butt was still covered, and sat on my bed waiting for two dates instead of just one.

I had butterflies in my stomach. But not because I was worried about which date I’d kiss. I was a little more focused on figuring out the password into the underground lair of a secret society to meet my dead best friend.

Yeah, I was definitely not a normal girl.

When I finally heard the doorbell ring, I ran downstairs as fast as my fabulous gold heels would take me and found Liam and Seth squirming on my front porch. Technically, we had decided to go as a group to monitor any potential Brotherhood-Sisterhood activities, but I had to admit this whole threesome thing was getting a little tired.

“You look…” Seth began but appeared to be at a loss for words.

“Hot. I think the word you’re looking for is
hot
,” Liam finished for him.

I swear I’m not one of the “oh, this old thing?” type of girls. It’s just that my old dress happened to be a slinky black number. And Grace’s pearls spilled down the center of the V-shaped neckline, setting off the cut of the thin material. Guess sometimes that whole effortless beauty thing actually worked out. Good to know.

After a painfully awkward photo session with my parents and the Allens (Mrs. Allen couldn’t stop crying and blowing her nose), the three of us piled into Liam’s Jeep, an unlikely trio as we bounced down the road toward Pemberly Brown.

Seth’s suit was approximately ten sizes too big (is it just me, or can you hear his mom saying, “We want it a little big, honey, so you’ll have something nice to wear to all those college interviews. I’m sure that a growth spurt is just around the corner…”), and his red curls had been tamed by some serious man-product. Liam, on the other hand, wore a fitted, three-button corduroy blazer and dark jeans. He looked like he was going to a hip club opening in New York City instead of a school dance.

But when Seth opened the door for me and Liam held my hand to help me down, I smiled. I couldn’t help but stand a little straighter and hold my head a little higher as I walked with the two of them at my side. Seth was like the brother I’d never had. Well, aside from the fact that he was constantly asking me out.

And Liam, as guilty as it sometimes made me feel, reminded me how to be happy. He gave me chills when he touched me and filled me up with that I-need-to-kiss-this-boy-or-I-will-die type of feeling. Which was dramatic, yes, but also the best feeling in the world.

Pausing before the double doors that opened to the gym, I looked down at Seth and up at Liam and looped an arm through each of theirs. We had arrived.

The dance was in full swing as we pushed through the doors. Girls wore barely there dresses that probably required a few rolls of double-sided tape to keep things PG-13. Their necks were adorned with their dates’ discarded ties. The boys were already starting to sweat through their button-down shirts, their blazers carelessly strewn about the floor.

When you mix a Mardi-Gras-themed dance with teenage hormones, the result is a combination of girls who look largely like underage prostitutes and oversexed boys who dangle copious amounts of beads in hopes of finding a girl drunk enough (or slutty enough) to flash them. There were plenty of both. In short, it was every parent’s worst nightmare. Something the school administrators might want to consider next time they blindly approve one of Beefany’s or Taylor’s dance themes.

The three of us found seats on the bleachers, which had been decorated to look like a huge Mardi Gras float, and watched the chaos of Homecoming unfold from the sidelines.

“Any society sightings?” Seth asked between sips of punch, an anxious look on his face.

“No, I don’t think the future queen and king have made their entrance just yet.” I guess it goes without saying that Taylor and Alistair had been elected third-year Homecoming attendants this year. I, for one, was really looking forward to seeing them dance together. I was almost 100 percent positive they hated each other. Almost.

“Oh, they’re here,” Liam said. “Over there by the Bourbon Street sign.”

I followed Liam’s line of vision and surveyed Taylor and her groupies. They all wore the same dress in different colors. Taylor’s was a pale baby pink. With her white-blond hair in a low bun, she reminded me of a ballerina. Beefany couldn’t have contrasted more. She towered over Taylor in a bright turquoise version of the dress, which set off her olive skin and dark features.

Maddie stood hunched over in bright red, crossing her arms over her chest and looking like she wanted to melt into the floor and disappear. The rest of the girls wore orange, yellow, and purple. They looked like a flock of exotic birds. Of course, knowing these birds, it was only a matter of time before they went all Alfred Hitchcock on the place.

At that moment, Taylor looked directly at me. It was as though she could read my mind.

