Three Made in Heaven [Made in Heaven] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour) (7 page)

* * * *

Maddie wasn’t sure how long they lay there on the bed in a tangled mess of limbs, and it seemed neither of them cared. They were together and they finally felt at peace.

“I’ve never done that before,” Maddie said, breaking the silence. She reveled in the feeling of being sandwiched between them. The warmth of their bodies enveloped her, making her feel safe and cherished.

“Done what?” Charlie asked. “We know you weren’t a virgin, baby.” There was a hint of jealousy in his voice.

Maddie planted a featherlight kiss on Charlie’s lips. “I didn’t think that either of you felt the same way about me—that you would ever want me. I mean, you never showed any interest in me in a romantic way. I wasn’t even sure that you two were real no matter how much I wished that you were. I would have waited for both of you if I knew. And don’t forget I had to hear about the two of
you
with other women. You have no idea—” The last words stuck in her throat as she was overcome with emotion. She tried not to think about how Charlie and Cole learned to be such amazing lovers. Instead, she focused on the fact that she would be the only woman who would ever benefit from their expertise again.

“Shh…I’m sorry, Maddie,” Charlie said, hugging her close. “I didn’t mean to upset you. I’m a jealous idiot.”

“It’s all right, sweetheart,” Cole chimed in. He gave Charlie a sharp reprimanding look, though she knew he was just as jealous. “This has been hard on all three of us. There is no sense dwelling on the past. We’re together now and that’s all that matters.”

“So what is it that you haven’t done before?” Charlie asked, changing the subject.

Maddie blushed. “Um…”

“Don’t tell me you’ve never sucked cock before!” Charlie said incredulously.

“Real smooth, Charlie.” Cole laughed.

“What? You both know I like to get to the point. Don’t act all surprised.”

“Yes, and we love your potty mouth,” Maddie said.

“Well?”

“Yes, yes, okay,” Maddie admitted. She felt her cheeks were enflamed now. “I mean, no, I’ve never given a blow job before. I was never as comfortable with anyone as I am with the two of you. Was I okay?”

“No, baby, you were not ‘
okay
,’ you were absolutely fucking incredible! I can’t wait to fuck that sweet mouth of yours again, and I will, too. Real soon.”

“Charlie!” Maddie gasped, and then all three of them laughed at Charlie’s deliberate crudeness. She could tell that both men were deliriously happy discovering this little fact about her. And they were equally as happy that she felt comfortable with them. She wanted to please them as much as she knew they wanted to please her.

“You’re a natural, my love,” Charlie said. “Where did you learn how to do that? Did you practice on a banana or something?”

Cole and Maddie burst out laughing. They laughed so hard they shook the bed. Only Charlie could manage such a sweet endearment coupled with naughty banana antics in the same sentence.

“No, I did not defile a banana,” Maddie said after she finally calmed down. “I sort of went to an all-girl thing that Angela’s friend was hosting last year. It’s kind of like a Tupperware party but with sex toys and naughty lingerie.” They looked at her eagerly, willing for her to continue. “Anyway, the host…um…well, she demonstrated how to give the perfect blow job on a d–dildo.”

Maddie was thoroughly embarrassed now. She felt a blush creep all over her face and neck. Charlie and Cole, however, were not laughing. They looked at her like they were two predators and she was their prey.

“Did you buy anything?” Cole asked, his voice low and seductive.

“Y–Yes.” Maddie’s voice shook as she replied. She felt herself growing hot and wet at their ravenous stares.

“What did you buy, Maddie?” Charlie asked in an equally seductive tone. He squeezed her breast and kissed her shoulder while Cole’s hand moved down to play with the tender lips of her sex. She was soaking wet, dripping all over his hand.

“Answer the question,” Cole commanded. He plunged a finger inside her wet pussy, while his thumb stroked her aching clit.

“Ugn…” she muttered incoherently. “A vibrator!” she gasped as Cole added another finger.

“Turn over, Maddie,” Charlie ordered. “I need to be inside you.”

* * * *

Cole withdrew his fingers and Maddie rolled onto her stomach. Charlie positioned himself behind her and pulled her toward him by her hips so that she was on her knees, resting on her elbows. Cole saw Charlie admiring the view of her glorious round ass in the air. He watched his friend bend down to kiss and nibble on each cheek. Cole positioned himself in front of her mouth and delighted in how eagerly she took him in. She hummed around him as Charlie, in one swift move, plunged deep inside her.