“Bradley and Alistair are here.” Liam nodded toward the double doors. Sure enough, the boys had arrived in style. They each had two first-year dates, one for each arm, and they looked very pleased with themselves.

I watched Naomi nudge Taylor and point at her brother. Taylor gave them a quick look and began moving across the dance floor. Beefany and three others quickly flew after her. Guess even high-school birds tended to move in flocks.

“Come on guys. Let’s take a lap.” I dragged my dates up off the bleachers, and we began to wind our way around Bourbon Street. I wanted to get a better view of whatever was about to go down on the court.

I was so focused on Taylor’s purposeful strides toward Alistair that I didn’t see Headmaster Sinclair until I literally ran right into him.

“Oh! Sorry.” I felt the color drain from my cheeks as I met his sharp eyes.

“Lovely to see you tonight, Ms. Lowry. I was just heading to the refreshment table. Care to join me?” His smile made me edgy.

I exchanged quick looks with Liam and Seth, but I didn’t really have a choice.

“Uh, sure. Of course.” I nervously wrapped Grace’s pearls around my finger, unwound and rewrapped them, thinking of Elisa Moore and her poor sister, Abigail. The headmaster’s brother had been cleared of the charges, but I didn’t know what to believe anymore. I was beginning to wonder if I’d ever be able to uncover the truth buried beneath all these years of lies.

I followed him as he walked toward the abandoned refreshment table, trying to figure out exactly how to play this.

“Well, Ms. Lowry, I have to admit I’ve been a little concerned about you lately.”

I did not like where this was heading.

“Really? Um, why?” It was a dangerous question to ask, and I could practically taste the bitterness of regret on my tongue after the words left my mouth.

He poured himself a glass of punch. “I hear you paid a visit to one of our alumni, Elisa Moore, poor woman. She lost her mind when her sister took her own life years ago.”

“I, um…I should really get back to my date…”

“Don’t be nervous. We’re among friends.” He nodded toward Liam and Seth waiting across the dance floor. “I’m just worried about you. I think you might be in over your head.”

“Well, you know what they say:
Veritas Vos Liberabit
. The truth shall set you free.” I forced myself to smile brightly.

“Please just be careful, Kate. You might not believe this, but I don’t want to see any other students get hurt.” He offered a smile, but it never reached his eyes.

Elisa’s thin form flashed to the front of my mind, and I thought of his brother, the all-American track star conveniently cleared of all the charges against him. Not to mention Headmaster Sinclair’s own name painted on the walls of Brown. No doubt the Brotherhood had a hand in everything. It was all connected.

“You know, Headmaster, thanks to my experiences here at Pemberly Brown, I really feel like I’ve learned how to take care of myself. But I appreciate your concern.”

I wasn’t bluffing. I felt strong. I knew that I’d be able to do what I had to do to uncover the truth, to finally save Grace. But as I walked back across the dance floor, back to the safety of Liam and Seth, I was happy I didn’t have to do it alone.

Well, that was awkward,” I said, trying to keep my voice steady in front of my faithful sidekicks. Liam shook his head back and forth, and Seth looked like he might poop his pants.

“He’s scary,” Seth said, eyes wide.

“Not scary. Scared.” Liam grabbed my hand. “This is the first time more than one person has been a threat to them. It’s easy to silence one guy but not so easy to shut three people up.”

I looked at him and smiled.

“They haven’t seen anything yet.”
Just wait until I find proof that the Brotherhood is involved
.

Liam smiled at me. “Hey, you want to…”

“Oh, my God,” I said, cutting him off, “is that…” I pointed at the entrance to the dance.

“Cameron,” Liam finished for me. Under normal circumstances I would have been worried we were turning into one of those annoying couples who finished each other’s sentences, but that night I was grateful he’d said the name I couldn’t.

“What the hell is he doing here?” Seth asked. “And where has he been?”

“I don’t know, but we need to find out,” I said, standing up.

We made our way through the sea of people and tried to keep up with Cameron. He was on a mission, and the crowd appeared to sense his determination, because they parted like the Red Sea to let him through. He came to an abrupt halt right next to Taylor, grabbed her arm, and twirled her around to face him. Her pink dress floated prettily around her thighs.