“God, Maddie,” Charlie grunted. “You feel incredible.”

“Mmm…” Cole moaned his agreement. He couldn’t say much more as he was too busy concentrating on the wicked things she was doing with her tongue. He popped out of her mouth briefly and shifted underneath her. She took him deeper into her mouth at this new angle and ran her hands up and down his firm abs as Charlie pumped into her from behind.

“So tight…ahhh,” Charlie cried out.

Cole caressed Maddie’s hand where it was splayed out over his abdomen. His other hand held her hair in a makeshift ponytail. He loved the site of her licking up and down his shaft and the way she sucked hard when taking him in her mouth. She took him all the way to the base of her throat several times. She got wilder the louder he moaned. When she looked up at him, cupped his balls, and then bared her teeth around his shaft, he came undone. Like with Charlie before, she swallowed every drop and held him in her mouth until he stopped shuddering.

“Charlie,” she whimpered when her mouth was empty. “I need…I need to—”

* * * *

“Anything, baby. I’ve got you.”

Charlie set a furious pace now, desperate as she was for a release. Cole stared at her adoringly as he caressed her face. She held onto him as Charlie thrust deeper and faster into her.

Charlie bent forward, placing his hands on either side of Maddie, and buried his face in the back of her neck. He was in heaven. This new angle allowed him to thrust deeper, and by the sound of her wild grunting and moaning, it seemed he was hitting a very sweet spot with every thrust.

Her pussy gripped his dick so hard it made him see stars. Her vaginal walls felt like a velvet sheath encasing his cock to the hilt. In and out he thrust, groaning loudly. Never had he experienced such an intense sexual experience. He felt her in every pore of his body, and he prepared himself for the intensity of the coming orgasm, sure that it would be earth shattering.

Maddie reached back and slid her hand in Charlie’s hair, giving it a tug. They both moaned loudly and together ground out their release. They stayed like that, quivering for a few minutes before collapsing on top of Cole.

All three of them were too sated and dazed to care and eventually, with a little maneuvering to avoid crushing Cole, they fell asleep, practically piled up on one another.

The sun was beginning to set, filtering in a soft light through the closed curtains.

At some point during their nap, they adjusted to a more comfortable position. Charlie was behind Maddie on the right side of the bed, spooning her. His face was buried in her hair, and one hand rested on her hip. Cole was on the left side facing her. His chin rested on the top of her head, and her arm was wound around his neck. They were still naked on top of the comforter, but Cole had covered them all up with a fluffy throw blanket Maddie kept at the foot of the bed.

Charlie awoke, nuzzling Maddie’s neck and inhaling the intoxicatingly sweet flowery scent of her hair. He propped himself on his elbow and found Cole awake, too.

“She’s amazing, isn’t she?” Charlie said. He stroked Maddie’s arm and bent forward to kiss her shoulder.

Cole pulled back to look at her. She looked completely at peace. “Yes, she is,” he replied. “She looks like an angel.” His voice was still gravelly from sleep. He and Charlie were both touching her skin underneath the blanket. “We can’t lose her, Charlie. Now that I found her—that I found you both, I am never letting either one of you go.”

“I’m not going anywhere, man, and neither is she,” Charlie said fervently. “We will find the bastard who wants to hurt her and I swear, Cole, I’m gonna fucking kill him if he lays a hand on her.”

“Not if I kill him first. You should have seen her face in the nightmare, Charlie. She was so terrified. She doesn’t even know how real the danger is.”

“We’re going to have to tell her, you know. We can’t keep this from her. We need her to be on her guard.”

“I agree,” Cole said. “Not tonight, though. Tonight, I just want to feel and not think. We can tell her tomorrow.”

Charlie was in full agreement with Cole. There would be plenty of time for talking later. Right now all he wanted was to make love to Maddie repeatedly. He would never get enough of her, and as far as he was concerned, this was only their first day of forever. He threw back the blanket, admiring her naked form, and then he and Cole began to kiss their girl awake.

* * * *

Maddie awoke to the most titillating sensations. She felt warm hands and hot mouths touching and kissing her body. She opened her eyes to find Cole sliding in between her legs, spreading them wide and dipping his head down for a taste. Charlie, meanwhile, was dipping his tongue into her navel and licking in and around it in slow sensual circles. Her hips bucked when Cole used his thumbs to open her wide and slip his tongue into her hole. He slid his tongue in and out then swirled it around her dripping flesh. Charlie hovered over her breasts, teasing her nipples with flicks of his tongue before fully sucking on them in turn.

“Oh, God!” she moaned. “Please don’t stop.”

* * * *

Cole nearly came apart watching her undulating hips and her face, a mask of pure ecstasy. He gripped her hips to keep her steady and sucked her throbbing clit hard into his mouth. Her hands fisted the comforter underneath her, and she thrashed her head from side to side as she screamed out her release.

Cole was thrilled that he and Charlie could make her fall apart like that. He knew that her sexual experience was limited and unfulfilling, and now he knew that it was because she had wanted him and Charlie all along. In truth, neither he nor Charlie had ever experienced such orgasmic bliss with any of their past lovers either. They had both repeatedly admitted that to each other on numerous occasions. Cole and Charlie both had always pined for Maddie just as she had pined for them.

“Oh my God, what you two do to me!” Maddie said, still nearly breathless. “I hope that I—that I didn’t disappoint—”

“Sweetheart,” Cole said, cutting her off when he realized the ridiculous direction she was going in. “This has been the most amazing experience…I have no words to even describe—”

“I do,” Charlie chimed in. “Your pussy and your mouth are absolute heaven and I can’t wait to fuck that sweet little ass of yours.”

“Charlie!” Maddie gasped.

Cole gave Charlie an exasperated look, but Charlie just threw his head back and let out a booming laugh. Cole felt his cheeks redden, and Charlie threw him a knowing look. He was just as eager about making love to Maddie together as Charlie was. He also knew how to read Maddie’s changing expressions. Where he first saw shock and fear, he now saw curiosity, even though it was still mixed with a bit of trepidation. He wouldn’t push her though, and they would still need to get her ready if she was willing.

“Hey, I never claimed to be a poet, but if you like dirty limericks, I’m your man,” Charlie joked. “I’ll leave the flowery stuff to you guys. Be sure to throw some of it my way, too. I’m a very sensitive man.” Even though he said it jokingly, Cole knew that it was mostly true. He was aware of the walls Charlie put up around himself with others, but Cole was glad he let them all down with him and Maddie.

“Although Maddie could inspire an anthology of poetry, right now I don’t want to skirt around my feelings with anything
flowery
,” Cole stated. He caressed Maddie’s cheek with the back of his knuckles, stared at her intently, and said, “I love you, Madeline…so much. That’s all I really want to say right now.”

* * * *

Maddie’s heart swelled. She loved the way her full name rolled off his tongue, and his heartfelt declaration, along with the adoring way he looked at her, made her insides melt. She felt his words to the very depths of her soul and loved him and Charlie just as deeply.

She put her hand against his cheek and softly said, “I love you, too, Cole.” Then she turned to look at Charlie and placed her other hand on his cheek. “And I love you, Charlie. I love you and Cole more than anything in this world,” she added, gazing back and forth between her men.

“And I love you, baby.” Charlie said passionately. He brushed his lips whisper soft against hers. “God, I love you!”

Then Maddie’s stomach growled, causing all three of them to laugh heartily. “I guess we have to fit in our basic human needs somewhere in between all the sex,” she said. “Speaking of which, I really need to pee.” She crawled over Charlie and climbed off of the bed. She gave them a seductive backward glance as she strolled—without a stitch on—to the sole bathroom in the hallway. She noticed both men very much admiring the view and her deliberate slow movements.

* * * *

When she stepped out of the bathroom, she heard the guys laughing in the kitchen and the opening and closing of cabinets. She went back into her bedroom and slipped on Cole’s rumpled-up shirt, buttoning it up as she walked out into the hallway.

She thought about what Charlie had said while she was in the bathroom. She wasn’t shocked by his vulgarity but by the fact that he wanted to have anal sex with her. She definitely never did
that
before. Though the idea of Charlie and Cole being inside of her at the same time excited her, the prospect of a rather large penis invading her sphincter seemed scary as hell.