We hid behind a few fake streetlights and watched the scene unfold.

“We need to talk,” Cameron said, eyes darting left and right wildly.

Beefany planted herself between them, protecting her queen. “Oh, Cameron. You’re back.” She cocked her head and sighed dramatically. “Sorry, but you’ll have to catch up with Taylor later. We’re right in the middle of something. Not a good time.”

Cameron grabbed Beefany by the arm and pulled so that her face was mere inches from his own.

“We need to talk. Now,” he repeated.

“Fine. Go ahead,” Beefany said as if she were bored by the whole tiresome situation.

“In private.”

“No, whatever you have to say, you can say it here. In front of everyone. Taylor isn’t going anywhere with you alone.” Beefany nodded to their audience.

“That’s how you want to play it? Fine. I’m done with your lies, your threats. I know the three of you were there that night. I saw you when I was leaving,” he said. Maddie took a step away from the crowd, crumpling into herself like a discarded piece of paper.

I wasn’t sure how many people in the room knew what night he was talking about, but I felt a collective gasp.

“I have no idea what you’re talking about, Cameron,” Taylor said softly.

Beefany took over again, her voice loud and sharp. “Are you sure you’re okay? Maybe I should call a teacher over here. I think all those drugs are really starting to take their toll.”

Cameron grabbed Taylor by the arms, and I could already see two angry red welts forming around his fingers. He swore, a droplet of saliva backlit by the strobe lights spinning above us.

“I want to know what happened in that chapel. I saw her invitation.”

Taylor’s icy eyes widened for a split second, revealing fear and maybe even a little weakness.

Beefany swooped into action. “Maddie!” she cried. “Get Headmaster Sinclair over here right now. Cameron is clearly high, and he needs help.”

Maddie stood frozen to her spot, probably torn between obeying her leader and disappearing into the crowd. Before she could make up her mind, Headmaster Sinclair came running.

“Cameron, you shouldn’t be here.” He pried Cameron’s fingers off Taylor’s arms. “We have a lot to discuss, son. Why don’t we take this conversation some place more private?”

“Get him out of here,” Taylor said with quiet authority.

“That’s enough, Ms. Wright. I’ll take care of this.” The headmaster dragged Cameron out of the dance as a crowd gathered. The two moved past me, and I heard the headmaster hiss, “I thought I made myself clear to your parents. This school is no longer the best place for you, Cameron.”

I turned to Seth. “Did you hear that?”

Seth nodded his head. “I was right. He was at Cameron’s house.”

Suddenly Cameron shook himself free from the headmaster’s grip and came rushing back at me.

“Don’t let them get away with it.” His voice was thick with emotion.

I stood frozen as the headmaster whipped back around, grabbed Cameron by the arm, and escorted him toward the exit once again. Cameron was almost completely hunched over as he walked, as if to protect himself from the looks of pity and disgust from both his friends and enemies.

I felt tears prick my eyes. In a way we were both in this together. We both wanted the same thing. The truth. And revenge.

I managed to break away from Liam and Seth and ran after Cameron and the headmaster. By the time I’d caught up, they were walking into the school office.

“I’ve tried so hard to protect you. I know this might be hard for someone like you to understand, but there are traditions of honor within this school that simply can’t be broken. Tragic mistakes were made that night, but there’s no undoing them, and no good will come from the truth getting out.” Headmaster Sinclair maintained a tight grip on Cameron’s arm.

I hung on to his use of the word “honor.” It was such a simple word, but it said so much about his involvement with the Brotherhood. He may not have had anything to do with the fire, but he had been covering for the Brotherhood, hiding their secrets all this time.

“You don’t understand what happened that night. It was them…they…” Cameron’s face was twisted with desperation. I wanted to run over to him, but I kept myself hidden around the corner of lockers. “I tried to tell you. I even tried telling the police. I was supposed to meet Grace in the chapel that night.”

“I know all about what happened that night, Cameron. You are the one who doesn’t understand. This situation is far more complex than it might seem.” Headmaster Sinclair’s voice was fading as they moved deeper into his office. “You are no longer a student here. It’s over.”

I stood there paralyzed, unable to find the courage to storm the office and smart enough to know it wouldn’t make any difference if I did. Besides, I had a date with a ghost.